My wife happened to come across a Facebook post where someone was asking for recommendations on a pizza place. A lot of people recommended Brooklyn Square Pizza. So I checked the "One Bite" and saw that Dave Portnoy gave it a great review as I immediately got excited. This pizza is AMAZING! The dough to so soft, sauce is perfect! Golly! Highly recommend this place. One bite, everybody knows the rule! read more

Brooklyn Square Pizza - Brooklyn Square - Pizza Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

I ordered a cheese square for delivery. After about an hour fifteen, of waiting for my cheese pie, I call only to be told it was on its way. Half hour later my pie showed up. I found out from the driver that I was number 9 of 10 delivery's they gave her. I love aged cheese, just not on my pizza. read more

The Pizza Was So Delicious And Very Good Will Go Back Again! Give It An A+ From Kirsten Vaccaro read more

Pizza was overly salty and dry, but to add to this poor experience was the lack of the cooks wearing masks. Totally understand if the open kitchen is hot but the chit chat back and forth while the cooks are making and boxing your pizza makes you want to cancel the pick-up and walk out the door. Woman who worked the cash register wore her mask and was polite. read more

Delicious pizza, counter girl was sweet, was ready when I showed up for pick up - glad I chose this spot! Huge pie - could feed at least 6 people - highly recommend! read more

Brooklyn Square Pizza - NJ Square Pie - Pizza Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

Excellent Sicilian pizza- tasty sauce and very fresh mozzarella cheese. One of the top few I have ever had.

Received gift certificate for Christmas and ordered 2 pies on April 9. Looked forward to arriving home and enjoying with my family. Pizza was over cooked and burned with the cheese molten and tasteless. What a disappointment, no quality control, threw away. Both pie's identical and terrible. read more

Honey moon pie well done is a game changer. I am drooling thinking about it.... maybe I'll order some now that I am thinking about it read more

Brooklyn Square Pizza - Honeymoon - Pizza Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

Great pizza, cheese steak, chicken cutlet sub, Caesar salad, eggplant rolatini. quick delivery and excellent customer service.

Calamari was almost white and soggy I took one bite and threw it out. Chicken wings were amazing hot and crispy so good. I also ordered my favorite Honeymoon Pie it was also delicious. Calamari was definitely a let down would not recommend. read more

Brooklyn Square Pizza - Calamari - Pizza Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

See all

Great pizza in Toms River NJ. Had their famous Brooklyn sqaure slice. Fresh mutz, homemade sauce and layer of Pecorino Romano cheese on thick crust. Awesome flavor. They have multiple locations and Barstool has rated it. Go-to pizza spot in Toms River/Brick area. read more

Brooklyn Square Pizza - Original Brooklyn Square slice (left). Vodka sauce slice (right). Both great. - Pizza Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

The absolute best in the area? The Honeymoon pizza is our go to! But Everything is the highest quality! The dinners will shock you! Not your dad's Pizzeria, the food here is the kind you tell everyone about and then wish you had not lol! read more

Brooklyn Square Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

See all

Terrible. The worst service. If you feel like being aggravated for a simple pizza order then Brooklyn Square is where it's at. Their pizza is hit or miss. You'll be waiting 2hrs+ for a plain pie. It's laughable. They'd never survive Brooklyn that's for sure. read more

It was called Pizza Rustica. Now they took over and they aren't that bad. Big pizza review person over here. I scored them at a 9.1 and that's high for me. read more

Brooklyn Square Pizza - the front of the restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

See all

I am not one to leave an online review about a restaurant, but this was something very out of the ordinary. As much as I love the food at brooklyn square, this is starting to put a bad taste in my mouth. I work construction locally around brick and toms river and i usually stop in at least once a week for lunch, and i usually see one of the workers sleeping while i'm there. This guy must be the owner because I'm not sure who would get away with sleeping on the job and smelling like booze. I went to use the restroom while i was there today and i didn't even realize the guy laying there until i came out because he was hidden behind pizza boxes. this just amazes me and i'm not sure how this guy thinks it's okay to smell of alcohol and nap in the middle of the store where people are trying to eat... read more

