With dozens of local pizza places in the Setauket/Stony Brook/Port Jeff area, I understand options are plentiful... but there's something to be said about Via Pizza being a true, classic Italian family run joint! They have the best plain slice around and know how to make solid parm heros. Their specialty slices are excellent too. Don't be afraid to customize pizzas, salads or anything really, as they will be sure to meet your requests. I have been to Via hundreds of times in my life (literally) and have never been disappointed. Family-run, classic pizza parlor that's affordable, delicious and consistent! read more

Via Pizza - monster salads with a true local! - Pizza Near Me - East Setauket, New York

Pizza,chicken Parmesan cutlet hero and zeppole are very good. Freshly made. Service is great.

The people who work here couldn't care less. Went to pick up need to go order and the awkwardness that ensued was un parallel. The high schooler behind the counter maybe said three words while being confused before handing me my order. Very little seating. Food was very sub par. Will not go again. read more

We ordered two cheese pies.Pizza was very good as always consistent never too oily. I also ordered a small Greek salad. The lettuce was crisp and plenty of feta cheese. The service is always friendly. This is a basically a take out pizza place. There are tables available if you want to grab a slice but it is not intended to be a dine in restaurant. That is fine because that was all I wanted to do. The tables are clean and neat. If I wanted to ambiance I would go to a restaurant to sit down and be served. read more

Pizza slices are HUGE! We got the large BBQ chicken pizza pie and 6 garlic knots for 5 people. Ended up having two slices left over for the next day. There's a small sit down area when you walk into the restaurant, but it is mostly meant for take out. The food itself is quite solid, I think it makes for a consistently 7-8/10 slice. This spot is absolutely a regular for me given its ease, price, quality, and portion sizes. For a bonus, I do also love getting pizza dough from them and making homemade pizza. Their kindness in this (and this tradition in general) makes me extremely content. read more

Decent place for a quick slice! Lots of options. Don't sleep on the appetizer sampler. Delicious! White pizza was good, but not best I've ever had. Skip the bathroom - it was not clean . read more

Along with the best pizza around Via also has great hot heroes especially the eggplant, chicken parm and meatball heroes. The eggplant is always fresh and cooked properly, the chicken cutlets are crispy on the outside and cooked just right on the inside and the meatballs are full of flavor and cooked to perfection. read more

Every single thing we ordered was mind blowing good. Opened the pizza box the second we got back into the car (parked directly in front of Via) and i wouldnt be surprised if the folks there got 1st row seats to the two of us doing the "this is soooo good" head nod over and over. Incredible crust and balance of toppings. We got a few slices and garlic bread and chicken parm. The slices are huge as well as the serving of chicken parm being able to feed a fam of 3-4. Hope youre on your way now, you wont regret it. read more

Via Pizza - Grandma Pizza Slice Broccoli Rabe & Sausage Slice Cant remember the bottom left slice name Buffalo Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza Slice - Pizza Near Me - East Setauket, New York

I may be hungover, but so was this pizza. A regular pie, half sausage, extra crispy, nothing crazy. Ignoring the fold on the pie, the cut was absolutely insane. Not proportional at all. My small party of hungover minions cannot be evenly fed. The crust is also NOT crispy at all. I can't pick a piece up without making a mess. This isn't the convenient meal I dreamed of. I never really come here but my fiancé loves the place. We were in need of a quick meal and while we will eat this pizza cause we are desperate; the world must know that we are never going back. read more

See all

Five years of returning visits and perfection hasn't changed. There are some more fun creations that have emerged over the years, but their grandma slice still can't be beat by anything this Island has to offer. read more

great pizzeria right off the main road! The staff is very attentive and the pizza is amazing! Worth trying all the different types of pizzas! read more

Great local pizza spot! Highly recommended in an area that has no shortage of pizza places to pick from. Their pastas and entrees and good as well and the portion sizes are a nice surprise. read more

I am the Executive Director at a local senior living community. Our residents have been requesting that we order takeout pizza to switch things up a bit for our dinner service. I placed a large order at the last minute and couldn't be more impressed with how kind and generous they were in the process. The pizza was delicious and our residents are now begging me to schedule another pizza night for them. Thank you Via Pizza for being a great local business that we are proud to support. I can't imagine we will be ordering pizza from anywhere else for the foreseeable future. read more

Had pizza, pinwheels, and some rigatoni ala vodka. Food was good but I was given the wrong pie. Still good. Was my first time here and I am looking forward to trying it again. Love the fact that it is an old school pizza shop with the owner present and working the counter. read more

Updating my review to say that I've been here many times, and it's still my favorite pizza place in the area. The guys behind the counter are always very friendly, and the pizza is always delicious. I love their crust, and their vegetable toppings are great. I'm especially a fan of their mushrooms--I've been disappointed by some other local places that serve wet, soggy mushrooms on top of the pizza. I'm also really grateful that Via now offers a vegan cheese option. I tried it for the first time the other day, and it was delicious! I'll definitely be ordering it again. I was at a work party a few months ago, and someone had several pizzas delivered. Everyone was commenting on how good it was. I was not surprised to find out it was from Via! read more

Classic LI pizza joint - good variety and crispy crust. Consistently satisfying for lunch or a quick dinner.

