This is the best company on Martha's Vineyard! Heidi and Marc always have wonderful products at…read morereasonable prices. They are a major destination for our annual visit !!! Thank you for making each trip special. Your products never dusaaping! Every thing always goes well as has been the case for over 20 years. The items that Marc and Heidi cultivate and offer for sale are beautiful

Whether it is a visit to Marc at the push cart in Vineyard Haven or seeing his wife Heidi at the…read more"store" in Edgartown, going to Whatever Silver is a MUST for my wife and I when we visit the Vineyard. The quality of their silver products is outstanding and they go out of their way to also find a right match for their customers. My wife looks forward to new items for her returning to teaching school or for the small white boxes under the tree at Christmas.

First time in Nantucket. Walked into this shop, saw a stunning ring, said I was going to shop…read morearound and that i might be back. Couldn't find anything that i loved more so i found my way back. Bought a beautiful silver ring w acid etching and a centered pearl. Really cute place! Lots of beautiful choices. Was fortunate to meet Victoria herself ~ lovely lady. Will visit again!

I moved back to western Massachusetts, from the Cape, and attempted to get two silver bracelets…read morecleaned. A wave bracelet and a Cape Cod bracelet, with very poor results. I called Elfstone at Mashpee Commons where I purchased them. I was told that I could send them in with money for the return postage, cleaning would be free. I am so very happy with the results. They sparkle!

Nice jewelry store in Mashpee Commons. Mostly silver jewelry but some gold. They also carry…read morewatches too from a brand name. Friendly employees and cute store. Just walked in to look around when we were in the area. Lots of merchandise.

For a decade I've been collecting Rolex watches, and while I've never personally bought one here…read more.. yet... I'm certain I will. When on the island, my bride and I, during 'the season' always stop in; seasonal store. Very friendly staff, and a wonderful and exceptionally knowledgeable owner, Edward, who jets between the island and Miami. He hustles, works hard, and has the time to talk with you. Prices there are very good. Lots of Submariners and GMTs, and many other high end watches too (e.g., Patek Philippe, etc.), but Rollies are my passion. Cash or credit. I highly recommend a visit when in island! Nice clothing selection too!

Very weird owner. Wanted to buy a watch. He didn't want to sell it at that moment, he wanted to…read moresend it to me, but would never complete the sale. It was so weird. I reached out to him multiple times. Had to be the weirdest interaction ever.

I went into the store in Oak Bluffs casually looking for jewelry and I walked out with an amazing…read moresterling silver bracelet. The man at the counter (the owner) was friendly but not overbearing, and every piece of jewelry in the cases were 50% off. Even if this were a gimmicky way of making you feel like you're getting a great deal, I still felt like it was a bargain. I fell in love with a bracelet but didn't want to commit on impulse, so I asked when they closed to see if I could come back. It was almost 6 and he told me they technically "close" at 6, but that he had some merchandising to do and would probably keep the shop open a bit late. He also gave me his cell phone number and said I could call and if I was interested in anything and he could ship it to me. One of the bracelets that I tried on was uncomfortable and he told me that he is also a silversmith and would be happy to fix it for me, free of charge, if I wanted the bracelet. I am sure he was just trying to make a sale, but the fact that he went out of his way to make sure I could get what I wanted really made an impression on me! I ended up going back to purchase the bracelet later that evening and the shop was still open. He stayed late to make sure the bracelet was fully polished before I walked out the door with it. Overall, I think Slight Indulgence is a great place to shop on the Vineyard, just from my experience buying jewelry alone. I didn't even get a chance to really look at their clothes and other accessories, but upon walking in I saw a billion things that I loved. Next time I'm in the Vineyard, I'll be back!

