One of the best gf crusts we have tried. Normally, we make our own crusts at home. We were away from home and traveling with another Celiac person. Small town Michigan is not where we expected to find such amazing crusts! Service was good, albeit stressed. Our server was covering over half of the restaurant and doing very well. My only suggestion is bigger TVs to attract the sports viewing crowd read more

Darling Italian restaurant in downtown Bay City. My margarita was OK. I had the BLT Pizza, but it lacked bacon. Sat outside, which was nice. read more

See all

Ordered your Brooklyn Boys Pizza and it was the worst pizza ever. Cold when it was delivered and it looked like all the ingredients were just thrown on pieces were cut so big I could barely hold on to it. Very disappointed as I was really hungry for pizza. read more

This place is a true gem! I took my brother here and it was the first time for both of us! Coming from Southern California, and living in metropolitan areas, such as Chicago, where pizza and Italian food are king, BB really showed up! The service was amazing and the food was even better!! I had the pasta meatballs, while my brother had the fettuccine Alfredo! Both dishes were on point! I imbibed on some Moscato wine, and that was to die for! The calamari app was outstanding! I will definitely be visiting Brooklyn Boyz again, when I am in Bay City!!! Great job everyone! read more

Brooklyn Boyz Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bay City, Michigan

See all

Ordered a large custom pizza. Had a thinner NY style crust, which I like. I was just passing through Bay City and didn't want to order from a chain. Good value. If I lived there, I would order again. read more

On a busy Friday night in town,surrounded by lots of pretty classic cars in the closed out main street,we were hungry and super excited to try pizza in this place. The menu is big,staff are busy yet super accomodating and quick to attend to all their customers,and we were allowed to sit outside accompanied by our pup. We ordered Margaritas and a large chef's special pizza-even before we had a taste,a customer nearby started raving out loud that "it's the best pizza she ever had in her life"! Whilst I wouldn't be so brave to make such a statement,both the pizza and the cocktails were yummy,and I'd highly recommend others to make a stop when in the area,and order some! read more

Brooklyn Boyz Pizza - Margarita - Pizza Near Me - Bay City, Michigan

See all

We were looking for some good pizza in the area. We picked this as I came highly rated. Oh boy, did they not disappoint! This pizza was absolutely delicious. We made a few customizations to the vegetarian pizza. We had the regular crust and real cheese, but they do have vegan options here which was a huge excitement for us as we are vegetarian. We would love to have tried all the vegan options as well. The crust of this pizza is light and airy and absolutely fantastic. The sauce is one of a kind and handmade in house. You will not be disappointed if you come to this restaurant. The service is amazing and very friendly. The inside of this restaurant is definitely decorated with a New York vibe. We will return again when in the area and try their other menu options. read more

See all

Even though I came here in the middle of the day and there wasnt very many people there my Server went above and beyond. He got me my drinks nearly as soon as they were finished and was on top of it! I will definitely be coming back here with friends so they can see how good it is here. The food was also A++++ i loved it and will be getting food here agin it tasted just as delicious as it looked my pizza was cooked perfectly i loved it read more

See all

I got large pizza and it wasn't cooked properly! And the manager Kevin has no hospitality! They suck!!

My husband and I were driving through Bay City on our way home from a jaunt around the thumb and wanted an easy dinner we could grab as takeout and enjoy by the river during sunset. Pizza? Yes, pizza fits that bill perfectly. I found Brooklyn Boyz on Yelp and made a call from our car. 20 minutes later, we were scooping up a delicious order of garlic knots and a 14 inch deluxe with pepperoni, ham, mushrooms, onions, and green peppers. We got it to the park just a few minutes away and enjoyed a truly delicious, piping hot pizza and fantastic garlic knots. It really is very, very good. The gal that took my order and rang up up at the bar was VERY nice. The space inside is small but has some nice seating with an old school pizza parlor meets pub vibe. It was so welcoming I kinda regretted not dining in person but that waterfront sunset was pretty great so no complaints either way. Yay Brooklyn Boyz! Keep up the good 'za! read more

