The ice cream was tasty, variety decent and the kids who work there are very friendly. In Parker, definitely a go to.

The best treat! This place is a must if you are in Parker area! The salted snickers bar and peanut butter are my favorites! Cookies are delicious too! read more

Good enough ice cream to get us to stop on a cold day!! Rich and delicious! The staff are friendly and generous on the scoop size. They also have sundaes, shakes, malts and candy. Great place to stop to satisfy your ice cream cravings! read more

Wow! Oh WOW! I had the combo of Coconut Almond Joy and Salted Snickers!! Both were sooooo delicious! My first time visiting and it won't be my last! read more

We love the ice cream here it is so good! Also love supporting small businesses. If you like supporting local don't think twice go here!

Fudge is good. Ice cream quantity is a lot. Coconut ice crean is tasty. Would like to have more toppings

Great ice cream. Good service. Solid variety of flavors to choose from. Wish it was a little closer to me but we've always loved coming here. read more

They make all their ice cream in house. It's amazing. Salted Snickers! Caramel Oreo! This place is now our weekly treat. Dog park then ice cream. I went to another local ice cream shop in Castle Rock and their ice cream is made by Meadow Gold. Not Butterfield's. And it's the same price! They also have home made cookies which we haven tried yet and other selections of candy. read more

Very tasty ice cream- some of the best I've had. Only compliant would be that the serving sizes can vary quite a bit. You can get a large that is full and the next time it will be light and about 3/4 full. 5 stars for the ice cream and 3 stars for shorting the servings sometimes= 4 stars. read more

We heard about this shop from our realtor. He told us his family makes him bring some home every time he is in Parker. I can see why. The ice cream was delicious, you can tell they make it themselves. You can buy the ice cream in a cup or a cone or you can get it to go in a pint container. read more

We love this shop.. from the ice cream to the staff everything is just wonderful! The flavors are trouble and we spend too much time and money here! read more

The best ice cream in Colorado! Very nice owners. Please check out this small business!!!!

We have been to all the best known ice cream shops in the Denver metro area but nothing comes close to the ice cream at Butterfields! The malted chocolate heath is to die! Teenagers usually run the place and are pretty good on customer service considering...maybe they are being encouraged to improve on customer relations. read more

Best ice cream in Parker. Always great service and the flavors are so yummy you can't go wrong!

Great ice cream. Great service. Cherry vanilla is great. Convenient location and value

At the risk of sounding snobby I might call myself an ice cream connoisseur. After trying several flavors (they have an average variety) I felt like ice cream here was also average. It tastes good, definitely not great. I sampled several flavors and thought they all could improve. It might depend on what you like as to how much you like their ice cream though - I don't like chocolate and as such did not try any of the chocolatey flavors. The service was normal, there wasn't a lot of space to sit so don't go during busy hours. Overall not a bad experience, just not a memorable one. read more

Such a fun, quaint ice cream shop. Love going there with my daughter! Really yummy flavors and toppings!

The ice cream is always good and the service in the past has been great! I understand a lot of people are under more stress with Covid, however when I went tonight with my family 3 of the 4 teenagers working there were not very friendly and did not greet us. My 8 year old son just wanted to see the ice cream selections and we did not see the small labels on the chairs stating to stay back from the ice cream case. One the teenage boys was very rude and said "Could you get your kid back from the case." And it was not asked nicely, it was rudely stated. I naturally apologized and said "sorry, I didn't see your small sign." My son felt like he did something wrong just by wanting to see the ice cream. The only one in there who was friendly and greeted us afterwards was a nice tall, blonde haired young man! He's the only reason we got our ice cream there. I know times are different now but have a little grace especially with younger children going through this too. read more

Really great place. The coconut ice cream is as good as any ice cream I've had. Always had great service too.

This is my favorite ice cream shop. The flavors, servings, and service are fantastic. My favorites are candy cane, confetti, peanut butter blast, lemon cream, salted snickers... it's all good. Highly recommend! read more

Great little local ice cream shop. Took my wife and kids here for the first time last night and everyone enjoyed it. We tried four different flavors, and the consensus favorite was the Caramel Oreo ice cream. The seating is limited to only a few tables, but no other customers were there when we arrived. A steady stream of folks arrived after we did, and I was thankful we were able to snag a table when we did. The two employees working were friendly and quick. read more

Good, friendly service - Nice creative flavors to go along with some classics. I went with the double scoop of Salted Caramel and Malted Chocolate Heath. The wife went with Butterfield Bakery Bites and Rocky Road. Oh, and the double scoop was really like 4 scoops!! read more

Great, friendly service. Really nice people. S'mores and confetti ice cream were delicious and the portions were ample. We will definitely visit again. Yum! Nice to have homemade, delicious local made ice cram so close. read more