Brooklyn Square Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

See all

This place is inconsistent, the pizza is much better on the week days. If you order a thin crust pizza on a busy day you may be getting a crust that is 1/2 cooked before the rest of the ingredients go on the pizza, that makes for a hard unsatisfying crust. I understand that when you're busy you need to speed the process up, that's fine as long as it doesn't compromise the finished product. read more

The service here is absolutely terrible and rude. Every single time I go there to pick up slices with my family, to go, the lady always starts off with a rude, "tell me how many slices ya getting first so I can have a box ready." Lady, I don't know what everyone wants until we see what you have. They are not friendly at all, no matter the day or time you go there. The pasta fagioli is extremely salty also. There are way too many pizzerias in Silverton for the service to be this rude. Do better. read more

I'm only leaving 1 star because there's no option for less. My family and I decided to try this place based on their reputation for having great pizzas. Unfortunately after walking in and having to seat ourselves, I tried to place an order at the counter and was told the lady behind the counter would come serve us. We borrowed a wine key from another guest and sat. And sat. 15 minutes later, another table that came in, was helped within minutes of arriving. My wife and I were infuriated and walked out. I stopped to say "thanks for absolutely nothing" on our way out. It's one thing to be short staffed, it's another to completely ignore your customers and then skip right over them after they had waited so patiently. It will be a long time before we try this place again, if ever. read more

This is the favored place of Everyone in town. They are friendly and treat you like family. When I eat there, sometimes the other guests sit at the table and share their food so you can try a new menu item. I recommend the Arugula salad, the Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza! Calamari...each meal is remarkable. Order Out or Take home! read more

This pizza is may possibly be the best pizza in NJ! Over the top delicious. I just wish they had GF options. read more

Just went to Brooklyn Square Pizza in Toms River, ordered there famous upside down square, the pie was "cooked" in 10 mins and I was told they had a fresh one cooking that we can have. Well the pizza wasn't hot from the oven the way it should have been, so clearly the dough was already cooked in advance and he added toppings to it and then it went into the oven. It was good, but not great. read more

Was decent pizza . Staff was friendly and lady behind counter reminded me of my Aunt from Brooklyn. Had the upside down pie. Sauce was good crust was ok but not like L&B. read more

This joint is hot or cold. Having family over , I decided to order Brooklyn for a surprise! What a mistake. Two and a half hours for delivery????? It ain't that good. I will never order a pizza from you again! read more

What can I say, they have great pizza. They messed up once and gave me a more expensive pie and called me. I had to turn around and go back so maybe better customer service but it happens I guess read more

Hands down the best pizza in Toms River! The lady working today was super sweet over the phone. Great pizza and excellent customer service.

Its decent. Was much better when they opened. Not sure what changed, but as you can see from other reviews... im not the only one feeling this way. read more

Pizza perfection! This is the real deal folks, I highly recommend the pizza . Run to this place . read more

Saw this on Bar Stool Sports, was really excited about it. It was better than I could have imagined. I found our new pizza place. read more

It takes a lot to impress me when it comes to pizza, one of my all-time favorite foods. Growing up, we had pizza from Patsy's Tavern every Friday night and in the summer, it was Maruca's. I still love both. So when I heard good things about Brooklyn Square pizza from someone whose opinion I trust, I knew I had to try it. It did not disappoint. We tried the upside down square pie, and it was phenomenal. The crust had the perfect crunch to it, yet airy, and not at all floppy or soggy. The sauce was exactly the way I like it - tangy yet sweet at the same time, with no overpowering oregano to ruin it. I think it's my new favorite pizza, and that's saying a lot. I want to try the rest but it's going to be hard to not order the square upside down again. It was that good. read more

