Came back in after coming here in the past with family. Just like last time, the service was great, and our food came out pretty quickly. My food, however, was just not that good. I had the chicken carbonara, which was very under seasoned and lacking flavor. Additionally, the chicken was way overcooked. My girlfriend had the gnocchi which was also lacking in flavor. Overall, just like last time, I did like the intimate setting, but I just do not think the quality was quite as good this time around. Especially for the price, I think I may try somewhere else in the future. read more

See all

Cardone is an easy 5 star. The chef is also the owner! Amazing food, amazing service! You can not go wrong here! Sooo many great choices on the menu! To be honest, I made reservations without knowing west to expect. It was my girlfriend's birthday and I proposed right before we're got there. I was hoping this place was private and romantic. Because unfortunately there are no pictures of the restaurant from the inside. But it was beautiful! Exactly what I had hoped for to make our celebration even more special. Cordones delivering! Thank you sooo much for making our celebration even more special! Thank you! We have plans to return. read more

See all

Great atmosphere for a date or just a family get together. The waitstaff was very strong and so professional. Totally appreciated it. The food was great, the stuffed shells are amazing and the bread is a must the cannoli was very good read more

Cardone's Restaurant & Bar - Stuffed Shells - Italian Near Me - Westerville, Ohio

See all

I made a reservation for my family to try this spot on my birthday. It is a little hole in the wall Italian place, it has a cute patio but could use a little updating inside. Our waitress was super sweet and patient with my big family. We started with some wine and cocktails and the arancini, meatball and calamari. The arancini was really good but the meatball was not great, it had no flavor and their marinara was too sweet for me. Their entrees all come with a salad which I love and I upgraded to the wedge which was delicious. For my meal I got the gnocchi which was super tasty. I'd say that most people really enjoyed their meals (the scallop pasta was not a hit). Dessert is really where they shine, we tried the cannoli which was top notch and the chifeletti which was also unique and delicious. It was a fun little place to try but with so many options in Columbus I don't think I'll be back read more

See all

Great Italian restaurant with excellent food, friendly service, and a warm atmosphere. I can't wait to go back again soon!

First off wanted to mention that our server was amazing, and she was helpful, she wanted to correct everything we didn't like, replace meals, etc. but the food was simply not good at all. We ordered arancini and it was so bland inside. I had a pasta dish that was just ricotta and spinach, no pasta, largely my own misunderstanding but it wasn't good. We went to celebrate a birthday and it was fine. The server was attentive, the drinks were fine. They do charge a cake cutting fee, which I've never heard of or experienced, but it wasn't an issue for us. The only thing that was fine to the taste was the lasagna. 2 stars simply for the service and her attempt to tell us we should've told her we didn't like it. She noticed bc we all had leftovers and none of us liked it enough to take anything home. read more

First time here and probably not going back. The menu posted outside had different prices than the menu which was given to us at the table, however didn't realize that until the bill came. Anyway, I ordered the soup of the day which was Manhattan clam chowder (bowl) which actually was very tasty! Then I ordered a wedge salad which in my opinion, had way too much dressing on it and wasn't huge like other establishments! The bread was good that was served. read more

Cardone's Restaurant & Bar - Manhattan clam chowder - Italian Near Me - Westerville, Ohio

