Love their cheesecake. I came here Saturday morning to get a cheesecake. After reviewing many places, I decided to try out Cheesy Eddie, and their cheesecake does not disappoint me. It's creamy and not too sweet as other bakery (still a little bit sweet for me, but their sugar level is acceptable). The store is small and a bit hidden. Staffs are friendly. The only thing I wish is the 1lb type could be a bit cheaper. Or I think getting 2lb will be better value read more

See all

I absolutely love coming here to buy their amazing carrot cakes for birthdays and celebrations. I'm not joking when I say that they make the BEST carrots cakes I have ever tasted. It's in a convenient location, has ample parking spots, staff are friendly, helpful and patient. The mini Jack and Jill cookies are always a crowd pleaser too but the carrot cake is my absolute favorite. Interior is very clean. Highly recommend if you're craving something sweet! read more

Stopped in to their Henrietta location to pick up some desserts for a work event. Easy to access and park at Regional market . Love their beautiful bright mural on the building. The shop is smaller inside but has a few display cases showcasing all their delicious desserts that have made them so popular over the years. I was picking up a carrot cake and a variety of cupcakes. I had to sample their chocolate and cream cheese frosting bites... mmmmm This location has been here since 2019 after their south ave store was so busy. I need to comeback and try their mini desserts! read more

See all

Recently tried Cheesy Eddie's for the first time and was not diappointed! I tried a pumpkin spice slice and it was delicious! No notes!!! I can't wait to go back for more. read more

Desserts are phenomenal!!! I am not a cake person, I actually do not like cake, but this place??? Oh my goddddd, their cake is so rich in flavor as well as moist! The carrot cake is the best cake I've ever had in my life! read more

Was excited to take my child here for their birthday.. they really wanted cupcakes and we were sorely disappointed. The cake in the cupcakes were EXTREMELY hard and dry, the only thing good was the icing, and it also was the only part of the cupcake we were willing to eat. We ended up throwing the cake part away, disappointed and waste of money. Cheesecake is good though. If we did go back, it would only be for the cheesecake. read more

A neighbor celebrating her birthday gave my husband and myself each some of Cheesy Eddie's carrot cake. This cake was wonderful; moist, sweet and delicious! Even better than the first time I had ever visited this bakery, which was in 1994 for our daughter's birthday cake. We have tried several other carrot cakes from other local bakeries and this one is the BEST! read more

I stopped here after running another errands in the rochester regional market. They have the best cheesecake I have had anywhere and that includes the famous one in nyc. They have so many varieties of cheesecake. The have slices and much larger full cheesecakes. The cookies stuffed with cream cheese frosting are a must grab. They also have full cakes and slices. My favorite part of this business is the slices. You can try a different variety each time you go and narrow down which is your favorite. Or get a full cheesecake and a few different slices. The staff were super friendly and welcoming. They were very patient when my son couldn't decide what he wanted. They are following all covid protocols read more

See all

We dropped by this location for curbside pickup and I am SO glad we did. You just cannot beat Cheesy Eddie's treats, be they at this location OR their South Ave location. I'll have to update my review when I actually have the chance to go into the warehouse once COVID is over, but the quality and process for curbside is simply the best. Some favorites of mine are the carrot cake (obviously), cheesecake, and the Jack or Jill's delight! Order online to save time and buy in BULK (yezzz) to eat treats for days. I love the team at Cheesy Eddie's and love how they've served the Rochester community so dutifully for so long. Endlessly grateful and looking forward to my next trip! read more

See all

Cheesecake & carrot cake delicious! Our go to for good desserts. It is nice that there is 2 bakeries in town.

