Try and try again this place is nothing like it's original owners, Frankie and Johnny. The service is not great. The food taste is subpar quality is not good. Prices are high portions are small...service is sadly not good at all...When you carefully explain exactly what you want to your waiter and they still bring you something that is not right and then say nothing about it when you tell them it is not right. You gotta give up on a place. It's just not worth spending the time or money.‍ That is why this restaurant is pretty much empty every time I've been in there and at 7 o'clock at night they're ready to close. It's a disappointing restaurant with disappointing food. read more

My office (12 people) ordered lunch specials today. The entire order was messed up. The waitress approached our pick up person yelling at her thinking that she was the person before her complaining, again, about her missing salads. The order was missing pasta for CHICKEN PARM and CHICKEN PICCATA. The waitress then argued that these dishes did NOT come with pasta or salad. The chicken sat in soup with nothing. She was rude and the lunches were ruined. Although we are a local business whose owners are friends, we will not order form them again. This has happened every time we have ordered from Casa Mia. Food bad. Service worse. read more

Excellent food and service. The atmosphere in the resultant I like being in your home dining room. The food is excellent.

I was saddened when the change over to casa mia happened. BUT, there was no drop off in quality. The food is great, the portions plentiful and the staff is terrific. One of the wait staff is a particular cutie. I had to work that in. But it's a great experience and well worth a visit. read more

Best baked clams we've ever had. Large enough portions for my wife and I to share a single dinner. Our go to Italian restaurant whenever we're in the area. read more

Haven't been here since the new owners. I was excited to hear they had the same chef and I recognized our server for many years (won't give her name because this is a "bad" review). I was shocked at how chaotic their whole service is. You have staff literally bumping into each other left and right. Plates dropping, cups dropping of their stacks), and the timing of how they bring out the food is just terrible. Our server said she takes the salad order first so people don't get cranky. That sounds good, but then no one comes back to get the drinks going or take the actual order. We had kids, we needed to get their order in for them. My wife and aunt were going to split an eggplant parm....but they brought out a chicken parm. Now here is the outrageous, the insulting part. It took a minute for us to figure out the mistake. My aunt cut and bit into the chicken before she realized, wait, we ordered the eggplant. We told the server, and she offered to get the correct dish out...but we were waiting so long for the meals to come out and didn't feel like waiting anymore, so we just said, don't worry about it, just take it off the bill. The server said she can't do that because we started eating it. After 1 bite!!!! That was just nuts! Anyway, I had the Marsala which was pretty good, not great. But their wings are still amazing. Frankie's has always been hit or miss, but tonight was mostly miss. read more

Every item we ordered was delicious: salad, pizza, and lasagna. The portions are huge and an order of lasagna could serve 3 to 4 easily. The staff were all very friendly and helpful. We will definitely go back next time we're in the area. read more

We always order company wide lunch on Fridays, and when we have visitors, it's consistent and filling. We been a customer for over 20 years, when it was Franky & Johnnie's! read more

Had dinner at Casa Mia last night, the food was soooo good, great service and excellent wine choices. Will be back again.

My first time here. Fresh warm Italian bread. fresh salad with Tasty Italian dressing. Eggplant parmigiana was quite goo. Generous portion. Prices are extremely reasonable. I'm defiantly coming back here ! read more

"Casa Mia" has excellent food and outstanding service. I've been going to this establishment for many years under its previous ownership, "Nardis, at Frankie and Johnnie's." The food is a step up from those days for every main course that I've ordered. The service is gracious and accommodating. read more

I remember this place as Frankie's and Johnnies. Same chef's have now taken over and the food is still excellent with large portions and fresh tasting ingredients read more

Good food, large portions, good service & reasonably priced. Ample parking; also good for take out. read more

Loved this place! Delicious food, friendly staff and huge portions. No frills but very comfortable - you'll feel like a local from the moment you walk in. Fresh bread and delicious house salad dressing. Lemon wine sauce on pasta was flavorful and delish. Great place - give it a try! read more

Had great dinner. Service was very good Janis was very friendly. Food was outstanding and plenty of it. Will definitely be back. read more

Great food. Ordered chicken piccata. Shared it with my wife. Rest of the family stated that food was delicious and had to take "doggy bags" home. Pleasant staff. Will return next time I am in this neck of the woods. Very casual ambience. Would recommend for family dinners. read more

Food was good, but overpriced for catering. We paid double what we would have paid at another restaurant. Unfortunately, it was too late to cancel. read more

Food was good , this restaurant had been there for many years under another name "Frankie and Johnny "

Breakfast was soooo good we got eggs bacon pancakes then later on that day, my coworker stuck there and we got taquitos and they were amazing. We got the chicken ones. read more

Great food. Huge portions. Good prices. Food is same as the old name. Been going there since 1982!!! Parm combo is the best !!

