Travis and his team are to notch! All are very knowledgeable and have the credentials and schooling…read moreto prove it. They are all passionate gemologists who really take the time to evaluate and accurately appraise every item you put in front of them. I trust their discernment and advice on everything precious gem related!

Very professional (and nice) Reception with Elizabeth. Travis took care of me for two watches. Very…read morefriendly and professional folks. Traveling from Orlando and they were able to accommodate me. Thanks so much, it's refreshing to deal with these folks. Good value price in appraisals for all they do. Very professional report.

I began a series of messages with Robert to do a last minute appraisal while visiting my daughter…read morein New York. While we decided to not do any appraisal at this time , I will say he rates five stars for response time, thoroughness of explanation of services and for courtesy. I would have enjoyed working with him.

I needed pearls appraised. I spoke to the representative and they explained the whole process in…read moregreat detail. I learned a lot about how porting it is to certify every piece of jewelry you own. The value of their services was reasonable. Cost and insuring your valuables are priceless.

With I could give them 10 stars!!!…read more I had an emergency situation where I needed diamonds set into a new setting plus needed it the same day! Asked around to all my contacts and did my Google and Yelp due diligence and I was referred to I. D. Jewelery without hesitation, even Google AI said go to them! First off it's a true family owned and operated business. And they treat you like family too (minus the drama) everyone was so warm and friendly. I first called and spoke to lovely Anna and she told me it was possible but to come in so their jeweler can take a look at it first. I got there around 11am and I told them my dilemma, Tammy and her team made me feel reassured all would work out and Yekutiel did not hesitate and got on the phone with his setter and told me to come back by 4:30. Mind. Freaking. Blown. They did a magnificent job of setting my diamonds into my new setting but they were also very impressed by the craftsmanship of my custom ring setting. Because it was an emergency situation, I was ready to pay over $1K for this service but the bill was not even close to that number. As the owner said, he is in the business of making people happy not price gauging his customers. The BEST in the jewelry business and I'm so looking forward to going back to get an actual custom piece made there very soon too!

Had a great experience with Tami. She was so kind and patient; never once tried to upsell us. We…read morewere getting a ring upgrade for a milestone anniversary. We walked in without an appointment and were helped right away. Highly recommend.

I used Sutton Certified Appraisals services two times. Toni…read morethe owner is an exceptionally attentive and professional appraiser. She was extremely detailed and took a lot of time to explain the process. The final appraisal for my late mothers estate was done so well that my attorney said to me that " he had never seen such a well formatted and concise appraisal". I highly recommend this company.

From the owner: Personal Property Appraisals. Art Appraisals. Antique Appraisals. Furniture Appraisals. Insurance…read moreAppraisals. Estate Appraisals. Matrimony Appraisals. Estate Liquidation.

Rob is extremely professional and always gets my job done as I requested. Their customer service is…read moregreat and the value is amazing . I have never been disappointed with any request and I highly recommend this business.

Both the receptionist and appraiser were incredibly knowledgeable and friendly. Katie, who…read moreappraised my engagement ring, took her time answering my questions in a professional yet warm manner. It was a great experience, and I highly recommend their services.

I had some old 14k gold jewelry to sell (broken name chain from when I was a kid and a name plate…read morebracelet that I never wear) and didn't know where to start. TBH I've never sold jewelry before and pawn shops/ "we buy gold" establishments always give off a weird vibe so I avoid them. But I'm moving pretty far away and holding on to broken jewelry that I haven't worn in 20 years simply doesn't make sense so I decided I would sell it rather than risking it getting lost in the move. I've seen this place many times in passing so after seeing positive reviews (albeit from many Yelp newbies) I decided to stop by. Mike was personable and helpful. I did end up selling my pieces, he briefly explained the gold market and we chatted a bit about the jewelry and how he does business. He clearly cares about he does. Overall it was an easy, chill transaction. He shared he was offering $70/g but as it was explained to me: that can change and also depends on how much you're selling. I'm no expert. Did I do a lot of research? Not really. But Mike seemed genuine, wasn't pushy and didn't give off a "tryna get you" vibe. If you're looking to sell or even buy secondhand jewelry, I definitely recommend swinging by and chatting with Mike. Store wasn't busy on a Thursday, early afternoon.

I was looking to unload a a bunch of gold and silver and came across Jersey city gold buyers…read more I gave Mike a call before coming in and was super friendly on the phone. Stopped in the next day and came to an extremely fair price on the gold and silver. He was knowledgeable and extremely friendly. I know other spots that definitely do not give as much as he does. Overall I'm extremely happy with the visit and sale. I'll most likely be using him for my Cuban chain that I'm looking to get as well. I'd without a doubt recommend using Mike if you're looking for an honest experience!

I do not have any experience with jewelry appraisal before or since my visit here, but I was…read moresatisfied overall with American Appraisal. Their location may not be the easiest to find, since it is on the second floor, but it is close enough to the edge of the Diamond District that you won't have to bob and weave past all the people trying to sell or buy jewelry before getting to the building. Pro-Tip: they have a camera trained at the door to the office, just go to the door and they'll buzz you in. I stood outside for two minutes and double-checked the address before opening the door into an office that is much nicer than the hallway and staircase just outside. I was a walk-in and was helped immediately. He looked over the item and I walked out 10 minutes later with the certificate, printed and laminated on the spot. I was able to download a digital copy for my insurance company the next day using the appraisal number on their site. Painless.

Don't leave a ton of reviews, but these guys are great…read more Awesome appraiser, Derek, was super nice and really knowledgeable. He shared fun details about my items as went. The process was quick and painless and the pricing was reasonable.

Bruce is extremely knowledgeable. He took time to explain everything and answer all my questions…read more Extremely fair prices. He has some great stories, too! Highly recommended.

Bruce was great. Messaged him in the morning and he was accommodating and able to meet with me the…read moresame day. His diamond knowledge is top notch. Highly recommend and will always work with Bruce in the future.