Ordered Stucs from Grubhub/DoorDash? through Yelp…read more The experience doing that was about 2-stars, because the delivery time was off and the driver did not view or was unable to view my directions. One of the options was for the driver to text when dropping off the pizza in the hotel lobby. He did not, so the concierge had to call my cell phone. Not a big deal, but also not seamless. Because of this, the pizza was lukewarm. Again, not ideal, but we had a microwave in the room. That said, the pizza was delicious. We got a regular pan type 3-meat pizza and we loved it. There was just the right meat to cheese ratio, where you could taste all ingredients and not feel overwhelmed by one element over another. That can be a huge challenge with these meat pizzas. I would come back, but definitely will not use the Yelp app to order delivery. I think we want to try the deep dish next, since I am a self-proclaimed expert on the topic. With the delivery issues, I would have rated 3-stars or less, but I know that the experience was not Stucs-related.

This is purely a Pizza Review, but this is the worst pizza my family and I have ever had. Too much…read moresauce, and the sauce is too rich, kind of tasted like a lunchable pizza, but worse. The service was good and the ambiance is nice, but the pizza is so bad it has to be a 1 star review. We got a traditional hand tossed and a deep dish, deep dish was better but not by much.

Great pizza cooked in a Faulds oven old school. Supper thin full of flavor. This is a must try if…read moreyou're a pizza snob.

Well, I have lived in Appleton for six years. Why didn't I find this place before?! Cracker thin…read morecrust and just the right amount of toppings. The only improvement would be better napkins. I will be back again and again.

Atmosphere: Really relaxed vibe. Nice indoor and outdoor seating areas. There is a water refill…read morestation by the patio doors. They have an ordering station to place your orders for food/beer. They have a ton of board games to play while you drink or wait for your food. Great place to meet up to wind down. I've been here twice, once for drinks and once for food. Great experiences both times. Service: Friendly and informative. They have a slim team but are incredibly efficient. Food: They pizza is incredible, the crust is untouchable. I ordered the Dirty Martini pizza (they don't have it anymore *cries in salty olive tears*). This pizza is one of a kind. If anyone else had this available in the Fox Valley I would go there every week to get my fix. It's salty, savory, creamy, crunchy and CRAVE-ABLE. We ordered one other pizza on the menu that is a standard offering, The 99 Corvette. This was okay but we both fought over who got more pieces of the Dirty Martini Pizza. I can't wait to come back here for more fun.

Hop Yard has a relaxed, casual atmosphere and seems consciously geared toward the hipster/affluent…read moreworking professional crowd. Their staff are friendly and seem to enjoy themselves. They do not have physical menus or servers to take people's orders; customers scan a QR code to get the online menu and order at the bar area. I can't speak to the craft beer and wine aspect to the restaurant, but they do offer some delicious craft sodas for people looking for nonalcoholic options. Although they have "normal" woodfire pizza choices (traditional pepperoni, cheese, etc.), the highlight is their rotating menu of inventive specialty savory and dessert pizzas. I found their "normal" pizza to be just ok, but the tomato soup pizza (Souper Slice) was incredibly flavorful and unique! It's definitely worth taking the leap of faith for some of their more out-there sounding pizza options. Since they have limited oven space to cook the pizzas, food can take a while to come out if it's busy. Plan ahead and use that time to relax and enjoy their drinks, or come during an off-peak time for less wait.

I'm so happy I finally tried this place! I had the mac daddy pizza, and unlike every other mac &…read morecheese pizza I've had, it was an alfredo sauce base instead of cheese sauce.. and it WORKED! It was way better this way. The cheese curds were delicious too, and the cinna nugs were one of the best desserts I've ever had.

Went in to pick up a pizza and noticed a special: $4 cheesy bread with a pizza purchase. I asked if…read moreI could add it to my order, and the guy flatly said no. I wasn't asking for anything crazy, just to add a $4 item that was advertised in store (it wasn't even listed on their website, so I didn't know about it beforehand). No offer to help, no coupon, nothing, just a hard no, delivered like I'd asked for something unreasonable. On top of that, the total came to over $40 for one large and one small pizza, which already felt steep. Combined with the unhelpful service, it just wasn't worth it.

I came here for the kringle and was not disappointed. They have several flavors out to sample, but…read morenot all flavors. I ended up getting the Caramel Pecan Kringle and it was delicious. It was even better warmed up a little bit. I wish they had single pieces for sale because I would have loved to get multiple flavors. The half Kringle is already a pretty big size to commit to, so I couldn't get more than one.

I've been here several times for 'to go' orders, but hadn't yet been in the restaurant itself. I've…read morenow been twice, and it's great! The first thing to know is that servings are ginormous, so order accordingly! I ordered the breakfast sandwich (just a croissant with some ham and cheese) and it took up the whole plate, no lie! It was also delicious, the cheese was cheesy (and messy, which was a plus and a minus), and the croissant was light and fluffy. I also had one of their flavored lattes, and it was delicious as well. I know they use homemade syrups and it shows. Pro tip though-the lattes fill you up (not so great when they also give you huge portions of food). The staff is friendly, and service is pretty good. On our second visit we did wait quite a while for our food-it was busy, but not packed, so that felt a little off. But otherwise service has been great. They do have an outdoor seating area-we unfortunately haven't been able to try it yet, but I would like to as it looks great!

