Made a reservation for 10 people a few days out. They were super accommodating, and we even bumped…read moreit up by one like two days before. More kind and accommodating on the phone than just about any restaurant I've ever called. We came in like a half hour early, over the course of 20 minutes, cause we were traveling in multiple vehicles from ways away... I called ahead, but they said it was no problem at all. They were super helpful, I got drinks started while the rest of the party arrived. Ordered a bunch of appetizers... Mozzarella, sweet potato, waffle, fries, calamari... With like three different dipping sauces. Each of those was fantastic. Folks ordered burgers, chicken, cheesesteaks, traditional fair, like cottage pie, etc. Quantities were massive. Food was tasty. Many to go boxes were provided. The desserts were a surprise... I got my bread pudding to go. And then a few people got the lava cake and shared it. Great beer selection. Great cocktail selection. Great music on the speakers... At least I thought so, the Young'ns weren't as impressed with the sing-along Classics. Our server was beyond helpful, responsive, kind, accommodating,; probably one of the best I've ever had... Is that possible? Big party, I didn't check the details on the check... and the large party tip was included already. So I gave her too much cash for the tip, she stopped me on the way out and wanted to make sure I didn't screw up... Which I did. So she returned a couple bucks. But she earned every every bit for a tip yesterday.

Market Cross Pub in Carlisle feels like a staple of the downtown area, a traditional, slightly…read moreold-school pub that delivers about what you'd expect. I've been there a few times over the years, and each visit has been about the same: decent food, good drinks, and service that's friendly but sometimes a little slow compared to the crowd size. It's not exceptional, but it's steady, and there's value in that kind of reliability. The atmosphere is distinctly classic, with dark wood paneling, dim lighting, and an overall feel that's equal parts pub and old-school cigar bar. It's a little dated, but in a way that feels intentional--authentic to the town's character. You get the sense that a lot of local business deals and long lunches happen here, and that's part of the charm. The location is just off the main drag where most of the Carlisle festivals and events happen, which can affect how busy it gets. During downtown festivals, expect crowds, but otherwise, it's a good place to relax and catch up over a meal or a pint. Overall, Market Cross Pub isn't trying to reinvent itself--it's simply a solid, familiar spot with dependable food, friendly service, and an atmosphere that fits Carlisle perfectly.

Update 1/25/16: Today I picked up my commissioned piece as mentioned in my prior review. It is even…read moremore beautiful than I anticipated. (If I had the ability to add an additional star to my review, I would do so.) My custom piece is an enameled silver and gold pendant with a rainbow feather and dangling word "hope". There is a light blue natural zircon stone in "Hope"... light blue for prostate cancer ( one of the two cancers my husband has fought), as well as being my husband's birthstone. Etched on the back of the pendant is a Cancer Awareness ribbon. I am delighted with the result and craftsmanship of this piece. It holds a lot of personal meaning. There is no doubt I will be coming back to this location for jewelry repair, commissions, or gifts.

Fixed my great-grandmothers ring! So grateful, great customer service! Would definitely recommend!read more

Don't get in here that often, but it's nice to see it's always busy when I drive past. Stopped here…read morefor a late lunch and tried one of their Handcrafted Burgers® - the O-M-Cheeseburger®. Burger was good, although mine might have been a tad overdone as there was really no gooey-cheese as pictured - was more stuck to the plate....tasted good tho'. Service was good although no one offered refills ...weren't looking for any so that's ok. Vibe is still Applebee's '90s-'00s which is ok by me - definitely knew where I was! ;) Kind of a time-capsule for me ...good to come and reminisce!

this place gets busy but the burgers are fantastic . a little slow but hey , relax , have a drink…read moreand enjoy , life is too short .