After a game at The Rock, a parent recommended this little ice cream shop, so we had to give it a shot. Located in a small strip mall, sits this busy ice cream parlor. Service was quick and friendly. Plenty of parking in a large parking lot for the businesses in the strip. I went with the creamy coconut ice cream and the vanilla cherry. The creamy coconut is where it's at. Ice cream was very creamy and high quality. The cherry vanilla was ok but the coconut stole the show, so the cherry vanilla was up against a strong opponent. Great spot to grab high quality ice cream with great service! read more

Chester Ice Cream - Vanilla cherry on top and creamy coconut beneath. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Chester, New York

My first time here, and as a person who worked 12 years in the ice cream buissness as a kid I was impressed. The staff was very young but mature, respectful and the cleanliness was on spot. Its hard to find employees today like that in a younger generation so props on their training. Customers were helped promptly and they were patient with people making decisions. Their choices of hard icecream are numerous so theres no way that even the pickiest person cant find something they like. The order banana was so good. The soft serve was also very creamy and good. They have so many options from shakes to sundaes and all in-between read more

My son and I had the best ice cream at this place this afternoon!! I had so many cherries in my cone that there was moved a bite without them?! THE best ice cream we have ever had! Will definitely be back! read more

Fantastic ice cream - worth the stop. The fluffer nutter sundae was incredible. Lots of delicious flavors to choose from as well.

If you haven't tried the Chester ice cream at my local shop yet, you are seriously missing out. The texture is unbelievably smooth and creamy, and every bite tastes rich, fresh, and perfectly balanced -- not overly sweet, just pure ice cream perfection. You can tell it's made with care and quality ingredients. Whether you're stopping in after dinner or just treating yourself, it never disappoints. Hands down the best ice cream around. Once you try it, nothing else compares. read more

I likeChester ice cream. It is open all winter long and they have a lot of flavors to choose from. I have my favorites. Everyone is always so welcoming and very nice the owner He is a nice man. He's very friendly. I am an ice cream lover, so I go to Chester ice cream because they are very convenient for me in location and they are open every day even in the winter and I do go and pick my ice cream and I love their ice cream. It tastes so good each and every flavor and I've tried many so I would say go give it a try. You'll love Chester ice cream. read more

excellent homemade ice cream. great flavors. wish they had more than one sugar free ice cream

We stopped here with a group of nine. There's a huge line. The only worker (we found out her name is Abby) is running this place like nothing I've ever seen. Great customer service, exceptional listening, fast, and efficient. A huge line and she's smiling and so happy! Everyone is happy waiting because she is absolutely amazing! Wow! Great selection and amazing service! Thank you!!! UNG Rifle Team read more

Best ice cream in town. Fresh made. Place is super clean. Service is good. Great place for an ice cream cake that is made with just ice cream and no additives. read more

The creamery is a family favorite for me. The ice cream is delicious and they are super family oriented. The creamery makes excellent ice cream cakes and has never let my family or me down. However, don't ask them for extra peanut butter sauces as it creates an unnecessary conflict. I have been at other ice cream shops that have allowed me to buy peanut butter sauce as a side and as much as I wanted. When I asked the owner, he was offended I asked and told me I am asking to deplete his supplies to which he won't do. It was a simple - no. Instead it turned into this whole conversation about how I should just buy it online and that I wouldn't be able to get it at a shop. When I told him I have - he laughed and said I probably don't. Great ice cream, great atmosphere, amazing cakes, but really awkward interaction if you ask to buy a side of peanut butter sauce. read more

They got my order wrong and when we called they didn't seem to care. Which i guess is okay I feel we interrupted the party going on there. Oh well. read more

Dropped by one night from a weekend staying at Legoland resort. Inside of the ice cream shop is not anything exciting. There is a little sitting area with tables for you to enjoy your sweet treat. There is a Wide variety of different flavors to choose from. It was difficult to choose. Decided on the banana cookies and cream flavor and glad I did. It was Delicious! Would definitely come back the next time we're in town! read more

