Absolutely worth the hype! I finally made it to new The Cheesecake Lady location across from The Children's Museum, and I'm already planning my next visit. I tried the banana pudding cinnamon roll, the cheesecake brownie, and a large cheesecake cup with banana cheesecake and vanilla cheesecake loaded with chocolate chips and vanilla wafers. Every single bite was amazing. What surprised me most was the cheesecake brownie. I didn't expect it to steal the show, but wow! It was rich, fudgy, perfectly balanced, and honestly one of the best brownies I've had. The banana pudding cinnamon roll was soft, flavorful, and comforting, and the cheesecake cup was creamy, indulgent, and generously layered. My total was just over $25 for three large desserts that can definitely be shared and I'll be eating on for a couple days. Beyond the desserts, the store itself is bright, inviting, adorable, super clean, and welcoming. The staff is incredibly friendly, and you can genuinely feel the care that goes into everything. The owner is an amazing, hardworking woman, and it really shows in both the quality of the desserts and the atmosphere of the shop. If you're anywhere nearby, do yourself a favor and stop in. You won't leave disappointed and you definitely won't leave empty-handed. read more

See all

OMG if you are looking for some cheesecake that is rich in flavor and fulfilling then look no further. This cheesecake was the bomb and I love how you can create your own cheesecake when going to the store. Also she has cinnamon rolls that are good and they have cheesecake on them that you can decide on creating your own flavor mix. This store can get a person in trouble due to the delicious desserts she offers and then you being able to create your own you definitely can't go wrong with it. Customer service is A1 the workers explained the process to me and even though it was line they remained calm and worked through the process by remaining professional. The prices are very reasonable and I will definitely be going back here again when I'm downtown. The space is small but it was pretty inside. read more

See all

I love the cheesecake lady! She has the best cheesecake I've ever had. The new store is conveniently located on 30th and Illinois- you can park at gas station or free children's museum parking garage. The staff are always incredibly friendly and helpful. I placed a pre-order for a blueberry and lemon cheesecake for my mom's birthday. The communicate via text was easy and I definitely plan on placing future orders. You can walk into store to order to go cheesecake cups which are very popular and priced reasonably. read more

The Cheesecake Lady Indy - Blueberry and lemon cheesecake - Bakeries Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

If you want magic in a portable package, you must try this cheesecake! It is quickly becoming an Indy institution, with a little something for everyone. Even if you can't get in to downtown Indianapolis, she has her products in gas stations and convenience stores around the city so all sides of town get our cheesecake fix! read more

Yummy! biscoff cheesecake with Carmel, pecans and biscoff cookies! Love that you select the cheesecake and then whatever toppings! Paid $5 so a fellow veteran or child could enjoy a cheesecake on me! New place looks AWESOME and what a great location! If you haven't been you need to stop by! Right across from the Children's Museum! read more

See all

Of course I've done a review or two or three on The Cheesecake Lady lol. I just love this place and cheesecake. The warm greeting with smiling faces soon as you walk in is always awesome. The place is small and cozy and sometimes may get crowded at certain times of the day but so worth the wait. This time I got the BIG DEN DEN of cheesecake; a while Big slice of lemon cake crumbled throughout layers of strawberry cheesecake in a 1lb cup. I even had them top mine off with strawberries as well before they put on the last big slice of cake. It was ohhh soo good. If I could eat it all I'd definitely get it again lol. Go ahead and dive in. It's about $15 to $18 and again worth every penny. While your there don't forget to pay it forward and prepay for a child or Vet to get a free cup. read more

The Cheesecake Lady Indy - The BIG DEN DEN with strawberries on top - Bakeries Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

I have visited this location a few times The cheesecake jars are always so fresh. The service is always top notch. It's fun standing in line comparing the different flavors with the other customers. Just makes you wanna try them all. read more

My husband mentioned stopping by here because he's heard so much about it and I wanted a sweet treat. We walked in and the 2 ladies sort of explained how it works as far as ordering. I thought they would have ideas like Dairy Queen. So you pick the size and the price includes 2 toppings (there is a list) and you can add more. I went with lemon strawberry cheesecake. They put graham cracker on the bottom then the cheesecake and topped it with strawberry crunch. The cheesecake cake was more whipped and not dense. It was okay. The flavor was good and the price was fine I just wasn't a fan. My husband liked it a lot. He got biscoff with biscotti topping. read more

