Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Cape May Bait & Tackle

    5.0 (4 reviews)
    Open • 7:00 am - 5:00 pm

    Cape May Bait & Tackle Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Cape May Bait & Tackle

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    5 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    6 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    5 years ago

    Friendly place, Joe gives good advise on where to fish, his suggestions were spot on....thanks Joe.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    6 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Cape May Bait & Tackle

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Fishing 416 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Cape Star - P-51 fighter pilot in Korea. A true American hero. Thank you for your service Sir!

    Cape Star

    4.7(3 reviews)
    1.4 mi

    Groupon brought the 4 of us to the Cape Star -- at Utsch's Marina -- for a 3 hour whirl in the Cape…read moreMay bay -- just something different to do one morning while on our beach vacation in Wildwood Crest. This is NOT deep sea fishing -- and you will probably NOT take whatever you catch because it will be too small. But if trawling the 12 foot bay with 2 baited hooks on a basic rod/reel rig with the occasional hit interests you -- this charter could be your thing. The Groupon price point is quite reasonable. Captain Tony is an engaging and hospitable host and his new pontoon style boat is steady and accommodates a dozen plus very comfortably. That's about the complement we had on our morning excursion and this is the first year he is running this boat in Cape May. Top Tip: Great for kids who have never fished before -- they will land something -- we all did -- mostly baby sea bass and mud sharks. The crew is helpful and the experience pleasant.

    What a great excursion. We went on the 3 hour bay trip. The water was not choppy so no potential…read morefor sea sickness. The captain and mate were very helpful, explained how to fish, and knew a lot about the wildlife. The tour can hold 49 and there was 14 on the boat so there was plenty of personal interaction. One group caught 2 Flounders, another group caught a shark, and my group caught 2 crab and a Sea Robin. The day before, the captain told us they caught a 24 inch Flounder! Overall, this was a 5 Star trip. What I liked: Crew good with kids Crew always helping someone Reasonable price Dropped a crab trap on the way out (kids got to pick the spot) What I did not like: Sea bugs all over (crew offered big spray which helped) Catch more fish

    Photos
    Cape Star
    Cape Star
    Cape Star

    See all

    Miss Chris Boats - Aft Deck Miss Chris

    Miss Chris Boats

    3.4(20 reviews)
    1.2 mi

    we scheduled with them more than a month in advance. they canceled on us last minute. when i called…read moreto cancel the confirmation, they had an attitude. don't waste your money here.

    Last minute decision to come to Cape May…read more Jumped online and found a reasonable charter at the last moment. Worked out perfectly on a Thursday afternoon. Just the two of us picked the option for fishing. 1pm time. Read the tips to show up an hour early. The boat before us wasn't back yet, and the parking was none. There are maybe 3 businesses sharing one parking area and more businesses fighting for street parking. This was just a little frustrating. Once the boat tour before us came back and left, they get you double parked in their tiny lot. If you don't like that, come early to find street parking. Other than that. This is a bigger charter. You pay a rental for the rod when you purchase your ticket, which includes your fishing license. There are about 25 spots for rods built into the side of the boat, but we were fortunately there was not that many people. Even with only about 15 people on our side, with the drifting the boat does you are guaranteed to get tangled at least once. Thank goodness for Joe and the help on the boat. There in a flash to fix your rod, untangle, or unhook your fish. I can unhook my own bass, but I don't know salt water fish and didn't want to stick my finger in anything I didn't know. You get two cups of bait. They show you how to bait your hook, and once the hour long trip out is over, you do your line and go. The captain was great with getting us on the fish. I caught a couple of flounders, a bunch of bass and a sea Robin! I lost count of how many I caught. We caught lots and got a coupl of keepers. We didn't get the heaviest, but it was close. Bathrooms for all on the boat. Snacks for purchase. Sun shirts for purchase if needed. Be like the cool kids and take a slim rag for after you bait your hook. It's worth the money. If you wanted less people you will be paying more on a different charter. Again a shout out to a great ships crew and their great job. They cleaned our catch and were fun. Thanks for a great time.

    Photos
    Miss Chris Boats - Cabin and Snack Bar

    Cabin and Snack Bar

    Miss Chris Boats - Upper Deck

    Upper Deck

    Miss Chris Boats - Cabin of the Miss Chris

    See all

    Cabin of the Miss Chris

    Sea Star III - Deep Sea Fishing - Our party of 4

    Sea Star III - Deep Sea Fishing

    4.1(8 reviews)
    1.2 mi

    Fun trip on this boat, spacious interior . Caught a few small flounders , no keeper. Same was true…read morewith my previous trip a few years ago..nice crew though.

    We had a great experience with the Sea Star III. Two Dads, mid-50s, took our two teenage daughters…read morefishing for sea bass. Chuck and his crew were friendly, efficient, and courteous. They instructed us to ensure we caught fish. In speaking to Chuck, he's fished the waters around Cape May for 30+ years and had the opportunity to acquire the boat when the former owner retired, which he did. The captain put us on the reefs or wrecks that held sea bass and croakers. The crew was encouraging to us and our daughters and all of us caught fish, which the crew cleaned and filleted for us expertly. The fish we caught was breaded that evening and made for a delicious and memorable dinner with our girls when we got home. Many of the patrons on the boat were repeat customers. Rod rentals were reasonably priced and did the trick. A few notes, this is a smaller sized fishing boat so if it's rough on the day you head out, you're going to feel it. The day we went out the weather and surf was fine so no issues. There isn't a ton of shade on the boat so bring a hat and sunscreen. There are separate restrooms for men and women. Besides our daughters, there were a number of women on the boat, who all seemed to have a good time.

    Photos
    Sea Star III - Deep Sea Fishing - Our haul for the day

    Our haul for the day

    Sea Star III - Deep Sea Fishing
    Sea Star III - Deep Sea Fishing

    See all

    Higbee Beach Wildlife Management Area - Higbee Beach

    Higbee Beach Wildlife Management Area

    4.2(17 reviews)
    1.5 mi

    Higbee Beach was one of my favorite stops during my Cape May trip because it offered something…read morecompletely different from the traditional beach experience. This is not your typical beach with restaurants, boardwalks, and amenities. It's a peaceful, natural shoreline where you can enjoy wildlife, shells, beautiful views, and a quieter atmosphere. After spending time at the busier beaches, Higbee was the perfect place to slow down, walk around, and appreciate the beauty of nature. If you're looking for a more relaxed and less crowded Cape May experience, I definitely recommend adding Higbee Beach to your itinerary. Would I come back? Absolutely. Side note: HIGBEE BEACH is Hidden behind wooded dunes and far from the crowds, Higbee Beach is a wild, untouched stretch along the Delaware Bay. No lifeguards, no boardwalk, no badge required-just nature, birdwatching, and calm waters perfect for quiet mornings. Pro tip: bring water shoes.

    Beach on the bay side of Cape May. There are parts of it where you could lie out on the beach for…read morethe day but I don't think it's great for swimming with the other options in the area. During the late summer horseshoe crabs beach themselves here a lot too. It is very peaceful here and we did walk it in the evening which is great. One of the best sites for sunsets in New Jersey. If you ever catch a storm coming in over here that's a sight as well. If you're in the area it's definitely worth a visit.

    Photos
    Higbee Beach Wildlife Management Area - Before the drizzle

    Before the drizzle

    Higbee Beach Wildlife Management Area - Higbee Beach

    Higbee Beach

    Higbee Beach Wildlife Management Area - Haru is Happy

    See all

    Haru is Happy

    Cape May Bait & Tackle - fishing - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...