Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Butter Baker

    4.2 (82 reviews)
    Closed Closed
    Updated over 3 months ago

    Order Butter Baker Takeout or Delivery

    Butter Baker Photos

    Business Info

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Butter Baker

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Blueberry Cream Pie
    Cherrie T.

    New Blueberry Cream Pie soft serve flavour for August 2026! Super refreshing, and kind of reminds me of red grape :3 Also ordered the Raspberry & Pistachio cake; it was amazing, and everyone at the party loved it :)) The white chocolate on top tied really well with the cake! It was very easy to order items online for pick up. The shop is super cute with lots of different vendors with handcrafted products, like accessories, home decor, clothing, and even party. supplies!

    Strawberry Lychee + vanilla swirl (June 2026 flavor of the month)
    Wei-Hsin L.

    Love their soft serve ice cream flavors! Very light, refreshing and not too heavy. I like their cookie-like texture of the waffle cone as well. Perfect treat for a hot summer day or even on a cold one with a jacket on.

    Christmas cookie box
    Rachel L.

    I got a box of Christmas cookies from a friend over the holidays and it was so cute! It came with a variety of treats and a little card with what they are. The cookies were all really yummy and unique its own way. I love the variety of cookies. They are all not very sweet and very "homemade". It also came with a tea tin and small bag of granola. Such a great gift idea and hope they will have this seasonal box again!

    Matchamisu
    Angela F.

    I have to dedicate my 500th review to Butter Baker. Oh, their Matchamisu cake has won over my heart. That soft matcha chiffon cake combined with matcha tiramisu crème... is so freaking delicious. This is THE birthday cake I will be asking for every year now.

    Karmela C.

    I love butter baker! Usually I'm very picky with ice cream flavours. But no matter what the flavour, it never misses! I always look forward to the start of every month because I know they will have a new flavour. If you're not big into ice cream, definitely try their cookies, but make sure to ask if they can heat it up, the workers are always happy to do so. The store itself is quite hidden away from where the main streets are, but it's worth finding it. The inside gives cozy vibes. They sell more than just ice cream, they also sell cookies, tea, dining ware and novelty items as well. Overall, a great place with yummy ice cream!

    Mango, passion fruit, pineapple and coconut.
    Nan V.

    Cute, hidden shop in Markham. Saw some cakes and pastries. Not much selection compare to the downtown location. I got the Junes flavour ice cream. Good mixture of coconut, mango, pineapple and passion fruit. Tropical flavours and it's like a piña colada. No dine in, but there are benches outside where the parking is.

    Raspberry pistachio cake
    Victor H.

    I am going to update my review from b4 Sorry about the long delay I have been back though for their amazing soft serve ice cream I had a lemon sorbet this time and it was amazing, fantastical ( if that is even a word? ). The soft serve is to die for and deserves a 5 star just by itself But My review is only a 4 star because I also had a birthday cake. The raspberry pistachio cake Ok, it wasn't that bad I only reduced it by 1 star because it was kind of bland and ordinary. Maybe I was expecting more, but the cake didn't wow me. However listen yelpers. I will come back for their soft serve ice cream and recommend it any day of the week I can't wait until I'm back again to try a different flavour Buyer beware the ice cream was $8.02 after taxes, you could get a 1.5L tub for that price But Trust me this soft serve is worth every penny.

    Vivian L.

    Back again for their strawberry birthday cake flavour for Feb 2025. The perfect balance of sweet and a slight tang from the Greek yogurt and strawberry flavours. Tip- get the cone in a cup so you can share with someone!

    Maria Y.

    1. Affordable and delicious ice cream 2. Budget-friendly yet tasty ice cream 3. Great quality ice cream at a low price 4. Delightful ice cream that won't break the bank" 5. Scrumptious ice cream at an unbeatable price

    Grapefruit flavoured soft serve on a sugar cone. Delicious and refreshing!
    Joy W.

    A small store located at the end of a commercial strip plaza. On the outside the store appeared dark and I thought it was closed, so that can be deceiving. Ample parking right outside the store. Once inside it was a haven from the heat outside. A very cute and visually appealing store with thoughtful placement of specialty items and baked treats for sale. We had stopped by for the soft serve twist, grapefruit sorbet (non-dairy) and vanilla yoghurt (dairy). It was light, refreshing and had a distinct grapefruit flavour. We enjoyed it. It comes with either a sugar cone or in a cup. Pricier at $7.50. Other desserts, cakes and cookies are also displayed. There is only a two-seater bench inside.

    Cotton candy
    Sally W.

    The cakes n croissants r amazing but the ice cream amazing! I love the way the store is displayed so u must walk around the whole store see everything before making ur food process

    Carmen G.

    Love coming here for their soft serve during the summer months! This location is really hidden in the industrial areas, without any other commercial units around. So definitely won't be able to easily stumble upon this shop if you're in the area without knowing exactly where it is/ that it exists. However, the store front is adorable, with lots of local goods like candles, jams, cups. etc. They sell whole cakes, slices, baked pastries and soft serve. I've had their cakes before and they're good - slightly sweeter than I'd like. However, the highlight for me is their soft serve ice cream that changes with flavour monthly based on seasonal fruit! I especially love it when they have their passionfruit soft serve and cantaloupe soft serve - both so delicious and pretty to look at. Worth a drive to find this hidden gem in Markham!

    Kathleen W.

    I predominately visit Butter Baker for their soft served icecream! It is probably the best one uptown with unique flavours each month. There are some months where the flavours were a miss for me but I still go back cause the cone is delicious.

    Caramel Biscoff and Vanilla

    See all

    5 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 3 of 3

    Butter Baker Reviews in Other Languages

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Bakeries 12,878 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Yan's Soy Foods

    Yan's Soy Foods

    4.8(72 reviews)
    2.2 kmMilliken

    Yan's Soy Foods is a fantastic spot that lives up to its name. It is reminiscent of the beloved…read moreHong Kong soy food store. Their tofu pudding is absolutely delicious! Be prepared for a bit of a line on weekends. The store has ropes to guide the lineup. With all that said, Yan's is well worth the wait. This place has been around for decades. I have been a loyal supporter since their Market Village location. Although the new storefront is smaller with takeout only, it still offers the same great options that keep everyone coming back. The prices remain reasonable ($3 and up). Their soy milk is top-notch. My absolute favorite has to be the coconutmilk tofu pudding ($3.70). It is a delightful treat! If you are a fan of soy based desserts, Yan's Soy Food is a must-visit!

    Freaking amazing - glad I stopped by during my Toronto visit…read more This place has a massive line, however it seems they manage it very well, and it doesn't actually take as long as you would think it would. It's located by a food court - so you can swing by there if you wanted to sit and enjoy it right away, however food court was pretty busy, so may take some time for you to actually get a table. The tofu dessert was sooooo satisfying - warm, soft and literally just melts with just the right amount of sweetness - I wanted seconds right away. The soy milk was also not bad, that we toke home and enjoyed the following day. Will definitely find a chance to re-visit in the future!

    Photos
    Yan's Soy Foods - Long line to find out sold our

    Long line to find out sold our

    Yan's Soy Foods
    Yan's Soy Foods - Plain Dow fu fa

    See all

    Plain Dow fu fa

    Butter Baker - bakeries - Updated August 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...