Divine! Cheesy Eddies has the best cheesecake ever. I have indulged in their cheesecake on numerous occasions but why have I not visited the store sooner?! They have red velvet cake and carrot cake, just to name a few of the non cheesecake desserts. The 20 piece dessert tray I purchased had a nice variety of mini mouthwatering desserts, a nice way to sample the variety available. My favorite was the key lime cheesecake. We'll be enjoying a delicious carrot cake on Halloween. The carrot cake was decorated in the store at time of purchase - love the spider web decor. Bonus: no cross contamination of nuts for those with a nut allergy. I am looking forward to trying a gluten-free dessert at my next visit. Treat yourself & just do it. Easy parking. Great service. read more

Cheesy Eddie's - Carrot cake - Bakeries Near Me - Rochester, New York

Great location in Genesee Valley to the right and behind Palmer's. I already know that I love Cheesy Eddie's carrot cake and wonderful cookie sandwiches - so I thought this time around I would grab some cheesecake slices for dessert. I have been wanting to try the Black Button bourbon cream for awhile and was excited to see it was available as a slice option. The bourbon cream slice tasted like their basic cheesecake as a base, which is always rich, creamy and perfect, but I didn't appreciate much of a bourbon cream flavor in this cheesecake. The salted caramel type topping had a nice, buttery flavor making it still a great option. My husband likes more traditional flavors and loved the creamy, sweet fresh strawberry topping slice. I also love that they offer their cookie sandwiches in 3 sizes - mini, regular and a larger size. I got a mini of all three options - Peanut butter with a peanut butter creamy filling, chocolate chip with creamy filling and their well known oatmeal with cream cheese frosting filling - all three are amazing and you should try them all. Location is open, white with bright light, clean and has many options to choose from. They have full sized cheesecakes, cake slices, cheesecake slices, cookie sandwiches, pound cake and pound cake sandwiches with frosting in between and I spotted some brownies that also looked amazing that I plan to try next time. I love that they offer so many of their specialty flavors as single slices! Each slice approx. $5 - Great deal. read more

Cheesy Eddie's - Very subtle bourbon cream more caramel type flavor. - Bakeries Near Me - Rochester, New York

See all

Outstanding; some of the best cheesecake ever! First time trying it out. Highly recommend.

I bought 2 slices of cake for my dad's birthday - carrot and cheese cake. The shop is small but bright, clean and in a shopping area with lots of parking. The workers are friendly and helpful. Once we got back, we couldn't wait and dove right into them. The carrot cake was moist and a little bouncy. I'm not much of a frosting person but I liked their cake to frosting ratio. I haven't had had a good cheese cake in years so I wasn't expecting much but was pleasantly surprised! I'm saying this even thought it didn't have a crust which is my favorite part. I don't know how to describe desserts so I hope this makes sense. It was light but not airy like a Japanese one and had some body but didn't feel like cement in my stomach. *shrug* I tried. Normally I lean towards carrot but today I can't decide which I like better. read more

Cheesy Eddie's - Carrot and cheese cake - Bakeries Near Me - Rochester, New York

Cheesy Eddie's Bakery is a gem. Best place for carrot cake and cheesecake in Rochester. Their cookies are also amazing. The staff is friendly and worked efficiently during the busy pre holiday rush. I love that they have several different sizes of sampler cheesecakes to get slices of many different flavors they have to offer. The cheesecakes freeze very well if you want to save some for later. So far my favorite flavors are the original, peanut butter cup, oreo explosion, raspberry swirl, and cherry delight. The cupcakes and dessert trays are great for corporate gifting, bring to work treats and thank you gifts. They also sell gift certificates which are a great gift for someone who has everything. read more

My fiancé asked me what kind of cake i wanted for my bday... if you know me it's only 2 options... and the #1 option is always carrots cake. As we are visiting my fiancé's family here... this place came well recommended! Needless to say I was NOT disappointed!!! The cake was so lite and good. The frosting was sweet and creamy!!!! We will be ordering more before we leave! read more

Cheesy Eddie's - Carrot Cake - Bakeries Near Me - Rochester, New York

I'm so glad I took a moment to visit this location kitty corner from Palmer's. If you live in the city as I do sometimes getting to the South Ave location for parking is a royal pain in the butt. Here plenty of parking.. the inside is light and bright. They have all the usual suspects for your cheesecake dreams as a regular, gf or sugar free cheesecake. Staff is pleasant and helpful. Give them a whirl! read more

See all

Excellent dessert selection and are perfect for lunch, dinner or holiday menus. They are also, excellent for holiday gift presentations. Great service and sales associates in each bakery locations in Monroe County. read more