What an awesome place!! Not very big with only a few tables inside, but nan oh man they have plenty of options. The pies range from Mac n Cheese to probably whatever you can think of. Appetizers, pastas, salads, pies, heroes, calzones, desserts. Quick and super friendly service. Great place read more

This is a very small, unassuming little pizzeria. My wife and I had a dog rescue fund raising event nearby and we had 45 minutes to kill, so with our bellies rumbling, we stopped off for some pizza. With no prior knowledge of this particular establishment, all I could repeatedly say to myself was, "please don't suck, please don't suck." They didn't suck. Instead of my usual two regular slices, I went for the gold. I got one regular, one Sicilian, and a pepperoni pinwheel. My wife ordered a lasagna slice. The pinwheel was perfect, with pepperoni and a little bit of ham wrapped up in there. It was delicious. Moving onto my Sicilian slice, what can I say? The perfect amount of cheese, the crust was both soft and crisp. The sauce was tangy without being overly obvious. My wife's lasagna slice was fantastic. In fact, it was huge. I almost felt like they mistakenly gave us two slices, just forgetting to run the cutter down the middle. There was no chance that she was going to finish even a third of it, and since we knew we weren't going to eat leftovers at home (that's how I stay skinny), I took the bullet. It was a carb explosion, but it was totally worth it. Amazing, amazing, amazing. On top of all of that, the service was extremely friendly and attentive. I wish I lived in the area, I would go there more often. However, the next time I'm going by, I will remember to pull in and get something. Their selection is large for such a small place. I'm actually surprised, and disappointed, that there aren't more pictures. Recommended without hesitation. read more

Via Pizza - Plain, Sicilian and a pepperoni pinwheel - Pizza Near Me - East Setauket, New York

See all

I love the place it's best pizza around very clean prices is right and it's real Italian family

The pizza was a low 3 but the service brings it down. It was busy on a friday night which I completely understand. After waiting for 5 minutes at the counter a "regular" walks and literally 2 seconds in gets their order taken while im standing right there. I got my order taken right after but it kinda left a bad taste in my mouth. The other thing was that the pinwheel I got was stuck to the paper and the insides fell through the bottom. It turned into a gloopy mess that didnt taste that good. The lasagna slice and garlic knot slice were pretty good though. Im really not one to complain but I felt compelled to write this review. read more

Via Pizza - the bottom of the pinwheel - Pizza Near Me - East Setauket, New York

First time ordering from Via Pizza, not disappointed. We got a chicken/bacon/ranch which was PHENOMENAL, with relatively thin crust and packed with flavor. Also got a grandma Sicilian style pizza which was average (although to be honest I think I just personally prefer a higher cheese-to-tomato ratio, which contradicts the basic concept of a Sicilian pizza). Food was delivered very quickly (about 30 minutes) and was hot on arrival. May have a new favorite pizza joint in town! read more

Via Pizza - Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza - Pizza Near Me - East Setauket, New York

See all

Great local spot. Pizza is on point! The dough is special, just the right amount of crispy and tasty. I have a problem, it is very hard to just order a small amount. They are especially good the next morning (who doesn't love cold pizza). Their specialty pies are always changing and always interesting. Wife likes their stuffed garlic knots and ziti slices. Guys in their are always nice and friendly. It's your neighborhood spot. Support it! read more

I can't tell which I liked better, my pizza or the service. I shy away from pizzerias (or eating out for that matter) because of my severe allergy to parsley. I went in with my mom after an exhausting day half expecting to be turned away just as every other pizza place does when I scare them with my food allergies. The man behind the counter (who appeared to be either the owner or manager) offered to make me a custom slice. His exact words "I'll make you whatever you want and you won't have to worry about your allergies." I opted for a white slice with grilled chicken and sautéed spinach. It was PHENOMENAL. And the guy making the pizza was also SUPER nice and accommodating. Will 100000% be back!! read more

Via Pizza - White slice with grilled chicken and spinach - Pizza Near Me - East Setauket, New York

Love there pizza and service. A nice little gem hidden deep in Setauket! Highly recommend.

Super friendly staff, consistent quality. Imaginative new options. Penne A La Vodka is excellent. Great pasta choices in addition to the pizza . read more

Cheap but AMAZING Italian food, massive portions, and that's coming from someone visiting from Chicago. It's one factor in the "plus" column of my kid possibly going to Stony Brook. I was talking about your pasta just this morning. read more

Great regular and gluten free options. Super fast service. Friendly staff. Highly recommend.

