We come to Aspen several times a year and have typically had amazing dinning experiences. Our experience at Catch started when the pretentious hostage argued with me about our reservation. While we waited for our table to be ready, we headed to the bar to be ignored by the bartender. The bar back finally was willing to give us cocktails and when I asked the bartender for three additional cocktails. He ignored me, went back to the register printed my check and handed it to me. The wait staff seemed very disinterested in server our large party........... Never again. read more

We had an amazing dinner here with fabulous food & a lovely ambiance. For appetizers, we got the Ceasar salad and the king crab roll. Both were absolutely incredible. For dinner, we got the 10 oz NY chili butter strip steak which was cooked perfect. It was crispy on the outside and tender on the inside. We also got mashed potatoes which were absolutely unbelievable. Would highly recommend!! read more

Catch Steak - Steakhouses Near Me - Aspen, Colorado

Delicious meal. Great bar scene..... Filthy martini with blue cheese olives. Make a reservation. read more

Catch Steak - Steakhouses Near Me - Aspen, Colorado

Simply one of the best overall dinners we have ever had. Very hard to get a reservation, but understand why when you experience the atmosphere and food. Highly recommend the truffle steak, Mac and cheese, asparagus and my wife says the bananas foster dessert was best dessert of her life. Good vibes too from all the staff. read more

Sat at the bar and had dinner. Nice ambience -- but feels coastal, not really a mountain steakhouse vibe. Pleasant though. Like most "scenes" the food isn't as good as the atmosphere, and you're paying for the brand. *Blue crab roll was excellent. Best thing I had. Small portion though for $26. *Sizzling shrimp. These were very good. I thought these came with a lobster sauce -- the sauce was more like a spicy marinara to me. Very good shrimp/prawns, cooked perfectly. *Truffle filet. The highlight of a steakhouse should be the meat? Not here. Ordered it medium (more on that below) and it was cooked unevenly. Flavor from the truffle butter was great. The actual meat quality seemed off-- the meat was sinewy. Chewy-- hard to swallow. This filet didn't seem like it was prime or center cut, and for $62 ala carte it should be. It was tough. More like a sirloin from a fast-casual joint. For an 8oz filet this is as expensive as it gets (if not some kind of wagyu). This one ranks in the very bottom of high end steakhouse steaks I have had. I can make a better filet at home (or several for this price.) *Mashed potatoes. Very good. Resemble Pomme Aligot, for those who know what that is. But not cheesy. Annoyed they don't do bread here. Just their special pretzel bread for $14. I wanted my steak cooked "medium rare push" which is a normal request. Was told they can't do that. It is just adding a little extra time to medium rare, but they won't do that for you here. At least not for me. I also wanted to start with some appetizers then decide on my main course later. Sitting at the bar didn't think this would be a problem. Like the steak temperature request, it was a problem. All or nothing, and you get one shot to order (it wasn't busy.) To be fair, they did time the courses perfectly. Which is a plus, as this rarely happens anywhere. All of their wines I asked about were open the day before-- the one I settled on seemed off, but was drinkable. Also had some sake with my sushi. I prefer sake to be served from a Tokkuri and Ochoko, especially for $24. Not here. Served in a little wine glass. Staff was nice -- and friendly, welcoming. Everyone was great. Expected better, especially for the price. Paying for the scene and the brand. Disappointing special requests can't be accommodated, at least for me. I would return for the blue crab roll, but there are also some great sushi places in Aspen, so would be hard justifying a return just for that. read more

Catch Steak - 8oz Truffle Butter Filet - Steakhouses Near Me - Aspen, Colorado

Incredible experience at the bar for dinner!! We had amazing cocktails, great service, amazing sushi and steak. I'm not sure why this place has such bad reviews. The ambiance is beautiful, we had an amazing time! read more

See all

Catch Steak - Aspen is the latest extension of The Catch Hospitality Group extended their reach to Aspen. This location is one of the more spacious restaurants in Aspen. With grand views of Aspen Mountain, the fabulous interior and fun atmosphere create an energized romantic vibe. Instead of a heavy and traditional steak house vibe, Catch Steak Aspen creates a more lively, animated, and easy vibe. This is just one of the reasons it has become a hotspot. The other reason, and likely the main reason Catch has become a hotspot, is of course for the expected great food. The playful presentation of each appetizer immediately gets serious with each bite -- seriously good! My recommendation is to share the items you order, it almost seems the dishes are styled to be sharable. The appetizers and small dishes are the highlights of the menu. The next time I go, I likely will focus on the delectably savory starters and create a complete meal with the small bites. read more