If you like peanut butter pie, get one of the peanut butter blasts. It's a single serve flower-shaped peanut butter pie that is finished with peanut buttercup crumbles. It's so delicious. They rarely have them in stock as it is so I may regret sharing this gem. read more

This location is much bigger than the one in south wedge and feels industrial. Bonus: parking is plenty :) It's near Palmer's and Rochester Appliances and took me a bit to locate it. I came here for National Cheesecake Day - one free slice per person. I picked Amaretto besides other flavors: original, raspberry swirl, chocolate, key lime. read more

Cheesy Eddie's - National cheesecake day freebie! Amaretto cheesecake - Bakeries Near Me - Rochester, New York

Clean and bright. It was national cheesecake day so I got a free slice I chose key lime. It was okay. I'll stick to the real deal and not cheesecake flavored key lime because if anyone is going to do it right it will be cheesy Eddie's. I wasn't a huge fan of it. There seemed to be too many employees not knowing what to do but it's a new place so I won't be too harsh. It takes time for new places to run smoothly. Not everything is labeled. I asked what the pink frosted cupcake was as there was no signage on that one and two employees "thought" it was raspberry. The cashier/checkout station is CRAMPED. The design doesn't seem that well thought out. The cashier was obviously new and overwhelmed by the brisk business, the trainer was super patient and offered encouraging words which was nice to see. I think people who come here need to understand to not be in a hurry. I had the oatmeal cookie sandwiches and the Jane, a peanut butter cookie with smooth peanut butter filling and a carrot cake cupcake-all delicious! Of course-I mean it's CHEESY EDDIE'S read more

Cheesy Eddie's - Carrot cake cupcake - Bakeries Near Me - Rochester, New York

Hey friends! For those of you who think Cheesy Eddie's is just for cheesecake & carrot cake, guess again! I ordered this white raspberry-torte yesterday for a Graduation celebration and everyone was raving about it -- even people who never indulge in sweets! The cake is so light, the raspberry mouse is heavenly and then of course the famous cream cheese frosting. Highly, highly recommend! I will definitely be ordering again. https://shopcheesyeddies.com/collections/other-cakes/products/white-raspberry-torte read more

SO excited that this place has a second, new location! Baileys Irish Cream, Key Lime Pie, and Apple Caramel Streusel Cheesecakes were all SPECTACULAR!!! They have t- shirts, too! Come see them!! read more

Cheesy Eddie's - Super friendly staff! - Bakeries Near Me - Rochester, New York

See all

A family member bought us a few items for Valentine's Day this week. The chocolate tart we had was good but not wowing, same with the lime cheesecake. It was certainly a nice gesture but if I were to stop in myself I would try another product in the hopes it's better. read more

I visited today after a huge craving for a sweet snack. They had hand sanitizer right by the door and complied with COVID regulations. There was a large selection of sweets all in different sizes depending on how much you wanted which was nice. I got some cupcakes, slices of cheesecake, and mini cookie sandwiches. All were incredibly tasty, but I loved the mini cookie sandwiches. They were small enough to satisfy a craving without being too much sweetness. The oatmeal cookie was my favorite if I had to pick one. Overall nice selection and tasty treats at a good price read more

Love this cheesy eddie's location for celebrating national cheesecake day by giving away a free slice. I also stopped by to grab a pie, my carrot cake cheesecake! The location has plenty of parking and relatively spacious so patrons can stay 6 feet apart. Interior is simple, clean, with nice open display of goodies to choose from. read more

Best carrot cake and cheese cake! We have been celebrating special occasions and cravings with those treats for over 30 years...consistently outstanding! read more

The employees are so nice, friendly and provide great customer service! Can't wait to try their treats when I get home!

Best cheese cake in town for sure! Tried red velvet cheesecake, red velvet cupcake, carrot cake, oatmeal cookie, bourbon cheesecake. All were delicious. read more

Great!!! Red Velvet cake for my son's birthday was a big hit. Special thanks to Lindsay for going out of her way to help make things perfect. read more