Whenever we're in the area, we make it a point to stop by Cara Mia, and it never disappoints. The food is consistently delicious, no matter what we order, and the staff is always friendly and attentive. It's the kind of place that feels welcoming the moment you walk in. We've tried a bunch of different dishes over the years, and everything has been top-notch. The rigatoni fiorentina is one of our absolute favorites. This entree is rich, flavorful, and done just right every time. Even when we can't dine in, we'll swing by and pick something up to take home. It's that good. Whether it's a quick bite or a full dinner, Cara Mia has become one of our go-to spots in Seaford. read more

I received a couple of gift cards for this restaurant and decided to try it out. The food was good, delicious and pleasing. The servers made sure that we were kept hydrated and was very quick to attend to our needs. Although the restaurant is comparatively smaller. we never felt on top of other patrons. We enjoyed the food and definitely will be back. read more

See all

7/26/25. This was my first visit at their Seaford location. Cara Mia in Floral Park is one of my favs. Upon seating we wanted to order an app and peruse the menu, but Ashley said we would have to order everything at once. Uhm is this new bc I have never been told this before at the other location, ever. Normally I order the stuffed mushrooms, baked clams or fried calamari but I figured we would try something new, so we went with the fried zucchini. It arrived hot and crispy but the wedges were a tad too thick. As for entrees we had the fettuccine Alfredo and the Zuppa di pesce. Both dishes were plentiful and delicious. I also ordered a side of the bolognese sauce (for the bread). The caramel cheesecake was small and just okay. Service was fine just not on par with the FP location esp with that initial comment. read more

Cara Mia Restaurant - 7/26/25 - Italian Near Me - Seaford, New York

See all

I had written a review since taken down, about the hours of operation. My concern was promptly addressed and is appreciated. I returned to sample the veal sorrentino. It was not to my liking, tasted too much like wine, and the veal had little taste. Wasn't what I had expected and some may like it, but it was not what I have had elsewhere. Very good service, fair atmosphere. With so many Italian restaurants locally, I don't think I'll be back. read more

Such a hidden gem. The food is always incredible and service is always on point. Cute little restaurant so if wanting to go at a busier time definitely try to get a reservation. The cavatelli and burrata and pesto rigatoni are my top two pastas (love to add chicken cutlet to both as it's so thin and perfectly crispy and delicious). The baked clams and sausage and broccoli rabe egg rolls are both amazing as well! read more

See all

Tried this restaurant for the first time I'm very particular about food... the place was busy so we sat at the bar ... ordered the chicken rollatine with Marsala sauce it was amazing.... I will be back soon read more

So I recently had major surgery & my hairdresser Juanita in SEAFORD wanted to send a meal to my home for my family .Thank you Juanita for choosing Cara Mia in SEAFORD for the dinner. OMG First it was on time and steaming Hot From the sausage broccoli rabe egg rolls to the stuffed seafood clams with fresh hot bread to start. Then onto 3 different pasta dishes, veal piccata, fresh delicious salmon with steamed broccoli and topped off with the most tender chicken parm we ever experienced. Thank you Sergio and your entire crew. You made our night. ..JB read more

Cara Mia Restaurant - Italian Near Me - Seaford, New York

See all

I've driven past Cara Mia many times and finally got a chance to have dinner here. Everything was wonderful - the staff, the food, the drinks. My friends and I shared the broccoli rabe egg rolls, the shrimp monachino (highly recommend!! I never order shrimp when I go out to eat buy boy am I glad that my friend wanted them), the cavatelli with burrata and the chicken saltimbocca. The cosmos were the perfect color pink - because if you don't judge your Cosmo by the color then are you even drinking a good Cosmo? and the pumpkin espresso martini are what dreams are made of. I really loved out dinner and can't wait to come back. Shout out to Ryan our waiter and the bartender working that night - wonderful staff! read more

I loved this restaurant! I went with my boyfriend and sat outside and enjoyed the prettiest view. I also enjoyed that the service was prompt and that our waitress was very courteous. Finally, the food was delicious and was enough for leftovers, which I appreciated. read more