I wish I could've left a five star review but unfortunately two things occurred negatively in regards to my experience with the Silverton location. The pizza is good, a little pricey but you're paying for quality and the anti-pasta salad was very big and filling. However placed the order over the phone and according to women who took the order, the cooks made the wrong pizza, I understand that it does happen but they told us to bring the pizza back to the store which we did, had to wait quite some time for the new pizza. Ordered plain with half pepperoni received full pepperoni. During Covid I was surprised they wanted the pizza back but no worries, we did not touch it and did as they requested. The only other thing that was negative was no one behind the counter was wearing a mask but they have signs wanting customers to wear a mask which of course every customer in there was wearing one. Just an FYI to anyone that goes there they could be a little bit nicer on the phone and to their customers and respect the laws in place. read more

See all

Had such high hopes! We were told 45 minutes for pick up and it was exactly on time. We ordered a large plain pie. Brought it home only to find out that they don't slice their pizza! The crust was delicious but there was a very heavy hand of salt in the gravy. Tried and true local shops have nothing to fear here. One and done. read more

Happy we found this place to try! We ordered the Brooklyn Square & Peter's Special pies and were a fan of both! The Brooklyn Square was thicker crust but it was light & not dense like a typical Sicilian pie. The Peter's Special-- thin crust with fresh mozz was a favorite of the group. It was nice and crispy and something different. Definitely will return to try other pies on the menu! read more

Loved the pizza the first time About a year ago. Super impressed. The pst couple times it has showed up soggy. After a few months, we decided to give it another try based off of our originally couple experiences. Specifically asked for it to be crispy and not be soggy. This is what showed up in the picture. Wet. Not impressed anymore. read more

Brooklyn Square Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

We order from here a couple times a week and the food is delicious every time! Tonight, I tried the Chicken Grippo (chicken parm in vodka sauce). It was a HUGE portion and tasted amazing! Will definitely keep coming back. read more

Brooklyn Square Pizza - Chicken Grippo (after already eating two large pieces of chicken and a bunch of pasta)! - Pizza Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

Best Pizza in Town! Not easy to get through on the phone, but understandable as they are really busy right now with everything going on. They said it would be an hour and 45 mins which we were ok with and expected, we ordered early for this reason. But it showed up after only an hour, pleasant surprise! Thank you for an awesome dinner, you guys are great! read more

Brooklyn Square Pizza - Nonna Pie and Pepperoni, sooo good! - Pizza Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

Brooklyn Square - PLEASE GET ANOTHER PHONE LINE!! I really hate to deduct a star because we really like their pizza (sesame seeds on the crust is weird - but my husband likes it) and the service is great. BUT I have to carve 15 minutes out of my day to hit redial because their phone is always busy! After 170 tries today (yes 170 - see photo), I gave up! So some other place will get our business tonight. There is no way so many others are calling through at the same time. I usually have to start early (to us) at 4:30. I'm sure today's circumstances (corona) isn't helping, but this has been an issue since we started ordering from there before Christmas. Like I said, their food is good and the have good service/delivery. read more

Brooklyn Square Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

Let me start out by saying I've said for years that Toms River is dying for a good pizza place. I've been to all the "other guys" and i always felt like it was below average. Came in on a Friday afternoon and let me say this is the best pizza I've had in south jersey. Crust is delicious with sesame seeds and the buffalo chicken is A+! Highly recommend! read more

Not impressed. All the hype was not worth it. Had the spinach & artichoke, and was really not happy.

Ok, so I have been hearing talk about this so called - Brooklyn Square Pizza. The problem with that was, it wasn't close by until they came to Toms River. Perfect! My husband and I thought, maybe this could be our "go to" spot for pizza. Sooooo, I pick up and out I walk with this steamy box, inside was "Peter's Special". ( I know where some of your minds are right now. Hahah) Let's just say, I had to dig deep and really use some self restraint not to have a piece on the way home. The smell was amazing and the taste was even better!!!! (No, I waited till I got home). And Yes! This is our go to spot. We have only had 1 pie from there, but look forward to many more. read more

Brooklyn Square Pizza - Peter's Special - Pizza Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

Tried Brooklyn Square for a fourth time. This time I was prepared for them to overcook the pie. So, I was proactive and ordered the pie undercooked. Took it home and heated it to perfection. read more