This will be the second time I ordered mild buffalo wings and got bbq sauce. I tried. I'm done with this place. They are NOT F&J! I went back to get a refund and got an attitude about it. From the hostess AND a waitress ( I'm going to assume it was the owners wife) she insisted every restaurant is different with their buffalo sauce, I told her buffalo sauce is just that, NOT SPICY bbq sauce. These wings were $10.95. She tried to give me $11. More attitude when I asked for what I paid for. Never again! read more

Was happy to find Casa Mia open on Memorial day. Service was great. Had the shrimp arregonato. My lady had the veal franchise. Food was excellent. Portions were large. Will be back. This is one of the best restaurants in the area. Donald was a great waiter. read more

Excellent food- even better then before! Staff was very attentive - responding to whatever our requests were. Janice our waitress sets a great example of what excellence in the restaurant/ hospitality business should be. Definitely recommend and we can't wait to return. read more

Wasn't crazy about their pizza . That was the only thing I tried so I'm not able to comment on anything else. Their customer service is good. Very nice ppl read more

Glad we gave this restaurant a try. It was great. The male waiter was kind and attentive. The pizza was perfect. My husband had the veal parm with spaghetti. It was delicious. Give this restaurant a try. You will enjoy. read more

Great meal. We have a large party but was served efficiently. The waitress was super. Wish I lived close by so I could eat there weekly. read more

Came up from Long Island heard they were open again, well worth the ride. This place while the name changed the cook and staff still there are fabulous. Can't wait to return. Our meal was exactly as we remembered, we were summer camping people for 15 years, we are beyond thrilled to come back, missed Janice this time, Hugo was wonderful. So all you local people please support this wonderful place it is a rare gem. We are overloaded by meal choices done here, this remains are lifetime favorite. read more

My husband and I had dinner at "Casa Mia", formerly known as "Frankie & Johnny" or "Nardi's". We have been there many times before when it was under the old management, with good friends and on our own. We were never disappointed before, however, this time the new management and its cooks disappointed both of us. My husband and I first ordered fried calamari as an appetizer. It was a nice size portion, served with some marinara sauce. The shrimp were heavily breaded and fried, It did not taste fresh, more like done ahead of time then reheated. Not appealing at all. Next for the entrée my husband ordered a chicken, veal and shrimp parmigiana combo, heavily covered with mozzarella cheese, with a side of salad and French fries. My husband said that there were only two shrimps on his dish, and they were hard, which tells us that the shrimps were previously cooked (who knows when), then put on the dish and served with the chicken and veal which had no taste, no seasoning. As for me, I ordered a seafood combo, shrimp, scallops, and cod fish drowned in broth, butter and garlic sprinkled with some paprika. It came with a side of ziti with marinara sauce and a salad. Once again, the shrimps were hard and tasteless. The scallops I do not believe were sea scallops. They were thinly cut making one scallop look like ten, but that was not the case. The cod, perhaps one slice, rolled up and cut into smaller pieces. All of this was not very seasoned at all, most of it was left on the dish. The ziti with the marinara sauce was not bad. Both of our portions were over $26.00 each plus the appetizer. We only had a glass (or two) of water each...............no wine, beer or liquor available. They did offer canned soda at the cost of $4.00 each which we declined. We did not attempt to get any dessert. At the end our total bill was over $70.00 plus tip. The best part of this new restaurant under new management was the waitress (that attended to us, and another wonderful waitress,) Janice, who we knew from past years when eating at the previous restaurant Overall, (All in all), we were disappointed with "Casa Mia" and its new management. Thank you! read more

I was a loyal customer at the former "Frankie & Johnney's Italian restaurant which is now home to " Cas Mia" Italian restaurant. The transfer of ownership did not change anything. Same great pizza, great entrees and the place was remodeled 5 years ago and nothing had to be redone. The staff is very friendly and efficient. The food is delicious and the price is reasonable. I frequented the former for 30 years and I hope I can do the same for CASA MIA! Just good food and service will make them a staple in the county. read more

dont expect to pay what is listed on their menu. The new owners have changed the pricing structure, but this is not reflected on what you actually pay. Try ordering an eggplant parm hero for the listed price of $7. and you will end up paying $9.50. read more