Overall the place had good food in West Yellowstone. The burgers were big and very unique and good…read more My wife got a spinach salad with mixed greens instead of spinach. That was okay but would've been nice to be told. Finally, we asked for takeout, they charged a 10% gratuity for it. I don't think I've ever been charged for take out. It would've been nice if they would have communicated before taking the order. With the credit card surcharge we paid 13% of the bill in these fees which was almost as much as the kids cheeseburger. Good Food but added costs!!

Great service! Fantastic Burgers! love the vibe. The outside live music was a bonus :)read more

A welcome late- dinner respite after a long delay leaving Yellowstone. We ate outside on the patio-…read morethere's plenty of indoor and outdoor seating, so even though it's crowded, it can accommodate a lot of people. The cinnamon pretzels are the best pretzels we've ever had- wow!! They're soft, coated in cinnamon sugar, and accompanied by the most delectable icing. I'd return just to get these for dessert. The buff bites were also excellent- I got the huckleberry BBQ sauce, it hit the spot, and definitely was enough for a meal. My husband got the country fried buffalo steak with mashed potatoes and also loved it. It's standard bar/grill food, something for everyone, but be sure to get the pretzels!

Buffalo bar was pretty good. It's a bit removed from the main drag but I had the west-Mex Buffalo…read moreburger and my wife had an order of wings (naked) and sweet potato fries. The burger was GREAT! Beware the roasted jalapeño as it definitely has a good kick, but I took bites of mine along with the burger and it was great. The wife's wings for being naked and not sauced were well seasoned and a good size for the price, recommend a side of fries or SP fries for only $3. Service was quick, we sat in less than 5 minutes with no reservation. Atmosphere was exactly what you would expect for a bar with sports and video poker, overall 8.5/10 after a long day, they need to keep their menus updated when they remove seasonal beers for a 9/10 or rounded 5 stars.

Excellent food and service! We came here for our "nice" dinner during our Yellowstone trip. Their…read moremenu looked very inviting! They don't take reservations and their is a long wait for dinner (great place, busy place!). I woukd suggest getting on the waitlist and then go shopping. They have an excellent waitlist system that you can see where you are and how long you have waited. Our wait was about 90 minutes as we were told. We came back when we were close to.the top. They share the building with other businesses and a nice lobby area to wait in. For cocktails, both husband and son ordered Old Fashions 1910! Made perfectly! They really enjoyed their drinks! I ordered the Flat Iron Steak and a House Salad. The steak.came with a chimichurri sauce, asparagus, and potatoes au-gratin. The steak was a pergect size, 8 oz. The star was the potatoes au-gratin! My husband ordered the Bison Meatloaf. Something you can't get just anywhere. Came with asparagus abashed potatoes. Generous size and he ate every bite! Excellent choice! My son ordered the Chicken Prosciutto Pasta. Perfect portion! Prosciutto was fried up crispy! He enjoyed his selection. We were too full dessert but could not pass on their Blueberry Bread Pudding. We took it to go along with Huckleberry ice cream and enjoyed the next day! Our server was Haeley and she was excellent. Although we had a carafe of water on our table, ahe made sure to refill.our waters. She checked on us often. In addition, the woman. Working reception was amazing. Juggling all the people on the waitlist. So many cing in.and hearing the long wait. She was patient and very friendly.

This was the best meal we had on our entire west trip. The elk rack was amazing, I can't remember a…read moresteak that good in years. My Fiance got the trout but subbed mashed potatoes for the rice, and blew her away also. For dessert, the blueberry bread pudding with huckleberry ice cream is an amazing combo. We tried to go here 2 days in a row around 8:30pm, they close at 9. One night was too busy so we went elsewhere but we got lucky the 2nd night and found seats at the bar. The bartender was super nice and helpful with picking out the best stuff. Our drinks were also great. Huge selection of whiskeys and looks like every liquor. The building the place is in is pretty cool too, check out the brewery that's nearby. And also pickup bear spray for rent near the front door.

