I was planning a surprise proposal party for my now fiancé and thought of everything except the dessert. So a month before the big day I found myself scrambling. After reading reviews I decided to go with CiCi's Cakery but was still nervous. But from the moment Theresa replied to my email she was nothing but delightful and easy to work with. Then when everyone tasted the cupcakes and cake they were floored. I had so many people ask me who made them and tell me how good they were. They couldn't believe that I had found such a great baker from a random Yelp search. I would highly recommend CiCi's Cakery and Theresa to any and every one. I just hope she's ready for my email when it's time for my wedding! read more

CiCi's Cakery - Bakeries Near Me

Fantastic artistry, aroma, and taste in the 5" cake I ordered for my wife's birthday. With only 7 days' notice, Theresa was able to fit in our order and created a delicious and stunningly beautiful wild strawberry-buttercream-frosted, vanilla bean cake that was rich and the perfect size for 3 to 4 of us- we still have about a half a cake leftover after two days! We are dyed-in-the-wool Carvel ice cream cake fans, but can easily say this was the best cake we have ever eaten. Theresa and her work are worth every penny, and we will definitely be repeat customers- can't wait to try her cupcakes next. I do recommend ordering further in advance than we did, since she books up fast! read more

CiCi's Cakery - 5" birthday cake front - Bakeries Near Me

See all

I found CiCi's Cakery on Instagram after moving to Ridgewood - and realized she lives on my street - of course, I had to order from her for my son's 1st birthday party! Theresa worked with me to design the perfect cake for the "Lucky One"-themed party (he's a St. Patrick's Day baby, so it was only fitting). The cake was so beautiful and equally delicious. I'd highly recommend for any special occasion! read more

CiCi's Cakery - Bakeries Near Me

for my daughter's first bday I knew I had to have Theresa make her cake. Theresa was super accommodating! She suggested we try a different flavor this time, so we decided on the earl grey and vanilla flavor and it was stepping into a hot shower after shoveling snow type amazing. i'm not much of a cake person and i had 2 servings, that type of good good. my daughter loved it too and everyone asked for Theresa's number! the decoration was beautiful and she even added some extra flowers to make the cake pop ive watched enough food network to know this woman would win all the Cake Wars read more

CiCi's Cakery - Bakeries Near Me

We're repeat customers to CiCi's Cakery for this Super Smash Bros. birthday cake. We stuck with the flavor (matcha with black sesame frosting) as the cake we ordered last year. Theresa was super responsive on email and easy to work with on the cake design. The cake was cute and delicious - thank you! We'll be back again soon! read more

CiCi's Cakery - Bakeries Near Me

See all

Beautiful cake, great to work with and design what you want, delicious, unique flavors.

For my 30th Birthday, I wanted a game of thrones theme cake. Told Theresa my vision and she executed beyond me expectations. She has unique flavors to choose from which I found exciting. I got a vanilla cake with chai buttercream. The cake was absolutely delicious and so moist. All my guest enjoyed it! I was sad to cut the cake because it was so gorgeous! Theresa was very prompt with her email communication. Very professional and kind. I will definitely recommend her to others and now consider her my go-to person for cakes! read more

CiCi's Cakery - Game of thrones theme cake. Vanilla cake with chai buttercream. - Bakeries Near Me

See all

Ordered a custom made cake for a gender reveal for my sister's baby. Theresa was very accommodating and helpful! She was able to have the order done in less than 1 week. The cake was very well made - design and taste. I will definitely be ordering from her again in the future! read more

See all

Theresa runs a fantastic business and offers superior quality baked goods, uniquely flavored and extremely appealing. I had the pleasure of ordering cupcakes for a family birthday celebration and I found her to be extremely responsive, patient and professional. I had ordered Pandan cupcakes, something I had never had before and they were superb! I will surely recommend and use her again in the future. read more

