Sorellis is all about expectations. If your expecting a taste of "The Hill" in Cedar hill like the…read moremenu claims, your going to be disappointed. If your expecting typical dried out sandwiches or greasy bar food then you may be surprised... Ordered the appetizer sampler to start. All 3 items were good. Typical bar type food, nothing special. The red sauce/marinara was a bit of a turn off and super chunky, at least the cup that we were served was. Everything was fried perfectly though, and I particularly liked the fried mushrooms and the toasted ravioli's. Moving on to the burger... It was okay, but pretty measly in size, especially considering the price. It is advertised as a 1/3lb which is already pretty small IMO, and it was also missing the bacon I had requested added on. I didn't notice it till the 2nd or so bite so I didn't mention it to the waitress but I also wasn't charged for it so no big deal. Fries were good, extra crispy battered type that I like. My guest had the tortellini. They tried to eat it but only made it through a few bites before they decided it just wasn't that great. No amount of adding salt, pepper, or mixing up the cold tortellini on top with the hotter ones swimming in the cheese bechamel below was going to save that. According to them the best part of that dish was the garlic roll. I tried it and personally didn't think it was terrible, bland for sure and definitely not worthy of an Italian restaurant, but not the worst I've ever had. It honestly tased as you would expect it to when ordering pasta from a bar and grill. Something you typically don't do. Service on the Friday night we came was sub par. I can't fault what appeared to be the only waitress because it seemed that she had at a lot going on scattered in both the bar area and the less smoky dining area, but this meant we only saw her for ordering the food, and when the apps and food were brought out. We were actually ready to go at least 10 minutes before she finally came back around with the check. Food we were served was also not super hot and the time between the apps being delivered and the main course was painfully slow. Bottom line, I don't foresee myself making the drive from High Ridge to Cedar hill just for Sorellis. I have a rule however that I always give second chances, and I would like to try out the pizza, as well as some of the other apps too, so whenever that second chance happens, I'll be sure to write an updated review.

Stopped in there to see the menu and check out the restaurant as soon as I stepped in the door, the…read moresmoke was overwhelming. I don't like to eat at restaurants where you have to inhale somebody else's smoke.

F#ck all of the sensitive little cry babies leaving bad reviews. This place is awesome! I have…read moreeaten here a couple of dozen times and not once have I had a bad experience.

I had to wait 45 minutes, just for the pizza to not even be ready. There was nobody there and yet…read moreIt still took way too long, in the end, we never got our pizza and left. Horrible service

One of my favorite pizzas. Always good. Friendly staff. Amazing small town treasure.read more

Pizza is good although crust is not fresh made. we went to shop as well as it is advertised as…read morehaving antiques for sale. on several trips store is ina mess and no prices on items, no help from staff.

Have been a few times for breakfast and the fried chicken , both were enjoyable. Was kind of…read moreshocked last time when they had raised the price on all white chicken , it took quite a jump. Not sure we'll go back at that price. Food and service were both good.

Love the atmosphere however I spent $45 for 2 sandwiches with a side. And the sandwiches were a…read more5/10 maybe. Cool place but not worth the money at all.

Wow! An amazing hidden gem in a small town that is sure to please any palate!…read more The service - 5 Stars! The staff treats you like family and are on it, no matter how busy. They are fun and made us want to keep coming back (which we did)! * Sammy - you are SPECTACULAR! The food - 5 stars! From the pretzel and yummy cheese to the pizza, absolutely spot on. The French onion soup had a depth of flavor and topped with an oversized piece of bread covered in cheese - heavenly! The salads are fresh and the dressings are on the top of the list I have tasted. The atmosphere - 5 stars! It's a lovely, yet smaller restaurant that is decorated to suite any person that walks in. Extremely clean and the patrons all know each other. The owners are welcoming and care about their customers. It's like dinner and a show with the entire interactions. I need to try the BBQ next time I'm in town!

A charming little bar & grill with standard pub fare. Service was quick on a busy Saturday…read moreafternoon. I had the "Best" French Dip, which was decent but far from the best I've ever had. Their fries are shoestring, almost similar to McDonald's, which isn't my favorite style at a sit-down restaurant. Next time I would probably order one of their specialities as they sound a little more exciting than what I got.

We love coming here when we are dropping off our son at camp. We only wish it was closer to home…read more The pizza is 10/10. We love the deluxe and the chicken bacon ranch pizza. The staff is friendly and welcoming. There's a small game room for kids.

We eat here all the time. It is a little slow but the food is good. The people are always polite…read moreand friendly.

The wife and I have been coming here since they were in the small spot by Gordon's Cheesesteaks…read more It's been awesome watching them grow. The new location is great, and I can't wait to come back when it's warmer and they've got those big garage doors open. The pizza is top notch -- the Buffalo chicken is hands down the best buffalo chicken pizza I've ever had. The ranch is homemade and unreal. The staff and service are always amazing. When my son was just two years old, they even put together a little balance bike for him to ride around. That kind of stuff sticks with you.

Being from Chicagoland I really like pizza. Really fun environment and clearly a local favorite as…read moreit was packed inside and out when we arrived. Super friendly staff and a clean place too. Wood fired pizza was good and we all enjoyed it.

It's fabulous!! We sat on the outside patio during Farmington Country Days and had a great night…read more Expert service by Hannah, great beer, cocktails and apps to start. Once we were ready for a "main" we chose the flatbread "Godfather" and it was excellent. After the apps it was too much for us to finish, but it was cooked to perfection.

This is a neat place with good food. The building is old and really neat inside. I love these type…read moreof places. The staff was friendly. We got in at the right time. It filled up right after we got there. It wasn't the fastest place to eat but wasn't unreasonable. The pizza is fancy, but good. I wasn't expecting that. I'm guessing we could have ordered a regular pepperoni or something like that, but we went with the Godfather and Margarita. Both were excellent. Spinach artichoke dip was fantastic. I'll definitely eat here again. I failed to take pics. Argh....sorry.

Best pizza in town! The crust is perfect, thin but not too thin, and the toppings are top quality…read more Best pie in town! From Cowan's which is attached nextdoor. Best service in town! Comfy and quaint to dine in and have a beer, though we usually pick up, and the owners and staff are all great!

Pizza is very good, crisp bottom. Wings were good too. Waitress was a little slow, but she was newread more

We have been going for a long time. Best pizza Been coming…read moresince I was a kid Now I bring my kids and my grandkids.

Our 4th time to stop here on the way to a Cardinals game in The Lou and it's still a 5 star,…read moreamazing place. Clean, attentive, friendly place, serving hot fresh delicious Italian food at a fair price. They also have a beautifully lit outdoor dining patio with umbrellas with a nice view of Main Street.. Main Street is fun to walk and explore too.