Brooklyn Boyz Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bay City, Michigan

See all

Servers are a little gæ but the food is pretty good. :) ....... ....... ......... ........ ....... ..... ....... .... Pizza is good. Round sausage, black, black olives. Bud light and Budweiser read more

Just over priced bowling alley quality pizza, no crisp to it and super greasy. We got the garlic trio knots, pepperoni pizza, and a Cesar salad and spent $50... read more

Brooklyn Boyz Pizza - Greasy pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bay City, Michigan

Loved the vegan options at Brooklyn Boyz and can't wait to stop back! Unfortunately, our visit was twice as long as expected because they had to remake one of the pizzas (dairy free, not vegan), as the normal sauce has parmesan in it. The staff member was apologetic and luckily it didn't cause any real issues. I highly recommend getting an XL for leftovers, it reheats well! read more

Brooklyn Boyz Pizza - The Vegan Specialty Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bay City, Michigan

See all

We really enjoyed the food here. The garlic knots were fresh and tasted so good, and the portion was generous. The white pizza was our favorite especially with ricotta, and the veggie pizza was also very good. It's a small dining room but there's also outdoor seating in the nicer months. I recommend making a reservation on weekends. Our server was nice and kept checking on us. read more

See all

We ordered a cheese pizza without sauce on July 22. Odd request because it was our dogs Birthday, we even explained that. We also ordered a pizza with ham and pineapple. We picked up the pizza headed to a local brewery found the plain pizza had sauce. So big disappointment. Also the pizza is pretty expensive and not great. We did not call and complain as we had our dog and didn't have time to wait even longer. I'm sure it seems silly to say we were celebrating our dog but we are still paying customers and it wasn't busy at the time either. read more

This place is a Bay City treasure. Awesome pizza. Great Italian food. The restaurant is so great. Love the atmosphere. Old school Italian. The users are the absolute best. They too are Bay City Treasures. They exemplify the word service. This place is the best. Must have! Order now! read more

I tried Brooklyn Boyz Pizza for the first time last week. I only intended to have a slice. I knew from the first bite that theres no way Iwould only have one. I ended up having 4. Excellent pizza. read more

Wow! Just wow, wow, wow! This is my favorite pizza in Michigan I think! So many items on the menu sounded great. The decor is wood, warm and cozy pizzeria style. We wanted to go again, but they are closed on Sundays and Mondays. read more

Brooklyn Boyz Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bay City, Michigan

See all

terrible environment not to mention I found a bright red hair in my pizza I do not recommend if you're looking for good pizza

Pizza was really good and so was the calzone! Service was great as well. Didn't eat as the establishment so can't comment on how it was inside. read more

Same as it was other times we ventured up to Bay City... delicious! I opted for my usual Margarita pizza and my husband got a calzone which was huge! Always get the garlic knots !!! read more

Brooklyn Boyz Pizza - Margarita pizza (fresh basil ) - Pizza Near Me - Bay City, Michigan

Awesome time as always at BB's. Kevin & staff do a great job, above and beyond with service and making sure the experience is superb. A few glasses of wine, meatballs, garlic knots, Spinach dip, and the ravioli. Literally everything we ordered was good. They have somewhat of a smaller menu allowing them to be really good at the things they do offer. The Lobster and Crab ravioli (real crab, real lobster) is out of this world. A staple and must have. read more

I cannot tell you enough how divine their pizza is. I don't care where else you're thinking of going, forget those places and bring your business here. Not only is the food fantastic, the service is superb and the owner, Kevin, is incredible, walking around to most every table and getting guests and working just as hard in every role like the rest of his staff does. You'll love this place just as much as we do... we drove 6 hours for it read more

See all

Excellent dishes on Friday at a staple in downtown Bay City. Kevin & his staff did a fantastic job with swift service and a welcoming environment. Pizza was fresh right out of oven & pasta dishes were creamy and hot! read more

See all

Just had dinner there this evening. Wonderful service and great food! Chicken Parmesan and chicken Alfredo, perfect'!

