Bellvale Farms Creamery is one of those places that instantly reminds you why simple summer…read moretraditions never get old. We came here for a refreshing treat on a cool Sunday evening, and it absolutely did not disappoint. Luckily, the weather kept the crowds manageable -- busy, but nowhere near the chaos of a hot summer afternoon. Nestled in the mountains of Warwick, NY, this creamery has such a charming, peaceful vibe. I first discovered it a few years ago after taking my nephew apple picking nearby, so I was excited to finally make my way back. The scenic drive alone is worth it. On this visit, they were serving customers inside only, but during peak summer days they also open the walk-up windows, which seems like a smart system for handling bigger crowds. Inside, the L-shaped counter setup helps keep the line moving efficiently even when there are multiple groups waiting. One thing I truly appreciated as someone with a gluten allergy was how clearly they labeled the gluten-free flavors on the menu. It made ordering stress-free and saved me from having to ask a million questions. Honestly, I wish every ice cream shop did this. Another huge bonus: they allow two flavors in a small size! I ordered the Great White Way and Calf Trax with rainbow sprinkles, and both flavors were absolutely delicious. After grabbing your ice cream, there are picnic tables outside overlooking breathtaking mountain views. It's the kind of place where you could easily sit for hours, relax, and just take in the scenery while enjoying your cone. The staff was friendly, parking was plentiful (always appreciated), and the overall experience was exactly what I hoped for. Bellvale Farms Creamery continues to live up to the hype, and I already can't wait to go back.

I ended up at Bellvale Farms Creamery after accidentally crashing my friend's bachelorette weekend,…read morewhich honestly feels very on brand for me. I had never been here before, so I went in completely blind, but the second I got out of the car, I understood why people come here. First of all: parking on BOTH sides of the street. Say less. Nothing ruins a cute little ice cream trip faster than circling for parking while your will to live slowly leaves your body. Then there's the smell. The scent wafting through the air should honestly be studied because it had me floating toward the building like a cartoon character following a pie cooling on a windowsill. I'm not saying the aroma dragged me in against my will...but I'm also not *not* saying that. Inside, the shop is set up in an "L" shape, and they have the flavors posted both outside AND inside, which I deeply appreciated because nobody needs the chaos of 14 people trying to read one tiny menu while pretending they're ready to order. They let you sample flavors before committing, which is dangerous for someone like me because suddenly I become an ice cream sommelier. I ended up getting Bellvale Bog and Calf Trax and let me tell you: absolutely worth it. 10/10. No notes. And somehow it gets even better once you walk back outside because there are picnic tables with a view that is genuinely stunning. Like, annoyingly picturesque. The kind of view that makes you stop mid-bite and rethink your life choices. For a completely spontaneous stop, this ended up being one of the highlights of the day. I will absolutely be back, and this time intentionally.

Delicious ice cream, great flavors and awesome shakes. Fantastic staff too! Best in the arearead more

Soft serve that won't budge! It was a hot night and my daughter and I got cones with twist. The ice…read morecream kept its shape and didn't immediately start melting down our hands. It was delicious and creamy and the woman working the window was so kind and friendly!

Got my daughter her birthday cake since we were in that area and it was a decision that we…read moreregretted immediately. The ice cream tasted old, perhaps even expired if at all possible. It did not have that " taste " one might expect from Carvel especially for the price they charge. My wife called them on 4/1/15 and asked for the manager who, what a shock, was not available but he'll call back. As of this post, 40 minutes from now will be April 15 and still NO call. Apparently customer service and ice cream that should taste like ice cream are not a priority. Please go to Ramsey or Nanuet for a better Carvel where the product tastes fresh and not like they just scooped it from a batch that has been laying around for a year or two.

Attention! Attention! This location is under new ownership since about 2017. Polite and…read moreprofessional service. Exceptionally clean. You can sit outside on a bench and enjoy your ice cream or enjoy the locations AC inside with seating available. Support your local Carvels!

Very clean and neat with plenty of indoor seating ice cream shop. I give a lot of credit to the…read moreworker here, since after I came in for ice cream, all the other customers came in talking on there cell phones rather than actually ordering and she was very patient and polite with them, despite all rude indecisive people walking in making her wait to serve them. This place also out of all ice cream places in Middletown has the largest and best selection for if you dairy ice cream or sorbet. I had cannoli ice cream it was good , but white chocolate raspberry Rocky Mountain ice cream was amazing, definitely never seen before and would recommend easily.

Why have I not found this place sooner! Wow! Upon walking in we were greeted by the two female…read morestaff who were so sweet. I got the banana ice cream which was DELICIOUS!!! We also got a soft serve vanilla ice cream which was also just as good. They are so generous with their portions. I would much rather give my business to a place like this as opposed to a commercial ice cream location. I will definitely be back soon and a plus is that they are open all year round! They accept cash/card and plenty of parking outside in their lot. Very cute decor and ambiance inside as well!

They made my day today! Gelati with non-dairy vanilla! No other area ice cream parlor has that as…read morean option--even one that sells the gelati in a nearby town. Service was excellent and the ambiance is always cozy on a nice hot summer night. My family ordered the Cookie Monster, an Oreo and a Vanilla shake. They were happy with their orders too. Great spot on a hot summer night.

