Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Carl's Coney Island

    3.6 (7 reviews)
    Closed Closed
    Updated a few days ago

    Carl's Coney Island Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Carl's Coney Island

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    4 days ago

    Best coneys I've come across! Friendly staff and laid back environment. The taco salad is very good as well and the (reg) servings are big!

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Tim H.
    3
    17
    11

    5 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 1
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Ray J.
    0
    16
    3

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Great service. All employees were friendly and happy to help. Great food. I always enjoy this place. The coney's are awesome!

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Very bad. The chilli tasted like hormel or wolf brand chilli. If you like I Lander or downtown coney island, avoid this place.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Carl's Coney Island

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for New American 6,552 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Cow & Cabbage - Gnocchi

    Cow & Cabbage

    4.6(14 reviews)
    4.1 miCherry Street

    Fabulous! This was my second time dining here and it was perfection. We had the fried chicken and…read moredumplings and the farmer's pie along with deviled eggs. The servers were delightful and atmosphere - on point. Dining options were upstairs or you could dine on the main floor in the grocery area. Both were great options.

    What a great experience. We had a friend visit recently and he told us we must go as soon as we…read morewere able. We sat upstairs (which I would recommend for dinner). Service was spot on throughout the entire night. We started with the deviled eggs, half plain and half Chef's Choice. The Chef's Choice were the best, drizzled with chili crisp (or pickled Szechuan peppercorns) and topped with a tiny gherkin and fresh dill. The soup of the day was a cabbage and radish soup. It was interesting and very homey but I wish I had ordered the salad. I had the Novarro Farm sweet Potato Gnocchi (kale and pecan pesto, Birch Bottom Farm Georgia candy roaster, fresh chevre). I was a little hesitant about the kale pesto but should NOT have been. This dish was delicious--great garlic flavor. Would order again. The burger looked amazing and while The Hubs said it was good, he also said it needed some more spice. They had a couple of rotating beers from Heirloom--a Mexican Lager and an Italian Pilsner. I had the Water Lily cocktail, their take on an Aviation. Order it just because it's beautiful (and refreshing). The photo does not depict the deep color of it. I asked what other gin based cocktails they had on their menu. They didn't but the server/bartender offered to make me a Bee's Knees for the second round. It was delicious! The atmosphere here is casual but the food is elevated. I kept thinking this is what a French bistro would be like inside. I want to come back and shop the market. Oh, and the apple pie was excellent as well!

    Photos
    Cow & Cabbage - Menu

    Menu

    Cow & Cabbage - Beans

    Beans

    Cow & Cabbage - Cornbread

    See all

    Cornbread

    Oren - Chicken sandwich with fries

    Oren

    4.4(131 reviews)
    3.0 mi
    $$$

    Dinner tonight was terrific. i came to Tulsa to celebrate my sister in law and brother's special…read morebirthdays. I asked them to select a very nice restaurant, they selected Oren. I contacted the restaurant to see if they could acknowledge this special event. The reply Igot was, "...of course, dessert is on us". I thought, how nice. When we arrived at Oren, our table was ready and waiting with a Happy Birthday o the table. And, our menus were specially printed and across the top read: Happy Birthday Ronnie and Allen,, what a lovely touch! Our server, Ava, was wonderful and very attentive, We ordered Caponata, which was probably the best I ever had. We each ordered a salad, I had the Cherry Tomato with goat cheese--delish! We ordered the trout and the short ribs with pasta, also quite yummy. For dessert we had sherbet and the vanilla ice cream sundae. As an added treat, Ava brought us chocolate chip cookies. All and all a wonderful celebratory dinner. I highly recommend

    Huge bar, great selection of whisky! Im pregnant so couldn't partake. But, just looking at…read moreeveryones fancy drink orders was fun and they all looked amazing. Ambiance reminds me of a fancy place you would find in a larger city. Upscale and minimalistic. Very pleasant. I sat at the bar so unsure about service at a table. Unfortunately, I felt overlooked at the bar, especially since I wasn't drinking. The staff was extremely busy making drinks and I had to get their attention whenever I needed anything. Would recommend making reservations to get a table seat to receive proper service. I ordered the burger with fries. Cooked well but the flavor was nothing special. Will return and try something else!

    Photos
    Oren - Bar

    Bar

    Oren - Butternut Squash Soup

    Butternut Squash Soup

    Oren - Fresh to Death cocktail

    See all

    Fresh to Death cocktail

    The Avery - Shrimp Carbonara

    The Avery

    4.0(66 reviews)
    4.2 miDowntown
    $$

    Tonight I dined solo and late. Service was excellent even after 9 pm. Ordered The Cyrus Burger…read morewhich was supposed to be layered with pickles, fried onions, and mustard. The pickles were very good, but the onions were super thin and long strings that slung the mustard, which there was WAY too much of all over the place every time you took a bite as I wasn't able to cut them easy with my bite. Opted for the onion rings which were superb!! Easy bite through that was clean and didn't pull out the onion like you might find with sonic onion rings.

    I sat at the bar which was comfortable and clean. The bartender was very friendly and helpful when…read moreI asked a few questions about the menu. She kept my fountain drink full! I'm a keto dieter, and I will say that there are several tasty options to choose from. I will often get a burger with no bun, which is what I was craving today. This one went beyond my expectations! It was a hand-formed 8oz patty, and the chef was able to make it a perfect medium rare. It was delectably juicy, seasoned just right, and the cheese, peppers, onions and tomatoes topped it off perfectly. My salad had nice big slices of Parmesan cheese on top, and the lettuce was fresh and crisp, the dressing just right. Removing croutons is never a problem, but I appreciated that they happily left them off when they prepared the salad. If you're looking for keto options, you'll find many good choices here!