See all

Came here for a nice girls night and was not disappointed. It was surprisingly busy for a Wednesday so we grabbed a round of drinks at the bar while we waited for a table-bartender was super friendly. I stuck to wine the whole night until dessert where I had to get the pumpkin espresso martini. I'm here for all the fall drinks and this was divine! We started with the broccoli rabe egg rolls-not my fav but the others enjoyed them. For entrees, we split the shrimp monachino-omg this dish was to die for. It was so flavorful, it was my favorite of the 3. We also got the cavatelli with burrata and the chicken saltimbocca ...the chicken was ok but would prob try something different next time but the pasta was excellent. The portions were huge, very easily split 3 ways and our server Ryan was very friendly. I would def come again. read more

See all

We came here twice so I felt like it was time to give a review. The first time we sat outside during the summer in the little alleyway which was nicely decorated with string lights. The last time we went we sat inside of course. It is a quaint little Italian restaurant. Our waitress was very sweet. We jumped right into our meals this time, but last time we enjoyed the broccoli rabe egg rolls. I had the spicy rigatoni which was a spicy a la vodka sauce topped with 2 burrata balls and my husband had a fish special stuffed with lobster. We ended with cappuccinos and creme brulee which was delicious. You won't go home hungry! read more

See all

In an area saturated with restaurants it is hard to find a great one let alone a great one that has been around for a while. Classy and delicious is the first thing that comes to mind. Professional and friendly service too. Large portions and a varied and interesting menu. Chicken, Veal, and a huge bowl of seafood Frutta di Mare are the stars. Well-lit yet intimate setting and tolerable noise level round out a great dining experience. Full bar and wine list reservations are a must and parking lot behind the restaurant can get crowded. Come here. read more

Cara Mia Restaurant - Italian Near Me - Seaford, New York

This intimate restaurant with a cute outdoor space seemed perfect for a small birthday gathering with family. Overall the food was decent, we tried the tortellini soup which was REALLY good. All the entrees were good. The flounder my MIL got was pretty small but all other meals were well portioned and came with pasta or side salad. Our waitress attempted to be nice, but I just didn't get a great vibe from her as her answers were short and at times, rude. All other staff were friendly and helpful. I'm glad we tried this restaurant but not sure I'd go back. read more

Cara Mia Restaurant - Monachino Shrimp - Italian Near Me - Seaford, New York

came for my birthday a little early. It was practically empty but it started to fill up quickly. The food was very good came out relatively quickly. Service was good and not over the top. read more

We had my daughter's baby shower at Cara Mia in Seaford, and it went so great that I had to write a review. Sergio is managing the restaurant and he spoke with me on the phone and met with me several times before the big day. He was patient, kind, gave me great suggestions and was very responsive. He was so flexible- every request I had was "no problem"! Jose and Ashley were working our party and they were both excellent. Their service was impeccable. They were polite, obviously very knowledgeable and efficient. The quality of the food was outstanding, as usual. Many of our guests had never been to Cara Mia before- but now it's on their list of great restaurants to eat at. Cara Mia Restaurant in Seaford is an excellent venue for a private party! Great for just a regular dinner as well read more

See all

Busy. Good food. Large portions. Food was over sauced but well cooked. A little noisy

Great experience here at Cara mia. Their chicken saltimbacca is phenomenal. Plus I love they give you tons of bread to soak up the yummy sauce. I hate places that give you 1 tiny little bread roll like wtf. Great food I will bump to a 5 star rating after trying a couple more things. read more

Lost s star!! Appetizers took a long time and were very small!!!! and bone fragments in the italian egg roll--no joke! wife and i almost chipped teeth. Wife and aunts fish entree serving a little small. My shrimp was a good portion size. Service good. read more

Arrived at 5:30pm on a Saturday night and there was a half hour wait for a table of 4. They don't take reservations on Saturdays, and the waiting area by the bar was tight. When we eventually got seated, service was prompt and attentive. We ordered the mussels in oreganata sauce to start, and thoroughly enjoyed this app. For entrees, we ordered the flounder, black linguine, rigatoni fiorentina, and spaghetti and meatballs. Everyone enjoyed their food overall, but the shrimp in the black linguine was overcooked. Will definitely return! read more

