Used their catering services at work. Bummed I didn't get any pictures but we had a big variety of…read morethings and everything was delicious. Everything from penne, alla vodka, chicken parm, eggplant parm, sliders with garlic knots as the bread, salad, chicken cutlets, plain cheese pizza, etc. All were really good.

I came here with my two-year-old and we sat down to eat. The girl at the counter told us she would…read morebring the food to our table, so we sat at an empty one. We ordered two slices and an order of six knots. She brought the two slices, and I simply asked to confirm if the knots were included in the order. She gave me the nastiest look and said, "I only have two hands, geez." I was honestly taken aback and said, "Whoa, that was rude." When she came back, instead of handing the food to us, she placed the knots on the empty table next to me like we were animals. I was in complete disbelief. She was rude for absolutely no reason. I was just confirming the order. Never again. Just flat out disgusting. And my toddler begged me for pizza and I had to get up and ask for a refund because there was no way we would just sit there and eat in a rude uncomfortable environment. What happen to humanity!

Stopped by La Supreme Pizza for dinner with family a few weeks ago and had a great time all around…read more It was a first time visit for most of us, but we came based on a recommendation that they had one of the best Sicilian pepperoni slices in the area. If you're wondering, yes, it totally lived up to the hype. What else went well? The service and really all of the other food we ordered. Just a positive experience overall. La Supreme Pizza is a small pizza shop located in a strip of businesses. There's plenty of free parking shared among the other shops. The inside does have a few tables if you want to enjoy your food on site. We were a party of seven people and took up almost half of the seating area. The staff was really accommodating and helpful as we tried to organize the order for so many people. All of the food was great. Some standout items for me included the Sicilian Pepperoni slices, stuffed garlic knots, and the plain slice. Highly recommend any of these items. My first visit to La Supreme Pizza was a hit. My family and I would definitely return in the future the next time we're in Oakdale.

This one was hard to review. I wanted to give 3 and a half stars. We were in this strip of…read morebusinesses for an afternoon show at CM theater. Starving when we got out, the pizza smelled great from outside the doors, so in we went. Five tables inside a small old school looking pizza place. Four of them occupied on a Saturday around 5:30pm. Went to the counter, 2 girls behind the counter, one gentleman making pizza. No one acknowledged my presence when looking in the case full of decent looking pizza. I asked if I could please have 2 regular slices, a pepperoni slice and a grandma slice. I didn't see any fountain drinks so I picked a can of soda out of the case. The young girl put the pizza in the oven and another girl brought all of the pizza to the table on a tray. We got our own plastic utensils and there was salt, pepper, garlic powder, cheese and napkins on each table. The regular cheese pizza was great! Cheese to sauce ratio was perfect. Crispy on the bottom, soft and chewy on the inside. Hot and a tad bit greasy. The size of the slices were different though. One was big and one was small. The pepperoni slice was weird. You would think it was a regular cheese slice with pepperoni on top. But it wasn't anything like the other cheese slices. It was thicker with a lot more cheese and a lot less sauce. The pepperoni was the best part. I don't know what was going on with this slice. There was a plastic squeeze bottle of honey on the counter, but I didn't use it. It just said "honey". (Not Hot) Lastly, the grandma slice was super fresh. Corner slice with a flavorful sauce. A hint of garlic without obvious chunks and the cheese to sauce ratio was on point. However, it was cold! Not luke warm, cold! I don't know why or how it came to the table this way. We didn't have time to wait again for it to be warmed up. It's a shame, it would have been so much better if it was hot. Oh and the can of soda was warm. Cold can, war soda. Whaaat!? We weren't asked to pay before sitting down. I guess it was the honor system until we finished eating? Regardless, we cleaned the table and went to the counter to pay. I was the first person on the line and the same girl who took my order played with the register for about 2 minutes after I told her I'd like to pay. She scrolled and scrolled and then said "would you mind waiting a few minutes?" and proceeded to help the next customer with a pick up order. I was pushed off to the side but didn't leave her sight because we had to go. She looked at me again and asked "what did you order again?" I get it. It was 15 minutes ago and we didn't pay right away, but you could have said 5 minutes ago that you didn't recall what we had instead of pushing me to the side to help someone else. It just didn't sit right with me. So after I told her what we ordered, she asked me a second time as she fumbled with the register! I told her again and I asked her for a receipt. She told me a "cash total". Hmmm, I thought we weren't doing that any longer in NY without signage. I had the cash and handed it to her. She gave me the change but no receipt. I had to ask for that again as well. So again, this was a tough one to review. It was our first time. The food was hit or miss. There was no customer service (with the exception of the girl who brought the tray of food over to the table). No thank you for coming or have a nice day. Would we go back? Yes, if in that strip of stores. Otherwise, we would keep driving down the road until we hit The Pizzeria in Bayport. No food pics as we were in a rush.