See all

This was one of the best meals I've ever had! The filet is cooked perfectly. The pasta is packed with the most amazing flavors and cooked to perfection. The creamed corn had us all hooked & the fries were delish! read more

Catch Steak - Filet, spicy vodka pasta, creamed corn. 10/10! - Steakhouses Near Me - Aspen, Colorado

See all

Best steak I've had in town. There are a few spaces more intimate and a few with more staff but the food has been excellent on 3x visits. read more

Catch Steak - 12oz Prime Bone-In Cowgirl Ribeye (32 Day) with a side of chili sauce. Unnecessary but very tasty. - Steakhouses Near Me - Aspen, Colorado

Best steak I've ever had. Everything was absolutely amazing. Catch Steak Martini with stuffed olives is a must get and loved the presentation. Wagyu Beef Carpaccio was so flavorful, capers were the perfect touch. Hamachi Crudo was buttery. And then the Filet with truffle butter was perfect cooked with a crispy outside. Whipped mashed potatoes are a MUST GET. Can't go wrong with anything on the menu here. read more

See all

This was our second time at Catch Steak in Aspen, and it really solidified our conflicting feelings regarding the restaurant. While the food is good, the service is pushy and the ambiance is mediocre. The steak was well seasoned though a bit on the rare side (ordered medium rare), while the branzino was incredibly light and flavorful. The croquettes are always a favorite of the table, as well. However, our server, Steven, continually insisted that we order pricier items on the menu, ranging from starters such as the caviar to desserts. He even only gave us the option between sparkling and still water, omitting tap water as an option and forcing us to pay $45 just for water. Overall, although the food is good, a better dining experience could be found elsewhere in Aspen. read more

Over salty branzino- too oily spinach- waiter forgot my order and I waited too long. I think this is just common hospitality at catch restaurants because i experienced worse in miami read more

Came for dinner on a Thursday at prime dinner hour. The style is intimate, with a large bar area, and saloon style booth seating. A nice mix of the beautiful young crowd and older regulars. We had ranch waters that were well mixed. The jumbo shrimp weren't quite as jumbo as were accustomed to but delicious none the less. Our server was attentive and genuinely enjoyed explaining the menu. The wagyu filet with truffle butter was prepared perfectly. The creamed spinach was indulgent while the asparagus had a hint of lemon and very crisp. Finished it off with the coconut cream cake which came with a side of gelato. Definitely a necessary dinner spot in Aspen! read more

Catch Steak - Wagyu filet, asparagus, Blue Cheese Creamed Spinach - Steakhouses Near Me - Aspen, Colorado

See all

This review is mostly about service. We were a party of 4. While the service was attentive, it felt rushed and dismissive. It is an extensive and expensive menu that requires some thought. We ordered drinks and needed time to review all the options. We were told we could not order an appetizer at the same time with drinks, we would have to place our entire order at once. You cannot order an appetizer with your drinks while looking at the menu?? No. I assume this is so people do not linger, and have a leisurely meal. We were again told that you had to place the whole order at once and that they would "course it out". When the two appetizers came out (by a runner, not our server) they did not come at the same time. Each couple was sharing an appetizer, which we had made clear, so one couple was eating while the other waited. Not only was this awkward, it's really inexcusable for a high end restaurant that should be catering to its patrons, not the other way around. The food was good but definitely overpriced. I'd say that's ok if I felt it was top notch service and we were being catered to and not managed. Instead it was just pretentious. read more

The ambiance and food great but service is horrible. They forgot some of the items we ordered and the food took a little long to come out. read more

Catch Steak - Crispy Potato Croquettes - Steakhouses Near Me - Aspen, Colorado

You just can't get a better meal - Checks every box - cool bar, great people - cool scene - just gotta go! Once again we had the "cap of the rib-eye" - tastiest steak ... ever!!! Best Steak!!!! Simple spinach side about perfect!!! The "Twice as nice" sushi roll was outstanding - great drinks!!! Super fun bartenders, pax and Adam ... and the best Som in town, Miles ... this is just a great restaurant in every way!!! A+++ people - food - everything!!! read more

