Stopped by La Supreme Pizza for dinner with family a few weeks ago and had a great time all around. It was a first time visit for most of us, but we came based on a recommendation that they had one of the best Sicilian pepperoni slices in the area. If you're wondering, yes, it totally lived up to the hype. What else went well? The service and really all of the other food we ordered. Just a positive experience overall. La Supreme Pizza is a small pizza shop located in a strip of businesses. There's plenty of free parking shared among the other shops. The inside does have a few tables if you want to enjoy your food on site. We were a party of seven people and took up almost half of the seating area. The staff was really accommodating and helpful as we tried to organize the order for so many people. All of the food was great. Some standout items for me included the Sicilian Pepperoni slices, stuffed garlic knots, and the plain slice. Highly recommend any of these items. My first visit to La Supreme Pizza was a hit. My family and I would definitely return in the future the next time we're in Oakdale. read more

See all

This one was hard to review. I wanted to give 3 and a half stars. We were in this strip of businesses for an afternoon show at CM theater. Starving when we got out, the pizza smelled great from outside the doors, so in we went. Five tables inside a small old school looking pizza place. Four of them occupied on a Saturday around 5:30pm. Went to the counter, 2 girls behind the counter, one gentleman making pizza. No one acknowledged my presence when looking in the case full of decent looking pizza. I asked if I could please have 2 regular slices, a pepperoni slice and a grandma slice. I didn't see any fountain drinks so I picked a can of soda out of the case. The young girl put the pizza in the oven and another girl brought all of the pizza to the table on a tray. We got our own plastic utensils and there was salt, pepper, garlic powder, cheese and napkins on each table. The regular cheese pizza was great! Cheese to sauce ratio was perfect. Crispy on the bottom, soft and chewy on the inside. Hot and a tad bit greasy. The size of the slices were different though. One was big and one was small. The pepperoni slice was weird. You would think it was a regular cheese slice with pepperoni on top. But it wasn't anything like the other cheese slices. It was thicker with a lot more cheese and a lot less sauce. The pepperoni was the best part. I don't know what was going on with this slice. There was a plastic squeeze bottle of honey on the counter, but I didn't use it. It just said "honey". (Not Hot) Lastly, the grandma slice was super fresh. Corner slice with a flavorful sauce. A hint of garlic without obvious chunks and the cheese to sauce ratio was on point. However, it was cold! Not luke warm, cold! I don't know why or how it came to the table this way. We didn't have time to wait again for it to be warmed up. It's a shame, it would have been so much better if it was hot. Oh and the can of soda was warm. Cold can, war soda. Whaaat!? We weren't asked to pay before sitting down. I guess it was the honor system until we finished eating? Regardless, we cleaned the table and went to the counter to pay. I was the first person on the line and the same girl who took my order played with the register for about 2 minutes after I told her I'd like to pay. She scrolled and scrolled and then said "would you mind waiting a few minutes?" and proceeded to help the next customer with a pick up order. I was pushed off to the side but didn't leave her sight because we had to go. She looked at me again and asked "what did you order again?" I get it. It was 15 minutes ago and we didn't pay right away, but you could have said 5 minutes ago that you didn't recall what we had instead of pushing me to the side to help someone else. It just didn't sit right with me. So after I told her what we ordered, she asked me a second time as she fumbled with the register! I told her again and I asked her for a receipt. She told me a "cash total". Hmmm, I thought we weren't doing that any longer in NY without signage. I had the cash and handed it to her. She gave me the change but no receipt. I had to ask for that again as well. So again, this was a tough one to review. It was our first time. The food was hit or miss. There was no customer service (with the exception of the girl who brought the tray of food over to the table). No thank you for coming or have a nice day. Would we go back? Yes, if in that strip of stores. Otherwise, we would keep driving down the road until we hit The Pizzeria in Bayport. No food pics as we were in a rush. read more

La Supreme Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Oakdale, New York

Stopped in today for their spaghetti & meatballs lunch special and it did not disappoint. The place was clean and organized. There were tables outside with umbrellas for the nice weather. Each table had napkins and seasonings. The lunch was very very good! A generous portion of spaghetti and two smallish but delicious meatballs. They even included two garlic knots! I'd grab this special again in a second and I'd also like to try others. Nice work! read more

I did not have a good experience yesterday (3/10/26) when I came in for a slice of pizza with a friend. The young woman behind the counter was not friendly at all and it felt like she was annoyed that we were there. I also don't understand how an eating establishment does not have a bathroom for customers to use.... Overall, it was a very unpleasant experience. read more

Great pizza! The area is small, but it's a cute little pizza shop and such a nice location! The service was great and the workers are very friendly and helpful! read more

They don't care about people. I ordered DoorDash they made the dasher wait over 30 minutes for 1 pizza pie. These people are trash. I left the dasher an extra 5 bucks but that mustve been over an hour of his time. I called to complain, they told me to get lost. read more

My friends my wife and I got sick from the food from this place beware We all ate same food we all had diarrhoea. We will never order from here again read more

The food is good fast delivery the customer service is awesome and sweet allow the girl are very sweet

Excellent pizza. Good variety of specialty slices and all that I've tried have been very good. Service is quick and polite.