We ordered a lemon blueberry cheesecake for my Mom's birthday. She said it was the best thing she's ever had! It was creamy and the flavor was great. I thought the lemon would be tart and it wasn't. The size was great for our party. read more

This hit the spot, I love cheesecake, I got strawberries and biscoff crumble. Def hit my craving. Also had the brownie and banana cinamon roll. I took the baby home to warm up and added ice cream. The only problem is im 1 hour away and have to come when I come to indy. read more

Great spot to grab some dessert! Love that they have so many different sizes to pick from as well as a ton of flavors! While the cups are a perfect way to eat this dessert on the go- I prefer a normal slice of cheesecake as I don't really like whipcream. I tried the Carmel and cookies and cream. They have a cute photo opp along the wall! I'd be interested in trying the peach cobbler and birthday cake in the future! read more

The Cheesecake Lady Indy - two cups of ice cream - Bakeries Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

What a cute place with such lovely decadent desserts!!! I enjoyed my banana Biscoff pudding which was light and didn't carry any intense banana flavor. There were a whole variety of flavors such as cherry, strawberry, raspberry, cookies and cream and chocolate brownies. The cheesecakes are served in 6oz and 12oz plastic to go cups which are pretty easy and convenient to carry. Customer service was quick and easy. Locally owned this place is a keeper and definitely recommend! read more

See all

Visited the Cheese Cake lady today and purchased a couple different flavors. Three of us tried them after dinner. All three of us disliked the texture. They were very cloying claggy. I expected a texture like refrigerator cheese cake. Sort of a mousse like texture. All three were very much like the viscosity of honey. Not quite a liquid not quite a solid. Of the three flavors the strawberry tasted best. I wish they them luck on the new business. They just weren't obviously our thing. read more

See all

It's been long over due that I get my words in about The Cheesecake Lady Indy, especially now that she's opened up her storefront location. The first time I tried the Cheesecake Lady, she was still running her business out of the Indy Kitchen on Central/Fall Creek. Starting a business over the pandemic is not an easy feat, and I'm super excited to have been able to follow her journey. Let's just say if you don't follow her socials, you definitely should - she is transparent, authentic, and clearly dedicated to her customers and product. She's always open to customer suggestions from cheesecake flavors to how to navigate business practices (i.e. starting a buy-one program for the kids, other community engagement opportunities, Just-Tips events for customers). I love supporting a business as a whole - good product but also good people and thoughtful practices. If you got this far, you're probably wondering when I'm going to start talking about the most important part - the cheesecake? Here we go, things to note about the Cheesecake Lady: - Originally known for her No-Bake Cheesecakes, fun mix-ins and crumbles, and hits the mark on fun flavors. My personal favorite is her classic Strawberry Crunch! You can buy these in 5-6 oz. cups or 12- 14 oz cups. Price range from $5.50 - $14 - which warrants it as a special treat yo'self moment. (She takes pre-orders for full cheesecakes too) - Products have expanded to baked cheesecakes, cookie sandwiches, cake slices, etc. - still with awesome flavor combos. - She's on Doordash and you can also buy her products at different locations throughout Indy and the Greater Indy area. - Rotating Menu options on the daily - she can sell out quick. Enough rambling from me - go and support this local women-owned, BIPOC business! read more

The Cheesecake Lady Indy - Caramel Cake No-Bake Cheesecake 6 oz, Red Velevet No-Bake Cheesecake Cup, and Oatmeal Cookie Baked Cheesecake - Bakeries Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Although my waistline appreciated the limited hours before, it brought me so much joy when the storefront opened! They are always so welcoming and as a recovering fundraiser, their philanthropic efforts and community mindedness only make me want to buy the entire cooler of cheesecake. In fact, every time I walk in the door someone asks "Is there a specific flavor you're looking for?" My first thought is "I'm not even supposed to be in here" It's like Target, but for desserts - you can't stay away and you always get one of everything ‍ read more

The Cheesecake Lady Indy - Bakeries Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Always consistent and delicious. This is our 2nd large delivery order for our company Christmas Party. Our staff has been waiting on these amazing individual cheesecake servings since last year! Our order was delivered early and always exceeds our expectations. read more

We had OLD cheesecake from Leo's on Emerson. Called ahead as we were traveling. Wish staff at Leo's had told us cheesecake expired that day.

