Whether it is a visit to Marc at the push cart in Vineyard Haven or seeing his wife Heidi at the "store" in Edgartown, going to Whatever Silver is a MUST for my wife and I when we visit the Vineyard. The quality of their silver products is outstanding and they go out of their way to also find a right match for their customers. My wife looks forward to new items for her returning to teaching school or for the small white boxes under the tree at Christmas. read more

I am a jewelry fanatic and I love love the silver at Whatever. I pretty much go to MV every summer and I go to the store at least three times during that week to explore the many unique pieces there. I always take my friends who haven't been to the island and they fall in love with Whatever as well. I've even had to email them to order pieces that were admired for my friends. I've never had jewelry from the store that I didn't receive compliments on and I've never purchased something that was sub par and that turned colors given proper care. Many people don't know what it takes to care for silver. read more

We sail to the Vineyard at least once a year and my first stop is to see Mark and expand my silver jewelry collection! He offers a unique selection of great quality products; Rings, Bracelets, Earrings and Pendants. I also gift shop with him for my Daughters and Friends! read more

This review is about the cart in Vineyard Haven: The cart has cute stuff and is in a prime location, but I will never go back because of the way the man running it treated us. I went there with my sister and we both stayed together looking at one cart at a time and were the only customers there. I tried on one ring and one bracelet and immediately put them back. The man running the cart came over and asked us if we took a ring that was missing from a cart. We told him no and showed him our hands and he said "okay" in a tone like he didn't believe us at all. We didn't steal the ring and we didn't do anything sketchy- he accused us because he thought he knew his inventory better than he did. If he is going to be suspicious of every customer that crosses his path, he could simply watch them more closely to see that they are not stealing, especially when he has a grand total of two people browsing one cart at a time. Then he might not run into the issue of falsely accusing innocent customers of stealing when all they did was look at his jewelry and try on two pieces. Bad business, and the jewelry is not good enough to be worth subjecting oneself to such offensive behavior. read more

My daughter found a special bracelet that she treasured all year as it reminded her of the great family times we have each summer when we get to the Vineyard. Somehow she lost it during the school year and was crushed thinking that she would never find another one. I contacted Marc and Heidi and explained my situation. They graciously said they would put the same item aside for us when we arrived this year and true to their word...they did! My little girl is thrilled and our family vacation is off to a great start! Thank you Whatever Sterling and Marc & Heidi!! read more

This is an amazing store. Super friendly and their jewelry is unique and beautiful! Owned by Marc and Heidi Glasser, they take pride in their work. Heidi is a very talented artist with some of her work hanging in the store in Edgartown. Look out for much more coming soon. They have a diverse, multicultural staff that are super helpful and have been with them for many years. I highly recommend either location, Vineyard Haven or Edgartown for some of the best prices and most beautiful jewelry on the island read more

Exclusively sterling silver jewelry. They have a decent selection but I bought an ankle bracelet that broke within FOUR HOURS. Brought it back the next day and was told that because it was an ankle bracelet, they would not replace/exchange because "clearly" I was the one who had broken it. They also refused to repair it. The manager offered me another bracelet at cost, meaning I would not be reimbursed for my broken anklet, but I could pay 50% of the price for another one -- in other words, paying $45 total for a new $30 ankle bracelet. Poor customer service and bad policy. If you won't guarantee your jewelry, don't sell it. read more

You know they say that "BEAUTY IS AS BEAUTY DOES" and so goes my NEGATIVE EXPERIENCE at "Whatever." I wanted to return a necklace and earring set on principle. My sister ( we are African American ) was ill treated in a way that insinuated she wasn't welcome in the store. My purchase was made a day later and while she had made reference to it, I did not realize just how disturbed she was at the time. Heidi Glasser would not allow for a return, only an exchange. Here's a message for Ms. Glasser: Treat EVERYONE with respect; my lovely shiney set has been tarnished by this incident! read more

Despite the ridiculous name "Whatever", this is a cute little jewelry store specializing in sterling silver. The prices are reasonable and there is a good selection of styles. read more

Great selection of beautiful hand made sterling silver jewelry at reasonable prices. I couldn't decide on earrings, but I did find an awesome bracelet that I am very happy with. I will definitely shop there again. read more

This is a store with nice merchandise but poor customer service. I was treated as if I was bothering the young woman working. She never smiled or responded to me at all. And.. I was a paying customer! I can't imagine what she would be like for those just browsing. read more

Went to marthas vinyard this weekend and found this wonderful shop named WHATEVER SILVER on Main in Egartown.What a nice clean store.what nice sales people. I bought a beautiful necklace, braclet, and earrings, All one of a kind, can't wait too go back,to see what else I will find, what a great experience. read more

The sales people in this small shop run hot and cold. Nothing special about their demeanors or their style in taking care of their customers. Seem high and mighty whenever I've been in and have other business on their minds. Whatever is their name, because whatever is their nature. It says it all in the name. Their stock in silver jewelry is nice, you can choose something for sure if you want to pay high prices, but that's Edgartown, MV. read more

Love this store! I always stop in on my vacation to check out their new selection, and have been shopping here for 8 years. My go to place for unique gifts. I love that I can get one of a kind pieces that I can actually afford. Great, friendly staff. read more

NOT SILVER JEWELRY!!! I purchased a ring in September 2012 and it was tarnished and corroding a few weeks later. I emailed the owner and she said I must have 'used bleach' and that's what happened to my 'genuine silver'. I didn't use bleach and it isn't silver. I ask for a replacement ring that IS real silver and she did not respond to my complaint and has been ignoring the BBB. I sent her a video with the ring and demonstrated that it is not silver with a magnet (real silver will not be attracted to a magnet). The ring is stamped .925 on the inside and it is a fake. I will take down this post if she will simply respond to the BBB and send a replacement. read more