Me and my wife have been dining here for the last 18-20 years and we have come to the same conclusion that the chef has changed as our friends have suggested. Where there was always plenty of sauce on the pasta now dry because of the lack of sauce and too al denti. I had the veal Monachino and it lacked the usual taste become there was very lttle sweet vermouth used. My wife was also not happy with what she ordered. So, to management, you need to hang out in the kitchen and watch how dishes are prepared, and if I am wrong, I hope it was a bad night for the chef. read more

I've been here a few times and every time I go it gets better! They don't take reservations so my group of 8 went at 5 PM on a Saturday and didn't have an issue getting seated, but by 5:30/6, every table was taken. We got a few apps which included mozzarella sticks, calamari, zucc sticks. For the main meal I got eggplant rollatini which was SOOOOO GOOD which came with a side of any pasta I wanted. I had leftovers for the next day. Staff is friendly and atmosphere is clean! Thanks! read more

We had been here years ago and it was good, but now its our go-to spot for italian food locally. They just know how to cook!!! Proteins perfect, pasta and sauce's outstanding with the gnocchi being the best and most perfectly cooked we have ever had. Service also excellent for such a tight and busy spot. Small place so prepare to wait as no reservations for small groups less than 6 but its worth it I assure you!!! Enjoy! read more

Great celebration at Cara Mia of Seaford! Family birthday celebration with out standing service and the most tasteful delicious meals conveniently located on Merrick Road. Community minded & Family owned/operated. We have had many dinners, attended Business meetings & celebrations within this restaurant, which is quiet and is the perfect family setting. read more

See all

We use to love this place. Ordered all the time. Always received generous portions of delicious food. We ordered pasta today and only received half of the container. Each order is 25$. Plus 4 small pieces of white bread. Very disappointed. Will have to explore other option now. read more

Cara Mia Restaurant - Italian Near Me - Seaford, New York

See all

The food was delish, service was very good & attentive, ambiance is very polished & comfortable. I recommend this restaurant one of the best. read more

First time eating here. Nice ambiance, waitress was outstanding. Unfortunately the best part of the meal was the cocktails. I had the blueberry bliss and my husband had a vodka martini. To start with we had the baked clams and the arugula salad. For main course we had the chicken saltimbocca and the pork chop valdostano. Everything was lacking in flavor. The breadcrumbs on the clams were mushy. We were disappointed. read more

See all

I was expecting way more from this place . But i came to find out it's just highly overrated.The food was close to mediocre, the service was super slow . The ambiance was alright . The outside seating area . Is nicer than inside . read more

Food is always great. Look forward every weekend to view and eat specials. Staff is friendly and attentive. Ambiance is great nice vibe good feeling read more

Absolutely fantastic!! Food Service You name it! The best! I can no longer have tomatoes. So what am I doing at an Italian restaurant? Enjoying the best Pesto on Long Island!!! read more

One of my favorites Italians restaurant. Good food, the service is pretty good . They can get busy . Nice small bar but they make great drinks. read more

First time at the Seaford location, and was very satisfied with our meal. No reservations taken, but when we arrived the hostess took down our name and number and gave us a call when our table was ready, so we could walk around a bit while we waited. The bread basket was phenomenal with multiple types of bread, and both the mozzarella sticks and caprese salad we had as appetizers were delicious - though the marinara with the mozzarella sticks gave off tomato soup flavor vibes. For the main, I had the cavatelli and burrata with spicy vodka sauce, which was so creamy, saucy, and delicious with perfectly cooked pasta. My friend had the gnocchi bolognese which she also found super saucy, tender, and delicious. Definitely a place we'll be back to - highly recommend! read more

See all

My husband and I came to cara mia Saturday night and everything from the staff, to the ambiance, and food was absolutely impeccable. Our server Emma was extremely helpful when it came to the menu and her service was some of the best we've ever gotten on the island. We tried the pasta special and it was AMAZING. Definitely coming back here!!!!!! read more