I ordered a cake for my birthday based on yelp reviews. Communication was fast, easy and professional. I had an idea in mind and Theresa was able to capture what I wanted in the cake. I chose the red velvet with cream cheese frosting. I wanted fresh flowers, and she used the colors I like and hints of gold on the frosting that matched the gold candles I ordered. The cake was elegant and delicious! Pick up was very easy. I got a lot of compliments on the cake decor, flavor and texture. I will order again if I need another delicious and beautiful cake. Check out her IG page @cicis_cakery. read more

CiCi's Cakery - Red velvet Cake with cream cheese frosting. - Bakeries Near Me

Cici's bakery was very accommodating with our requests. We had the vanilla rainbow buttercream cake and the flavor was outstanding.It was not too sweet which i liked. The kids were awed when we cut the cake to reveal the layers of rainbow cake inside. we also ordered a bunch of cupcakes to try out. It was nicely packaged and she gave us directions on how to storage it till the party. She's very efficient with communication. read more

Theresa's cakes were everything I imagined and more. I stumbled across her cakes a couple of years ago, but finally had the opportunity to order one this past year. She is really responsive to emails and very easy to work with. I ordered the Totoro cake as a birthday surprise and everyone has said how amazing it looked and how great it tasted. I would definitely recommend Cici's Cakery for anyone that wants to surprise their loved ones! read more

I was looking for a chocolate cake for my husband's birthday and found CiCi's Cakery on Yelp looking up "Best Chocolate Cakes in Brooklyn" with 5 stars. I contacted Theresa a couple days before needing the cake for Dec 31th and she happily agreed with short notice. The cake looked amazing when she sent me the picture and I couldn't wait to see if it tasted as good as it looked and it did. The cake was moist and delicious. The salted caramel buttercream icing was amazing including the decorative hearts on the cake. You would think caramel would make it too sweet but it was just right. I will definitely order my future cake needs from CiCi's Cakery. read more

CiCi's Cakery - Bakeries Near Me

Theresa made me the most beautiful, unique, creative and DELICIOUS cake for my sons first birthday this past weekend. I told her my theme and she flew with it. She was available to answer any questions I had and presented me with various amazing options to choose from. I couldn't be happier with the results. Sometimes when you buy a beautiful cake, you compromise on taste and moistness -but you get the full package with CIcis Cakery:) thank you so much for making the perfect cake for my son. I am a a life long customer! read more

My boyfriend surprised me with a birthday cake from CiCi's recently and I was blown away. Not only was the cake absolutely delicious but it was so beautifully and delicately decorated. The cake was a lovely caramel flavor with salted caramel icing and lovely piped pink flowers, perfection! I would highly recommend CiCi's for custom cakes! read more

CiCi's Cakery - Bakeries Near Me

I got a gorgeous cake from CiCI's - devils food with salted caramel buttercream. It was painted in watercolors and edged in gold trim. Absolutely beautiful. Usually cakes that pretty taste just ok- but not in this case-it was DELICIOUS!!!!! I wish I had a reason to get a cake every week from here! read more

My husband bought CiCi's cake for my birthday, it looks very pretty and he got me the earl grey flavor which was delicious! Totally will get more from her next time! read more

CiCi's Cakery - Soo pretty and elegant - Bakeries Near Me

See all

Cici's Cakery blew me away with their flexible service and amazing cakes. I called in an order a few days in advance, had no idea what I wanted, and Theresa helped me decide on a vanilla cake with chai filling/frosting. She was up front about saying she had never done chai flavoring before but was up to the task. Lo and behold, this chai filling was crazy good and I can't believe a human being can make frosting taste that much like chai. I super recommend this if you want something a little unusual but still reliably tasty. The cake was crazy moist without a hint of artificial flavoring. It honestly tasted like eating a vanilla wafer dunked in chai, and normally I really don't care for cakes. Theresa was an absolute pro and even followed up the next day to ask if the cake was up to our expectations. Eating one of her cakes is like watching a whole season of Great British Bake Off in terms of making one appreciate the fine art of baking. I absolutely recommend Cici's. read more

