Best pizza I've had since I left Jersey in 2019. I've tried a lot of pizza since we moved here and I mean a lot of pizza but Brooklyn Joe's is the best hands down! I would highly recommend but definitely you will need a bib as the grease needs about a roll of paper towels lol! Yum!!! read more

food is over priced and is no where near the quality of Carmela's of Stuart. owner told me when i had a complaint that i should order else where. something i shared with friends who will no longer eat there. Nathan is a very rude owner in my opinion. i give this place an "f" . i would rather have a frozen pizza than eating this crap. read more

I had what truly amazed me as I didn't really have high hopes for but a 100% genuinely delicious Philly Cheesesteak sandwich at Brooklyn Joes Pizzeria, SE Dixie, Stuart. Green peppers hate me so I had onions, mushrooms and american cheese (a tad extra che ‍). I will definitely go back for another. I know the pizza is great and so is Lasagna. No small size pizza which is tough for 1 person but I get a slice to go sometimes. Ciao read more

Came up to Stuart for the Air show and was craving pizza after going to the gym read the reviews and had to try since the pizza place we normally go to was closing at 8pm. Great Chicago style pizza read more

Brooklyn Joe's - Sicilian pizza with sausage, green peppers and black olives - Pizza Near Me - Stuart, Florida

I've lived in Mariner Sands for 10 years & just discovered Brooklyn Joe's Pizza! OMG! I can't believe what I missed! Super-thin, perfect crust, delicious Italian pizza just like the Pescuma family in Long Island always made! TRUE NEW YORK PUZZA! "Right here in River City." Oops. I mean Stuart! And only 10 minutes away! Two days later back for more with my daughter who also couldn't believe it. We ate there & are hooked! read more

My favorite white pizza of all time. My go to order is 1/2 Greek and 1/2 White add pepperoni. When visiting Stuart, I'll get this pizza once a week. It's my favorite pizza place...period. read more

Brooklyn Joe's - 1/2 Greek and 1/2 White with Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Stuart, Florida

I'm going to give me honest opinion. we ordered a sausage, peppers and onions pizza and the cheese was nonexistent. Really minimal cheese. And they claim to be a New York style pizza, no where close. The pizza is right in line with Pizza Hut quality and taste. The crust was so thin that the pizza just folds down when you pick it up. The most disappointing part is we bought two. this is my honest review. thin crust, no cheese, and the taste. It really taste and looks like a Pizza Hit pizza? But twice the cost. read more

A true New Yorker strives to find a local pizza spot as close to nyc as possible and this is it! I ordered online. The restaurant is in a busy plaza adjacent to Barton's jewelry. I walked in to a full restaurant-pleasantly high energy filled with pleased patrons. Walked up to the counter, was greeted and handed my fresh hot pie. Got home had a slice...mind blown!!!! Delicious is an understatement! Attentive fresh ingredients. The pizza dough is to die for-thin but stable, crispy but not burnt. Light but flavorful. Thank you to the staff and owner-I'll be back definitely!! FYI-I ordered a pie with extra cheese and half pepperoni. I always order extra cheese because most places are cheap with their cheese..but not here. So much that next time I will forgo the extra cheese! read more

Brooklyn Joe's - Fresh pepperoni and extra cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Stuart, Florida

See all

I found half a roach in my Italian sub! The driver picked his nose before handling orders!

Brooklyn Joe's thin pizza is my family's favorite. Anytime we are in the area we are sure to stop by for a pie or two The pizza is consistently hot & fresh. They have indoor seating & a couple of outdoor tables. The staff is always helpful & friendly. They are closed on Sundays. We highly recommend to everyone read more

Our neighbor always order from Brooklyns. Our favorite is nonna pizza. They wings are delicious.

Love this spot! Gluten free pizza and wings are our go to! Yum!!!!! Recommend this spot! read more

See all

Delicious pizza and wings. The cooks provide good service, but I don't recommend dining inside, but outside dining is nice if the weather is good. The wings used to be priced really good, just over a dollar a wing, but they quickly went up in price. This was disappointing and lumped the restaurant in with everybody else, Post Covid-craze. read more

Love the pizza. Just a little neighborhood place inexpensive and the people are nice. Nothing fancy's

absolutely the greasiest and worst pizza i have ever had!! skimpy toppings not fresh, no flavor just dripping pooling heart burning grease.

We always order our pizza from Brooklyn Joes but for awhile it wasn't the same pizza we were use to getting. Last night 4/3/25 we tried it again and we were delighted. Kudo's to the pizza maker who made our pie. It was outstanding. I hope he/she makes our pie whenever we order. read more

Fantastic thin Grandma's Pizza and garlic knots! They also cook a nice white pie and so much more. Great delivery. Recommend!

Amazing service, good food, and great prices! We had pizza with the wings special and the salads were tasty.

Pizza tastes nasty. Steak and cheese sub is tasty but could use additional steak. Fried zeppole's are awesome.