This store is what my dad would call a "clip joint!" It has a nice window display, and when you go…read moreinside, the owners are super-friendly, asking you all sorts of (semi-intrusive) person questions about where you're from, where you're staying, how long, what you do for a living, etc. They're masters of The Shmooze, trying to relax you into thinking they're your friends. This could be seen as a lovely quality, but when it comes down to it, their goods are horribly over-priced! And even worse? The pricing isn't exactly straight-forward. Allow me to explain: Every summer, I walk into this store to see if anything has changed. And every year I'm greeted by the same "50% Off Jewelry!" sale signs prominently littering the very long jewelry display case that runs the entire length of the store. But if you look closer, in small letters, they've written that this sale only pertains to "select items"...and then when it gets down to it, it never seems to be the item that I ask to see! The prices are really high for sterling silver jewelry, by my experience, over twice what comparable items are priced at at similar stores in other towns on the Island...so it would make sense for the 50%-off sale gimick, if the items really are marked down... But I have yet to find any item there that the owner told me was on sale. I'm sure there ARE some, but it must be a very small selection that could easily be consolidated to one part of the sprawling display case without all the excessive, misleading red-inked sale signs all over the place! I'm not going to go as far as saying it's a bait-and-switch, but it also doesn't feel on the up-and-up. I haven't bought anything here as a result. They also have an abbreviated selection of women's beach-worthy clothing and shoes...maybe people will have better luck with these items? But they are also rather pricey for what they are made of and how they are made. This is a typical tourist trap store. But, I guess, if you have a lot of disposable income and prices don't matter that much to you, you may have a different impression of this place?

A treasure trove of a shop. I could not stop myself from finding items to take back home…read more Quality note cards, jewelry, plaques, wooden signs with heartfelt or quirky sayings on them. I got to meet sweet and pretty store owner Jan and her 4 year old pup, Luca. She individually wrapped most items with violet colored purple tissue.

The name says it all selling items radiating with luv & light, motivation, encouragement, family &…read morefriendship. You can find coffee cups, greeting cards, silk screenings/banners, jewelry, books, wine glasses, stones, altar supplies, writing materials, shirts & more with special messages engraved on some & for any occasion. I was hesitant about purchasing some "those are totally for me" wine glasses with the travel back home. Yet, the Owner informed me that I could order online & purchases over $100 results in free shipping. Speaking of which, the Owners were hanging things up & was so welcoming with sharing insight & assistance while we shopped throughout this atmosphere of positivity. Sanctuary is a must stop by boutique when visiting Oaks Bluffs on the Vineyard.

My fav jewelry store on Nantucket - every piece I've purchased is perfection! Will be returning…read moreevery summer

I bought a bracelet from here for $600 and I was told it was REAL gold. Not even 4 days into my…read moretrip here it starts to turn silver. Pretty jewlery horrible quality. I am upset because it is so pretty but I was lied to about what it is made out of.

I very seldom post negative reviews but sometimes they are just really warranted…read more I must confess the experience I had at Jewel in the Sea in the summer of '24 soured me on this store. In fact, so bad was my experience it still bothers us more than a year later and I opted to Yelp about it. Prior to '24 I've bought sterling Nantucket basket bracelets for all my daughters and bride, without any incident at this store. Summer of '24: Milling about Town, we went into the Jewel in the Sea. Working the store counter was a young African American woman who was pre-occupied with her laptop. There was no one else in the store, just my bride and me. Walking through the store, I spy a knock-off, Swatch-esque, wristwatch. I collect wristwatches, so I asked her how much this one was. She proceeded to bark at me that she was busy and told me to wait. So much for that gracious Nantucket customer service; the poor little princess from Manhattan College. Now, I never talk down to people like she did to me, and there was really no reason for her to do so; it was a gesture of power and control. After waiting about eight minutes, I picked up the watch to read the price tag. She then started to yell at me, implying that I was trying to steal it. Please note, the wristwatch was not locked up or under glass. Maybe this store is great, maybe their merchandise is nice, and the prices are reasonable. However, the help they employed in '24, at least the day we visited, was downright exceptionally rude. I was even more surprised to read that Nantucket Today rated this store as 'the best' on the island! IMHO, Nantucket Today's judgement is lacking. Plenty of other jewelry stores on the island and in Town.

scammers they took…read morethe money and never delivered. they said they were going to make the bracelet custom fit and lied about it being worked on, but finally after checking in over the span of 2-3 months, they admitted that the order was never in production to begin with. the owner was condescending on the phone call and tried to justify unethical business practices and throw the whole issue under the rug