I stumbled upon The Cheesecake Lady via social media. I followed for months before I tried her cheesecake. Loved it. I watched her grow her business and open her storefront. Free street parking is available. A sign greets you from the sidewalk displaying the flavors. Inside is decorated in bright pink and yellow. There is even an area for pics. She offers a variety of cheesecake and other treats. Flavors are updated via her social media. I try a new flavor every time, lol. I've enjoyed them all. Local. Black owned. Woman owned. read more

See all

Cute little storefront to pop-in and grab some cheesecake goodness. She has lots of no bake cups with great flavors (that seasonal sweet potato pie was my favorite) but the new baked cheesecake slices she offers are We also did her cheesecake baking class and it was so much fun! read more

The Cheesecake Lady Indy - I made this cheesecake with homemade caramel and chocolate ganache at one of her classes! - Bakeries Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

The best cheesecake around! The new location is next to the old be bella store front. Across from hops and hoagies. There is a cute setup inside. There are cookers where you pick from the available options. She sells out quick when she opens of the popular limited stuff. She's open 12-6 and closed on sun and mon. I can't go until after work during the week and she sells out within the hour and less of opening. I got lucky and there were cups of her other usual flavors. I like the peach cobbler and tried the double chocolate brownie and that was sooo good!! read more

See all

I've heard a lot about The Cheesecake Lady but never got a chance to try her cheesecakes until she started stocking at Bonded Oil in Shelbyville. They sold out quick the first few nights and were hard to get. She had just stocked Bonded Oil one night last week, and my boyfriend was on his way home from work at the same time. He stopped by there and picked up some. She has many flavors/choice's to choose from, and he got the peach cobbler, strawberry crunch, and banana pudding cheesecakes. OMG, they were all absolutely delicious and full of so much flavor. I also like how they are sold as single servings. If you're ever in Indianapolis or see her cheesecakes somewhere, I highly recommend them. If you like cheesecake, you'll love this. read more

The Cheesecake Lady Indy - Bakeries Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Nice assortment of cheesecakes to choose from. Cute shop with the cutest background/backdrop for photo ops as soon as you walk through the door! The guy at the front counter was a help in trying to decide what to get. I tried a flavor that didn't does as well and it was 25% off; caramel brownie. I must say that I wasn't a fan, but glad I gave it a try. I learned that I prefer my brownie by itself rather than being accompanied with cheesecake. The portion sizes are perfect for if you just want to satisfy your sweet tooth, you want to indulge or if you want to indulge indulge! Ha! She also offers, what I would like to call, a 4 way; 4 different flavors of cheesecake. If cheesecakes are your thing, stop by and give the Cheesecake Lady a try! read more

See all

What an awesome place. Locally owned with delicious cheesecake by the slice and also whole cakes if you order a few days in advance. The peanut butter slices are incredible. They also offer a couple sizes of cheesecake cups that include cake and fruit flavors. The staff is super friendly and the shop is adorable with balloons and decor. Street parking. Show up early as they usually run out daily. read more

See all

A small shop close to Butler University. Parking wasn't great but was able to just park out front and run in for my items. If I wasn't looking for this place, it would have been easy to miss! The woman who helped was really nice! I got the option of 2 6oz cups or 1 12oz cup. I got 2 6oz cups of the cookies n cream and the chocolate peanut butter brownie. Bother were good! But the square snap containers were tough to open. I also got a 16oz cup of banana pudding which was okay. I don't love banana pudding so this might just be a preference. I wish it had more wafer cookies or real banana pieces to break up the thick cheesecake filling in the large cup. The Chocolate Peanut Butter Cheesecake slice was my favorite. I loved the thickness and all the chocolate chips. This spot is a little far from my house but if I was close by and looking for something to satisfy a sweet tooth, I'd drop in again! read more

See all

Love having the Cheesecake Lady nearby on 42nd St. Delicious desserts that our family enjoys frequently. Devoured the Biscoff cheesecake cup just today! read more