From the reviews we expected greatness but we all thought it was simply good. Service was excellent. Garlic knots were excellent. Pizza was a bit bland, greasy and soggy. Pools of grease. And there were no meats on it. Just peppers and shrooms. read more

He made me feel like I was getting New York pizza before flying home to Florida for Christmas

We ordered Pizzas to go for our group. Good pizza! Nice thin crust and lots of toppings. I'll be back!

I cannot say enough wonderful things about this restaurant. Recently moved to this area, we experienced waiting for our movers to arrive as they were a week late. Having a dog, we felt getting a pizza and a salad was an easy way to eat in our hotel. The first three places we tried were disappointing and we begin to wonder if anyone knew how to make a proper pizza here in Florida. Then we tried Brooklyn Joes! Angels sang and our faith in Italian pizza maker's was restored. Trust me when I say this place is a gem! If you like delicious thin crust pizza, this is your best option. Try the meatballs, the lasagna and anything else because honestly, everything we tried here has been amazing! The prices are moderate definitely not overpriced. This is our go to pizza joint! The staff is friendly and the service fast! Highly recommend Brooklyn Joes! read more

Best pizza, best team that works there, very attentive, great music!!! Great selection of pizzas,salads and the beer is nice and cold! read more

A new find for me in Stuart. Have gotten take-out three straight weeks and have not been disappointed. Have gotten pizza each time and I would say Brooklyn Joe's is my new favorite in Martin County. Got the wings for first time tonight, definitely better than most in the area. Staff has also been very friendly and didn't try to force me to order online when I wanted to phone in my order. If You haven't been here yet, I definitely recommend ordering-up a pie read more

So good! I usually get delivery, always hot and never soggy! Their pizza brings me back to Brooklyn

Good selection of pizza slices available at lunch. My wife and I had the 2 slices with a drink special. I had a meat lover and a cheese slice. My wife had a veggie and cheese slice. We will be back. read more

This place still has the BEST darn NY style pizza in Stuart....hands down!!! Well worthy of 10 stars if that was the option read more

Brooklyn Joe's - Large NY style pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Stuart, Florida

We could NOT BELIEVE this pizza! We ordered a 16" 'The Works' pizza, take out. We ate it hot, we ate it warm and we ate it cold the next day and could not believe how good it was. OHhhh the sauce was perfect...not acidic, spiced to perfection and the cheese was so real, not rubbery and tasteless. We were visiting from outta state and found this by accident, and we both truly feel this was the BEST we've ever experienced. Service was great and pricing was average for the size. We will def go back when we return to the area! read more

Amazing food, never disappointed. Always a go to when your not sure of what you want. I recommend this place all the time. I always order more then I can eat so I would have leftovers. read more

Go to pizza !!!! Eggplant ricotta and sausage !!! This pizza is amazing! I'm not from New York but this pizza is the best pizza we've had in Florida. And the garlic knots...... delicious ! So happy read more

Brooklyn Joe's - Eggplant ricotta and sausage - Pizza Near Me - Stuart, Florida

We called for a pizza pick up, but when we got there we wanted to stay and have our dinner. The staff was nothing but accommodating and laid back, and friendly. We had a beer, they kept our pie warm. Salad was good. The white pizza was very good, thin crust and great cheese! We would go again! Thanks we had a great dinner! read more

Great home cooking. Great pizza. Friendly staff. This is our new favorite pizza place.

This chicken parm was on the money! I was surprised at the bonus garlic knots. The salad was great, it had black olives which I love and what looked like an Italian dry seasoning. Soooo good! I definitely overate and I still have left overs. Good portion size read more

Brooklyn Joe's - Chicken Parm, garlic knots and salad - Pizza Near Me - Stuart, Florida

Brooklyn joes is my favorite pizza in Martin county ! I always get the cheese pizza , they are always consistent & the price is right for a 26 year old on a budget. read more

The best pizza in 100 mile radius. Go see Nate, you can't go wrong... and if gas prices have you down, get your pie on Tuesday or Wednesday and enjoy his specials. read more

I got the Supreme pizza, meatballs and eggplant Parmesan sandwich. All were good and I had food for days.

Went here for the first time yesterday at the recommendation of our friends and wow it was amazing! Got two half and half gourmets which is a great option if you want to try several things. Meat lovers and the works as well as white pizza and buffalo chicken. Buffalo chicken was the favorite for our group! Would recommend and will definitely be back! read more

Brooklyn Joe's - Buffalo chicken and white pizza - Pizza Near Me - Stuart, Florida

See all

Solid!! Great any style pizza. Will definitely come back.Solid slices. Very friendly people and it is pretty conveniently located. All we had here so far was slices reheated but that is typically the best way to judge a pizza place. We will definitely be back read more

This is actually the best pizza I've had left new york! That's been since 1988 so there you go. And my son I got him a stromboli with meat in it he loved it he just said it was great. If you're nearby this is a great place to go Indian Street is closed down so it's kind of a pain in the ass but I still want two times within a week. Go get you some good pizza! read more