Great ice cream! I come from midwest dairy country and know what good ice cream is...............and no, Blue Bell is not good ice cream. This place is a Parker gem and we are lucky to have this fine ice cream so close to home. The shop is spotless, you could literally eat off the floor. The staff is very friendly, always willing to help, and the servings are generous. They also make malts, and they use REAL MALT POWDER! Can you imagine that. I do wish that they had more traditional ice cream flavors like Cherry nut, butter brickle, black raspberry, maple walnut, sweet cream etc, etc. Still, you can't go wrong here, this place is good. read more

Awesome ice cream from a great local place. Always busy but that means it's good. Worth a little wait on a Friday or Saturday. Thanks guys read more

Best ice cream in Parker! They've got unique flavors as well as the regular flavors. Delicious hot fudge! Kind people.

So glad this place exists. Me and wife live in the nearby neighborhood and will walk here for a great treat. Their butter pecan is perfection. The chocolate sorbet is unbelievably dairy free. The salted snickers, the blood orange sorbet, the rocky road, salted caramel, the classics and the new flavors are all delicious. Family owned, fresh made, small batch, friendly, and delicious. read more

Amazing! Hands-down the best ice cream I've ever had. All the samples I've tried have been delicious but I always order the Carmel Oreo. Super friendly staff and large portions. read more

By far the best Ice Cream around. Great selection and good tasting homemade ice cream. Had the cookie dough and it was fantastic. Will definitely be back. read more

Yum! This is my favorite ice cream spot in the area. They have so many flavors to choose from. I have yet to try any that I didn't like. The Oreo Caramel is my favorite. The staff is always friendly and they keep the line moving without making me feel rushed when it's my turn to sample and order. They're also very generous with their scoops! Will be going back again and again. read more

This place just opened up, but they already have the best homemade ice cream in Parker. I tried the chocolate ice cream, and it was delicious, dark and complex. Can't wait to go back and try some of the other flavors (cinnamon!). The owner told us he lives right across the street, and his kids help run the place... they're making it easy to support a local business! read more

Great place for ice cream! Awesome that it's family owned and operated. My wife and I wanted to try two flavors each, but not eat a ton of ice cream, so we each got single scoops with half of each flavor we wanted. This turned out to be like double scoops! I can't imagine how much ice cream you'd get with the true double scoop. The employees were friendly and let us try as many samples as we wanted, as there are many flavors to choose from! The caramel mocha and honey almond crunch were our favorites. Highly recommend if you're craving ice cream! read more

good stuff, you can taste the freshness. It definitely separates them from the competition

My favorite place for ice cream in Parker by far! But so sad they don't have the Nutella brownie! Came in just for that and it's gone! Bring it back please! read more

It's so nice to see a family run store. The people are so friendly and the ice cream is delicious!! Well worth going to check them out.

Very good ice cream and generous portion sizes. They have a seasonal flavor right now is pumpkin Oreo and it was very good. The staff is friendly as well. This place is definitely better than a lot of the ice cream places in Denver. read more

Best ice cream in town by far! They have tons of flavors, I loved the chocolate. The staff is always super nice.

What a great local find! Very creamy, rich, mouthwatering ice cream! You can taste all the flavors until you decide. The good old-fashioned flavors were there, but they have great creative specialty flavors. I loved the salted caramel Oreo, and my husband's coconut almond chunk was fantastic! read more

I almost didn't go to Butterfield's based on the reviews about the quality of customer service....I should have got with my instincts. While I will tell you the ice cream is amazing, the price and customer service was not. My wife and I paid $8 and some change for 3 scoops, nothing fancy, just 3 scoops. The gal behind the counter didn't even turn around from making waffle cones when she greeted us. She just talked to us with her back to us. Also, her scoops were very stingy. Another person was waited on by the other girl there and his were much bigger. I don't know why businesses don't understand service. I'll never be back. I'll pay more for an inferior product if the service is awesome. I'm sorry, but your ice cream isn't good enough to be treated that way. read more

Great selection but the atmosphere in here is quiet as a funeral. Put some music on and turn on the dang lights.

