I was looking to place a large order for a work event so I reached out to a few local vendors in…read moreearly January. I needed 40 boxes of 6 piece truffles the week before Valentine's Day. Newfangled was amazing! They responded to my initial inquiry within a few hours. Quick replies really go a long way in my world! They sent an invoice, confirmed my pick up date, and just like that I was on to my next to-do. The chocolates were incredible and truly like little pieces of art! They were also much bigger than I was anticipating but no one is going to be sad about MORE chocolate. My only feedback is that I didn't ask each truffle flavor to be placed in the same placement of each box. This was for a chocolate and wine pairing so that made it a bit trickier because they were mixed throughout. Thankfully, we decided to plate the truffles so it all worked out. I'll definitely use Newfangled again in the future!

You've probably seen them around town…read more They're the ones with the cute cardboard packaging, stuffed with drool-inducing goodies such as Frittle (bite size peanuty bites) and pralines. You can buy them all around town too. Most recently, I've spotted a full Frittle display in my local Kroger and purchased a few pralines from Yats on Mass Ave. They're beginning to sweep the country as well, so be sure to be on the lookout! The owner is sweet, and the combination of her ambition and the deliciousness of the product really have be sold on being a lifelong fan.

Ever since I saw that Goody2Treats was opening up at this small strip center near Fall Creek and…read moreEmerson, I eagerly anticipated their arrival as it was taking over the final spot in the strip center and added a unique business to this area. Goody2Treats is a bakery that seems to have a strong emphasis on cupcakes along with such goodies as cookies, chocolate covered pretzels, chocolate covered strawberries, cake pops, chocolate covered oreos, bundt cakes and a whole lot more. | They're nestled in this strip center right next to Indy Burger Joint. It's a relatively small storefront. It's simply but attractively decorated and the employee I met was super friendly. I ordered a Oreo Chocolate Cupcake. It was a jumbo cupcake that came in at $7, though they do have a variety of prices and you can definitely satisfy your sweet tooth here quite reasonably. I actually took the cupcake next door as I had planned to have dinner at Indy Burger Joint. It was quite delicious and I would easily order it again. Goody2Treats also offers classes and catering. As a fun fact, they're also getting ready to open up a spot inside Castleton Square Mall's Food Court. This neighborhood really needed something like this and Goody2Treats will hopefully find the love it deserves. I believe I'm correct in saying this is a locally owned, Black owned business This strip center is relatively new with pretty strong accessibility including appropriate parking spots and ramps. The door is a one-sided glass door that I found pretty workable. The interior is wheelchair friendly including a couple table options if you want to eat your item in-house. While I'm not quite ready to fork over the 5th star yet, Goody2Treats is close and I wouldn't be surprised if I do so eventually. With tasty treats and friendly employees, Goody2Treats is a welcome addition to this neighborhood and I look forward to returning in the near future.

OMG if you are looking for a place with delicious cupcakes that are moist and have a twist to them…read morethan look no further. This dessert place has a lot of great desserts and not just cupcakes.. I have had the banana cheesecake which was really good. The prices are very reasonable. The owner is friendly. There is great customer service in this establishment. It is decorated really nice and is very welcoming. I will be going back here again.

I'd had the privilege of enjoying Cretia Cakes at Zoobilation and Museum by Moonlight and fell in…read morelove! Both times--if I remember correctly--I fell in love with the caramel cake. While I was initially bummed to find out they didn't have an always-open storefront (or perhaps not yet ), I knew that when the chance arose for a cake or cupcake order, I'd want to order directly from Cretia Cakes. In hosting family and friends recently, this was the perfect opportunity. I ordered three dozen cupcakes: caramel cupcakes with caramel flavored buttercream (some they also added caramel drizzle on) and coconut with coconut buttercream. Incredibly moist and delicious! Some cupcakes it feels the icing is the star while the cake is just average, but I truly enjoy the balance of both and I believe Cretia's offers this. The team was careful to verify my order to ensure it was right and even followed up further to ensure they followed all of my details correctly. Pro tip -- 1) Cretia has cake and much more! I also ordered three pans of yeast rolls which were so scrumptious and perfect with the rest of our dinner. 2) Be sure to check their website and social media for specials and deals. I missed the deadline for mine so don't miss out like me! Highly recommend Cretia Cakes for your next gathering -- big or small. Thanks Cretia & Team!

Everything was delicious! I really like the dew drops and the mexican wedding cookies. Her…read morecaramel cake is divine and the homemade rolls were so buttery and soft. everything was 10/10

OMG if you are looking for some cheesecake that is rich in flavor and fulfilling then look no…read morefurther. This cheesecake was the bomb and I love how you can create your own cheesecake when going to the store. Also she has cinnamon rolls that are good and they have cheesecake on them that you can decide on creating your own flavor mix. This store can get a person in trouble due to the delicious desserts she offers and then you being able to create your own you definitely can't go wrong with it. Customer service is A1 the workers explained the process to me and even though it was line they remained calm and worked through the process by remaining professional. The prices are very reasonable and I will definitely be going back here again when I'm downtown. The space is small but it was pretty inside.

