Would rate 6 stars if I could. Great Food, tasted AMAZING…read more Great customer service! Ask for Madison!!! Got us seated in like 5 mins and we had 6 people. Sat outside, there was a beautiful river and some birds around. Great experience overall.

My meal was good. Service was poor from when I walked in, sat at the bar and then left. It wasn't…read moreworth the cost. Very sad I wasted my birthday dinner here, the Angler was much better the next night.

We came here our first night on vacation from Montana and had a great time. It was one of the only…read moreplaces in the winter season (April 11th). We loved getting to know our bartender Jewel. She was super quick, personable, and great to talk to. We hope to be back in the future and see more of Island Park in the summer!

Just thought I'd add a little update to my last review. Just had the Hawaiian pizza and it was…read moredelicious. Stopped to charge my car again for the third time as I drove through this area in the last week. I got to tell you I love the people that work here and the atmosphere and the food. If I lived here in the area, I would hang out here all the time. Good food, good company, and good prices. The owner should know that having that charger across the parking lot has brought in $100 of business in the last week that never would've stopped here if it weren't for those chargers...... And that's my situation.

We always stay at the cabins here at the pines once a year. The restaurant had been closed for a…read morewhile and it finally opened. It was my first time trying it. It is more expensive but we really enjoyed it and I'd eat here again next time we visit. We met the owner and she was very nice. We had a great waitress as well. My mom and I ordered the fried pickles and they were excellent. They came with fry sauce, I was so happy this restaurant had fry sauce. My mom ordered a salad which she enjoyed. I ordered the Philly cheesesteak with fries. Our waitress and the owner suggested that and said that is what they are known for and it was so good! It was a great recommendation. The portions were filling as well.

Probably the best Philly I've ever had! They've sold over 20,000 since November 2023! Absolutely…read moreinsane! First time in Island park and first food stop. Definitely will be back. Service was great

Great spot that even locals seem to love! Bit pricey, but the food and drinks were made so well…read moreyou don't feel ripped off. Service was great too! Love the rustic decor!

There is barely any restaurant in this small town that offers Bison meat entrees. As it is known to…read morebe different in the area compared to major cities selection of meat. The Buffalo Bar happens to be highly ranked as it will constantly be crowded during peak tourist season. Upon entering will be walked into a group of customers waiting for their table and name to be called. There are a good amount of table inside and have lots of tv for a good entertainment and enjoyment. Average wait time is typically 30 minutes plus during peak dining time. The servers are nice, provided the food and other necessities quickly. Attentive with water refills. The foods were presented well and they gave a good amount of food for the price. Worth eating here once.

Great place to stop for a soda or burger. I got curds and loved them. The service was extra friendlyread more

This place is a must-stop if you're in the area! I had the hamburger, and it was excellent--juicy,…read moreflavorful, and cooked just right. The meal included fries and a drink for only $10.99, which is a great value. I decided to upgrade to the waffle fries, and they were absolutely awesome--crispy, seasoned perfectly, and worth every penny. Great food, great prices, and friendly service. I'll definitely be back!

Ambiance is great. Our server was very attentive and had a great personality They have a very…read morelimited dinner menue salmon, chicken and pork ribs when i was there. Sides were good my wife's fish was good. My ribs were not. Definitely not prepared properly were not fall off the bone. I think the place has a lot of possibility. It just missed the mark for me. Also not that it mattered to me but they do not serve alcohol.

We realized at 1pm that we were all hungry. Yelped a few places in the area. The Cafe was close…read moreand we had to hustle because they closed at 3 pm. Arrived by 1:30pm and got seated. What a cute homey place with nice staff. We had 2 orders of grilled chicken salad and a ham and cheese sandwich. The food arrived and looked good. The chicken was nicely grilled, tender and still warm. There were also tomatoes, cheese and cucumbers. I ate it all. My friend also enjoyed her sandwich. We heard from staff that breakfast was awesome. Another trip is warranted. Parking lot right out front. No masks needed.

As others have noted, the food is pretty great, the service less so. The restaurant has indoor and…read moreoutdoor tables with a nice view of the lake. There is also a bar downstairs that had a live band. It is a very casual place, they serve your water in disposable plastic cups on the table. The portions here are large and each entree comes with a soup or salad so you won't leave hungry. There were only two waitresses when we sat down to dinner and that was not enough for the number of tables they have. It was hard to get a waitress to place our order and the food took forever to come out and when it did, everything came out at once (appetizers and entrees). We had hoped the soup or salad that come with the entrees would at least come out quickly, but it did not. We tried the bison burger (pretty good but nothing special), trashcan nachos with chicken (delicious) and I got the bison short rib which was exceptional with the chicken noodle soup (I liked that it had a few pieces of potato in it, we were in Idaho after all). The bison was cooked nicely and came with a generous portion of mashed potatoes and zucchini. I really enjoyed it and would happily eat it again. The prices are reasonable given the portion, but they need to work on the timing of the food and getting more help or more attentive help.

Beautiful location with great views of the lake. Cocktails were great and the food was good…read more Disappointed in the Trashcan nachos served with canned, not real/shredded cheese, but the chicken parm was delicious.

Really beautiful setting. Was able to seat myself. Service was great from beginning to end. Food…read morewas great. I also ordered the peach crumble to go. Would come back if I was in the area.

Really nice ambiance, like an upscale cabin, overlooking the river where you can see people fly…read morefishing. The restaurant is on a gravel lane off the main road and is nice to walk around. They have outdoor dining where dogs are allowed as well as indoor dining with a bar. As of May 2026 when we went, the menu online was not the menu we received when we dined in, so I attached a photo but keep in mind it can change. The service here was great, it was out waitress Brooke's first night and she was wonderful. The manager and staff overall were fantastic and the food came out at a good pace, not too long or short a wait. For starters we ordered the grilled peach burrata salad, elk and bison chili, crispy brussel sprouts and chicken wings with huckleberry bbq sauce. Each of these were very tasty and we would eat them all again. I would argue the appetizers were better than the entrees. The wings were slightly under par compared to the other dishes, but that is just because they needed more huckleberry flavor (very light). For entrees we ordered the pan seared trout and the grilled ribeye. Both were massive portions, the trout came with wild rice and asparagus, the steak came with goat cheese mashed potatoes and brussel sprouts. The trout was served as two big filets (found a few small bones, but no big deal) and was cooked well, but one filet needed more seasoning and was a little fishy tasting. The rice was a bit boring and dry, but the asparagus were superb. The ribeye was cooked nicely and tasted even better with the chipotle lime butter it came with. The mashed potatoes were great and did taste of goat cheese and the brussel sprouts were delicious, very similar to the appetizer preparation. Similar to the trout, the portion of steak was large, but a good portion of it was gristle and fat (about 30-40%). Overall a nice meal with huge serving sizes. Had we known how big the entrees would be, we may have shared one or ordered less appetizers. Great service with a pleasant ambiance.