OMG the peach and strawberry cream pies are incredible and completely worth the price! my family was so excited to enjoy them, I'm honestly not sure how they werent devoured in the car. staff was friendly and made recommendations - wish we lived closer to go back and get more pie! read more

Briermere has been one of my favorite pie spots for years, and I finally got to try the famous Peach Cream Pie after always missing it. Wow...the hype is real! Now it's a tie between the Peach Cream and Raspberry Cream pies. (The peach is only available in the summer, so don't miss it.) The apple cider is still the best. If you haven't been here yet, what are you waiting for? A North Fork trip isn't complete without Briermere! read more

Briermere Farms - Bakeries Near Me - Riverhead, New York

I'm happy to report that the hype around the raspberry cream pie is legit and would even go as far as to say it's not hyped enough. After drooling over pictures during the last year, I made the hike out to Riverhead, NY and got one. After eating about 1/4 of the pie, I'm already mourning the end and now need to figure out how to get more. It's the perfect pie - lovely crust with a tart/sweet combination. The stand itself is very charming - there are lots other baked goods, jams, and flowers for purchase. read more

Briermere Farms - Bakeries Near Me - Riverhead, New York

See all

The raspberry cream pie was delicious. Would get it again. It was so hard to pick a pie, wish they had slices so we could try more. Guess we have to go back again LoL. The carrot cake with walnut was alright. Nothing special. Thin layer of frosting. read more

Briermere Farms - Raspberry cream pie - Bakeries Near Me - Riverhead, New York

See all

Some of the best pies you can get on Long Island! It's definitely worth the trip even though it's pretty far east and north. Saw NJ and CT licenses so people are coming from out of state just to get these pies. We got the raspberry cream and peach cherry. Both delicious but will try more next time because I'm positive they all taste amazing! There's not much parking but people come in and out within 15 minutes typically. The pie line is usually outside the store since the inside is so small. I recommend knowing what you want before going in so they can just pack it for you immediately and keep the line moving. There's a nice field next to the store if you want to walk around a bit after the drive. There's a porta-potty read more

See all

Very fresh but I prefer the cooked fruit pies with the scrumptious double crust. I felt like I couldn't really taste the crust on this one. And if you're gonna go for a cream pie the raspberries is a much better choice. Cute little store with lots of pies for sale! Service is friendly and quick. read more

See all

Their fresh fruit pies are amazing!! We got the fresh strawberry and blueberry pies this time. Kinda pricy but so worth it. We also got a few variety of fresh apples and oatmeal raisin cookies. Both were fresh and tasted good. Can't wait to be back now that the weather is getting warmer and Briermere farms is open again. read more

See all

June 2026 Went to Briemere farms to buy a nice delicious pie. Today's pick! We chose Strawberry Cream Pie. The Cream is DELICIOUS!!! read more

See all

Growing up on Long Island, making the trip out to Briermere Farms for Thanksgiving pies is one of my favorite traditions, and clearly, I'm not alone. Briermere is a true Long Island favorite! Every year, my family and I brave the drive and it's always 100% worth it. We always make sure to pick up three pies: the classic apple, the pumpkin, and our absolute must have, the apple crumb. The apple crumb is a personal favorite, the topping has the perfect amount of crumb, and try it warm with vanilla ice cream .. chefs kiss.We also never leave without a box of their chocolate chip cookies with pecans, and if you haven't tried their apple butter, you're missing out. Spread it on toast or pastries and it's absolutely delicious. The farm stand itself is so cute, especially around the holidays. They have fresh breads, jams, and seasonal produce! Whether you're grabbing corn, tomatoes or berries, they have it all. Even though Briermere gets extremely busy, especially right before Thanksgiving, the staff have the whole system down to a science. The traffic can get crazy with so many people picking up their pies, but there are always people out there directing cars, guiding people safely across the parking lot, directing the lines, and keeping everything organized and moving smoothly. It's clear how much they value their customers, even during the rush! Briermere Farms is as much about the memories as it is the pies and treats. If you're anywhere near Riverhead or just looking for the best pies on Long Island, a trip to Briermere should absolutely be on your holiday to-do list! read more

Briermere Farms - Bakeries Near Me - Riverhead, New York

Came and got the blueberry cream pie and chocolate cream pie. Decided to stop by and try out these flavors bc we loved their peach cream pie. Blueberry was good and the chocolate was okay but neither cake could match up to the peach pie which is not available this season. Highly recommend coming for the peach pie. read more