Great pizza in the corner of Uncle Guiseppe shopping center in Smithtown. Friendly service and…read morequality pizza Can stand up with the big boys of Brooklyn and Queens Try and judge for yourself

Now let's keep it real, it's very hard to find a good pizzeria that is worth 5 stars especially in…read moreNew York when there's a pizzeria on every corner. Now this is Tucked away in the corner of the parking lot with lots of competition around so it may go unnoticed. But from the food and the service from the girl at the counter this was a great experience. The inside is very cool, they also serve alcohol. I loved the decor all over. Now it is a bit pricy, I paid about $7 for a buffalo chicken slice which is fine considering the amount of chicken they put on the slice! This slice was loaded. I asked for it well done and they delivered. The buffalo chicken slice was crispy, no flop at all and loaded with flavor. Absolutely great place, now granted my rating is based off just trying this once but it was outstanding. The girl who works the counter is super sweet and very very well deserving of 5 stars herself. When I'm in the area I am excited to come back and try some more of their pizza. Great experience.

LARGE CHEESE PIZZA FOR 10.99 hard to beat lol also had the toxic wings 12 for 12.99 now that was…read morekind of pricey but they were good we asked them to make them extra crispy which we highly recommend. They give you blue cheese ranch for the wings so I would say something if you want regular ranch.

Quality is always better than quantity Working Man pricing in the heart of St James by far the best…read moreItalian food from here to Smithtown the quality of food that you don't expect from a little Pizzeria

Amazing pizza, I've gone here several times and the quality is consistently great. The guy making…read morethe pizzas (the owner?) is a very nice guy working hard every time I've been there night or day. Try the Upside down chicken Vodka pie, it's unbelievable!!!

First time visiting after a recommendation from a family member, and we were very happy we gave it…read morea try! We ordered takeout and went with the Arrows Meal Deal, which included a regular pie, baked ziti, chicken parm hero, and six garlic knots. The pizza was very good, the baked ziti was delicious, and the garlic knots were great. Everything was fresh and enjoyable. The restaurant itself was very clean, and the staff was pleasant and welcoming. Overall, a great first experience. We would definitely recommend it. Don't live in the area but if I did I would be a regular customer

This place lives up the New York Pizza ! The Chicken tenders…read moreand fries were way above average! The next day leftover pizza was like fresh bread

The people who work here couldn't care less. Went to pick up need to go order and the awkwardness…read morethat ensued was un parallel. The high schooler behind the counter maybe said three words while being confused before handing me my order. Very little seating. Food was very sub par. Will not go again.

Pretty tasty and filling two slices of fresh Sicilian pizza. Along with a Diet Pepsi fountain soda…read moreit hit the spot for around $10. Plenty of available seating mid afternoon. Nice staff who brought the pizza to my table as I waited. Located in the College Plaza shopping center.

Came for a quick bite ordered meatball Parmesan hero to stay (one other couple in there and they…read morebought slices. I waited just under 30 minutes and went back up to the counter to see what was wrong. Below are pictures of the hero. Bread had to be stale when they started the process ... never again I ate the meatballs and cheese... not that good but I was hungry

This was one of those visits where I really wanted to like this place and I did! Pizza was top…read morenotch! Wings were great! Garlic knots were spectacular! My wife & I were just saying we havent had a good garlic knot in forever but KCs answered the bell. The pricing was great too! Gameday specials all the time, and I believe $1 wings for Knick nights... I'll be visiting this place as a regular from now on!

I tried this place bc of there TikToks and I honestly didn't know it was so close to me and boy am…read moreI happy I did I haven't had the pizza yet but I have been here once a week since trying for the wings they have some unbelievable wings and sauce man the spicy garlic parm is my personal fav