Great pizza and good service. We ordered from the Tucson AZ store by accident but they took our order here and got it out to us quickly. read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Italian Near Me - Wilmington, North Carolina

See all

Just ordered delivery from here for the first time. Got a small vodka pie added sausage, chicken parm hero and side of meatballs. Crust on the pizza is perfectly crispy.. ton of sausage, good sauce. May get it well done next time but it is still 100% the best pizza I have had in ILM. Chicken parm hero is fantastic - the bread is crusty and toasted. Haven't tried the meatballs yet but there are 2 huge meatballs with a good amount of sauce for $5.50 - No brainer. Delivery time was quoted almost an hour. I'm about 4 miles away and it was here in less than 30 minutes. I can't wait to order again. read more

The best pizza in the area. Also very solid sandwiches, especially the chicken panini. Don't forget the rice ball, it's out of this world!

Great slice option, the chicken Mozzarella calzone is really good too (ask for more marinara containers)

It's hard to find good pizza in the area but Brooklyn Pizza is awesome! The crust is pretty perfect, not too thin and not too thick with a nice texture. The cheese and sauce are are fresh, flavorful and seasoned well. The staff is very friendly and the place is spotless. The only negative I have is with the chicken Parm hero, the chicken was good but the bread was lacking. Maybe it's because I brought it home and the time it took caused the bread to get soggy but it also tasted a little stale. Maybe next time I'll ask for the bread to be toasted. Bottom line- great food and great staff, I hope they keep it that way! read more

This place has the best pizza in town. I'd you like authentic NY style pizza, this is you place.

Best pizza joint in town tied with Hoobies! Everything is fresh, flavorful and all around delicious. I've been eating there for years but every visit is perfect! Never had a bad experience. read more

Pizza is great, pasta is awesome. The tortellini is a house fav!Can not go wrong with Brooklyn!!! They were longer than I expected with my order, and the delivery guy would not take payment. I was not upset and it was not expected. They are a great company and my favorite pizza for sure!! read more

It's good, but ... in my opinion, some of their offerings (Sicilian Grandmother) is stupidly overpriced... especially when they charge $3 per each and every topping. It's good, but not that good. Additionally, the last slice I purchased was burned on the bottom. A good friend of mine gad the same experience. I asked him why he didn't call them on it. He said that his response would be to just stop buying from them if they can't get it right when you charge that much money. read more

Best delivery pizza around two locations our family go to excellent food and service priced reasonably.

I am basing this review after several attempts fyi. This is my go to place for delivery. The pizza is very thin crust, perfect balance of cheese and sauce. I am from western NY, and all the places back home used canned mushrooms for their pizzas. Please don't ever change that. The texture and flavor puts me right back to childhood and is incredibly nostalgic and delicious. I always order double mushrooms and they don't disappoint. The chicken cutlet sandwich I called in an order to personalize (no options on the website) was flipping amazing. The bread, the lightly fried cutlet, and all the weird stuff I put on my hero (the guy on the phone was really patient and nice to me- I felt bad for personalizing something) was really well executed and tasted fresh. The cheesesteak is really unique. So much flavor- and again the sub roll they use is the perfect vessel. Huge amount of meat. Lovely. Wings are lightly breaded, but not overpoweringly so. They are huge wings- way bigger than most of the restaurants in the area. The skin didn't get rubbery when I ate leftovers the next day. Good ranch too (restaurant quality- not hidden valley). The prices are very fair in comparison to larger chains. You're getting much better product, and the largest size pizza is absolutely massive. All in all, I'll probably be ordering a couple times a month when I feel lazy and don't want to cook or if I feel nostalgic for a taste of home. read more

If your looking for good Italian food, you won't be disappointed. They have the best chicken parmigiana sandwich, chicken cutlets, calzones, and pastas. Delicious! read more

I really loved everything about the pizza here. We got the thin Brooklyn style. Pizza crust was chewy and awesome and I wanted to drink the sauce. read more

Great Grandma Sicilian! Have not been to the new location yet- but it looks great for a nice spring day!

Best pizza in Wilmington. Pretty close to the actual Brooklyn. Decent variety and purchase by the slice is nice. Chicken and broccoli roll a favorite in my house. read more

Super good pizza, very nice staff as well. The place is super clean and I love the outside area as well

Wow!! What an awesome place!!! Small joint but awesome food and pizza!! I'd argue the best in ILM---Coming from a Jersey native.

Had the Linguinie with white clam sauce Delicious plenty of clams and sauce for dunking Also had a margarita pizza also excellent

Absolutely delicious food!! And delivered an hour earlier than excepted! 100% will be ordering from here again, highly recommend

Pizza was amazing (Sicillian and regular)... garlic knots amazing. Meatballs need some work though.

Sausage tastes like shit, was pale and looked old and boiled, worst pizza slice I've ever eaten, was also $5 for one slice with three toppings read more

Great thin-crusted NY style pizza at a reasonable price. Fresh ingredients and a well balanced sauce. Also, great service.

The best pizza shop in wilmington for a good classic pie. The calzones are amazing too!! Friendly staff and everything is made fresh, hard to find good pizza in wilmington so definitely glad to have found it here. read more

Great pizzas and delivery . Don't know what else to say but try it I believe you will enjoy it. I'm new here and have not been everywhere so it's difficult to give long reviews. I ordered delivery twice and we enjoyed our pizza very much. read more

I live in carolina beac.h. Brooklyn pizza is the best!! The drive is worth itbest pizza around

This place is Awesome! Especially for only being open one week! I have tried the cheese pizza and Sausage and pepper heroes so far. Both were delicious! Definitely found my new go to! read more

This place used to be real good real New York pizza, not anymore. Even the attitudes there stink I would recommend the one in porters neck over this weeks ago. They were all the time change ownership and they don't give a crap. We moved here 20 years ago. The place was fantastic change the ownership. It's as good as Pizza Hut. I ordered the pizza to pick up an hour to an hour and a half went down to block another good pizza place 30 minutes when I talk to Peterson on the phone they don't care go down the block I live around the corner I would not recommend this place anybody ever again and we use it recommend Brooklyn Pizza all the time but it's not Brooklyn anymore. It was when the old owner Anthony after that it went down. They don't seem to care about to go someplace else it's like OK see you later. I'll never go there again. Bad attitudes. read more

Best pizza in town. I lived in NY and in Boston, and I've had great pizza. This place is legit. Absolutely huuuge menu, lots of options, but we usually get the pizza and salads. NY style large slices, good crunchy crust and quality toppings. IIRC, Anthony, who started the place, had a family shop in Brooklyn where he learned from his dad and uncles. He has a place in Hampstead now called Nunzios with pretty much the same food read more