Chester Ice Cream is Great! Take it from a kid who grew up in Yonkers. We had Carvel Cakes... that's it. They were great. Fast forward to 2022- Carvel Cakes are not what they used to be growing up in the 70's. I purchased an Ice Cream Cake from Chester last week for Mother's Day. As soon as the lady handed it to me I knew it was going to be good. IT WAS HEAVY!!! Not full of air. Delicious. Plenty of chocolate crunchies! Highly recommended. Buying a cake for my Wife's Birthday tomorrow. She loved it (a Bronx Girl). Keep up the good work people. Thank You for a great, fresh, delicious product. read more

Best homemade ice cream ever! Randomly stumble upon it when we were coming back from Legoland. It is soooo good. MUST TRY the blueberry pie and peach melba. Both are seasonal. The strawberry and vanilla taste really good too. They are not too sweet and doesn't leave that sweet aftertaste. Prices are very reasonable. Service was great. Looks like they make ice cream cake and ice cream sandwiches as well. Wish we live closer so we can bring some home!! read more

The best ice cream! Visiting New York and stopped by on our way to NYC. Friendly staff, great service and such wonderful ice cream flavors. read more

The workers here are great! I asked asked about a food allergy (soy) and one of the girls immediately took out an allergy list and reviewed it with me! I feel very comfortable coming here now. I'll be back ! read more

Exceptional ice cream, nice people. I miss Dairy Queen and Carvel living in this area and their soft serve blows either one away. My wife got their hard ice cream which was great too. Got a sundae and they put (good quality) hot fudge on the bottom, ice cream on that, then more hot fudge and whip cream. I think I just gained a pound writing this review. read more

This place is amazing. The ice cream is delicious and fresh, and the staff is super nice and incredibly accommodating. They went to amazing lengths to give me ice cream for a family member who has horrible nut allergies. I wish every business could be so understanding and helpful! This place is the best! read more

Very nice staff and excellent ice cream. The ice cream is homemade (not made onsite if that matters). Easy to miss in the strip mall but highly recommended. read more

Best ice cream ever!!! Hubby bought cookies n cream and salted caramel for me yesterday and we were both amazed by how good they were!! N I know my ice cream, give it a try people you won't be disappointed. N from what I heard, really decent price too and huge scoops of ice cream!! read more

I've been coming here ever since they've opened and I am never disappointed. I always buy their coconut ice cream and it is delicious. All of the workers are always very nice even when I come right before close. Really good ice cream spot and I love that they make treats for dogs too! read more

Great ice cream, outstanding service from a young lady who let me sample anything and made great suggestions for me. Will return.

The ice cream is very smooth and delicious! Perfect place for a nice dessert ;) #GrahamSlam

The best ice cream place! Their recipe is a true winner! This place is a hidden gem ~ absolutely delicious.

This great ice cream establishment is located in the Quickway Plaza Strip mall on Rt 17m, just off exit 126 on NYS Rt 17. Their ice cream is simply delicious. They offer many flavors of hard ice cream, not the standard fare made by national companies,but rather a more creamier content made by a custom distributor of high end ice cream from out of state they also offer soft serve ice cream that is excellent as well, again a higher end mix. Chester ice cream is family owned , offers specials I hadn't seen elsewhere and is worth a trip! Everyone there is ultra friendly. As they are located in the strip mall and Not a free standing building , many people seem to by unaware of it. Never a line yet terrific dessert . Prices are very good to boot. Try it, you will not be disappointed ! read more

Really great, homemade ice cream. Their hard ice cream flavors are so good! The people working are also very nice and the place is well taken care of read more

First off! Genius to have a ice cream place open throughout all the seasons. Second - my husband went in here and grabbed a couple pints for myself and the kids. He got the blue cookie monster - it was so creamy and so full of flavor and did not disappoint on the amount of cookies it had in it..every bite had chunks of cookies my kids went wild. The mint also creamy and so much flavor...the inside is pristine and very clean. We also shared a milkshake on the drive home that was just as delicious. What a hidden gem! Its just as good as bellvale creamery but open during the winter which is great for these pregnant cravings lol. Im gonna be enjoying these for the next few days and then definetly go back and try new flavors! Very good, happy we decided to stop and try it. In a sum up high qaulity ice cream and service and my new favorite treat. read more

Great family-owned ice cream shop! The ice cream is delicious and everyone is super friendly!