Whether it is a visit to Marc at the push cart in Vineyard Haven or seeing his wife Heidi at the…read more"store" in Edgartown, going to Whatever Silver is a MUST for my wife and I when we visit the Vineyard. The quality of their silver products is outstanding and they go out of their way to also find a right match for their customers. My wife looks forward to new items for her returning to teaching school or for the small white boxes under the tree at Christmas.

I am a jewelry fanatic and I love love the silver at Whatever. I pretty much go to MV every summer…read moreand I go to the store at least three times during that week to explore the many unique pieces there. I always take my friends who haven't been to the island and they fall in love with Whatever as well. I've even had to email them to order pieces that were admired for my friends. I've never had jewelry from the store that I didn't receive compliments on and I've never purchased something that was sub par and that turned colors given proper care. Many people don't know what it takes to care for silver.

Terrible experience, my friend and I walked in the store and were looked at up and down. When we…read morewere shopping around the store, one of the 3 workers who were standing and staring at us whispered "are they leaving yet". Will not return, and will not be getting my money.

Clothes and accessories are great and unique, very preppy (if you are into that)…read more Staff is horrendous!

Does being horribly rude to your customers or ignoring them while you chat on the phone to your…read morefriend help you to sell your overpriced clothes? I think not. There are tons of other boutiques on Martha's Vineyard that employ friendly people where you can go to buy preppy pink and green clothing. I encourage you all to go there instead of Nell.

Cute shop. I believe it's just called Rags. Anyway, stylish items and decent prices considering…read morethe location. I think it's the owner perhaps who is rude. Just cold is how I would describe it. No warm and fuzzy as you walk in. They lock the doors at exactly 5pm. Some of the staff is fine and helpful.

Quality merchandise and the most helpful staff. Worth a…read morevisit if you're in the Vineyard.

Yes the place still has deals, but "Fred" is never there ( 2 years in a row ) now. Not sure if the…read moreplace was sold or Fred retired and he let a new crew run the place. 2 years in a row, unfriendly sales staff. Not the old town feel from before, but if you want good deals, go. Part of returning to a business is to talk to the owners or regular staff. Not the case here any longer.

Thankfully Trader Fred's donated clothing and underwear to our 50 brave souls from Venezuela. Thank…read moreyou . .

The amount you like this place depends on what you're looking for. This place is like the estate…read moresale of an old woman's house in Edgartown. Everything is dated, and it has this "dead rich lady" vibe. If you want to walk out with something that's already nice, you might find something, but you probably won't. If you want a good project, this place is a goldmine. I'm big on refinishing furniture, and the furniture I've found here has been way higher quality with more potential than at the Vineyard Haven thrift store (or any of the Ikea reject stuff in Boston). Lots of solid wood, lots of interesting pieces. This is the only thrift store I've ever seen selling scratched, vintage Herman Miller furniture. I would say this place is reasonably priced considering what they sell, but that the price range is high compared to the Dumptique or VH Thrift Store.

There has been a very positive change in staffing here and the place is more organized, but if you…read moreare looking for bargains and nice quality, think again. It's sad to say it, because I love the Vineyard and I love thrift shops, but this place is overpriced for this kind of shop, and mainly filled with tired old junk. Look around. Maybe you will find a jewel, as I have. But when they have broken items from the Christmas Tree shop (label still on) that are priced at double their original price, I just have to say something is wrong here.

i love the designs and fabrics that are offered and of course the sales. It's my first stop in…read moreVinyard Haven, when I visit Martha's Vinyard.

Wonderful selection with luring displays. A day trip is too short to investigate everything there…read more Great jewelry which is not found in many places.