Thank you The Cheesecake Lady Indy for inviting us to try some of the best cheesecake I have ever had! I had heard some talk about the Cheesecake Lady and how fast she sells out. So I got there a little after she opened to make sure I got to see all she had to offer. I was not disappointed. I love carmel cake so when I saw that flavor-- I had to have it. The carmel cake was moist and the flavor was great. Then the Cheesecake was creamy, smooth, and sooo tasty. The balance of the two together was AWESOME! I would have never thought the combination would work but this shows the creativity of The Cheesecake Lady of Indy. Now peanut butter chocolate-- you know that is always a great combo. I thought i tasted some reese cup in it--- yummy! I really like the 6oz size-- it helps me with portion control cause once you start eating this Cheesecake you don't want to stop. I immediately told my girls they need to go check out the Cheesecake Lady Indy! The staff was really nice and helpful. The decor is cute and fun. Thanks for such a yummy experience. #YelpElite #YelpIndy read more

See all

The service is great and the cheesecake is unreal. I have been there a few times. There is limited street parking but I have been able to find somewhere to park. I ordered a baked cheesecake for my birthday and it was delicious read more

The Cheesecake Lady Indy - Baked banana cream - Bakeries Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

When I say I come with spoon in hand along with money, I mean it!! These treats are amazingly good! The service is out of this world and the ambiance is eye catching, fun, creative, and makes you feel good before you even purchase! I love finding these treats out when I am not near and they so just so good! Will be getting more! read more

Delicious!! Went here to get cheesecakes for my husband's birthday. Cheesecake is his favorite and he could pick just one we had to get 2! Awesome area in the front of the store with a Photo Booth. This is more of a grab and go, cheesecake express! read more

The Cheesecake Lady Indy - Bakeries Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

I've heard a lot of great things about The Cheesecake Lady--maybe that's why my expectations were so high. Unfortunately, it didn't make the mark for me. I tried the Banana Pudding Cheesecake and the Classic Cherry. The banana lacked a banana flavor and the cherry only had one small cherry on top with very little syrup with it. Both seemed to mostly just be a sweetened blended cream cheese. I'm actually familiar with the style of cheesecake so I wasn't thrown off by that. At the price point, I'm not sure I'll be returning but if I see her out and about at an event--I might grab one again! read more

What a cute little store! Beautiful color work inside with a cute setup for taking pictures for those who are dying for a photoshoot spot. The lady behind the counter was lovely and welcoming, talking to us all about the products in store! We ended up walking out with a no bake strawberry cheesecake and a slice of peanut butter nutter butter cheesecake, as well as some freeze dried cheesecake bites. All were delicious! I'm not a cheesecake fan but thought the strawberry was really something special. My husband, the real cheesecake lover, adored everything and would have happily bought out that store. Parking was complicated and a little frustrating but we did go on a Saturday at prime time for lunch. Be prepared to do a few circles. You'll most likely be parallel parking so be prepared for that. It's definitely worth it for yummy cheesecake tho! read more

How do you say, "no" to cheesecake? You don't! I was a little hesitant at first about going because of no parking; however, once you get there, this is not a problem. The store is very cute especially with the photo setup in the corner. I ended up choosing the two 6oz cheesecakes (banana bread and caramel) and then decided that I couldn't walk away with just two and ended up purchasing cookies and cream, and the turtle flavor. I've only tried the banana cream flavor as of now as the others are in my freezer so I have myself a little treat throughout the month of March. read more

See all

I work with the Cheesecake lady and her customer service is top tier and the cheesecake is so good !

Whenever I go no matter whose working they are so kind. Inside is so beautiful and clean. They will do a buy 2 get 1 free and I ALWAYS have to stop thru when I see that sign out. Strawberry Cheesecake, Banana Pudding, and the cookies and cream are my perfect trio for the sale! And they even started making low fat options but I told her I need all my fats lol! read more

Top 3 cheesecake I've had, and I eat a lot of cheesecake. Cutest little shop and great service.

This was delicious. So worth the money. I just got the classic cheesecake and it was rich and creamy. I definitely will go back.

Good cheesecake, glad they offer small portions because it is super rich and I could only eat a little bit. Great place for dessert after a meal at Hoagies and Hops! read more

the custom cheesecakes are absolutely delicious. pre made cups and slices are perfection. the banana pudding and cinnamon roll flavors are our favorite!! if you like cheesecake. you'll love this! read more

No bake cheesecake, if that's your thing then you will love it. For me it was too much cream cheese not enough flavor. There's potential though.. read more