6/8/19 I've seen some pictures on Instagram and I kept saying I have to try this place out. I finally did and had a fantastic time. To start there's street parking and also a parking lot in the back. We arrived around 6pm and hostess seated us right away. Complimentary assorted breads and bruschetta came out immediately. Danielle (Dani) was our waitress and she sealed the deal for the 5 star rating. She was incredibly sweet and informative. She took great care of us and checked in on us. She told us about some her favorite dishes which my fiancée and I are now looking forward to trying. I love amazing service! And now onto the food! Baked clams- I wasn't a fan tasted way too fishy to me. I have baked clams often and don't recall this taste. Zucchini flower- a special and it was delicious! Fried and stuffed with cheese, marinara sauce on the side. Spicy vodka with burrata- Amazing! I love fresh homemade pasta. It was cooked perfectly! Just enough sauce and the burrata delicious as well. We wanted to try their veal special but unfortunately were too full so we ordered some cappuccinos. They were great and piping hot just as I like! I read some reviews about prices being on the high side. To be honest with you I found the prices to be incredibly fair. I really look forward to coming back due to the amazing service and great food! read more

Cara Mia Restaurant - Spicy vodka with burrata - delicious and pasta was homemade. Perfectly al dente. - Italian Near Me - Seaford, New York

See all

By far the best salad and grilled shrimp I've ever had- whenever we go or get take out, the Russo chopped with 2 orders of grilled shrimp is my go to. (I'm very picky with fish and their shrimp is always perfect) The restaurant itself is a warm and cozy vibe - one of my favorite places for a date night with my hubby or dinner with the girls. Def make a reservation as it's small and gets busy quick! read more

Cara Mia is a nice restaurant with fresh good quality dishes. It is rated highly in the area for Italian food. I would say the things that surprised me and were less than I anticipated when visiting were... First, the menu is pretty standard as standard comes. Not much in the way of creativity or individuality with the selection. Straight chicken parmigiana, vodka pasta, etc... They did have one thing that was different and stood out. It was a sausage and broccoli rabe egg roll. Delicious, different and we enjoyed it. They should put more things in the menu like that. Also while clean and neat establishment, it kinda felt a little plain towards the from by the window. Meaning not a lot of decor type atmosphere. I mean you are taking your date for a dinner and you want to feel a little more than sitting in an open front window eating like your in a fish bowl being watched. Maybe some window treatments, or even a classy frosted window decorative sticker or a chandelier hanging form the ceiling would dress it up. They definitely do a good job but for me to come back and spend money that's you drop on a dinner I would prefer some more interesting menu choices and a warmer decor. read more

I have been coming here since they first opened in Queens! The best Italian food in New York!!! Everything is freshly made and the portions are large. The baked chopped clams are amazing, as is the Chicken Capri and Chicken Sweet Melissa! Carlo and the staff make this such a pleasurable dining experience!! read more

Do you like Chicken Marsala!? I like it too! How do you like your Chicken Marsala regular, creamy or aldente!? Just regular I guess. Regular! Cara Mia in Seaford makes a delicious Chicken Marsala seasoned to perfection served in a yummy marsala sauce with suculant mushrooms & the stuffed Rigatoni was a very flavorful dish aswell! Its no surprise Cara Mia is considered one of the best Italian restaurants in seatown Baby! read more

See all

We went here on a cold Friday night for a date night without a reservation and got sat within minutes of arriving. The restaurant is very cozy and down to earth. The service was great. Their menu is full of variety. The baked clams were very good. My husband got the chicken parm and I got the Chicken Sorrentino and it was spectacular. One of the best chicken dishes ever: juicy, flavorful, sweet from the marsala, salty from tbe prosciutto, freshness from the eggplant! Will definitely come back here. read more

See all

Good food and nice service Loud and a bit annoying sound volume and I don't like restaurant that do not take reservations But good --was above average read more

Lunch was a 2 star experience. The inflated 4.5 star rating is simply inaccurate. Spaghetti and meatballs was really disappointing like ragu out of the jar with overly breaded meatballs. Nothing good to say about it. Chicken marsala also no taste, sauce overly sweet. No way these dishes were prepared by an Italian chef. Bread was good, Caesar salad was good. You can do as good or better with take out from a pizza place. read more