Absolutely worth the hype!…read more I finally made it to new The Cheesecake Lady location across from The Children's Museum, and I'm already planning my next visit. I tried the banana pudding cinnamon roll, the cheesecake brownie, and a large cheesecake cup with banana cheesecake and vanilla cheesecake loaded with chocolate chips and vanilla wafers. Every single bite was amazing. What surprised me most was the cheesecake brownie. I didn't expect it to steal the show, but wow! It was rich, fudgy, perfectly balanced, and honestly one of the best brownies I've had. The banana pudding cinnamon roll was soft, flavorful, and comforting, and the cheesecake cup was creamy, indulgent, and generously layered. My total was just over $25 for three large desserts that can definitely be shared and I'll be eating on for a couple days. Beyond the desserts, the store itself is bright, inviting, adorable, super clean, and welcoming. The staff is incredibly friendly, and you can genuinely feel the care that goes into everything. The owner is an amazing, hardworking woman, and it really shows in both the quality of the desserts and the atmosphere of the shop. If you're anywhere nearby, do yourself a favor and stop in. You won't leave disappointed and you definitely won't leave empty-handed.

What a way to end a birthday ! I had seen reviews for the Flying Cupcake online and knew it's what…read moreI wanted on my big day. I didn't realize there were three locations until my friend drove us over to keystone instead of staying in Carmel. When you walk in, you wouldn't think it was anything special. The inside is pretty small. They have a bakery case with the flavors they have on hand. The lady at the counter didn't say anything to us, so I assumed it was just an order from the bakery case type of deal. I think the cupcakes were $5, which seemed kind of expensive after the fact. The cupcake I got was the "Here Comes the Bride". It was an almond cake and was super delicious ! The buttercream was good, but very rich. My friend got a caramel cupcake and later said it was also very good. Glad I came for the experience !

The red velvet Elvis gets me every single time!…read more I love the flying cupcake and their amazing cake options. Their locations are whimsical and imaginative and the tastes are out of this world!

Felicia is professional, personable and knows how to bake and decorate a cake! It was chocolate,…read morevery moist with cream cheese icing, delicious. I found Felicia on yelp, and she had great reviews. I spoke with her about my decorating ideas. She was easy to communicate with. The cake exceeded my expectations!! I highly recommend her!!!

I had this cake at a celebration event the other day and it was so delicious! It was chocolate cake…read morewith green vanilla frosting. There were a few thick layers between the 3 stacked cakes. There was plenty of cake for everyone and leftovers to take home for the guest of honor. Be sure to cut the cake in thin pieces since its 3 layers. The artistry of the design shows how skilled the owner/ baker is! I'd recommend getting a cake from this place again! It was amazing!

I should have written this review three years ago after our first amazing experience with Black Cat…read moreBakery. I have two little boys who are allergic to eggs. It had been a big challenge to find a bakery that could accommodate their allergies and we were never able to find one that could make the kind of cool cakes their friends had for their birthdays. And then we found Black Cat Bakery. Audra is truly an artist! Not only are the cakes decorated to perfection, they are absolutely delicious. Our family members are not vegan and they tell us at every party that it's the best cake they've ever had. For our latest cake, Audra went out of her way to 3D print a dragon using plant-based materials to make our birthday boy's dragon cake dreams come true. I encourage everyone to try Black Cat. Not only are you getting a beautiful cake, you're supporting a truly kind, creative small-business owner!

I bought 20 homemade vegan pop tarts here recently for an event. Want vegan treats too? Email owner…read moreAudra here: blackcatbakeryindy@gmail.com. Audra is so nice and communicative! She sent an invoice my way and had the treats ready to pick up at Refinery46. The poptarts are sooo cute and delicious. I ordered the brown sugar and strawberry ones and loved both. The s'mores ones look amazing, so I'll try those next time! You can also find Black Cat Bakery at The Farmer & The Flea outdoor market downtown by the CCIC building too. Both vegan and non-vegan folks will love 'em!

I stopped in for some pan dulce, and yes, Kelly's has some pan dulce. You will find your conchas…read moreand your puerquitos. You'll also find galletas, orejas and much more. I decided on a sugary cuernito, except mine was shaped more like a circle than a horn. It was still delicious. When you walk into Kelly's Cakes, you will see a bakery case to your left with all of the pan dulce and bolillos. Then there's a smaller refrigerated case at the front by the register with cake slices, jelly / pudding cups, and some whole cakes. From reading the other reviews, it sounds like Kelly's makes cakes and desserts to order, but I don't know about that! I was just stopping in to get a sweet bread. If you're looking for some pan dulce on the east side, this is a great place to find it.

Amazing selection of all sorts of sweets at affordable prices! My husband and I enjoyed picking out…read morea few different options and will definitely be back!