Every flavor my family and I tried is amazing. the staff is friendly and welcoming and creates a…read morecomfortable atmosphere.

First time going here and I am obsessed with it. I love the decor and how well lite it was. My…read morehusband and I got confused on where it actually was. The GPS brought us to the back of the store when it said it was on Wellwood. It's right across from Our Lady Perpetual on Wellwood. You can park in the back but it is a bit of a walk. It shares the same space as an Italian restaurant looking place. They have all different types of flavors, some I haven't even heard of. There are a few vegan flavors but from what I remember I think it was between 2-3 flavors. I got the peanut cookie dough in a large with rainbow sprinkles and saw that there were more flavors at the other side. For a medium and a large it was about $17. They do serve ice cream in a wafer cone as well. I'll definitely be coming back here to try more flavors

This is the cutest little ice cream shop! My cousin and I found it when we were recently walking…read morethrough the village. It's located centrally in Amityville Village and has a old time feel to it. The server was very sweet to us and even gave me a sample of the ice cream when I couldn't decide which I wanted. I was torn between the Baileys ice cream and the cinnamon ice cream and she recommended the cinnamon flavor. I was so glad she did because it was delicious and even my mom who doesn't care for sweets agreed. The shop also has plenty of toppings so I decided to top my scoop off with pretzels. I highly recommend that combo to everyone! My cousin was also very happy with her birthday cake flavor! But definitely stop in and try this local shop out. You will not regret it.

Quant little ice cream shop in the village of Amityville, that has all the cute mom and pop ice…read morecream feels. They feature some classic ice cream options with a few specialty options. I got the peppermint bark ice cream with oreos and my wife got the mint chip and chocolate. All the flavors were delicious. The peppermint wasn't to aggressive and it was nice and creamy. They also have a nice milk shake selection as well as some pre-made chipwiches. We met the owner who was super friendly and helpful. Overall, a nice spot to try if your feeling some ice cream. Enjoy!

I love love love getting to feel like a kid again and getting Play Doh (dough?) ice cream at…read moreHershey's Ice Cream now that they've opened up closer to home. This place is immaculately clean, such friendly service, greeted with a smile! Can't wait to go back soon. All I needed was one scoop on a cone and I was a VERY happy young lady. Awesome portion for the price. Thank you, thank you. We'll be back very soon!

This place is such a great little hidden gem! They have fun events for the children, interesting…read moreice cream flavors, and the staff are friendly, and smile the whole time which is contagious! I will definitely bring my kids again!

First time here and it was excellent. The ice-cream was super creamy and delicious. I had the…read more"Toasted Almond Crunch", which tasted just like your classic Good Humor Toasted Almond bar on a stick but better because it was homemade! So good. My husband had the "Hot Chocolate", which was a milk chocolatey icecream with marshmallows. He gave it a thumbs up too! Service was great! Scoop size was generous and the place was immaculate. I highly recommend and will be back. I hardly ever give five stars but this place needs to be recognized.

Mann's Homemade Ice Cream shop just might be my new go-to ice cream spot. I am a bit disappointed…read morethey didn't have pistachio. But they have a great variety of other flavors to choose from - some traditional and other original. I got a double scoop cup of raspberry cheesecake and cherry vanilla. Sooo good! Prices were average and service was friendly with the ambiance being -well your typical ice cream shop design. The parking is atrocious especially on a busy evening like a Friday, but I will be back. If you're in the area and have a crave for ice cream, check out Mann's!

This Mr Softee has been around for a long time serving the same delicious soft ice cream every…read moretime. I especially enjoy his banana Split with the works oh so heavenly good and his sundaes and also delicious and at a reasonable price.He shows up around 5:30 pm on the nose during the summer months.

My family loves Swirls and Twirls. They have great froyo and ice cream. They have tons of toppings…read more The place is decorated beautifully and the employees are always friendly and helpful. I strongly recommend this establishment!!

Went here with my two kids. They have two cups, one for a fixed price and one for weight, coming in…read moreI missed the sign that explains this. My cup and my daughters I barely filled up, maybe 1/4-1/3 of the cup. Go to pay and charged me 30 for 3 cups. Later I realized my mistake and while it was my mistake, you'd think that the cashier would mention that I'm paying a fixed price when I'm barely taking anything in two of the 3 cups. So right after paying I said oh can I fill my daughter's cup up since it's a fixed price? The cashier told me no... So while it was my mistake and I realize that, terrible customer service and they should be ashamed of not even trying to rectify the situation. One mistake and they lost a costumer that lives 3 minutes away. Hope it was worth it. Went in at 2:00 on 5/27/26

I moved out of LI three years ago, but this is my first stop whenever I'm back in town!! I usually…read moreget the mangonadas (sandía or mango), and they're consistently SO good!! The store itself is very colorful and vibrant, with all types of candy and snacks from Mexico. The staff is very efficient. I highly recommend it and look forward to my next visit :)

The place is well decorated with a small dining area and friendly staff that will help you choose…read morebetween the large variety of delicious looking desserts that they have.

Ive been coming to this place for years now. I really like their variety of items in the menu. My…read morefamily and I love ordering boba tea drinks from here because they dont overfill them with ice and they have a lot of flavors to choose from. Their waffles menu are also very good! The people working here are always nice and the service is fast. You dont wait around for too long.

Customer service was so great. Visited on a rainy Saturday. Had quite a few menu items, my favorite…read morewas the waffle, thin, crunchy, hot and cold mix with the ice cream. The tapioca boba was chewy and plentiful in the mango milk tea. The decor could be better - lots of decals and plastic backdrops but it seemed clean and organized.

I'm currently stuck at home recovering from a hospital stay, and can't physically cool like I…read morewanted to for St Patrick's Day. Let me tell you, ordering DoorDash from Amity Ales was an amazing choice! My wife had the "casey-filla," a corned beef quesadilla..... that she loved. I had a meal of corned beef, cabbage, potatoes and carrots. The corned beef was amazing! So tender, and not salty. I wish it wasn't a special, and they offered it all year! Hats off to the chef for making something I'd be proud to call my own!

Spacious area! Great service! One little hiccup at the end where we were charged for someone else's…read morebill but it was reversed. Love their brunch options! Every brunch meal comes with certain free cocktails. Will be back for more!

Amazing food! My in-laws followed this place from Islandia…read more. and the food is just as amazing as it was when they were in Islandia. Maybe even better.. Everything we had was amazing. The chicken dumplings were amazing and the chicken won tons Were perfect!! Highly recommend!!! There is NOT a bad item on the menu!!! You cannot go wrong with anything on the menu!!! The service is amazing so friendly and the staff is super responsive!

So I ate here on Saturday and the food was great. Ambiance…read morenot so much. Service was ok only because only a few individuals are there. I had the curry puffs, pad Thai noddles and the fish. All delicious. I will go back but I think I have to choose wisely because the food is good and the place is small. Go on the wrong day and you will be waiting a while I think. Just speculating though. Go, you will not be disappointed.