Ice cream is good, but they are NEVER open the hours they post on the website. 10mins early, or an hour early, you never know. It sucks yo drive there with kids when they say they are open only to arrive 30mins before closing time to a bunch of teenagers inside saying "we're closed". This time the were several other families that left at the same time. I root for small businesses, but this one is trying hard not to serve eager customers. Unfortunate... read more

I was so excited to hear that this was a family owned ice cream place! :) So precious! As soon as you walk in, the employees greet you and ask if you would like to try any samples. All the flavors look delicious.. and so very hard to choose from. I tried the Butterfield's baked goods ice cream? I think that's what it was called lol. But the cookie dough looked SO GOOD. there was so much visible cookie dough.. it seemed to take up half of the ice cream! But I did want to try something unique.. and the Butterfields' baked goods flavor was definitely different. It had some brownie pieces and cookie pieces and perhaps fudge pieces? Who knows... but it was delicious :) I also sampled the caramel oreo.. and that was delicious as well :) Can't wait to come back to try more flavors! read more

We were welcomed into the store not realizing they had closed at 9 and it was 9 when we walked in. We had been welcomed and asked what we wanted but had not decided yet. When the other family walked in and said they had called ahead we were then told we couldn't be served because we had not called ahead. If you have already welcomed us in and started serving us I believe the service we received was wrong. One of the employees served us and we were able to get our ice cream. Good ice cream just bad service. read more

Great ice cream and fresh cones. They were happy to answer any questions we had about new flavors. I would recommend this place to someone in search of good fresh ice cream. read more

Malted Milk Heath Bar, Butterdoodle, S'mores, and Salted Snickerdoodle... The homemade flavors here are unique and SO YUMMY! The portions are generous and the prices are pretty good. This is the BEST ice cream place in the greater Denver area by far. Can't wait to go back! read more

Wow what a find in town of Parker. When my kids told me about this place, I was hesitant at first, thinking its probably another typical ice cream shop that serves ice cream no different than the tubs you can buy in the freezer section of your local grocery store. I was pleasantly surprised to find this shop to serve very well made ice cream which did not taste like it had a lot of artificial ingredients. We throughly enjoyed black cherry, strawberry, chocolate, lemon flavors. The portions are generous and service was great. Two young guys working that day were prompt and friendly and assisted customers with a lot of patience as everyone wanted to sample different flavors. What a gem and great addition to Parker. read more

You have to go here, everything is homemade and you can tell. This is going to sound boring but please try the vanilla as they use real vanilla beans and it is the most perfect ice-cream ever. It is not too sweet, it is like you stepped back in time. Also try the waffle cone as they make them right there too. I cannot believe any other ice-cream store stays open with this one in town. read more

I'm not really into ice cream. When I go to ice cream parlors, I usually get rainbow sherbet. They didn't have any sherbet. I got a "single scoop" of cherry vanilla and salted caramel. It was good. But more than that, it was huge. The single was way more ice cream than I needed. Be advised haha. read more

Butterfield's Ice Cream - "Single scoop" of salted caramel and cherry vanilla. Humongous. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Parker, Colorado

Parker STAPLE! If you are looking for some unbelievable ice cream, and want a local shop! This is the place to be. Recommend the cappuccino chocolate chip, or the mud pie! read more

Ice cream is delicious! It's a definitely a must try. The employees that work here are awesome and provide great service. My only complaint is when paying at the register, it asks for tips and then another tip box asking for tips, only to find out that the employees don't really get these tips? When I tip, I assume it goes directly to the employees providing the service. Just felt like you are just paying extra for the ice cream. read more

I loved this little ice cream shop. The ice cream was delicious (I got the cinnamon) the variety of flavors they had were kinda different but unique and all were yummy. The service was also good, came here on a busy night and everyone was super friendly and explained flavors and all that good stuff. Would definitely go back. read more

This was a great a treat. Ice cream is flavorable and did not melt very quickly. Waffle cone was fresh, and it was priced reasonably. I would go back. read more

I love butter-fields many flavors. They also are the only good place to get ice cream in parker!

Horrible disrespectful staff. Great Ice cream but worst teenage staff ever.. if you want Ice cream expect some disrespect on the side. Definitely won't be going back specially because this. Wanted to support local especially during these times but dealing with staff is NOT worth it. Would LOVE for an owner to contact me so I could let them know. read more

The best ice cream anywhere! All natural ingredients, family owned, wonderful shop! Hard working staff.

Best ice cream around, unique flavors, friendly staff, always a nice treat! Favorite flavor is butterdoodle.

The best of the best when it comes to ice cream. They have by far the best ice cream and some very creative flavors. I have found no match for Butterfield's in the Denver metro area. Great service and always very accommodating. Worth the drive if your not in the Parker area. read more