See all

I was looking for an Italian restaurant that was NOT Olive Garden. Mom loves OG and I hate it as I only get salads and OG has no salad option. Yes, I know they have the endless soup, salad, breadsticks. But all I want is a decent salad and not one drowning in OG dressing. Mom loves the tour of Italy - essentially the lasagna. So I was looking in Westerville as she also wanted to drive thru Otterbein as she had been on the campus 65 years + ago. As luck had it, I found Cardone's on Yelp. I peaked at the menu and it looked fine. A little pricier than I had hoped but I also think I need to get used to higher restaurant prices. We did not have reservations and the waiter that greeted looked down his nose at us as a result. Sorry - never been here before so I didn't know that all the cool people make reservations. Fortunately, they had a couple open tables for "people like us" - as well as outdoor seating. Nevermind that they had PLENTY of other empty tables that were not filled while we were there. In fact, not many people came to eat in while we were there, I think every single person walking in the door was picking up carry out. But back to our meal - we were seated in one of the 2 tables for non-reservation people and were lucky enough to have David as our server. He did not look down his nose at us and didn't make us feel bad for only getting water and a diet cola for drinks. Neither Mom nor I drink alcohol and she doesn't even do tea or soda. She's strictly a water girl. I had to help Mom with the menu as she wasn't sure what bolognase sause was. She wanted the lasagna but has a very bland palate and avoids all spicy dishes. So she was good with the lasagna and side salad. I, on the other hand, was happy to pick from several salads and add a protein. I went with the Cardone's salad ever though I don't normally like fruit with my greens. I added chicken and we were set. David brought us a basket of warm bread which was absolutely delicious! I usually don't do carbs but I hadn't eaten all day and just had to try and piece in the olive oil. I love the heals and this one did not disappoint. In fact, I may have also eaten the other heal in the basket. But I'm not owning it. Meals arrived in good time. Mom's lasagna came in a nice square bowl. She absolutely LOVED it, eating more despite being full and saying she was done. As a follow up - she took some home in a doggie bag and it was just as delicious on reheat for lunch the following day. My salad was also superb. The perfect size and built in a lovely bed of greens. The fruit choice was just perfect and complimented the grilled chicken and vinaigrette that came with it. I ate and enjoyed every bite. So I was vindicated for taking us to an Italian restaurant that was not OG as the lasagna was likely better than her usual favorite with the tour of italy. Will I be back? Not sure. Hubby works up this way and I'll mention it for future consideration. Final thanks to David for making great suggestions and being so friendly and helpful. read more

See all

Service was okay. Food was not! Sub par ingredients in sub par dishes. Salad was supermarket special. Osso Bucco was gamey and not good.

This is our 8th Valentine's Day at Cardone's. We found this restaurant our first year dating and usually find our way back here. This year we went with some wine, arancini, manicotti and a Caesar salad with chicken. It was pretty good :) the atmosphere is romantic (although we were a little packed in and could hear the tables next to us) but it was nice. The service was good and we had a lovely time. I think this is a great date night spot. Definitely leave the kids at home as I think this spot is a little more adult oriented than other restaurants. read more

This was our first time visiting this upscale Italian restaurant. Our party of five came on a Friday night, and we didn't have a reservation. However, it's a good idea to do so because the restaurant was quickly filled up after we arrived. All entrees are served with a House Salad. Their bread didn't look appetizing, but don't let that fool you. The taste and texture was amazing! The Stuffed Shells (large pasta shells stuffed with beef, pork, cheese, and herbs, baked with marinara) was a hit. The Chicken Parmesan (breaded chicken breast topped with marinara and fresh mozzarella, served with spaghetti) was also good. There is a section called Pizzas & Flatbreads, meaning you have a choice to have it made your way. I ordered the Pepperoni & Four Cheese (Pepperoni and tomato sauce with mozzarella, parmesan, gorgonzola, and pecorino cheeses) as a pizza. Be aware, this is not a Pepperoni pizza for a ten-year old. That is, unless they like gorgonzola. I should have read the fine print, because I wasn't expecting the gorgonzola, which is my kryptonite. My whole body weakened, and I could only manage to eat a couple of small pieces. So, if you really, really don't like gorgonzola (like me) maybe you could ask for a substitution of cheeses. Now, I always like to try an authentic Italian cannoli, and theirs is the real deal. Two good-sized cannoli come filled with cream and chocolate chips, and drizzled with more chocolate. The presentation was spectacular! Will I come again? Yes. The ambiance is tasteful, calm and serene, and there is outdoor dining as well. read more

See all

This place is too notch!! Everything from the service to the food!! We had the stuffed mushrooms for an appetizer and my mouth is still watering from those! An amazing start for an amazing dinning experience. So cheesy and juicy! My son ordered the pizza and I am so glad he did because that's probably the best pizza we've had in Columbus! So light and airy crust and the sauce hits different than most plus the cheese chefs kiss! My husband ordered the veal and myself I had the caprese chicken! Both dishes were good! We had zero complaints, zero things to critique and we will be back many more times to have the pizza and try out some other magnificent dishes!! read more