I feel like I just had a Michelin level meal experience…read more Tuna Tataki was tonight's special - so unbelievably tasty I ordered it twice! Mouth feel and flavors straight out of a professional sushi restaurant. Well done Chefs The Mary is a true Margherita pizza and the dough/sauce/cheese ratio is perfect. Great crust. Wonderfully cooked in their wood fired oven. Top notch food, kind and attentive service from my server/bartender Courtney, ambiance of great music and the hum of happy folks enjoying their meals. Could not ask for more. I will be back. Many more times. Oh and I took their cake home with a pistachio cream topping - UNREAL!!

Field & Fire is a hidden gem!…read more Delicious entrees, great wines and bourbon complement the cozy atmosphere and service! We loved our dinner, sharing meatballs as appetizers, a perfectly prepared tenderloin and a delicious dessert! Can't wait to come back and try the pizza!

I Came Back to Appleton... Wisconsin Immediately Fed Me…read more There are many ways to kick off an HS Reunion weekend. Apparently, the correct Wisconsin way is cheese curds, a soft pretzel, beer cheese, mustard, and craft beer. One of my host~family sisters and longtime friends brought me to Stone Arch Brewpub shortly after I touched down in Appleton, and this was exactly the kind of welcome~back I needed. Let's talk about those cheese curds. Pillowy. Soft. Tender. Ridiculously good. I don't say this lightly, but these may be some of the best cheese curds I've ever eaten. Then came the pretzel~super buttery and incredibly soft~with Wisconsin beer cheese and mustard for dipping. At that point, the reunion could have ended and I would've considered the trip successful. But we weren't done. We worked our way through an assortment of craft beers spanning Hazy IPAs, West Coast IPAs, Sours and Gose~style beers. The atmosphere was cool, the service was great, and the combination of food, beer and catching up with an old friend made this feel like the perfect beginning to my return to Appleton. Sometimes the best travel experiences aren't about finding the newest or trendiest place. Sometimes it's about sitting down with someone who knows you, sharing some great food and beer, and realizing some things really do feel like coming home. Stone Arch was a damn good way to start the reunion. Would absolutely return.

The food was delicious. The waitress was kind and accommodating, and the service was excellent. I…read moreloved the warm glow of the restaurant and the feel of It's beautiful, rustic and historical decor. I didn't wanna leave! I will surely be back.

Chef's kiss! What a great little place. Pleasant but nondescript interior, mix of booths and…read moretables. We stopped late on a sunny Saturday afternoon, and it was not busy at all. Ordered breadsticks as an appetizer and a 14" Luigi's Special, which I'm told is the most popular choice. It should be. Wow! After our breadsticks, which came quickly, were piping hot, crusty on the outside and soft on the inside, the pizza arrived - and it was superb. Very tasty, great quality toppings (which I won't list, leaving to you to look up on the menu), very nice thin crust, and lovely sauce. I packed away a little more than I should've, because it was so good. Eating for pleasure, right? So yes, highly recommended, and we will be back.

I have been a customer of Luigi's since day one. They have very tasty food and it is affordable. I…read morenever tried the Cannelloni until today. Wow. It is fantastic. Too often the beef is a bit dry or runny with sauce. Not at Luigi's it was perfect.

I love their pizza. The crust is my favorite part but when it's burnt it's not so good. Little…read moredisappointed in the customer service.

Nice place, larger inside than it looks outside. There is a patio for dining al fresco. It's dark…read moreand cozy inside. The booths have a very private feel. I enjoyed the ambiance. Service was friendly and fast. I think there only two servers working the floor. They were flying! We ordered eggplant fries for an appetizer and they were delicious. Our pizza was the Wiseguy Loaded Extra, and was great. Hand tossed crust was cooked perfectly, not soggy or doughy in the middle at all. Toppings were good, the cheese was very good. The onions were sweet and tasty. We'll be back for more of the pizza. The only false note was the "pint" of Guinness. The wee glass would get you laughed out of the place in Ireland! It looked like a 12 ounce glass, not 16 for sure. Even on the tab it said "pint". But otherwise a fine place and we will come back for sure. Edit: I see our server's name is Zachary. Nice job, man!

Yay! Just stopped at Sal's, my old stomping ground pizzeria…read morefrom party nights in Appleton. Awesome slices and great service, nothing has changed. Tried the new lasagna pizza, awesome... My wife got the chicken, bacon, ranch slice and said it was the best she ever had! That is saying something, since she is quite picky about her favorite type of pizza everyone... Take note Sal's rocks. Always has. Ooooooooh yeahhhhhh!

Margarita pizza, but no basil! Veggie pizza all tasted like cardboard. The Cannolis was not…read moreedible.