    Photos
    The Avery - Decor

    Decor

    The Avery - Cocktail

    Cocktail

    The Avery - (her Britney Spears Dirty) martini

    See all

    (her Britney Spears Dirty) martini

    Bird and Bottle - Pimento Burger

    Bird and Bottle

    4.3(299 reviews)
    5.1 miMidtown
    $$$

    food moms brought me home leftovers from brunch, including…read moreplantain, waffle, eggs, and toast. the plantain was thick, juicy, and delicious, the waffle same, with syrup infusion as a bonus, the toast with infusion too, butter variety that is, and eggs, lil cheese, excellently cooked, pun habit, sorry, and a meal which any beverage would pair perfectly, and though, i'm not currently recalling if it was coffee or water I'd paired, the meal as a whole was perfect. service momma graciously offered me leftovers after brunching with her friend, absolutely amazing service, love, momma. ambiance giving environmentally friendly based on togo container material that looked like recycled material, though not entirely certain.

    This is a tough one. We didn't get there until 3:00. Starved. It was a "sit anywhere" situation…read more Only 2 others in the entire dining room, but the bar seemed pretty busy. Only visible staff was the bartender (owner?). She was a terrific waitress. Love those $4 martinis. Hubby ordered his fav fish & chips, I ordered the "Black & Blue" flatbread. I would have sent back his whole plate. Instead of toasty brown everything was burnt. The black & blue: some great flavor from the cheese, tomatoes, pickled red onion, nonmemorable horseradish sauce, pretty presentation. My opinion, leave off what little steak there is. Adds nothing to the flavor, only some tough chew bites. The crust: I know there's argument here. I'm usually for good char on a pizza (I've had pizza all around Italy). But this was burnt and smelled burnt. Disappointed? Way. We'd wanted to get there for some time. I'm still intrigued by some of their menu items. We may give them another chance and view this as a very off day.

    Photos
    Bird and Bottle - Cute prosecco glasses

    Cute prosecco glasses

    Bird and Bottle
    Bird and Bottle

    See all

    The Chalkboard Kitchen + Bar - Eggs Benedict

    The Chalkboard Kitchen + Bar

    3.8(272 reviews)
    3.6 miUptown
    $$$

    One of the things I've learned over time, is that we kind of all go out for a couple of reasons…read more Most importantly, we want to just enjoy something that isn't at our house, something that presents differently, an elevated level. This place had this element and more. We went into the bar for relaxation and fun. We enjoyed the beef Wellington pastry, the fried green tomatoes, and the wedge salad. All of those kind of sound simple individually, but in truth, they each elevated our eating experience to a level that I was very happy to enjoy. Now let's take it to another level when I critique the atmosphere, this is the kind of place, you felt like you walked into and you can dress casually, but you can also dress a bit more special and you wouldn't feel out a place. How you're treated as a customer is very important. We were treated like the kind of customer that you hope to be treated like, like you belong. Our bartender tonight was Marlon. And we will come back many more times because his service was warm, inviting and approachable. I hope he enjoyed our interaction as much as we enjoyed our time with him. We will be back for sure.

    The chalkboard is my staple restaurant. I stay at The Ambassador, almost never go any place else to…read moreeat. All the staff are amazing, in particular, Skylar in the bar on Thursday evenings. Skylar is an amazing bartender. She listens and aims to please. Her cocktails are spectacular!!!

    Photos
    The Chalkboard Kitchen + Bar - Our bar and dining area is the perfect place for a happy hour drink or special dinner.

    Our bar and dining area is the perfect place for a happy hour drink or special dinner.

    The Chalkboard Kitchen + Bar - Rosemary infused tallow fries

    Rosemary infused tallow fries

    The Chalkboard Kitchen + Bar - Sparkling Rose Blackberry Julep

    See all

    Sparkling Rose Blackberry Julep

    Redrock Canyon Grill

    Redrock Canyon Grill

    4.4(697 reviews)
    7.0 mi
    $$

    I've been here many of times and it's been great every single time…read more Their food here is great! I really enjoyed my enchiladas. It was my first time trying them. Also, their steaks here are really good. The service is great too. Our waiter was very nice and helpful. This Redrock is clean and has a good ambiance to it. Overall, great restaurant and I highly recommend it.

    First timer... Let's dig in - The jalapeño cornbread…read morestarted things off with a kick! 10/10 Warm, comforting and full of flavor. For my starter I ordered "Our Nice Little Salad" this beauty was crisp, fresh, and had tomatoes that popped in your mouth and bursted with flavor. The in-house croutons had that perfect buttery crunch, spiced pecans added a unique boldness and the homemade ranch was thick and creamy. I will say I had to ask three times for ranch. I just kept waiting. For our main courses we had the bone-in pork chop. Thick, juicy, and properly rested paired with red mashed potatoes.... Which were very good. The seasonal corn - was gone so quick! It was just so delicious. Ate that right up!! The shrimp scampi leaned heavily into garlic and butter in the best possible way. Shrimp were big, tender and juicy. Unfortunately my rotisserie chicken.... was very dry. I kept choking because of that. I was unable to eat it, that was disappointing. As far as atmosphere... very warm lighting, intimate feels, candle lit, steady energy, attentive staff. The dining room hums with laughter and happy customers... but without overtaking the conversation at our table. The volume was comfortable considering it was a full house.

    Photos
    Redrock Canyon Grill
    Redrock Canyon Grill
    Redrock Canyon Grill

    See all

    Carl's Coney Island - newamerican - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...