We came if for a beer and to share an app. They had so many beers to choose from on tap! They had…read morea wide variety, lagers, ales, brown ales, IPAs and a sour beer of the month, which they let us try before buying. It has a real pub atmosphere with a great otter motif in the stained glass above the bar, and a long bar with lots of seating (there were also tables, of course). We even bought a shot glass from there (we love otters). The wait staff and bartenders were nice and friendly and attentive. The appetizer was a Jalapeno cream cheese stuffed wanton with a huckleberry dipping sauce. The jalapeno was finely diced and mixed in with the cream cheese. The dipping sauce was a little thin but complemented the wanton. The menu wasn't all that tempting to us (people were mostly ordering burgers and similar items) and we weren't very hungry so we just had our beer and left but we did enjoy our time there. And it's within walking distance of all the downtown action. Oh... and they really celebrated the area, but just with huckleberry, bison burger and the otter theme, but by featuring many local breweries. I like that :-)

Nice place! We went for dinner and were surprised it wasn't super packed...the night before every…read moreplace in town was over loaded. This evening wasn't bad. No wait at all. We ordered a bison burger to split with fries and drinks. They had no problem with us sharing these large portions. The food was tasty as well. The location was pretty close to our hotel, so we just crossed the street and walked to it. Our server was very nice and attentive. Cost-wise, the meal is on par with everyone else in town. They do not serve dessert at all. I was hoping for something like a cobbler or any sort of ice cream, but no luck. The server did recommend The City Creamery down about a block or two. We followed up on that and were pleased! I recommend this place.

Excellent food and service! We were hankering for BBQ after a long day in the Park. We chose…read moreBeartooth and so glad we did. The staff was so friendly and helpful with suggestions. We ordered two dinner plates to share between three people, plenty of food. One two-meat dinner, Sliced Brisket and Pulled Pork. The other was Smoked Sausage. Threats were all so good. Of course we always like the Brisket best but honestly, glad we tried them all. Both dinners came with two sides, plenty to share between us three. We had Summer Slaw, Potato Salad, Green Chili Creamed Corn, and Cowboy Caviar. All were very tasty! Hard to know which one I would choose again, all four! Our server was Kiki! She was wonderful! They close soon for the season so hurry in if you are in town!

Great homestyle bbq, house made bbq chips, and friendly service!…read more I ordered the pulled pork sandwich and summer slaw and they paired great together! All of our food came out super quick and tasted amazing. Our server went out of her way to make sure we had everything we could need and treated everyone like family!

Bullwinkle's was one of our favorite stops in West Yellowstone…read more We read reviews about the owner, Brenda, being super involved in the restaurant. Sure enough the moment we walked in we met her. An absolutely wonderful lady who took care of us from beginning to end of our experience and works her butt off to make sure that everybody has a wonderful experience at her restaurant. She seats patrons, waits tables, busses tables, and even brought us a jacket and souvenirs that we left at the table after dinner. (Bet she cleans bathrooms too, total team player). The general restaurant ambience was semi sports bar and semi steakhouse. They are connected to a casino and bar, which is a good time as well as a liquor store. Really anything you could ask for all in one location. The fillet came out a little bit rare, but they were more than willing to cook it longer, and the taste profile was great. The elk T-bone came out cooked wonderfully and had a gamey flavor that I would highly recommend trying if you're a fan of white tail venison (Tennessee boy here). I do think that you should get maybe a bit more asparagus for each $50 meal, but the ambience and service more than made up for the lack of vegetables. All in all, we highly recommend this for a nice dinner out, and the service will more than likely make you smile!

We ate dinner here on our second night at Yellowstone. We came before the dinner rush and was…read moreseated immediately. I had the elk T- bone steak for dinner with baked potato. It also came with asparagus. The steak must have been cooked early and let to sit longer than needed as some parts of it were on the well side. I decided to eat it anyways. The medium rare portion was good. The baked potato was smaller compared to the other baked potato I had the previous night. Though I did find this size much preferable. The huckleberry cheesecake was delicious. The huckleberry sauce as not too sweet. The cheesecake texture was light. My son enjoyed it. I found the staff friendly and our server engaging.

