Casa Nuevo is a nice spot for a good dinner. Nice interior and prices are a bit higher than other Mexican restaurants, however the food ingredients are much better. Fresher may be the word. Chorizo chicken and a chicken fajita were our orders. Along with a half pitcher of Margarita. Chorizo chicken had plenty of flavor and was good. The fajita was ok, but bland. We both thought it needed something. Also ordered a queso cheese dip for the nachos. That was good. Overall, nice experience and we would return. read more

One of the better Mexican restaurants in the area. The restaurant was great. The atmosphere and noice levels were perfect. The food and service were great. There was a good variety of food and beverages to choose from. I would highly recommend trying this place it's worth the visit. read more

Came here with family for an impromptu dinner. There were 7 of us that included a baby. They easily accommodated us. The bar is in the front and they have some rooms to accommodate diners easily. Nice space. Decorated for Christmas. Server brought drinks around quickly. And left us with the menu for a bit. We all ordered different things. Food came out fast and hot. I got the spinach quesadilla that comes with soup. Both were very good. Quesadilla had a bit of spice that I couldn't figure out where it came from. It was good though. But if you don't like spice you may not want this. Soup was hot and full of veggies and chicken. Very good. Overall the service was good and so was the food. Prices are about average. Plenty of parking. They had Christmas themed drinks. Fun! I'd definitely go back. read more

What a cute & cozy restaurant- - we loved everything about this place . Owner Juan was tending bar - made well mixed skinny margaritas. Chips were so crispy with perfectly blended salsa . I ordered the seafood enchiladas & hubby ordered the Bulldog burrito with ground beef . Seafood enchiladas had tender shrimp & scallops with the perfect cheesy creamy sauce and the ground beef in the Bulldog burrito was so well seasoned & vegetables were sautéed to perfection . Rice with both dishes were flavorful- highly recommend and can't wait to return read more

Casa Nueva Mexican Restaurant Bar & Grill - Bulldog burrito - Tacos Near Me - Stow, Ohio

See all

My friend and I stopped by Casa Nueva on a Friday night, and everything from the service to the food and atmosphere was really solid. We were given chips and salsa almost immediately after being seated, which was very nice. All the staff we talked to were super friendly, and our server was great. We split the steak fajitas, quesabirria tacos, and queso with chorizo--everything was packed with flavor and just what we were hoping for. It was our first time there, and we had a great experience. I'll definitely be back! read more

See all

Tried this for the first time. So glad we did. The service was great, the food was so delicious, and it was Monday - so the $5 margaritas were also really tasty. My wife and I are vegan and they had multiple options. They also have many gluten free options if you want or need that. Plus chicken, steak, shrimp vegetarian ... something for everyone. The white rice with cilantro was perfectly fluffy and sticky and the fresh cilantro added wonderfully to the flavor. The complimentary chips and salsa are really good too. I asked for a side of hot sauce and I received some of the best homemade sauce I've ever tasted. It's a great menu with so many choices as well as ala cart options. If you like real authentic Mexican food get here now and enjoy. It was the best Mexican food we have had since visiting Mexico City. A M A Z I N G F O O D ! read more

Casa Nueva Mexican Restaurant Bar & Grill - Outside dining - Tacos Near Me - Stow, Ohio

First time checking out this place, and the menu was huge! Lots of options to choose from and seemed to have great authentic options. We loved the ambiance and service was great! Can't wait to return and try something new!! read more

See all

Wow this place is amazing. So homemade and delicious. My non vegan mother in law loved it. Amazing menu. So fresh. I'm vegan. Vegan people seriously go here also. Lots of choices. The flavor is incredible. The margarita Monday is especially fun. I had the build your own burrito. I think this is some of the best Mexican food I have had, even better than Mexico City. I can't wait to return. The service is wonderful also. Wow! Go here people!! read more

Casa Nueva Mexican Restaurant Bar & Grill - This place is awesome!!!!!!!! - Tacos Near Me - Stow, Ohio

The food is NOT TEX MEX. Thank the cooking gods. It's a mix of all the best flavors with portions that meet your needs and spicy to meet your palate. Especially like the 3-kind sampler of queso, street corn and guacamole. Each is just spicy enough with enough chips to suit. Oh, the chips are thick! Oddly never had before, but they aren't from a bag! Enjoy read more