The scallop fresco was very good. The service was good and friendly. Unfortunately that's where the good stops. There were gnats in the bathroom and by the end of the night they were surrounding the bar area. The veal was chewy and didn't have good flavor. The fri glass of moscato was flat, I asked for another and they kindly opened a new bottle and poured from it. That glass was good. read more

See all

Such a refreshing change! The food is like your mom or grandma's cooking, but on a different level. The food has a very home-cooked feel to it, but the flavors and the time taken to carefully prepare each dish sets Cardone's apart from other restaurants. The service was superb. The waitress was very kind and attentive, but not hovering at all. The restaurant was very clean and has a small/romantic/cozy bistro vibe. The food and drinks from appetizer to dessert were amazing. This is a restaurant where you want to keep coming back to try different dishes. Cardone's is everything you want and more for a nice dinner out. read more

Found this place on Yelp, while in town on business. A wonderful refreshing change from chain restaurants. Staff was attentive and knowledgeable. I had the lobster bisque and the Gorgonzola gnocchi. Both were wonderful. Gnocchi had a great flavor without being overpowering. Small intimate space would be perfect for a date or special occasion. read more

5/5 on all fronts. Hannah, our waiter, was fantastic with quick and attentive service. We came in with my 1 year old nephew and they showed great patience despite being a higher-end restaurant. Food felt like home and was worth every dollar. Great choices on wine as well. read more

We have gone a few times and each time we've had Awesome food, Great service and a very nice atmosphere. Highly recommend!

Rude and incompetent manager. Utter failure. I ordered take out for Valentine's Day. I showed up at the time the food was promised. I waited 30 more minutes on the patio (dining room was packed with people apparently getting their food) for my order with no response. Ultimately, I asked for my food or my money back. The hostile and rude manager lectured me for complaining rather than providing service. His excuse was, "Come on man, it's Valentine's Day. Don't come in here and be hard." My money was eventually refunded and I left. I will not be back and advise anyone to avoid this place. While annoyed, I was not rude. My Valentine's Day dinner was ultimately from Wendy's. Cardone's ruined my plans. To be lectured by the rude and incompetent manager for daring to ask for a refund for something not delivered after waiting 30 minutes was upsetting. Avoid this place. read more

Adorable little place .. the house red wine is delightful .. bar tender is amazing .. love the spaghetti and meatballs and the lasagna . The star is the lemoncello flute. They also have seafood chef specials which are also delicious . Cheese bread with garlic and dipping oil is served warm . Highly recommend Cardones read more

See all

Amazing! My daughter and I just enjoyed the best homemade meal in a restaurant setting. Let me say - the pictures do not do this place justice. Fresh fresh fresh! We shared the eggplant appetizer. Then, split the gnocchi with beef ragu - a very generous serving even once split. The gnocchi was soft and pillowy. Finally, fresh stuffed cannoli that were room temp, crispy and creamy all at once. Highly recommend you stop by for a warm welcome and meal of true indulgence!! read more

We had a wonderful dinner here last night! Their lasagna is huge and delicious. Intimate inside and wonderful patio. Excellent food. Attentive service. Nice wine selection too. We will go here regularly. read more

Service was very good. Food wasn't great. Cold butter for bread. Servers appear to also be your bartender or drink mixer.

Everything was absolutely delicious! My entree, the chicken carbonara, was amazing! Can't believe I've never been here before but will definitely be back! read more

Cardone's Restaurant & Bar - Chicken Carbonara - Italian Near Me - Westerville, Ohio

They made us Chicken Carbonara even though they had removed it from the menu. It was really good. As was the warm Caprese Salad. Server was awesome. She was friendly and right on top of everything. read more

Atmosphere, genuine Italian food, great menu and service. The Cardone salad was impressive. At most restaurants they throw in lettuce. Couple tomatos and cucumber slices. My salad actually looked "hand crafted." Neat , the red raspberries neatly spaces around the bowl and an awesome homemade basalmic dressing. Lasagna was outstanding. Our server (Dave) did an outstanding job. read more

Incredible experience. Kennedy was our waitress and was so attentive and sweet. She made a great wine recommendation and explained the menu and specials perfectly. Everything was truly amazing. I can't wait to go back. read more

