I guess the output of food depends on what chef is working . I've visited and had amazing food . And other times not . The couches by the restroom need a serious replacement. They are stained and some had what looked like dinner mats covering them . read more

Place is FIRE. So many good choices of food. I love the Brothers Pizza Burger. The taste of the Calzone on the burger was amazing good. Love the spice and seasonings to it. Was not spicy, but it had that good kick to it. My girlfriend loved the Greek Salad. We eat lots of Greek Salads. Can't wait to come back here again. read more

Wonderful go to spot for good pizza and spot on chicken parm Always call up delivery times are very fast read more

All of our plates are delicious! Pasta tastes home made and sauces are amazing. The margherita pizza was my favorite! Will not disappoint you. The place is a little too dark for my taste, but the food is worth it! read more

See all

Amazing food the ambience was great The staff was great either so everything was perfect. Thank you so much. read more

Best pizza in north Jersey. Consistent quality. Authentic new York style pizza. Garlic knots are also excellent.

I came here with my coworkers during lunch, and we were blown away by the fast, polite service. Despite the rush hour, every table was spotless and the staff handled the crowd with a smile. Our pizzas arrived hot, fresh, and beautifully presented. The crust was golden and airy, and the toppings were generously layered. We all agreed it was one of the best pizzas we've had in a long time. read more

From the moment we entered, everything felt organized and calm. The tables were clean, the air smelled of fresh dough and herbs, and the service was quick. We ordered two personal-sized pizzas and were amazed by how fresh and flavorful they were. The ingredients tasted natural, not artificial like in many chain places. This is real pizza made with love and care. read more

The moment we stepped in, we were impressed by how spotless the place was. Every table was cleaned thoroughly, and the staff worked like a well-oiled machine. We tried the BBQ chicken pizza and it was packed with flavor. The crust had a slight crunch and the toppings were perfectly balanced. It's clear they care about every detail, from service to taste. This place is now on our regular list read more

Ordered a pie and it was Evidently old and was reheated. The cheese was orange liek it gets when it's been sitting there with teh grease and reheated. Disgusting. The crust Was buent and so was the cheese. As for cheese where the hell was it. It was so nasty I can take the cheese off liek You do when it's old pizza. The bread was gummy. I ordered to slice. The placed ordered a 10 percent discount. It was disgusting. And what the hell is 10peecent. How about a fresh pie. And not for nothing of they were gonna give me an old ass pie at least add fresh cheese to make it believable. Only gave it one star so I can post it. This is a disgrace and insulting to have this delivered. Never again. read more

Brothers Restaurant & Pizzeria - like rubber. This wasn't the first time I ordered from here. I wasn't impressed that first time but gave it another shot. Nope - Pizza Near Me - Edgewater, New Jersey

See all

Great customer service. Stays clean. Lastly the food does not disappoint. If you come here order the pizza and pasta.

Good local pizzeria by Edgewater. Fast delivery, ordered delivery and came in less than 30min. Ordered the meat lovers pizza and chicken wings. Pizza was good amount of ingredients, not to greasy and flop was good. Wings was regular baked wings came with side of blue cheese. No complaints, good pizza. read more

See all

From the time you open the you are greeted a smile and a hello.The food is a one the pizza the best ,chicken Pam , mixed salad all good.

The second time I ordered a take out lunch...& was waiting for 15 minutes until the wrong item was handed to me.... is the last time. Best of luck. read more

My new go to pizza place for take out and delivery! I am new to the area and couldn't find a good pizza joint that makes Hawaiin pies! Hands down best place in the area ! A always get mine well done ....hate soupy pizza read more

Brothers Restaurant & Pizzeria - Yummm - Pizza Near Me - Edgewater, New Jersey

Great friendly staff. Pizzas can be customized according to your likes. Their Philly Cheese Steak is also pretty good, but we went there mostly for the pizza. read more

I just really like this place. I usually stop in for a slice or two and the gentlemen behind the counter are always very nice. My favorite pie by far is the vodka penne pizza. It seems like with the virus crisis, I seem to be ordering a lot of pizza, and I'm very happy with my home town variety. I ordered the vodka penne pie last night with sausage and pepperoni and will have enough for a couple meals. Use the slice app foe another 5% off. One of my mainstays! read more

Their marinara sauce is wondrous. - The mushroom pasta has a red sauce- very good. - Spinach rolls were the best. Get one. Or two or three. They come with marinara as well (refillable), and I mostly used mine as a delicious spoon for the sauce. - Pizza was ok- margherita pizza had cheese, basil, and whole slices of tomato on it, which I found a bit strange. It also caused the pizza to be a bit leaky because of the tomatoes. Not New York style, but the crust was still chewy with good flavor. Service: fantastic. Refilled stuff when we needed it, pushed tables together because of our large party, got extra napkins and silverware when asked. Great experience. FYI- they don't have water or soda on tap, so you'll have to get them in cans and bottles and stuff. There's a self-serve fridge. read more

Ordered family's bday pizzas / food via Grubhub at 6PM. Was given ETA of 7PM. At 6:55PM got a text notice that the restaurant cancelled the order. Bday began with no food but the cake. Other family members had to drive out in a rush to find other foods. Ruined the bday and the evening for the family. read more

Through out the years living in Saddle Brook we had finally found the perfect place. From pizza to pasta and their delicious sandwiches. You can't go wrong. They make their own bread. Have some pasta fagioli with homemade bread. OMG It's a meal in itself. You cannot go wrong ordering from Brothers. read more