We ate here tonight with my wife and one of my daughters. First, I was impressed with the cleanliness of the restaurant and the ambiance. The decor was beautiful, and they had soft soothing music playing very quietly. It felt warmer and more inviting than most Mexican restaurants. They brought out chips and salsa immediately after we were seated, and the chips were nice and warm. I ordered the Dos Amigos Burritos (two burritos, one beef and one chicken). My wife ordered the Enchiladas Verdes. Both dishes tasted as good and as fresh as they appear. The prices were reasonable too. I was very impressed and we will definitely be back. Bring cash though, they tack on 4% extra for credit/debit transactions. read more

Casa Nueva Mexican Restaurant Bar & Grill - Enchiladas Verdes - Tacos Near Me - Stow, Ohio

See all

Food was really good. Nice place but wasn't a lot of people to add to the ambience. Probably went at wrong time but food was solid.

After our first visit, we wondered why we waited so long to eat here. The servers were friendly and efficient. The food was out so quickly I barely had a chance to dive into the great house made tortilla chips and salsa. The food was delicious and plentiful. A great value and comfortable location. We dined early and by the time we finished the tables were filling fast. We are adding Casa Nueva to our regular dining out list. read more

We really enjoyed our dining experience at Casa Nueva. The service was excellent, as well as the very cool ambiance. I had the enchiladas mixta, which were good, after we had the chips and salsa. We both had the margarita fights, which has several options to choose from. Fun! read more

Casa Nueva Mexican Restaurant Bar & Grill - Margarita flight - Tacos Near Me - Stow, Ohio

See all

The best queso dip I've ever tasted! Fast and friendly service! Great new outdoor seating also!

Went for dinner on a Wednesday night. I am not a fan of "American Mexican". Most of it is way to bland, prepackaged food - nothing like you would get in Mexico. Casa Nueva is not one of those places. They have taken an old Pizza Hut building and done a great job decorating the inside. Three dimensional wall behind the bar, wood, brick and corrugated metal. There are fake plants which aren't my favorite but my wife liked them. They were well placed to be fair. The bar is well stocked with Tequila and the main bartender has created a custom drink menu,. If you part take in adult beverages I highly suggest trying one of her creations. The food is good and not your typical burritos/tacos. They do have those and I am sure they are good but there are other dishes so come with an adventurous spirit. My only complaints are that the retired beans are uninspired. Better than most but nothing special. Also the rice was burst open, probably from cooking at too much heat, and also wasn't great. If they fixed those to issues I would give them five stars. If you are in the area give Casa Nueva a try! read more

Check this spot out! Y'all will never be disappointed. The food was amazing and the atmosphere was top notch. 10000% recommended. read more

Casa Nueva Mexican Restaurant Bar & Grill - Tacos Near Me - Stow, Ohio

This is one of the best Mexican places I have ever ate at! Great food great prices and great people!!!

Looking for a new lunch spot. This use to be an old Pizza Hut. Interior of a very nice lookout no but my table is wobbly. Service was okay not bad not great. First Mexican restaurant where I was never offered complimentary chips and salsa. Menu is one side alcohol for whose enjoy. Other side has a wide variety for f food offerings I went with my stand by chicken fajitas which comes with a side salad and choice of side. I chose the chicken soup Food came out quick which was nice. This was about 1pm on a Wednesday That were it got odd for me. The portions are right on for price in my opinion but I hot the typical skillet for f fajitas mixed with green and red peppers and Onion. There was nothing else with like a sour cream or salsa No offerings or m table either nor was I asked Salad was big but lacked an noticeable salad dressing. So I at two bites and moved on Soup had cut up avacado on it and was okay Fajita came with 3 tortillas I would not come back to dine in. Possibly get take out so I can doctor it up at home. read more

First time here. Food was really good. The salsa was kinda spicy so if you do not like spicy stuff, maybe go with the queso. The service was good, however the hostess wrote our phone number down wrong so we waited in our car for a phone call that never came. We eventually walked in and asked when our table would be ready. The restaurant is located in a old Pizza Hut but You could never tell. The margaritas were awesome. We will definitely come back. Ambiance was relaxing. read more

What a wonderful Mexican restaurant! The carne asada tacos were divine as were the reasonably priced premium tequilas! ;) And our server Rebecca was awesome too! read more