See all

Had dinner here on a Tuesday night but we were very disappointed with the service. Sadly we were celebrating two anniversaries and we reserved a month in advance to avoid any hiccups. Host Ryan was great and did give us nice table although we had to wait maybe 15 minutes. Bar and drinks also great. Food overall good but service was not. Our server had too many tables and would disappear for a long while leaving us without plates for appetizers and flatware. We were here last year and because service was so great then we came back but not the case this year. We ordered a few appetizers first two came relatively quickly but sushi took almost an hour into our reservation. We had to ask server if it was still coming. Then once it did arrive we had no plates and server was nowhere to be found. He didn't check on us at all until we were done. We placed dinner order which also took very long again we had to ask why the delay and he had no clue. We know all restaurants this time of year are busy and some delays are expected but how the server handles that delay is what matters. At this point we didn't even want to stay for dessert so we paid and left. We truly regret coming here on such a special occasion when we could have gone to one of the many other options in town. We won't be returning. read more

See all

The worst service in aspen goes to ...drum roll... Catch steakhouse! We were really excited for the new hip spot in town as we frequent the staples in aspen. However, I would recommend sticking to aspens original spots. We had no clue who our server was since we waited 45 min for one. Our steak was cooked improperly and then just brought over 25 min later after it was put on the grill for a bit longer. The place has a lot of potential as the ambiance is a different pace in aspen. However, I would not recommend due its low level of service. Your time is worth somewhere else, trust me. read more

Frequent diner of West Hollywood and nyc location. For was 4 out of 10. Very disappointed. Service was very very slow. And food was just ok. read more

One of the best meals we've had in a long time. Himachi is a must. Delicious flavors. We shared a couple of rolls and a steak. Sit at the bar for really special service! read more

Catch Steak - Steakhouses Near Me - Aspen, Colorado

See all

Definitely a good place if you're into scenery. I was a little bit disappointed with the prices, the portions, the acoustics, etc.

Amazing meal!! If you come to Aspen this is a MUST!! Been to many steakhouses and by far this is hands down best flavor perfectly cooked and the blue cheese creamed spinach is a masterpiece!! Fun inviting atmosphere read more

See all

Finally!! A real legit steak house comes to Aspen. We had a fantastic meal last night! The apps were stellar , great salmon , the A5 was totally legit, and the bone in rib-eye perfect. Fantastic drinks and desserts. David Richardson the general manager ( from Mats also well run) is a pro and appreciates your business. Wait staff well trained and NO bad attitude ! Also great Vibe going on and crowd and the space is arguably one of the best in Aspen. We are local half the year and if your from a major city , you will have good comparisons to find this rates at the top and not just the current overpriced , poor service , bad attitude theoretical "steak joint " currently we were stuck with in Aspen. Our friends are their several times over last few week with good experience too. The Klein family will be back. Thanks David! read more

First time leaving a review- unfortunately Catch Steak called for it. Overall- The experience was unfortunate and subpar for the price tag associated with a meal here. The good: The two stars are only for drinks + ambiance. The drinks were amazing, refreshing, and innovative. The ambiance was incredibly fun && decor is beautiful. Maybe coming here for drinks only is the way to go. The Bad: If you advertise that you are a higher quality restaurant than I expect that. Our steaks and pasta were at best mediocre- quality and taste. The server was nice but very slow. We left a generous gratuity despite the flaws and incredible disappointment. However, $431 is appalling and not at all worth the experience. Unless you are only going for the drinks- there are many other great restaurants nearby that actually work to earn your business in every aspect- reward them with your business, not here. read more

10/10 Incredible service, outstanding food, such great vibes. The baked alaska is a must! Also enjoyed the pretzel bread, drinks, blue king roll, truffle butter steak, mashed potatoes and waffle fries! read more

Catch Steak - cocktails - Steakhouses Near Me - Aspen, Colorado

I've been to steak houses all over the country but this restaurant was by far the best place I've ever eaten at. The steak was Fantastic, the flavors were amazing. And the service was excellent. I can't say enough great things about Catch Steak. read more