We just moved into the area and have been trying to find our new go to takeout restaurants. Driving down the road not far from my house, I almost missed Via Pizza. This tiny little pizzeria on the North side of 25 is low key and easy to miss. But look for it and find it, you'll be glad you did. After pulling into the parking lot, I quickly checked yelp. There were no customers inside, which for a pizza place is usually a bad sign, but after quickly reading some reviews I decided it was worth a try. I ordered a ziti slice. It was delicious. My fiancé ordered a buffalo slice and a regular slice. We both really enjoyed our food. While we were eating more and more people started coming in. They seem to do a fair amount of takeout. We must have arrived during a lull. We liked our food so much we returned the following week for another go around. I ordered a pinwheel (pepperoni and ham) and white slice my fiancé ordered a tortellini slice and another regular slice. Once again, we were both pleased. I think we've found our new pizza place:) They make a lot of unique specialty slices, ones I haven't seen everywhere else and their regular slice is quite good too. I'm happy to have found this hidden gem and I look forward to eating my way through their menu!:) read more

See all

After moving to area we have been looking for a go-to pizza place. This is it. They have now become a weekly vice for us. Momma like the margarita pizza and I am the fan in f the social pizza. Simply amazing. read more

Just moved to the area, so glad we have a delicious pizza place nearby! Their margherita pizza and fried eggplant pizza were so yummy! I didn't get to take any pics bc we ate everything so quickly! Try them you won't regret it! read more

We're obsessed with the grandma pie! (Extra sauce puts it over the edge!) the people who work there are always so nice, too.

Always a satisfying pizza experience! One night my husband and I even called them back after picking up the pizza to let them know how delicious it was. My only complaint is their garlic knots can definitely use some work. They're generally very greasy and doughy, but it doesn't stop us from ordering from them frequently. read more

Gotta love Via Pizza and the staff. Awesome variety of pizza and they even deliver to the beach. We are here almost every week. Definitely a fan favorite in our house. read more

the pizza was ok. they have many different kinds. it turned my stomach when the counter person handled money and then handled the food. quite frankly I wanted to give it back to him, but I didn't want to embarrass him. NEVER HANDLE FOOD AND MONEY WITHOUT WASHING YOUR HANDS. please use gloves. read more

Their grandma slice is probably the best that they have. So many types of pizzas. Only criticism is that their slice for the chicken masala is a bit thin when I picked up my pizza it fell. read more

Chicken parm hero and pizza are delicious. Did pickup and food was nice and hot. Staff was friendly and food was ready when we arrived. We would definitely go back. read more

First time customer; ordered 2 Chicken Parm heros, one with peppers & onions. Absolutely fantastic. Very tasty: lots of chicken, lots of cheese, just the right amount of sauce (hate it when there's so much sauce, it's a sloppy mess to eat). Bread was toasty but soft inside. Gigantic! My new favorite place! read more

Lest you forget... I'm Asian, so what do I know about pizza? Not as much as you probably, but I do know that good pizza is a moving target; different things to different people. Out here on Long Island are a LOT of Italians. Not all the Italians from Italy, but they are Italians nonetheless. So this vest-pocket strip-mall pizzarria has a lot of credibility already going for it. Add to that an in-house mom (not the enormous apron-wearing broken-English speaking kitchen bully of yore, but a petite engaging, black turtleneck wearing, probably Saab-driving 21st century version). It felt like family working there with non-blood interns shoring up the stafft. Oh yeah, our call-in pizza was not made when we arrived. "Aiiiee" I think was the exact word uttered. So thick was the conversation with a regular in there about both the Giants and The Jets (ohh The Jets) not making it all the way that they had forgot completely to make our order. But we forgave that and joined in with the banter. Lucky for them we were football-friendly. They were truly sorry and overcompensated by giving us not the large salad we ordered but one-an-a-half times that. Also free garlic twists. As for the pizza it was good, different to me, but good; an anchovy and mushroom version. I thought the crust was too bulbous and large and the greater substrate, although having plenty of tensile strength, had too little compressive strength. Meaning? It did not have the structure to allow one to fold a slice in half (a la city) and not have it maintain its delta shape. Picture instead an origami crane's beak. The salad was excellent as were the twists. There were also interesting things in the glass cases, calzones etc. to marvel at. That alone made me want to come back. Conclusion? No great shakes; not the classic NYC street corner slice, but good competent pizza made with a big Italian heart. So style differences be damned I could get used to this. After all, Via is just another alternate pizza reality in the giant food mall of life. So go! Mangia! It's alright... read more

Was not disappointed by the pizza. We got a regular slice, buffalo chicken, eggplant parm, white slice and spinach/broccoli slice. The regular was really good, as was the buffalo. The S/B was good, the eggplant parm was tasty but too heavy, and the white slice was meh. Will definitely come back again. read more

The pizza is not bad but the prices are crazy. I paid $25 for a large 2-topping pizza (Hawaiian). I called in my order for pickup without seeing a menu and was extremely surprised at the total when I paid. The pizza itself was solid, although nothing exceptional that would justify the premium price. I would categorize it as "sloppy thin-crust". This is not a wood-fired pizza place with gourmet toppings or something like that. It's a little better than the Domino's down the street, but Domino's charges $8 for a large 3-topping pie during the week, which is a vastly better deal. Via's pizza definitely isn't worth triple the price. The store itself is unremarkable: a small place in a strip mall with a few seats. This just a take-out pizza parlor, not a full restaurant. Overall I would say the pizza itself gets a 4/5, but I'm knocking the total down to 2/5 because I just feel ripped off by the outrageous price. read more