The onion rings reheated well done - but that was my fault (I over sprayed them). Regardless, the…read moreonion rings were still full of flavor ; but just like burnt toast due to my lack of time management

Just ate here and it was GREAT! The owner/operator makes good food and has a gluten free fryer. I…read morehad the fish and chips and no reaction! James is a kind soul and loved that we brought our dog with us. My girls loved his burgers and my wife had the fish and chips as well and enjoyed them. Thank you for serving GF food especially in a town that needs options!

A decent option for dining in West Yellowstone. After a long day of travel and adventure in the…read morepark, we were ready for a quick and filling meal. Old Town Cafe was our pick since it seemed to have a variety of different dishes, including options without meat, and the prices seemed reasonable compared to some nearby competitors. The ambiance is casual with two different dining rooms and a few seats at the bar. We both enjoyed our meals - the trout entree and the chicken bacon pesto sandwich. Nothing fancy but they did the job and had generous portions. The huckleberry lemonade, a local drink, was also a refreshing surprise that wasn't too sweet. I definitely recommend giving this a try if you want to try something unique to the area. I'm all about casual dining, especially after a long day of activities, but will note that the waitress wasn't the friendliest and approached our table and asked how we wanted to pay the bill (one check or split) while I was only half finished with my meal. I definitely left rushed to finish and ended up taking my dinner roll to go to eat on my walk out.

UPDATE -- August 14: I reached out to management regarding this incident and received a prompt and…read moreprofessional response. They apologized for the experience and committed to addressing the issue with staff to ensure they understand the applicable service-animal policies and prevent similar issues in the future. I appreciate their willingness to address the matter constructively and hopefully I will still get to try one of their burgers.

Cold beer, nice staff. Great pizza!…read more A couple of days after we played pool in the Wild West Bar, some of us had heard their separate restaurant side had creative pizzas with good crust. This family-friendly restaurant is kept completely separate from the adult bar area, and no minors are allowed in the bar. We had beer from their craft list: Beyern Kolsch and Pigs Ass Porter. Lemonade for the kids. Salad and mac & cheese. Half and half pizza: Sacajawea was a luscious combo of artichoke hearts, spinach, kalamata olives, and feta cheese. And The Dude: sausage, canadian bacon, black olives, and surprising sauerkraut. Lots of other recipes on the menu, and build-your-own, too. Thin enough crust for some crisp, yet enough chew.

We rolled into West Yellowstone in the early evening after a long day of travelling and wanted…read moresomething simple. For us that usually means pizza, and Wild West looked like a good option. When we arrived we were told that it would be a 30 minute wait - no problem, we'll just stroll through town a bit until we get their text. We only got half a block away when we were told that our table was ready, so we hustled back. We each ordered a salad and got a large pizza to share. We chose the Blazing Saddles, which has hot Italian sausage, jalapeños, and banana peppers, plus onions and mushrooms. The salads were generous in size with fresh ingredients. The pizza was very good, but the sauce was a little sour and in general it was a little saltier than we would have preferred. The crust was very nicely done. Service was friendly and efficient. Prices were about what you'd expect in a tourist town. A decent experience overall.

15 total taps to choose from (only 11 pictured) but a great selection! I highly recommend the…read moreHebgen Hazy IPA. Happy hour from 3-5, $5 beers: we had 3 beers and a mocktail for only $25 after tip, so a great deal! Bartenders were quick and attentive and happy to control the TV for ya. Overall a great spot with a cool history. We will return tonight to the connected Madison Crossing restaurant for dinner. Stay tuned

Great restaurant with hearty food in West Yellowstone. You order drinks at the bar and food at the…read morecounter in the back corner. We grabbed seats after placing our order, and the staff brought us the food when it was ready. The spicy bison jambalaya was fantastic - it was super flavorful, came out piping hot, and was filled with bison, andouille sausage, chicken, and shrimp. The cornbread that came with it was not good. The Philly cheesesteak came loaded with steak and lots of fries on the side. The honey hot chicken wings were great. Service was very friendly & fast. The inside is spacious and was not crowded at 4:30pm, but the bar counter was pretty full with people enjoying happy hour.