I have eaten their ice cream before and it's delicious. However, I went there 5 minutes after their hours posted in their window and on Google said they were open. The door was locked, lights off, no one was inside, and calling their number posted in their window and online rang for a minute and then automatically disconnected. I waited an additional 5 minutes to see if anyone showed up and no one did. If you're open later, you need to update your hours everywhere. Great ice cream, but I guess you should assume they're not open until about an hour after they say. read more

The absolute best!! Great service and suggestions. We had plain vanilla which was amazing and the Carmel Oreo. Soooo Delicious!!! It is not good for my waistline to live so close to this amazing ice cream shop. And I love supporting a local business. This is a must try for all of you who live near and far!!! read more

Good ice cream but not really anything to write home about. Seems like they change out some flavors which is cool. The inside could be more welcoming. Seemed expensive for what it was. read more

Always leave here a happy customer! Nice combination of more traditional flavors and some new ones with a twist!

Yummy ice cream and waffle cone! The cinnamon was tasty and the chocolate was creamy! I will be back!

Unfortunately things have gone down hill here since the so card pandemic. No samples anymore due to "waste". Tonight we stopped for a scoop after supper. I normally get a malt and they are good. Tonight's was the worst malt I have ever had! Scoop sizes have gotten much smaller and prices went other direction in last couple years too. I used to eat this ice cream all the time. Now if I get back once or twice a year that's a lot. read more

Damn fine ice cream! Love small mom and pop ice cream shops and this place is great. Loved the sorbet and all the great flavors! Butterdoodle and Carmel Oreo favorites Will be back! read more

Butterfield's Ice Cream - Carmel Oreo - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Parker, Colorado

Came in from Utah and stopped by to get something. The service seemed a little understaffed but the wait was. Well worth it.

Delicious ice cream with a good variety of delicious flavors! Their chocolate lined waffle cones don't drip!

Have you ever been somewhere and they tell you they cannot sell you any ice cream because the machine is broken or out of service? Skip those places and head to Butterfield's Ice Cream - Made the old fashioned way, but hand. This place has so many great flavors, a few different types of cones, and even some pints to go. They also have candy and some drinks too. Very friendly service and recommend them hands down! read more

Delicious flavors and it tastes so fresh, it's hard to go back to store bought! They have unique flavors always rotating, too!

Mmmm, I recommend. The peanut butter blast/ caramel Oreo combo is amazing. Seating is limited.

Hands down the best ice cream in the Parker area! I've come here multiple times and always love the ice cream! They have a bunch of different flavors and will let you have lots of samples! It's homemade ice cream and you can definitely taste the difference! They also milk shakes and different toppings if you're looking to have more of a sundae. Usually on a weekend in the summer there's a line but it's well worth the wait! Definitely recommend Butterfields if you're in Parker and looking for ice cream!!!! read more

I love this ice cream! Have been buying here for many years. Always disappointed when I get there moments after closing time!

Great flavors that are house made and super friendly staff! This place is a local gem.

Love that we live so close to this family owned ice cream place. The selection is great. Love that they make everything fresh in store too! They even have a selection of old fashioned candy. read more

This was one of the best ice cream shops I have ever been to!! They have a lot of selection and family owned!

This ice cream was super creamy, plus they offer a large variety of tasteful flavors. I highly recommend it!

Amazing ice cream! If you go for a scoop and get a cone then you will have an amazing experience. Don't get a sundae. Way overpriced.

My husband loves ice cream and hasn't been to Butterfield's so we decided to stop by. To him the ice cream was just ok then add in the fact they don't do samples (due to waste and overhead) plus more expensive that most premium ice cream shops we have visited why go here? No need to come back. As far as the service, it was good - maybe the best part of the visit. read more