Good quality authentic food. I've been here 3 times since it's opened and ordered takeout twice. The food is good and *authentic* which I think a lot of other reviewers are disappointed over. It's not cheap sloppy Americanized Mexican food. It is good quality and made with some grandma's recipes. The meat is seasoned well and cooked perfectly--but not seasoned to the point of overwhelming the meat's natural flavor. The tortilla chips are house made, thick, and perfectly crisp with just the right amount of salt. The queso is mild and creamy with just the right amount of heat. If you like REAL Mexican food, you'll love this place. It's not white washed and it doesn't try to be. I highly recommend the street corn dip--I crave it every day. Give this place a try! read more

We have been to Casa Nueva several times now and I have to say this is the best Mexican food in Northeast Ohio! The menu is authentic and creative. The Seafood Poblano and the Baja Burrito are wonderful. The mole is the best I have ever had. Guacamole is excellent . The Margaritas selection is outstanding. The staff is as friendly as you will find. Very enjoyable dining experience!! read more

Beatrice was our bartender sh was so sweet I like white claw she required another more Hispanic seltzer and had knowledge of the newer restaurant. I love it's family owned and the menu is the wife's recipes.. the bathroom ms were clean! And the woman's room was so cute!! M read more

Casa Nueva Mexican Restaurant Bar & Grill - Delicious - Tacos Near Me - Stow, Ohio

I wanted to like this place so much and I'm hoping they can work out the kinks being a new place. Guacamole had zero salt. Corn esquite dip lacked salt. Pretty cool that you can get a Chile Relleno as a side dish for your entree but the tomatillo salsa was way too salty. Go easy on the club soda in the margaritas - a splash is all you need. We weren't the only ones who thought that - couple next to us actually sent theirs back. High five on actually producing a spicy camerones Diablo- not many places venture that spicy. Well done. Birra tacos were fantastic- another well done entree! This place just needs to work out some kinks. Correct the seasonings and this place is going to be solid. read more

We're from LA home of lotsa good Mexican food and Casa Nueva rocked it! We were totally surprised to find a great looking, friendly, a$$ kicking Margarita, super service, and magnificent food restaurant! I had the Chili Poblano and it was perfection. That being said and 1/2 price happy hour margaritas, this will be a place we look forward to returning! read more

Second time here and was looking forward to trying something new. Ordered the pozole verde. Service was good, but then after about 15 minutes I was told by our waiter they didn't have the pozole, would I like something else. So I quickly decided on their carne en su jugo instead. He had to check that they had that too, he then takes my order and then immediately brings out the rest of my families order. How did you not know until all their food was ready that you didn't have mine? So I watched my kids eat and my husband wait for me while his food got cold. He ordered the seafood poblano which said a poblano pepper stuffed with seafood, the seafood was lying on top of a sad pepper. Not as described. 15 minutes later my molten hot soup comes out. As I wait to be able to eat it, I notice the radish, cilantro, avocado and lime are all missing. They offer to remake it. I tell them no thanks. I don't want it since everyone else is done and I don't want to wait for it to be made again. They took away a full bowl of soup. I thought they would comp the late, incorrect meal I didn't eat. Nope. No discount given at all. Terrible way to do business. read more

I've been wanting to come here for a while since I drive past on my commute to work. The parking lot is usually always pretty full. We finally gave it a shot about two weeks ago. It was a Sunday and we arrive right at 8 (they closed at 9). There was a nice bar area that was mostly filled and a few other tables. There was apparently some confusion about who was taking our table, and we sat without being greeted for what was starting to feel like an awkward amount of time. I was a little concerned this was a bad sign of things to come, but thankfully I was wrong. Our server was extremely apologetic, got us chips and salsa, and took our drink order. I enjoyed my margarita, which tasted incredibly fresh (not the artificial lime green crap you see at other places). My partner commented on the number of Mexican restaurants all on the same road, but Casa Nueva is very different from Pancho and Leftys (which is more Mexican inspired than authentic) and El Campesino (which is more typical Mexican American food). The menu at Casa Nueva is somewhat smaller but seemed more authentic. I ordered the chipotle chicken, and I pleasantly surprised by both the heat of the sauce and the fact that the chicken had been grilled. It was delicious, and I enjoyed the refried beans as well (perfect consistency and great flavor). My partner had tacos with a tamale on the side, and he also raved about his meal. We both said we'd like to come back here and try more things. I did think it was a touch pricy, especially considering that most meals only come with rice OR beans, not both. But I think this was a unique addition to an area that doesn't have a ton of sit-down options, and I appreciated that it wasn't like the dime-a-dozen Mexican restaurants in the area. read more

