Delicious food! Definitely nice size portions and friendly customer service. Definitely recommend!read more

Welcoming Friendly clean establishment that took over sundried tomato…read more Pizza cooked to order Ample parking Clean restrooms A little warm and worker suggested to sit in dining room which was better Music was peaceful Welllit

If you're looking for the kind of pizza spot that leaves a lasting impression, this spot was one of…read morethem. We made a quick pit stop here before heading out to Long Beach to catch the sunset and some live music on a Friday night. Let me just say, this place absolutely hits the mark, whether you're grabbing a pie to go or taking your time and soaking in the lively, authentic pizzeria vibe. The ambiance is effortlessly inviting. When you step in, you're greeted by the smell of fresh baked dough, gooey cheese, and a friendly crew behind the counter. Even though we were in a rush, you could tell Saint James is the kind of place where locals gather, families grab an easy dinner, and pizza lovers unite over a hot, cheesy slice. The walls are filled with classic memorabilia, and there's just something homey and vibrant about the space. Now to the star of the show: the pizza! We ordered a classic cheese pie right from their Yelp page (super easy process, by the way! All the menu options are laid out with prices and descriptions, and online ordering was a breeze). The crust was that perfect balance of thin, crisp on the bottom, with just enough chew to make each bite satisfying. The cheese was plentiful, gooey, and rich, with a tangy tomato sauce that tasted homemade. We enjoyed our pie oceanside at the beach, and even after the drive it held up perfectly. No sogginess or limp crust! I can only imagine how fantastic their pies are fresh from the oven in-house. Next time, I'm grabbing a seat and trying the pasta, too.

The pizza was good, and so fresh made to order! The only down fall was the grandma was really oily-…read morebut still tasty! The staff was incredibly friendly I will definitely return just because of the service!

Really nice people and great pizza! I had the sausage pizza and it was delicious. A lot of fun…read moregetting a good slice visiting all the way from California.

The pizza here is really good. Perfect to go and get a really good solid slice. Service was quick…read moreand people are nice. Pizza was delicious.

I loved my first visit to The Pizzeria in Smithtown! I brought my nephew for our lunch date on a…read moreSaturday afternoon. The ambiance inside is bright, clean, and welcoming. From start to finish, the service was excellent. Our waitress was super friendly and sweet, especially when my nephew decided he didn't want to share a pizza with me (how rude). She laughed with me and quickly brought him his own cheese slice, which made him happy! We started with drinks. My nephew had apple juice, and I got the Montauk Wave Chaser on tap. For starters, we went with the mozzarella sticks. They were perfectly crispy on the outside, with gooey cheese inside, and a side of marinara. A classic done right. I tried their bruschetta slice, which I think I could eat a slice of this everyday. The crust had a hint of balsamic baked in, topped with fresh bruschetta, creamy burrata, basil, and a balsamic glaze drizzle. So good. We decided to go with the Aunt Danielle. The personal pizza was 16", perfect for sharing. Topped with vodka sauce, pepperoni, stracciatella cheese, fresh basil, and a perfect swirl of hot honey over the top. The hot honey was the star of the show here. The spicy pepperoni mixed with the hot honey, mmmm mm. I will definitely be back. This place is a Smithtown gem! Highly recommended for families or anyone who loves great pizza with a twist. I can't wait to try their wraps that you could see through the window counter.

Stopped by for a quick slice for lunch. The ambiance is light and roomy inside and the service is…read morefriendly. The plain cheese slice was just ok, I've had much better tasting slices. We tried the regular garlic knots and buffalo knots. Not much flavor to them and they were small at 70 cents each but they were soft and fresh. The tri-fecta with was decent with a nice thin olive oil crust.

I went for the first time a few days ago and we sat down to eat. Everyone at the table loved what…read morethey got and they give you bread with oil and garlic knots as a free appetizer that are also amazing. Tonight we ordered a Sicilian Pizza and it's the best I've ever had. Also the delivery was free and they got to me within 25 mins after saying it would be 30-45 minutes. Everything about this place is 10/10.

