I ordered a supreme pizza, I had heard that this pizzeria had good food. To my surprise, they offered more than just pizza. On the menu, you can find subs, pasta dishes, calzones, desserts, etc. This is actually a full menu restaurant with table service. I would have never found out if I didn't step in to pick up my order. The pizza was really nice, although the slices folded really bad and lost their shape, something unexpected for a slice that wasn't packed with meats and veggies. Yet, it was tasty all the while. I would probably order again, I haven't made up my mind. read more

Blue Spring Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Orange City, Florida

The customer service here is excellent. Everyone was so nice and accommodating as soon as I walked in the door. They greeted me and were helpful. It seemed to be a cozy little local place which I liked. The downside of this restaurant was the pizza itself. I got the Bianca slice. It was so dry. I had to drink a whole glass of water to get it down. Obviously with this being Yelp, this is my own opinion. But I wasn't impressed unfortunately. read more

See all

Stopped in here on a whim. Got seated quickly by a very friendly waitress who helps us order. We try a slice of pizza each, they came out quickly and they were BIG. The pizza had a great crust, good amount of cheese and toppings. I really love how they had salt/pepper, cheese, garlic and Italian seasoning on the table so I can add to mine. Can't think of anything negative to say about the place! Glad I wandered in for a slice. read more

See all

Small shop located on the corner of a major street. We were waiting at the light and was craving a slice. We pulled over and grabbed a couple slices along with their garlic rolls. It was all pretty good, especially the garlic rolls. Asked for extra garlic and they did not disappoint. The lady at the counter was very nice to us and quick to serve. read more

If I could give this establishment a -10, I most certainly would.... Horrible customer service!!! I genuinely don't understand what took so long. We ordered one large pizza and were told it would be ready in 20 minutes. Instead, we waited 45 minutes. The restaurant was empty and the kitchen was fully staffed. There was no lunch rush, no dinner rush, and no visible reason for such an excessive delay. And to top it off... the pizza was extremely salty, like the establishment. If it takes 45 minutes to make a single pizza when the restaurant is empty, I can only imagine what the wait is like when they're actually busy. The issue wasn't just the wait. It was being given a completely unrealistic time estimate and then left waiting with no explanation. Customers can be patient when businesses are honest, but don't tell people 20 minutes when it's really going to be nearly an hour. Very disappointing experience and not one I'll be repeating. read more

We had the Chicken Bacon Ranch and Buffalo Chicken pizzas as well as the garlic bread with cheese a couple weeks ago when we were in the area and the food and service were excellent. Definitely going back. read more

Amazing find. Great staff and the food came out fast and hot. Ambiance is very cozy but still a good amount of space. Good beer choices too - although it would have been nice to have an IPA choice. read more

Blue Spring Pizza - GARLIC KNOTS (6) - Pizza Near Me - Orange City, Florida

See all

The Best Pizza in Volusia County I truly enjoy coming to eat Pizza there. There Garlic Bread is Awesome and there Stromboli is amazing !

Very good pizza, wings, Caesar salad, and mozzarella sticks. Nice, clean restaurant and nice friendly (quick) service. Next time we'll try the desserts, they looked excellent. read more

Eat here frequently and it is cozy and the service is fantastic. I encourage you to try other items from the menu other than pizza. They are made fresh and sooo good. Love this place! read more

Stumbled on this place on the way to Blue Springs manatee park. What a gem! This is the closest to real NYC pizza I have had since moving to central Florida. I was totally shocked by how good the slices were. It's special rare that you can buy by the slice like we do up in NY. I was a little shocked to see how low the rating was when I decided to make a review because the pizza was spot on! Perhaps it is because it's not the fanciest of looking places, but that shouldn't matter when we are talking about getting a legitimate NYC slice. This is the only spot I would go to when I am back up in this area from Orlando read more

We had a large pizza. One 1/2 with pepperoni and bacon. The other 1/2 with green peppers, black olives, and onions. The pizza was excellent, good crust. Service was fast and good. read more

This place should have a line out the door. The salad was so fresh and their menu had so many yummy choices I couldn't decide. I went with the lunch special that had a meatball sub with it. Primo!!!! All beef meatballs so tender and definitely a fork and knife sandwich. The bread was crispy. I wouldn't have changed a thing read more

They're okay. I've got a friend who likes them and so we've been in a few times this summer. The food's good enough. Prices are reasonable. And the hospitality's been excellent despite suffering from staffing issues; we've been very forgiving with the waitress because she's been so nice but there's that. The kitchen is very slow. It's also been uncomfortably warm in there, which makes the whole experience that much less enjoyable and the wait almost unbearable. read more