Great, friendly service. Really nice people. S'mores and confetti ice cream were delicious and the portions were ample. We will definitely visit again. Yum! Nice to have homemade, delicious local made ice cram so close. read more

I can't remember when I ever had ice cream this good. For years the trend has been around the frozen yogurt places - and there are quite a few that I consider my favorites. However, if you want amazing, real homemade ice cream - this is the place. read more

Little pricey and ambience/decorating/furniture needs some help, otherwise no hesitation for 5 stars. Staff is delightful. Every flavor we sampled was VERY GOOD. I spent far too long picking my poison. And to hear it's a local family that is small-batching the ice cream...well, way to go! The reality is, I wish the s'mores I have experienced actually tasted like their s'more flavor, as well as the caramel oreo (wait, do caramel oreos actually exist)? Both better than the real thing. Glad we have ice cream closer to where we live, but the reality is, this place is worth traveling to. read more

I love ice cream and I have to say this is probably some of the best ice cream I've ever had. The salted caramel and salted snickers are my favorites. I always appreciate a family owned single operation that takes great pride in what they make read more

The BEST ice cream around! Family owned and delicious! The ice cream is all natural ingredients and the quality is amazing. SO great to have a local small business in Parker. The cookie dough is our favorite. Check it out! read more

This place had a great selection of ice cream, candies, and sodas, which has me excited to come back for more. The only thing that wasn't perfect about the place was the cleanliness. There are only a couple tables but the open tables were dirty even though there were four kids working. They were very friendly, but I wish they would have been a bit more proactive in that area. In fairness to them, some kid was sitting there hitting on the 2 girls the whole time with seemed to weird out the 2 other boys working there too, so they were preoccupied. read more

Great selection of homemade ice cream. Nice addition to this strip mall close to home

This is some of the best ice cream I have ever had! We ordered the strawberry lemonade and the caramel Oreo. The strawberry lemonade was fruity and light while the caramel Oreo was rich and delicious. The waffle cones were also perfect, especially the chocolate dipped one. The staff were were friendly and let us sample the flavors. Any time we are back in Parker we plan on coming! read more

This is not the cheapest place, but it's the best ice cream by far, and worth the price and drive past every other place in Parker.

Ok, so first off, the ice cream here is some of the best I've had. I've been here twice and gotten the caramel oreo both times--out of this world. My main issue has been with service, particularly one of the servers. The first time I visited, I was served by a shorter girl with brown hair. She seemed to be in the worst mood and was the most unpleasant person I'd ever met. But whatever, everyone has bad days so I don't mind, I got my ice cream and left. The SECOND time I visited, not even a few days later, this same girl got my ice cream again. My assumption about a bad day was completely wrong--she was just, if not more, of a salty grump. Acted as if she hated me and gave me a single scoop HALF that of my friends, who was helped by a different employee. I was super bummed because the prices here definitely are a little more on the pricey side so I didn't feel it was worth what I got. I love the ice cream here so I don't think this will stop me from going, but maybe I should just refuse to be helped by her so I can actually get a neutral, maybe even positive, interaction. read more

Wow! Great Ice Cream. The Caramel Oreo was great; the Mocha Caramel was amazing! Got the history of the place from the counter girl as well as insight on customer favorites, ingredients, etc. Family owned business makes it a plus in my book. Luckily, it's close enough to walk which will help alleviate indulging in this guilty pleasure! read more

Great experience tonight. This is a simple shop with good ice cream and great staff. Staff could have been part of ownership but I did not ask. Great service and knowledge shared with enthusiasm but without hype. I will say the pricing is moderate because nothing is cheap in Parker. I will be back. read more

I am in LOVE with this ice cream shop and all the different flavors they have to offer. The customer service is always wonderful and I'm always happy with my order. Definitely recommend. read more

Closed at 8:00, place had people all around...would be nice to be open later as Summer hits

Creamy soft ice cream. Nice staff. Good selection and all homemade. Very fair prices. Store is clean. Cinnamon is the best

Great ice cream, their s'mores ice cream is really good. They make the ice cream there and bake all of the cookies that go into the ice cream there. The service is always polite and the store smells like fresh baked cookies. read more

Best ice cream ever! We used to live by southlands and would drive there every night. The only downside is that they started closing at 8 and my husband works until 8 so we don't get to have it very often any more. But the days we can we are there! read more

The ice cream here is so yummy! You can definitely tell it's homemade. The employees were super kind and helpful too. Love that they have a kids "small cone" size too which was perfect for my kiddos. read more

The best Ice Cream place in town. Love it Live it Need it. Homemade and always adding new flavors!

Salted Carmel Yum! Hand made waffle cones. Pricey even for Parker. Right next to Papa Murphy's pizza, so a convenient stop.

I found out about Butterfield's a few weeks ago and have been there twice since! The ice cream is great and lots of options. I highly recommend it! read more

My family and I frequent this ice cream shop. Don't eat here, they put something in their ice cream to make you crave it daily! Unique and delightful flavors and the old fashioned favorites, too. Even the most discerning ice cream lover will find something here. By far the best treat in Parker! read more

Pros: This place always gives more than you would expect for a single scoop. It's incredibly delicious. Staff is always super friendly. Great value. Cons: They don't have nutritional information available for any of their varieties of ice cream. Still plan on visiting when in the area. read more