Food was fantastic and came out quick. Started with drinks and garlic knots. All 3 of us ordered an entree. I had the Lobster and Crab ravioli, wife had chicken fettuccine Alfredo and her dad ordered the shrimp fettuccine Alfredo, I don't eat shrimp, but they said it was the best they've had, I tried my wife's chicken Alfredo and it was tender and juicy and well seasoned chicken in a fantastic Alfredo. And the lobster and crab ravioli made with real crab and lobster in a sauce I do not know, but it was amazing, and Im Not much of a seafood person. Really a nice restaurant with a great atmosphere and amazing service. The only reasons I don't give it a 5 star is the loud live music that made it very difficult to have conversations with my wife and Father in law as we were seated in front of the guy singing and playing though talented at those, he couldn't remember all the lyrics to majority of the songs he played The pics are of after we started eating. The entrees all started with a salad before the main was brought out. Definitely amazing and will be going back for sure read more

See all

The food is outstanding, the owner Kevin is great. The staff also is great! Great atmosphere!

We found this restaurant on Yelp and decided to give it some try. What a wonderful experience! It's a small intimate Italian restaurant with incredible food!!!! We had an awesome waiter, snd even visited with the owner. They were very busy but still gave incredible service. Highly recommend this establishment!! read more

We bought two pizzas from here Saturday night and will never again!! The sauce was insignificant and tasteless and the toppings were a joke!! There was hardly any toppings and the green pepper and onion were sliced so thin that they truly look like strings. A waste of $36!!! read more

Brooklyn Boyz Pizza - Brooklyn Boyz pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bay City, Michigan

See all

Brooklyn Boyz has been highly recommended by my dear friend A G. forever, and we finally had the opportunity to try it out. The food was excellent and the service was great too. We started out with the garlic knots which were excellent, and enjoyed the pesto pasta and the creamy smoked pasta. Highly recommend! read more

Brooklyn Boyz Pizza - Creamy chicken presto pasta - Pizza Near Me - Bay City, Michigan

See all

It used to be much better. Garlic knots are still very good and the best item on the menu. The alfredo sauce lacks flavor and tastes like it was bought from a store. read more

This place is good but very expensive the pasta was 20 dollars that's way overpriced for a pasta

Pretty exceptional take away pizza. Had the large veggie and it was outstanding. Reasonable prices too for the quality. One of better pizzas I've had in recent years. read more

My sister loves the pizza here and we were excited they had gluten free options. I got extremely sick from gluten cross contamination. I don't think they have a separate prep space, oven space, or knowledge of cross contamination here. If you have celiac definitely steer clear! read more

THE KNOTS, oh my! Homemade garlic knots are a must on your visit! Pizza, Italian staples, good selection of reasonably priced drinks, wine and beer. Plus dinner entertainment on the weekends-- acoustic, blues, etc. Friendly and attentive service staff. Expect a wait on weekends-- they will take number and give you estimated time. Plenty of bars nearby to grab a drink while you wait. read more

We recently ordered takeout from Brooklyn Boyz and I have to say we were really impressed. The pasta and salad and soup we had were superb. The fact that the pasta wasn't overcooked set Brooklyn Boyz apart from almost any other midlevel Italian restaurant and the salad was fresh and the soup was hearty and not over salted. We will definite be back. Just be warned the food is rich and the servings are generous. read more

Kind waitress, fast service, crunch out side soft inside calamari, yummy Alfredo pasta, perfect cooked lasagna, good dough pizza, warm lightly seasoned tomato soup. This place made me instantly happy. Pleasant experience during family trip here. I am recommend this place if you are around this area. read more

See all

Great Staff and owners, very accommodating. Food is great ... real East Coast Italian, almost as good as my Grandmother made. Good place for a date or group. Regular Customers from the neighborhood become family quickly. read more

Great food every time. Always wonderful service. And I really appreciate their attention to detail when it comes to gluten free!

Great food and drinks. The garlic knots with blush sauce yum. 10/10 recommend the Pompeii pizza