See all

This was one of my favorite local restaurants in Westerville, up to last Saturday 6/22. The service was fine, but I had to send back two entries. 1st was the short ribs which I love. However, I received a giant rib which I could not cut the meat from the bone. In the past, the meat would just fall off the bone. I returned and ordered th salmon, which was so undercooked, I had to return that as well. At that point I did not order a third entree. When I received the bill I had to challenge the staff to remove the salmon from the bill. Not sure what happened last Saturday and hope it was just a bad night for the staff. I'll give them another opportunity but it will be a while. read more

3.9 stars. Paso Bucco was a home run. Tender, delicious and extremely well prepared. King Salmon is a little on the smaller size but is delicious. Canole and Tiramisu are 5 star. read more

Delicious homemade Italian food. Short ribs melt in your mouth. Wonderful pastas and meat dishes. One star off for the dining area, it's dated, old fashioned, and a little smushed. Service is wonderful. read more

A little hole in the wall but a best-kept secret for sure! This place was outstanding from the service, the food, the extensive wine selection, the ambiance, all of it! Easy parking. Quiet. A great place for a date who appreciates really good Italian food. Go there! You won't regret it. read more

Had a great dinner with my wife last night. We enjoyed the arancini appetizer, wedge salads, gnocchi, and stuffed shells. Service was great, food was very well done. Very relaxing evening. read more

Delicious dinner out with friends! I had the spinach ricotta dumplings in a spicy red sauce. I would highly recommend the dish.

Very poor service and dinners not prepared to order. Was there Tuesday. Service to table with drinks very slow. Ordering was taken 30 minutes after sitting. Salads delivered 40 minutes later. Dinner plates delivered 35 minutes later, a hour and 45 minutes after sitting. Waiter just excuses that kitchen only has six burners. Three out of four dinner orders was not correctly prepared to order. If I could give no stars I would. read more

Tucked in the corner of strip mall off Main Street, this small Italian gem should not be over looked...especially since they have a nice lunch menu! Our waiter was super nice, answered all my Menu questions and provided good recommendations. Everyone at my table ordered a different dish and they all had great things to say about their dish. When asked if my co workers would return they all agreed- yes! They offer coke products. Their house salad and Italian dressing was great (I usually judge an Italian restaurant solely on their Italian dressing and yes, passed the test!) I loved the garlic bread they provide before the meal comes out. They had special soup of clam Chowder and it was pretty darn good! Impressed and looking forward to a second visit! read more

See all

Great pizza. We are a regular for the pepperoni mushroom pizza. Very accommodating staff that will work with you.

Good service and pleasant atmosphere. Special was a bit pricey for portion size but tasty.

Thee Best cannolis in Columbus! We ordered the Stuffed Portobello mushrooms an order of the fried mozzarella and capped it off with the cannolis!!! Pricey but worth it! I sincerely recommend!!!! read more

A group of 10 went to Cardone's last night (Saturday) to celebrate a bachelorette. The staff were awesome- two waiters took great care of us and we joked that there was a water ninja because we never noticed them filling our glasses! We started with two orders of arancini which I would recommended. Entrees come with a salad so we got those next (upcharge for a salad other than the house). We all enjoyed our entrees: cheese ravioli, the seafood pasta special of the night, sausage arrabiata, and chicken carbonara. The price was reasonable for the amount and quality of food and for including a salad ($16-24 for entrees). A few of us shared a bottle of the house Pinot noir for $19 (or $5 glass) which I thought was a good deal! Really liked the ambiance and music- dimly lit and intimate so good for a date or small group (but also was good for a non-rowdy bachelorette party). Will definitely go back!! read more

See all

It's ok. It wont make you puke or anything, but it's also not something to be remembered. My daughter's pizza crust was burnt and the sauce had a very weird flavor. I ordered the chicken carbonara. The sauce on this was very runny and not very good either. Chicken in the dish was cooked well....but that's about the only positive. They use small, skinny corkscrew shaped pasta, which is weird. I've never had carbonara with that type of pasta before...its definitely NOT house made either...or even close. I usually do try desserts when I go to a new restaurant for the 1st time, but I was so underwhelmed by the main course, I didnt bother here. The 1 great thing about this visit was our server Kennedy. She was awesome. read more

Clean, pride in ownership..... solid....very enjoyable and good food. Try to sit outside. Unpretentious but very fine