Stopped by as I passed the strip mall where this pizza joint was located. Did a quick check on my benchmark cuisine (garlic knots and vodka sauce), and stopped in as per the stellar reviews for same. Sometimes I am bitterly disappointed, but this time I was not! Tale of the tape: Garlic Knots I got them hot to go, and witnessed a procedure I've never seen before in garlic knot preparation. After a few minutes in the oven, they were brushed with a combination of garlic butter and parsley, after which a sprinkling of parmesan cheese was applied to all knots in the tin! Whoa! The knots are large in size, have a light crisp and an airy texture which I've never experienced before in a garlic knot. The garlic flavor is definitely present, and overall I am impressed enough to give these knots a very good to bordering on greatness rating. I would definitely buy them again! Chicken alla Vodka slice Again, given the positive ratings, I was fortunate to get the last chicken vodka slice in the case. The crust is amazingly light and airy, despite its half inch thickness. The chicken is plentiful, and has a decent amount of vodka sauce among it . . . Perhaps the only part of the slice that comes up short is the mozzarella on top, but it doesn't take away from the goodness of this slice. The sauce is creamy and savory, enough for me to be enthusiastic about ordering a vodka pasta dish from this pizza restaurant. read more

La Supreme Pizza - Garlic Knots - served hot and brushed with garlic butter, and sprinkled with parmesan cheese. Excellent! - Pizza Near Me - Oakdale, New York

See all

Three months ago I was starving after grocery shopping nearby so I decided to take a chance on a Grandma's slice for which I paid $5 and change. I agree with the other two reviewers: subpar pizza with barely any sauce and overpriced. Counter service: Meh. No eye contact and no "thank you". read more

Went today for the first time . Very delicious . I saw a Detroit style pizza thay caught my eye and it was amazing . Grandma style was very good too . It's rare to see places on Long Island that have Detroit style . And this place has Detroit AND New York style . Highly recommend the meatball parm slice . read more

La Supreme Pizza - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Oakdale, New York

Trash. Horrible pizza. Threw most of it out, and not a friendly person in the place (even the new girl). Almost $10 for 2 slices. Looks like nobody cares enough about the place to clean up either. Left this place and went to Pizzaiola for lunch I didn't have to toss. read more

La Supreme Pizza - Cheese slice and chicken bacon ranch slice - Pizza Near Me - Oakdale, New York

Everybody knows that New York City is famous for great pizza. But what you may not know is that when you get deep into Suffolk County, you can expect to find some delicious slices there as well. La Supreme has all the elements of great pizza baked right inside. First and most important a nice sweet, tangy tomato sauce, sandwiched in between their crispy crust and some nice chewy, pillowy mozzarella. Interesting tidbit is that the slices are little fat triangles. A nice change, which makes them easy to handle. I'm not sure of the geometry behind this, but I'm sure happy I stumbled upon this terrific pizzeria in the heart of patchogue. read more

What a great place !!!! They catered my husbands birthday party and the food was fabulous !!!! I've never eaten here so I figured why not try out the pizza before having them cater. Both my daughters and I loved the pizza especially the garlic knot crust pizza. I ordered pizza, pepperoni pizza, penne with vodka sauce, garlic knots (best I've ever had) tossed salad and Caesar salad for 60 people and everyone raved about the food and the leftovers were delicious the next day!!! Ordering was easy (they were wonderful to deal with ) and they delivered on time. I'm looking forward to ordering from them again !!! read more

Love this place. Great service and their food is consistently good. I love the Stromboli, and they have a great cannoli. Ala Vidka sauce is amazing. read more

I would rate la supreme pizza three and a half stars. They have an interesting selection of pizzas including stuffed pizza, vegan cauliflower pizza, and pizza with garlic knots along the crust. I decided to go simple with a grandma slice. Thin, crispy crust. You can't go wrong with a grandma slice. read more

I've been going to this spot for years!! I didn't realize that it changed ownership. The food and the staff are subpar!!! Thank god for the Wendy's across from it!!! read more

Such a variety of pizza and they are all delicious!! Try the chicken Ala vodka pizza, you won't be disappointed!