I've lived in the area for about 15 years and had only tried Georgia's Pizza in Nesconset once…read morebefore--unfortunately, that first experience didn't leave much of an impression. Recently, I decided to give it another shot on two separate times, and some of their specialty pies: the vodka pizza with a garlic knot crust and the trio pizza (pesto, marinara, and vodka). I'll start with the positives--service was friendly and welcoming, which definitely made the experience more pleasant. And to be fair, the flavors across the pies were actually pretty good. The sauces complemented each other well. That said, the biggest issue--was the dough. It was noticeably undercooked which made the slices a bit doughy and hard to enjoy. On top of that, the pizza was quite greasy, which didn't help the overall texture. The undercooked dough stood out enough that it took away from what could have been a really solid pie. Another small note: the dining area looked like it could've used a quick sweep. Not a huge deal, but something that affects the overall impression when you walk in. I wouldn't completely write this place off, because the flavors are there and the staff is friendly. If I give it another try, I'd probably stick with a regular pie or maybe a Sicilian and specifically ask for it to be cooked well done. I think that could make a big difference.

Ordered a pie here for the first time for takeout, half margherita and half with pepperoni and…read moreonions. Nice thin cut pepperoni and not too salty. Good crust not too thick and bready because we prefer thin crust pies. Would return to try other dishes.

Decided to stop by after reading a bunch of really good reviews in Yelp, so glad we trusted it…read morebecause everything was amazing. This is a small strip mall restaurant, walked in at 5 and the place was empty, however the staff was amazing, we had questions due to dietary restrictions and our waitress was very gracious and of she didn't have an answer she went back to the kitchen to check. She recommended the rice balls and they were so good, really hot inside and not hard at all, filled with lots of mozzarella and a delicious vodka sauce and dollop of ricotta. The baked cod special was super tasty and came with some mussels on the side, bread basket was perfect and bread was super nice and warm. Fettuccini was delicious and creamy but not fatty or greasy. We had a wonderful dinner experience and will definitely recommend this restaurant to another looking for good food and great service.

Delicious pizza…read more Clean environment .tasty sandwiches Ice drinks To go or to stay. Wings piping hot and delicious w varied sauces

Just wanted to try something different been eating local pizza for the last 15 weeks since up here…read moreworking. Nice small place Pizza was very good had great crust and toppings. Glad to finally find a small salad dressing was great staff was very friendly. Will go back and try the wings looks like lots of flavors Don't go in with a crowd very small seating area.

Traditional New York Pizzeria that has it all! Pizza is OUTSTANDING, meatball parmesan, sausage,…read moreeggplant parmesan are ready and waiting for you to enjoy!!! Locals luv this place!!! Make sure to stop by and Michael & the guys!!!

I've heard their heroes are good (never had) but the pizza is trash. The sauce is very sweet and…read morethey don't put enough cheese or cook the pizza long enough. I remember it being better 20 years ago. The workers are nice and polite. Cash only. The only plus for me is that they are open late.

Great pizza in the corner of Uncle Guiseppe shopping center in Smithtown. Friendly service and…read morequality pizza Can stand up with the big boys of Brooklyn and Queens Try and judge for yourself

Now let's keep it real, it's very hard to find a good pizzeria that is worth 5 stars especially in…read moreNew York when there's a pizzeria on every corner. Now this is Tucked away in the corner of the parking lot with lots of competition around so it may go unnoticed. But from the food and the service from the girl at the counter this was a great experience. The inside is very cool, they also serve alcohol. I loved the decor all over. Now it is a bit pricy, I paid about $7 for a buffalo chicken slice which is fine considering the amount of chicken they put on the slice! This slice was loaded. I asked for it well done and they delivered. The buffalo chicken slice was crispy, no flop at all and loaded with flavor. Absolutely great place, now granted my rating is based off just trying this once but it was outstanding. The girl who works the counter is super sweet and very very well deserving of 5 stars herself. When I'm in the area I am excited to come back and try some more of their pizza. Great experience.

Wonderful and delicious! Worth the drive from anywhere to eat here ! They go above and beyond to…read moremake your experience a happy one! And the food is absolutely amazing . Seriously, you have got to try it ! Food ,service,Ambiance all over the top!!

Ate there recently before heading over to the movie theater close by. Plenty of ample parking, we…read morewalked through a very tight takeout area and was escorted to the seating in the rear. We were in a very nice booth, restaurant was very clean and service was attentive. We shared a house salad, that wasn't anything special, kind of bland. I ordered chicken piccata, chicken was tender, portion was large, but really couldn't enjoy it with the overuse of lemon in the sauce. We topped our meals with cappuccinos that we were very good.