I like to walk the trail and I always stop at trailside treats. They get busy, but they go so fast,…read moreit's worth a couple of minutes wait. I was pleased to hear that they make everything from scratch. I HIGHLY recommend the raspberry chocolate chip! Thanks trailside!!

We found this lovely little burger/ice cream shop while staying at Legoland New York. This was…read moreabout 10-15 minutes from the resort. The look reminds me of an old 50's style drive-up restaurant. The service was good. Our cashier was training but the owner stepped in and helped when she found that she had rung an item incorrectly, without me complaining about anything. The food came quick. My wife got the Delite burger, I got the Dirt Burger, my kids got chili dogs (boiled) and we got fries. The burgers were amazing. My wife tried my dirt burger and immediately regretted her choice. My kids (8,4,3) devoured their chili dogs in about 3.5 seconds, which for my picky eaters, is quite an amazing accomplishment. The fries were crispy and full of flavor. I'd give the food a 10/10. The prices were reasonable and the portions were good. Now....the ice cream. If you thought their food was good, the ice cream will blow you away. My wife got a Snow Storm with salted Caramel soft serve and m&m's blended inside. The salted caramel soft serve is a home made blend of theirs. It was AMAZING and I'm not even a salted caramel guy lol. I really enjoyed that the ice cream wasn't artificially dyed and was still white. I got a Mintastic Stacker. If you're a lover of mint chip ice cream like me, you'll love this. It was a sundae that was layered with hot fudge and brownie bites then mint chip ice cream then Oreos followed by more mint chip cream. It was not overly sweet and the brownie bites were really good. My 8 year old got a cookie dough ice cream milkshake and said it was really good. For my littles, they got a kids scoop of hard ice cream. The portion for a little kid was PERFECT. I give the ice cream a 10/10 as well. One of the owners was present and said they purchased the place in August of 2025. They said they're trying to bring customers back, I guess after the old owners may have had some issues. If you live in the area this could easily become a regular restaurant in your rotation of places to go. If you're visiting the area, I highly recommend this place for quick, cheap, good quality food with friendly service. It is only outside seating. It was raining the day we went so we ate in the car.

Had this amazing hot fudge Sunday at Miller's. Absolutely amazing soft serve ice cream, the perfect…read moreamount of hot fudge, and served in this cute little bucket. Perfection. Oh and the owner is super nice. Be sure to visit this place soon.

Went here on Friday June 13th 2025 with my parents to get some ice cream after dinner at nearby…read moreCaptain's table. Was a bit of a line too! Before you know it, it was our turn, and the line did move quickly. I ordered the cotton candy and queen of hearts in a cup, My dad ordered Queen of Hearts and Black Cherry in a cup, my mom ordered a soft vanila cone with chocolate sprinkles. The order came out the same way as last time! Because it was busy and raining, we decided to eat our ice cream in the car, and we all enjoyed our ice cream! Will be back soon!

I just had the French coffee, and vanilla ice cream, on a waffle cone and this was some of the best…read moreice cream I've had in a long time. Definitely a place you wanna stop by and get ice cream for sure The choices are endless, but it's cash only

If you haven't tried the Chester ice cream at my local shop yet, you are seriously missing out. The…read moretexture is unbelievably smooth and creamy, and every bite tastes rich, fresh, and perfectly balanced -- not overly sweet, just pure ice cream perfection. You can tell it's made with care and quality ingredients. Whether you're stopping in after dinner or just treating yourself, it never disappoints. Hands down the best ice cream around. Once you try it, nothing else compares.

After a game at The Rock, a parent recommended this little ice cream shop, so we had to give it a…read moreshot. Located in a small strip mall, sits this busy ice cream parlor. Service was quick and friendly. Plenty of parking in a large parking lot for the businesses in the strip. I went with the creamy coconut ice cream and the vanilla cherry. The creamy coconut is where it's at. Ice cream was very creamy and high quality. The cherry vanilla was ok but the coconut stole the show, so the cherry vanilla was up against a strong opponent. Great spot to grab high quality ice cream with great service!

This place is still dope. It's changed ownership a few times over the years but each new owner goes…read moreinto the business passionately and doesn't neglect the shop even when they wanted to sell it. New owners have shop feeling more open on the inside so it just looks super clean. They've blocked off some of the parking lot so that families & children can run around without worry about a driver not paying attention. Ice cream is really good and options are good. Fairly typical ice cream shop that I enjoy in this cute town.

This place is hands down one of the best I've been to! The service was quick and the employees were…read morepatient when trying to order with a family of 6. The Ice Cream was absolutely delicious! Lastly, once the some of the kids were done eating they even had corn hole boards and chalk for the kids to do! This may be the first spot I'd be willing to drive back to, all the way from New Jersey!

The two young ladies just served us & we were thrilled with their service & professionalism!!!…read moreHuge sundae ice cream (mint chocolate chip) & 2 scoops (pistachio & peach) in a cup with very YUMMY ice cream!!!!! Very reasonable price for the quality & deliciousness!!!!! So cute inside as well!

Great ice cream. Great price love the whole vibe. My kids and I love it. Everyone who works here is…read morevery nice and helpful. Our favorite ice cream place now.