Catch Steak - Truffle butter filet - Steakhouses Near Me - Aspen, Colorado

Nice atmosphere, friendly service And great food. We added it to our favorite stops in aspen! The crab roll is so good! read more

The best steak we've ever eaten!! We made a reservation and only had to wait 15 min for our table. We sat at the bar for a few drinks while we waited. Steak was cooked perfectly Our waitress was friendly and attentive All food was delicious prices are pretty high but the food and drinks were delicious. Plus it's Aspen so nothing is ever cheap here. Lol read more

See all

When Catch Steak first opened, we loved going to the restaurant. The manager, Richard, does an excellent job but the restaurant is so loud, one cannot even hear their own thoughts. The food is good but if you have any desire to talk with your friends, you will need to yell in order for anyone to hear what you're saying. Perhaps sitting outside presents a better option but the threat of rain sometimes does not allow the restaurant to use the outdoors. The sushi rolls are excellent, the cocktails are divine but I think the atmosphere is so chaotic and noisy, it is difficult to enjoy the meal. read more

I've enjoyed every meal that I've had at Catch Steakhouse. First, and most importantly, my steak was cooked properly every time. This is pretty normal for steak houses, yet not true for every single one. There's a great ambience, lots of music and energy and many different choices depending on what you're looking for. Great spot in Aspen, one of my favorites. read more

First time to Catch Steak Aspen. I loved it. Been to the one in LA many times. Love the outdoor portion here. With viees of the mountains. Food was delicious. Service was amazing. Would come back again for sure. read more

This place gets two stars because of the food and that's it. Service was not great like one would expect from a fancy over priced restaurant. Waiter asked what drinks we would like and came back 20 minutes later with our $6 cokes. We watched 3 tables get up and leave while we were in the restaurant. Not sure why they left but I did over hear one guy complain about waiting for service. That shouldn't happen at a restaurant that has 100 employees walking around. Manager seemed pushy and also choosy of who he talked to about how their meal was. Overall this place survives because it's in Aspen and the tourism will keep it afloat. Would never survive in an actual city. read more

Hostess was friendly. We were seated at a cramped table. Noise level was very high. Before settling into the seats while removing our jackets the waiter asked us what cocktail he could bring us. No smiling or Introductions from the waiter. We hadn't had any time to look at the menu. We were rushed. About fifteen minutes went by before the waiter returned and we were gathering our jackets because we had decided to leave. He was too late. Unfortunate. So many other fabulous options in Aspen. read more

What a great experience! The service is incredible. Every staff member made my husband and I feel special. Our meal was delicious and their specialty cocktails are fantastic. Be sure to try their Blue Cheese Creamed Spinach, Truffle Butter Filet and Cowgirl Ribeye. You won't be disappointed. The atmosphere is elegant and comfortable. read more

The ambience (lighting, furniture, music) was great. The staff was attentive but slightly arrogant? The food was good, but not great, especially compared to the price. Overall, Catch is the Range Rover of steak restaurants. High price tag, slightly pretentious, and mediocre quality. Kinda like a lot of things in Aspen read more

So basically all they want from you is to eat as fast as you can, pay and go... Steaks are not bad... next time just tell us to send the check we don't even need to show up... lol Ana, the server was nice tho but her manager... not much of a lady... read more

Made my reservation on OT because OT reviews averaged 4 plus stars. What a mistake because this restaurant is not worth the money. The steaks were not flavorful and the waffle fries were fast food quality. Service was slow and inattentive. They actually ran out of placemats (at 5:45 pm). We ate at the bar. I do not recommend this restaurant. read more

Sadly, the most chaotic dining experience in recent memory. From start to finish, the server mistakes, bad attitudes, and disorganization were unbelievable. Nothing short of herding guests like cattle. It was THAT bad. Manager Tracy was of no help and full of sarcasm. Clearly there is an issue with hiring the right people and training here. read more

Probably the most obnoxious door/floor person in Aspen... Granted the food is fine but Maddie/Madison is the most rude immature person in hospitality in Aspen. Childish, immature and cell phone addicted... Absurd this establish employs her... The food is ok, but pricey and certainly not worth the attitudes read more

Appears to be a nice restaurant but had to wait over 30 minutes when we had a reservation only to watch locals walk-ins be seated ahead of us without a reservation. The host was a smug prick and completely indignant. Reminder some common courtesy goes a long way. read more