See all

Rated in the middle because they have a fabulous Greek salad but their garlic knots need help. They were burnt and dried out and it seems only garlic powder...no fresh garlic. Very disappointed. read more

Blue Spring Pizza - Garlic knots - Pizza Near Me - Orange City, Florida

I placed an online order ahead of time for my family. I showed up alittle after the pick up time and my order was not ready...no problem. I cans sit and wait patiently, it happens. After an hour, I got up and asked where my order was, it was then they realized they never printed it for the kitchen. Another 10 before the owner asked me what she could do. Nothing really, it's to feed my family and my 4 year old. He doesn't care about your problems or what you can offer me for the inconvenience. HE WANTS TO EAT!!! I get problems happen, but this is a small dining room and I am sitting right in front of the counter. No one checked, asked, or looked into my Oder until I had to ask. This customer service is totally unacceptable. I WILL NEVER COME HERE AGAIN. It's not about compensation, it's about poor service and an unacceptable wait time. read more

I really wanted this to be better. When I walked in the place smelled amazing, had that mom & pop local pizza joint look and everything. Staff was OK, not super friendly, but not completely inattentive. The pizza was very underwhelming, and needed to finish baking. It's was on the verge of raw, not even browned on the crust edge and cool. On the other hand, the Greek salad was fantastic. Large portion, good variety of veggies. Good amount of ham and salami. read more

We ordered a Metro Supreme and it was verrrry good, we highly recommend it! You will too

The best real Italian on Orange City, anywhere else is second, at best. Worth waiting for delivery.

I ordered a 16' Bacon pizza with the tomatoes on the side, a cannoli and mozzarella sticks. The cannoli arrived a bit messy but was absolutely delicious and even my first ever trying one! The pizza was not so saucey ( which I like ) and had a sweetness to the tomato sauce, very savory! Love how the crust is not too crispy but also not soggy, infact it was just right. Customer Service was excellent as always and delivery arrived just 30 minutes after order was placed. Will be ordering from here again! read more

See all

Pizza was a true, authentic NY style and very good. Menu is huge and would love to have tried some. Had a chocolate drizzle cannoli which was sweet and perfect. Our waiter Tyler was awesome. His enthusiasm and attention to detail, great smile and personality were a welcome change to most of today's service. We will definitely stop on our next trip to see the manatees. Highly recommend this place if you find yourself in Blue Springs! read more

Ordered take out, 2 hot subs. I asked not be toasted, they weren't but the roll was totally "white", like it was not baked. Disappointed for $27 read more

A great find while in Florida. Large slices of pizza which is very fresh and delicious. Hubby had the Italian sub and was loaded with meat and cheese. Don't pass it up. read more

Blue springs pizza is one of those small corner pizzerias. Atmosphere is decent, it is a small place so it can get a little loud but not to often. The menu has a great selection of Italian dish's. From pizza to penne vodka. The wait staff really is attentive, my personal standard of your drink should never go below half without a refill Is always surpassed here. I mean clean, well mannered. I ate the chicken parmigiana, large portion served with large garlic knots, there will always be enough to take home. I enjoy eating here and I'd recommend it to anyone who's looking for a good Italian restaurant. It is worth mentioning that there cannolis are the closest to authentic Iv found sense I left NYC read more

Been in here for 40 minutes. We're the only ones in here. They've had maybe 3 call-ins while we've been in here. The crew is slow. The young lady who is working is next to useless. I hear a lot of conversation but haven't seen the pizza we ordered. Two employees just sat down at a table in the restaurant. Still no pizza. Haven't had a drink refill in 20+ minutes. But they have time to talk. One employee talking about waking up at about 2 am and puking. Nice....but where's my pizza? 45 minutes - still talking. 47 minutes - asked if we want ranch or blue cheese with pizza ...still no refill on the drinks. 50 minutes- pizza. Pretty good pizza. Truth is pizza is pretty good at this place. Service on Friday and Saturday is pretty good. Service during the week is horrendous. Third time that we've been in on a week night and it's terrible service. 2 stars - food is good. Terrible weeknight service. read more

Pizza is over priced for the amount of toppings you receive. I literally had one bite sized piece of chicken per slice of pizza and no other toppings. No purple onion or green peppers or even a full layer of BBQ sauce. Just a drizzle of sauce. Some of the chicken still had fat on it so when you bit down on it it felt over cooked and rubbery. Crust and dough was decent but kind of dry and a little chewy. I feel bad for restaurants with the pandemic occurring but you would think a pizza joint would thrive due to deliveries and take out orders. This one just didn't seem to care about quality and the food felt cheap and underwhelming. I won't be going back again. read more

Blue Spring Pizza - BBQ Chicken Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Orange City, Florida

Excellent Pizza! We are from San Antonio TX visiting our friends. Wife wanted pizza to celebrate her birthday. She was so pleased! The gal who took our order was so pleasant and helpful. Delivery was perfect. We plan to be repeat customers. read more

Love love love this place ! Their bruschetta is off the chain! Ashley has been serving there for years! She and the other staff are wonderful. They all are very friendly , professional and always have a smile on their face ! Keep up the good work ! read more

Blue Spring Pizza - BRUSCHETTA - Pizza Near Me - Orange City, Florida

See all

Amazing food !! The pizza was delicious and the cannoli to die !!! Definitely going back again!!