Briermere Farms - Blueberry cream - Bakeries Near Me - Riverhead, New York

See all

I've known the owner for quite a while now, a true gentleman and one of the hardest working people I know. His products are the real deal. My mom LOVED their pies, and her college buddy was Julia Childs ( they kinda knew quality food ). I love their Peach Juice too. You cant go wrong there. Enjoy and bon appetite read more

I don't want to be dramatic but my life changed when I discovered Briermere Farms. I've heard of them for YEARS as the best pie you can get in NY state. As a certified pie-lover, and having been here twice now, I can confirm that I 100% agree. This was DELICIOUS. First of all, almost all the pies I got were even better after a day or two in the fridge. Menu changes daily, you can order ahead as well for pickup. Came around 3pm on a Saturday in October and ordered at the kiosk and they still had everything I wanted. BLUEBERRY PIE - was soooo divine. If it's warm, give it a few hours to cool down. Once it congeals, it is such a treat. It brings me so much joy and I wish I had my fridge stocked constantly with this pie. I also got the BLUEBERRY CRISP PIE literally the next weekend because I was obsessed, and back in the area. Mind you I live in NYC. But I had an opportunity to go back out here and would lie if I didn't say coming back here was part of my decision to do so, The crisp adds such a nice texture, though it is harder/crunchier than you would think, but again, once everything sets and the texture homogenizes a bit in the fridge - even more divine. Also tried the PUMPKIN PIE, APPLE CRISP PIE and they were similarly delicious. The pumpkin pie, though, is not too sweet, and is pumpkin-forward, really honoring the freshness of that pumpkin. The apples are nice and cinnamony and beautifully sweet. My friend got the STRAWBERRY RHUBARB which I found a bit more tart than I prefer, but was still really fresh and enjoyable. It's also not just about the pies. I got their fresh peach juice, a gallon of their apple cider, some of their cookes, and let me tell you that you can just taste how fresh everything is and how much love goes into their products. I also walked away with their apricot jam - and yes, delicious. RUN!! Do not walk. My life is sooooo much better now that Briermere Farms is in my life. read more

See all

The pros are that it's pretty close to the Riverhead area near the outlets and highways, the bathroom is relatively nice and well maintained, they have a good selection of juice (apple, cherry, peach, raspberry, blueberry), the flower selection is beautiful, and I've heard the pies are very good but haven't tried them. The pumpkin square was pretty good. The cons are that they don't sell pie slices by the slice which is what I was really hoping for, they don't have apple cider donuts, and there is nowhere to sit and eat. The service is kind of rushed and not super friendly. Overall good spot! read more

Briermere Farms - Pumpkin square - Bakeries Near Me - Riverhead, New York

See all

Everyone is picking up fruit, begs, flowers, pies at Briermere!'s! If you think you're going to breeze in fast on Sunday In August after 10 and mot have a crowd... well.. forgeddaboudit! Lol Everyone's patient and the line moves reasonably well. Everything is fresh and delicious here - and a mist have if put here. If you don't need A whole apple pie ... they have tartlets - same flakey soft pie crust and Apple inside. This is definitely the place for Long Island's best corn muffin. Ironically they taste even better the next day. It's been said that one of the brothers took a year perfecting the recipe. Heading back with the most indulgent item they have - Strawberry cream pie. And some fresh locally grown plums. read more

See all

Stopped by on the way home around 4pm and wanted to pick up one of their peach cream pie. My friend use to always picked one up on the way home from the area but the prices definitely been increasing as more influencers stop by since. I understand, but its pretty hefty for a pie. $50 is alot for a craving. Would be really nice if they can come out with a smaller options that might be in the $15-20 range. 1 star off because the value you get isn't the greatest. Beside that, the line moves fast and the parking was okay (we were lucky). Didnt had time to look at their produce selection that days since I didn't want to miss getting the pie. read more

Briermere Farms - Peach cream pie - Bakeries Near Me - Riverhead, New York

Everything I have had from here has been fabulous, from Pie to Egg Bread to huge brussels sprouts to sweet corn on the cob. Everything is so fresh and delicious! If you visit, don't leave without an Egg Bread! It's truly outstanding; it is reminiscent of my mother's homemade challah; I have never found any other that even comes close! It's dense yet fluffy; it doesn't need anything to stand out; makes excellent French Toast, but is delicious with just butter or with nothing at all! It also freezes very well! read more