Delicious food and good vibes! Only reason it has a 4 star is because it tends to be on the pricier side however the ingredients are nice and fresh! read more

Mom's 72nd birthday at Casa Nueva! The food was fantastic, outstanding portion sizes and they brought us homemade chips and salsa! I highly recommend this restaurant! Leslie is an outstanding waitress and she made us feel like family. read more

Casa Nueva Mexican Restaurant Bar & Grill - Mom, Dad and I - Tacos Near Me - Stow, Ohio

Excellent chicken fajitas!! Chips and salsa are great also. Our server was very friendly and quick.

Food is very good. The service is great and it is a nice little Mexican place. The prices are very reasonable for all the food and drinks we ordered! Overall a great hidden gem in Stow read more

The food is the most authentic Mexican. The wait staff are friendly and very polite. Highly recommend the ceviche.

The food was ok. Charge for chips. Even after ordering Togo. No refills on drinks and the were 5 dollars for soda a piece. Was excited to try but will not be back. We are the only people in the entire restaurant. Maybe be a bit more friendly. And not so pricey read more

This place is awesome! Went here with my wife and daughter on a Friday night on a whim, and everything was amazing. The food was perfect Mexican. The service was astounding, they even sang happy birthday to my daughter. The nachos and salsa were just right. Everyone was so friendly, I can't wait to go back! read more

First time going. The place was packed and people looked like they were having a good time. We were seated quickly. The lighting is dim and the menu has very small print. No salsa and chips for those who care. Since they are new and the kitchen doesn't have their timing down yet it might be a good idea to serve some chips. The servings were smaller and lighter fare than most Mexican restaurants. You will not need a take home box. My husband's dinner came out at least 5 minutes before mine. Then they brought me the wrong order. The refried beans were my side and they are so runny that it is a good thing they come in a bowl. The beans were also cold. I was warned by a person I knew who was dining there also tonight to order the flour tacos because the corn ones fell right apart and it was very messy to deal with. The shrimp tacos had a lot of cilantro and a couple of shrimp but not much else in them. My raspberry frozen margarita was good and our waiter Jerry was excellent. We probably won't be back. read more

review of Casa Nueva, Taco + Tequila Bar I wanted so much to like this place being nearby for me, ended up leaving unsatisfied. The decor was pleasant, menu font a little small. Water pitcher for the table was nice, chips & salsa were tasty but no refills. My four enchilada dish was kind of tasteless but okay serving size. Service was a bit slow, they may have been understaffed. The most disappointing thing was the margarita. $15 for a "top shelf" drink that I could not taste or feel (I'm a light drinker) from a place with tequila in the tag line is unacceptable. If we do return again I'll try a different entree but order a beer. read more

This place is great!!! Went there with my husband and the fresh homemade salsa and chips were perfect! His tacos were delicious(I'm picky and I kept asking for more bites) and I ordered the shredded chicken soup and it was fabulous. Can't wait to go back and try the waiters recommendations! read more

amazing menu and fresh ingredients. Best around! We have been there twice so far and can't wait to keep trying more things on the menu.

Awesome food great service and margaritas crafted perfectly!! The best part is the guacamole made tableside !!

Our third visit was yesterday. The menu is a lot to read and a large format, but I dealt with it. Got Al Pastor street tacos. They were very good and warm! The pork was small cubes and the pineapple is a good flavor builder in this taco. Soft corn tacos were yummy. Got the supreme service which included lettuce, tomato, sour cream. This made the dish extra tasty. I only could eat 2/3, took home the rest. Service was friendly and smiling. My other two visits were not as memorable as this one. A bit pricey, but the quality is worth it. You get a side with this dish. They never seem to have the cilantro rice, but I got the Mexican rice, my husband got the black beans. They were okay. Try this place three times, choose carefully, and you will find enjoyable dishes. Expect lots of four person booths, and a decent happy hour crowd with selections on the happy hour menu. I'm only familiar with full menu so far. We'll be back. read more