Don't let the outside fool you, like it almost fooled me! I walked in and the first thing I noticed was how clean the inside was and how it was Nicely updated! Eat in or take out. They had pizza by the slice which is what we got. I was able to see what other people had at their tables and the pasta, ziti and meatballs looked phenomenal! The pizza was very good and fresh brewed iced tea to top it off! Reasonable prices and service was fast to boot! We will be back read more

This pizzeria has good customer service and great appetizers pizza is good way to much oregano put they make it up with customer service o felt like a king with all the attention giving to us !!! Wow this is Customer service at its best Highly recommended and please support your locals thanks guys beat of luck read more

See all

We tried this place last night. Not good. Menu says, "Ceasar side salad: tossed in ceasar dressing.." Nope. Not tossed. A fistful of romaine, drizzled with dressing for FIVE BUCKS. Pizza not tasty, and expensive toppings - $2.50 each on the small pie. Bland crust, very little sauce (invisible, actually) And iced tea is 4 bucks. I'm not going back. read more

Amazing pizza The crust was perfect And the cannoli - omg !! The most wonderful cannoli I have had in years The staff was excellent Thank you Blue Spring pizza read more

haven't eaten yet for dinner, but the lunch dinner people are poor at best on the cooked on top overcooked on bottom slices cut they're making it hard for me to reorder read more

Best in the area, i generally don't review but saw a lot of Karen's piping up with one stars on Apple Maps. Take it easy on the pie @Lucy Z - Sauce Smithski read more

The food is amazing, it's comes off as a small NYC elegant mom and pop pizza diner, there's art on the walls of New York and the staff is super friendly. The Bacon Cheese Fries are a must as the bacon is perfectly cooked with melted cheese ontop. The garlic bread is cut open and served with a hot bowl of marinara sauce. The pizza is the best pizza in the area!!! The bottom of the pie is crunchy while the top has a nice thin layer of cheese. I honestly wonder if the owners is from NYC because this pizza restaurant is fantastic. Seriously come give this place a try after a nice cold blunge in the Blue Springs down the street! read more

See all

I literally live 5 blocks away from this place. No one can do anything nowadays with any sense of competence or any passion anymore. I ordered for pick up and was told 35 minutes until complete. Got home opened the food and it was as tho it had been sitting for that whole 35 minutes. Nuke warm and soggy. The 12" cheese pizza was the only thing that was cooked to what a standard of a pizza is worth. I'm going to order from other locals from now on. I'm done with this place. read more

Blue Spring Pizza - Soggy pizza right after picked up - Pizza Near Me - Orange City, Florida

The first time i ordered here was October 2024, the Calzone was the best i've ever had, and the service was great, went again maybe a few days later in October 2024, and the Bianca Pizza we got had a white / grey hair in it, i called and the manager i spoke with i think her name is Courtney, she was very nice and understanding gave me a discount next order i get, anyway fast forward to today, January 11,2025 I placed a pickup order at 2pm, i get there at 1:50 they said the order is ' just coming out' so i expected it to be hot, no it was not even Lukewarm, the Calzone i got was cold, and the jalapeño poppers i got were even more cold, like it was sitting out for over 30 minutes, also mid bite i take for the popper, i found a black what looked like a beard hair, called and complained i believe i talked to Courtney again and gave me a 10% discount like at this point i wanted a FULL refund but no i'm stuck at work, so i couldn't go back. 3 months ago i had the same problem and nothing has changed i will not be going back here cause they don't seem to care that they have loose hairs going in the togo orders as well the food quality gets worse the more i went here, ROMA pizza for win read more

Love the gluten-free pizza! And the friendly service. Comfortable and clean eating area. read more

I typically love this place and it's not like me to leave a review. This is my go to pizza joint. Super friendly, awesome food. I went to place an order online, double checked the time and pickup options, placed my order, paid online, then headed that way to pick it up. I go to open the front door to BSP and there's a sign that says closed until 8/8. I go to call for a refund and the line is disconnected. I wish they had updated their operating hours to reflect that they were closed. But I spent money and don't know when I'll get a refund because of this. Other than their phone being shut off, there isn't an email address to contact them. Let's hope reaching out on Facebook is good enough. read more