Holy cow Brieremere Farms, youve ruined all other pies for me. Yup, you've read that read that correctly. ALL OTHER PIES! These are most incredible pies I,'ve ever had. Pies I'll gladly drive over an hour for. Every trip feels completely worth it. Stopping here has become a cherished ritual anytime I'm out east. Every pie is homemade and overflowing with fresh flavor, and that quality truly comes through with each delicious bite. While I've loved everything from their fresh strawberry, peach, apple to the strawberry rhubarb, the Raspberry Cream Pie stands in a league of its own. It's the best I've ever tasted, with a flaky crust, luxuriously rich and tangy filling, and a smooth cream layer that makes it perfectly decadent. A word of advice: order ahead when you can, especially in peak seasons. These pies sell out fast--and it's easy to see why. The line does get long in the summer and around holidays, but the staff keeps it moving smoothly and stays wonderfully friendly. And honestly, once you take your first bite, any wait is instantly forgotten. I love bringing their pies as gifts. They're always a huge hit and leave everyone impressed. Simply put, a trip out east feels incomplete without a visit to this absolute gem of a farm. read more

The hype about the most expensive pie is REAL! Peach cream pie was well worth my $48 - I mean, it was literally peaches GALORE! Worth the visit - super organized, friendly staff & delicious options! Oh my! If you don't make the stop here, you're surely missing out! read more

Briermere Farms - Bakeries Near Me - Riverhead, New York

Oooof. The raspberry cream pie was better than I imagined. I have been dreaming of this pie for at least 2 years. I've never made the 3hr drive just to eat pie, but a friend came back from the Hamptons this weekend and brought one back for me. A thick layer of raspberry compote. An even thicker layer of rich, stiff cream with a hint of tang from cream cheese. A sugar cookie like crust. This pie is everything and more. It's the second best fruit pie I've ever had (Beachlake Bakery....) and definitely the best cream pie. I saw the peach cream pie, and I guess I'll have to wait till next year. I'm going to make it there person! read more

The pies from Briermere deserve 5 stars. We have tried over 8 different flavors of pie and each and everyone is worth the trip and the price. They also have a small amount of other baked goods as well as a small amount of locally grown vegetables and flowers that can be purchased. Although parking can sometimes be tricky it is usually pretty quick to open up as the check out line is quick and efficient. They have menu boards posted through out the line so you can get an idea of what you want before checking out. We've tried some other baked goods from them such as cookies, muffins, and other specialty items. Unfortunately these don't fall in the 5 star category. It seems that regardless of the item or flavor it is supposed to be, the taste falls flat in comparison to many other places. If you're going to briermere, skip the other baked goods and go for the pies. They are visually pleasing and the taste is out of the is world. You will not be disappointed in the quality or the selection. read more

See all

Nice farm stand with great offerings. Pies are amazing and they had great fresh juices. Pricey but the pie was absolutely loaded with fresh fruit. Chocolate cream pie was super tasty as well. Ordering system was efficient and went pretty quickly. read more

Briermere Farms - Blueberry Strawberry Cream - Bakeries Near Me - Riverhead, New York

Smaller than what I anticipated. The Apple crisp pie is really really good. Service was very quick. They package the pies very well too. The produce is a bit overpriced overall in my opinion compared to the other farms around. read more

See all

Their pies are everything! Brought family who have a sweet tooth and were visiting from out of state here and they were windblown. We made a little Long Island Fall day trip out of it by visiting Briermere Farms, local wineries, etc. we had the fresh cream pies and enjoyed it immensely. read more

See all

Whenever I'm in the area I must stop by for some fresh flowers, jams and baked goods. read more

See all

I have been hearing about these pies for years and found myself driving right past the farm for work. I immediately parked, there was no line (!!!), and got my raspberry cream pie- everyone I spoke to recommended this particular pie. I think it was $36, kind've steep but when I got home and opened it up OMG. It's prob like $20 in raspberries alone, well worth the price tag. The crust is so buttery, the cream is light and not too sweet and the raspberry top is perfect. Even my dessert picky husband was pleasantly surprised. Definitely coming back and would love to try other pies! read more

Briermere Farms - Bakeries Near Me - Riverhead, New York

See all

Fresh fruit cream pies here are sooo good! Wish I could find something even close to this in the city. Meanwhile we get a fix at least once a year with the 2 hr plus trek. Yes, it's THAT good read more