Waited in line for 30 minutes on a Tuesday to get to the front only to be told by the employee he didn't know how to make a sundae. I read him what the description was on their menu (2 or 3 flavors with a sauce, topping, whipped cream, and a cherry) and he reiterated it was his third shift and he didn't know how to make a sundae. He asked if I wanted anything else and I said I would wait for the other employee and he could move on to the couple behind me. neither the other employee nor the one that came out from the back waited on me despite hearing me say that I would wait for her. The couple behind me got the last of the flavor I had wanted and when they asked if there was anymore the employee again said it was his third shift and he didn't know. I understand being new but complete lack of customer service or even attempting communication with coworkers is pretty poor. I ended up walking out after being ignored by the other two employees even trying to get their attention. For the record there were 11 people ahead of me when I entered the store and it took 2 people 30 minutes to serve those 11. The majority of which appeared to have single scoops in cones. read more

My family and I have been coming in for the last 5 years and the ice cream is always absolutely amazing however the customer is always crap. Every time we've gone in the kids working are always really rude. We keep coming back because the ice cream is fantastic but I will say since the customer service is always bad it makes us not want to come in. read more

I loved this place. I always bring my out of towners here We went today and there are stools in front of the glass basically obstructing anyone's view that isn't an adult. My sweet girl couldn't see. I understand everyone is doing there best right now but what's the difference between the candies they have out for kids to touch and grab and then touching glass. Won't be back. Also the staff was less than friendly and a bit clueless. read more

Butterfield's Ice Cream - Chairs obstructing view, kids will not be able to see. Literally makes no sense. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Parker, Colorado

My husband and I moved to Parker in December. I've been wanting to try their ice cream and last week we finally did. So many flavors made choosing just one difficult. The staff was friendly and helpful. I'll go back again and again to try more flavors so yummy! read more

Love the butter doodle!! Have tasted nothing close to being this good :)) friendly servers too.

Great Ice Cream. Hayden was super attentive. Wish they had Huckleberry or my favorite flavors. But the Vanilla ice cream was the bomb.

Best ice cream place in Parker. Even has chocolate sorbet for my dairy allergic daughter and dairy free cones. Great family business in south Parker! read more

I rarely eat ice cream, only on days that end in Y. ;) So naturally, I'm a self appointed ice cream connoisseur. Butterfield's Ice Cream is super delicious, and the flavors are perfectly balanced. It's not too sweet to be sickly sweet, but it's not lacking in flavor either. The only thing I would change about this place is to have a toddler size, even their smallest is way too big for my kid. We'll definitely be back to try more flavors! read more

Top local spot for ice cream. Service is always good and the quality and variety of ice cream is fantastic. If you like ice cream, you'll love Butterfields. read more

Creamy, delicious ice cream. Favorite flavors were Confetti, Salted Caramel, Caramel Oreo, and Salted Snickers. I didn't care much for the Coconut Nut Chip - it didn't have a lot of flavor at all (I basically threw that flavor out.) They had quite a few other original/yummy sounding flavors as well. Waffle cones smelled great in the store and my kids said they were fantastic. read more

Wonderful flavors. Baked cookies on the weekends. Good portion sizes and good prices. The staff is very friendly

Love this place. Best ice cream in Parker. Staff is friendly and the shop is very clean.

The most delicious ice cream! I love the unique monthly special flavors too! I only wish they'd power spray the sidewalk area by the seating/bench area out front. There are layers of sticky ice cream goo & it just seems unsanitary. Please clean! :) read more

Wonderful ice cream! The Mud Pie in a waffle cone is my go to. The whole family loves this shop!

I bring my kiddo here after school every once in a while for a special treat. Every flavor is amazing! The cones are freshly made and delicious. Such a fun place to enjoy a sweet treat! We will definitely continue to come back. read more

Butterfield's is by far the BEST Ice cream in Parker! Every flavor is delicious and the staff is great!

It's okay, service was great. I think that I was expecting something like cold stone creamery so I can't complain but I think the prices are high for the ice cream. read more

Their ice cream is always so delicious! They have a wide variety in their easy pints to go cooler. I've never had a bad visit or product!

We absolutely love Butterfield's Ice Cream. Family favorites the salted-snicker and the cappuccino-chocolate chip. They have the BEST waffle cones in the state and their customer service is amazing. Love this family owned and operated business. They are reasonably priced, always have the freshest ice cream and their flavors are incredible! read more

The ice cream was tasty, variety decent and the kids who work there are very friendly. In Parker, definitely a go to.