Brother's Pizza, I really wanna love you but you make it so hard. Every time we order from them, we get hot pizza that has cheese that literally slides off the entire pizza, so you're left with saucy bread, as you stare down into the black void you imagine inside the pool of cheese now on your plate. For every New Yorker we know this is a absolute no-no. Please Brother's for the sake of the GW bridge toll please keep the cheese on the pizza. I'm willing to compromise. I can take anything else. The flavor is so so and marinara is doable when you're craving late night pizza for a Squid Game marathon, but I'd rather have to play childhood games on pain of death then eat one more piece of saucy bread. read more

The staff is so friendly and the view in the back is always a nice treat for a quick bite to eat. Loved the grilled veggies

Very poor. Soggy. Basically, not cooked through. they have gone downhill

Chicken fingers and mozzarella sticks were really good!! The pizza wasn't my fav but not bad either My favorite was the carrot cake because it was actually good and actually soft and seemed fresh unlike in many places, just wish the slice of cake would have been a little bigger for the price Overall, will definitely be ordering again read more

See all

I think the pizza and pasta dishes are outstanding, but I give it a 2 star rating for one reason only: THEY HAVE FOX NEWS ON EVERY TIME I'M TRYING TO EAT AND I HAVE TO SIT THROUGH NONSENSE AND IT UPSETS MY STOMACH EVERY TIME. My wife loves their pasta dishes and thinks the staff are friendly, but refuses to eat there because Fox News makes it so unappetizing. If they only knew how it drives away some their business. It's better not to have a TV at all. read more

This has nothing to do with the servers or quality of food. this is about delivery. Placed an order online at 4:20 on a Thursday night for one dinner, spaghetti and meatballs with a side salad and a piece of cake. it said 50 minutes to an hour. The food showed up at 6:50! 2 1/2 hours after placing the order! mind you, the condo is less than 2 miles from the restaurant. The person it was being sent to was going out at 7 and was walking out the door when he got notice the food arrived. So incredibly disappointed. Do not order delivery if you actually have plans to go out after dinner! read more

I ordered thru a third party delivery from them and delivery was wrong. However, they mare every effort to make right all the way to calling me back. Will definitely order from them again. A+++ customer service! read more

I found these guys on Eat24 when I was looking for a different pizza place to order from. And WOW!! I absolutely loved their pizza. I ordered a margarita pizza and it was different from the ones I had before but still super good. Their margarita pizza is basically slices of tomatoes (substitutes the sauce) , mozzarella and pieces of basil on top of a perfect soft and crunchy on the edges crust. I recommend this pizza a lot! The only thing I guess that could be considered a con is that it was warm almost cold when it got delivered, which I can't really complain about because they're at Edgewater and came all the way to Fairview to deliver. So I guess it's understandable because of the distance. Next time I'll just go pick it up at the store. Besides that tiny but understandable detail, this was perfect and I will definitely be a returning customer! read more

Brothers Restaurant & Pizzeria - Margarita Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Edgewater, New Jersey

Needed a very large order on the fly and they were able to help! Got the order to the office in under 45 min and the office was happy ! Thanks guys ! read more

Ordered delivery from here for football Sunday. Delivery arrived when expected, and greeted by a friendly delivery driver. Food was OK -- subpar to pizzas we have in Philadelphia and so was the calzone. The calzone was mostly filled with cheese and not much else. The pizza had an OK crust -- decent amount of canned mushrooms. The flavor was just not there, a very bland white pizza although there was mozzarella and ricotta. It needed more salt, or more garlic.. just more flavor overall. Not sure of other options in the area, but this one was meh. read more

They are consistent for take out. I like their veggie pizza. It take's me like...20 min just to get through one slice. The service on the phone is really pleasant and the man has a good sense of humor! read more

Been coming here since middle school. Best football pizza in edgewater/west ny/ weehawken

NYC style pizza, nice setting, good prices, quick service. Preferred choice for the mall. read more

Wish the girls at the bar spent more time tending to clients at the bar rather then talk to each other none stop. Practically impossible to get these girls attention for new drinks or to close out a bill. read more

Been goin here for a long time. Great food and reliable for solid quality. Don't get the gluten free.

These guys are awesome at everything they make. And they are great people too. Joseph is awesome. Even during the busiest of times, he still works with a smile on his face. Totally love that guy. read more

Chicken soup was perfect temperature even when I walked .3 mile to get it with my trainer. His salad had sooo many shrimp: the kale was a bit light. But the Slice of bbq pizza was not quite warm. read more

Food tastes good - delivery took over an hour and 15 minutes tho. Won't order form here again

This was the first time I ordered based off of Yelp reviews, I'm also new to the area. I ordered a grandma pie and a regular pie half sausage and pepperoni for my kids, and an order zeppolis. Delivery was fast, they didn't understand my order when I called and needed to wait for someone else to get on the phone (I speak English). I ordered light soft crust. The grandma pie is burnt and is not a grandma pie, it's a regular round pie with a few slices of mozzarella cheese on it. Not good at all. The regular pie was "ok" nothing spectacular. My daughter said it was fine and my son removed the cheese and toppings, but he's 9 so it doesn't mean much. I took a bite, because I didn't like the grandma pie and it was fine. The zeppolis are really good. Now I'll just get fat instead of full. Lol I will not order from here again. read more

Brothers Restaurant & Pizzeria - The one on the right is the "grandma" pie. - Pizza Near Me - Edgewater, New Jersey

See all

Delivery took over an hour, which we would have been ok with, if the food was actually edible when it got here. The pizza was decent, but cold. The calzone was burnt on the bottom & the mozzarella sticks weren't even cooked! They were still frozen in the middle & the breading on the outside was soggy! Definitely won't be ordering from here again! Contacted Grub Hub & they contacted the restaurant. The manger said he would give me a refund, ONLY if I changed my raiting to 5 stars. No Thanks! I'm not that desperate for my $30 back. read more