Came here on a weekday afternoon. No lines. Went straight to register. Service was great! Ordered the peach cream pies, oatmeal raisin cookies, chocolate chip with pecans, and banana bread. It made it all the way back to queens! Over 1hr and a half drive! It survived the drive ! The pie was still intact and didn't melt! The pie was so so fresh and delicious and cream was not so sweet! The cookies were delish! The banana bread was a bit dry. Will definitely be back for more pies and cookies!!!!! read more

See all

Ive been. buying the cherry cream pie for years, did you change the recipe? It has jam in the cherries and the crust was freezer burnt, so disappointing. read more

Second visit here. It's nice in the off season without a line. Last time we were here my buddy picked up a fruit cream pie. I liked it, but my friend is an absolute fanatic about their fruit cream pies. This time I bamboozled him into getting a blueberry crumb pie. It was the platonic idea of a pie. It was expensive, but the pie was enormous and fed our big group with ease. Highly recommended! read more

So made the drive from Nassau to Suffolk for my friend whom loves pies . They have a small market for produce ( prices are equivalent if not more than stores ) and some plants. We got the peach cream pie a lemon bar a peach muffin apple butter and their homemade fruit juice. The pie was good the preachers weren't t he sweetest but we ate a third of it right there. There are some benches to sit and eat but bring your own plates ! The lemon bar was mediocre and the muffin as well wasn't ever overwhelmed with peach flavor. The juice was good service was fine you stand in line and are called down and place your order. read more

See all

I love most of their pies that I have tasted. The coconut meringue is a newfound favorite. As well as the peach raspberry, cherries and cream pie both apple pies and my son loves the honey sticks. If you are in the area, you should definitely pay them a visit. They are expensive, but worth the price. read more

Briermere Farms is always a stop we make on our way to North Fork every summer. The farmstand is not very large, but you won't be able to miss it because so many cars pull in and out. In addition to their famous pies, Briermere Farms also sells juices, plants, fresh produce, jams and jellies, and baked goods. They are most well-known for their raspberry cream pie ($35) which is also my favorite. The crust is intensely buttery and flaky, while the whipped cream is lightly sweet and the fresh raspberry jam topping is tart and zippy (and seedy). Their peach cream pie ($45) is also phenomenal, with fresh soft peaches piled on top. There are tons of cash registers on hand, so while the line may seem long, it moves fairly quickly. If you are planning on transporting a cream pie home, they also sell insulated bags too, as the pies should not stay outside for more than 2-3 hours. I always pick up a slushie drink or two as well-- they usually come in the same flavor as the juices in the fridge but with a more satisfying texture (plus, you can mix the two flavors). read more

See all

Food was Pie and more Pie!! Fresh jam, preserves and cider! Just the best on Long Island. Just go!

This place was recommended by a local while we were in town. In a matter of 3 days we had 3 pies!! Two of the strawberry and blueberry cream pie and a chocolate cream pie. WOW is all we could say for days about these pies!! Huge, filling, fresh and just delicious!! We seriously couldn't decide which was our fav, chocolate or berry cream pie. read more

See all

Like always, a wonderful selection of homemade fruit and cream pies, cider, local corn. Local east end tomatoes are not ready until around July 24, but the ones from Georgia look nice. Don't worry about the line, it moves quickly and staff are helpful and easygoing. read more

See all

Always wonderful; long lines but move fast with a lot of workers. As a baker myself (person not professional) I'm fussy & enjoy all their treats read more

I see what all the hype is about, this raspberry crème pie was good. I might need to get a frozen mail order of this read more

Briermere Farms - The Fresh Fruit Raspberry Cream pie - Bakeries Near Me - Riverhead, New York

See all

Briermiere might be my new North Fork tradition wine tasting in one hand, pie fork in the other. Their apple pie is perfection: buttery crust that melts in your mouth without being soggy, filling that's sweet without being cloying. Pro tip: check the menu ahead, because there's usually a line. It moves fast, but you'll want to be ready so you can grab your pie and get back to your wine. read more

Simply put, it ain't what it used to be. Briermere has gone the way of Entenmanns. They thrive off a name that earned reverence and mystique. Now it's like The Emperors New Clothes. People seem somehow afraid to speak the truth. The pie is just not good anymore. It doesn't even seem as if they bake on site anymore. You're better off picking up a pie at any farm stand along the North Road. read more

Everything looked delicious! I played it safe with the apple crisp pie! Delish!!! Will have to go back for another kind!