Excellent plain cheese pie! Never got to try the specialty pies but I judge my pizza places on the traditional NY pizza. And they do this right ! Good cheese that's not watery like some places have. Nice doughy crust that's a bit thick for my taste but it a good crust nonetheless. read more

La Supreme Pizza - Just a good plain slice - Pizza Near Me - Oakdale, New York

Have been coming here for lunch for the past 7 years and the chicken Cesar wrap is still my favorite! And still tastes the same! Never greasy messy or soggy! Thank you La Supreme you have amazing homemade food read more

La Supreme Pizza - Grilled Chicken Caesar Wrap - Pizza Near Me - Oakdale, New York

BEST mozzarella sticks of all time. Chicken ceasar salad and fettuccine alfredo are perfection! Also reallllly delicious specialty slices! I order delivery direct from them all the time. Super friendly, accommodating & fast! Couldn't ask for more from a pizzeria! read more

This local Pizzeria in Oakdale has become our go to fave. They have a great regular slice, what more can you ask for? They have a good selection of specialty pizza's and your standard Italian dinner entrees. The staff is extremely friendly and accommodating. The restaurant is clean and presentation of food is fresh and yummy looking! I grew up in Oakdale and ate more slices than I can count in the restaurant it replaced. This place is far better in every way than Oakdale Pizza. You really can't go wrong here! read more

Hands-down best pizza parlor in all of Long Island. I would not steer you down the wrong path on this one, super sweet and friendly staff are just a bonus to the amazingly fresh food they serve. Imagine if you will a zep filled with cannoli cream Crack fueled total orgasm. Not a bit of the cream went to waste. For someone who smokes a lot of grass and rolls a lot of trees this place is super dangerous. Stop by today and get addicted. Sidenote I am a sucker" for a Polish boy in sweatpants read more

La Supreme Pizza - I left my heart in Le supreme - Pizza Near Me - Oakdale, New York

Penne alla vodka - YUMMMMMM! Plain slice delish and Caesar salad hit the spot. I ordered via door dash and everything was perfect. I'd definitely order from here again! read more

The Best. Entrees and pasta dishes. Excellent. Low salt and oil. Can't get any better.

We live in Manhattan and have been trying to find a decent Greek salad in our neighborhood, which you wouldn't think would be too hard to come by. We are out here for the weekend at an event and we'd drive out again just for this Greek salad alone. So good, above and beyond. Thank you! read more

Thanks so much to Vinny and La Supreme Pizza for catering our family party. For years, we have been regularly ordering take out and love the pizza and pasta dishes. Vinny was so easy to work with (he modified the catering menu to meet our needs - seafood linguini was awesome) he stopped over the house on the morning of our party to hand deliver some supplies and gave us a really great price - much better than any of the local competitors. All our guests raved about the food - it was amazing. Thanks to Matt who really helped out with delivery and the set up of the food! Really appreciate it!! If you're looking for a delish Italian meal, a quick slice or excellent catering, this is the place! Thanks La Supreme! read more

Pizza was good, however the large pie was small, slices were eaten in 5 bites. I've seen bigger frisbees

Was very disappointed with the food from this pizzeria. Have ordered from here in the past with no issues but this time everything was horrible from the meals to the desert. The baked ravioli as covered in greasy oil and the chocolate cake was old, stale and a melted mess. The chicken sandwich was supposed to have fresh spinach on it but it was cooked and bitter! What a waste of money! read more

Love this place for their vegan pizza! We know of several places to get vegan pizza in the area, but their sauce and dough is our absolute favorite! read more

Great pizza. Very nice staff. Definitely better priced than other local places. You could also order through the slice app.

Great food, garlic knots out of this world and penne alla vodka is awesome. And delivery on time.

Great Sicilian pizza. Had delivered to my hotel. Fast and easy. Great way to end a long day of travel.

The pizza tastes like regret. The heros taste like self loathing. I've made better food in soup kitchens. Prisoners in jail would send the food back if they were given this pizza. In the future, I will walk by this place even if they were giving away free food.. At least the previous owner made food that was edible. read more

Love their pizza! It's extra cheesy on thin crust, sauce isn't too sweet, lots of toppings.

Pizza and garlic knots are delicious! This is my regular pizza place for take out. I've also tried the chicken parm which was great- was able to divide it into multiple meals because the portion was large. read more

1This is my favorite pizzeria and Italian restaurant for miles and miles!! The pasta dishes are amazing.. penne ala dente with garlic, oil, sausage, broccoli rabe is amazing- the pizza is fresh and alot of varieties. Everything is good here and reasonably priced. read more

Fix the chewy crust and maybe I'll change my mind. My bf likes the specialty slices and keeps bringing this pizza home. That crust is killing me with how chewy it is. I've had this pizza about 4 separate times and the crust is always an issue for me. I didn't even finish my pizza yesterday due to the crust. read more

Had the Margarita pizza last night and it was the best pizza ive had in a while! The crust was crispy, the mozzarella and basil were fresh and the sauce was light. Soooo good! read more