Not only did Theresa create the most beautiful cake for my daughter's first birthday, but I had multiple compliments from family that it was the best cake they've ever had!! She was accommodating and quick to respond via email. I absolute recommend Ci-Ci's Cakery to all! read more

Cici's Cakery made my 50th birthday cake and it was gorgeous and delicious! I ordered her amazing signature Green Tea with black buttercream. Theresa is such an awesome person and very professional to work with. She even gave me some extra cake, how awesome is that!?! Thank you Cici's for being part of my milestone bday. NJ is so lucky to have you, we have a cakeshop that we can rely on. Your creations are truly beautiful! Good luck and more power! read more

CiCi's Cakery - a cake decorated with flowers - Bakeries Near Me

See all

Got the cake for my husband birthday. The cake was Beautiful design and taste delicious

Would highly recommend Cici's Cakery. Theresa was very responsive and helped create an even more beautiful cake than I imagined! I went for the green tea/sesame flavor since she told me it was most popular. There are some unique options to choose from and I can't wait until the next occasion to try something new. The cake was so perfect and tasted delicious, everyone at the party loved it. read more

CiCi's Cakery - Bakeries Near Me

See all

This review is long overdue, as I celebrated my birthday in March. Yet, there's no way, I would miss out on the opportunity to write a review of my experience with CiCi's Cakery. Theresa was absolutely amazing, and as you can see from my photos, her work is impeccable. Theresa, was very professional and super accommodating to my last-minute request for a birthday cake. Typically orders had to be placed a month in advance, and I literally contacted Theresa a week before my birthday. I sent over a picture to her of what my vision was for the cake, we talked about the little details and voila, she was able to make it happen for me, and I could not have been happier with the results. I would highly recommend CiCi's Cakery, because not only are the cakes delicious and the appearance esthetically appealing, but I can honestly say that Theresa actually cares about her customer's satisfaction and will exceed expectations. I was very much pleased with the turn out of my birthday cake and would definitely contact CiCi's Cakery for future orders. read more

CiCi's Cakery - Birthday Cake - Macarons not included - Bakeries Near Me

See all

Theresa did an amazing job making Blue Velvet XBOX cupcakes for a last minute party I planned for my son. The cupcakes were rich and very tasty, the frosting was absolutely perfect. I don't have a sweet tooth but everything was just right for me. Thank you again Theresa and CiCi's Cakery for being part of our milestone. Your contact details are stored for my next emergency order. I endorse and high recommend your business for all cakes, cupcakes, cookies, etc. read more

CiCi's Cakery - Bakeries Near Me

Great experience in getting a signature cake in less time! Awesome staff and Theresa is great to work with...my husband gave a surprise baby shower and the cake was superb! Will definitely recommend to others... read more

CiCi's Cakery - Bakeries Near Me

Cici's Cakery is known for incorporating only the finest natural and organic ingredients in every delicious cake that is baked, plus in their cupcakes, cookies, and cake pops. Cici's cakery also adds two special ingredients: joy and love of baking and designing from the heart. Each baked good we have tried (we have had many) has been special and unique. Not found in most places. I highly recommend all their baked goods! read more

CiCi's Cakery - These decadent whimsical flower cupcakes sure brought a smile to my face and knowing that they were all made by hand made it even sweeter! - Bakeries Near Me

See all

I found Theresa through Yelp and after seeing pictures of her beautiful cakes I decided to order two cakes for both my son and daughter's milestone birthdays. She was so kind, helpful, and easy to coordinate with to make my kids birthdays extra special. We loved the cakes so much and couldn't stop eating them! I cannot wait to order our next cake and highly recommend her cakes for any event! read more

See all

Theresa made a beautiful and, more importantly, delicious custom cake for a baby shower I hosted! It looked just like the image from the Pinterest board we wanted and the taste was perfection (early grey!). Not too sweet, moist, and one of the best cakes I've had, which most of the guests agreed as well. Coordinating via email was so easy and she was so responsive from start to finish. Highly recommend CiCi's Cakery! read more

CiCi's Cakery - Elegant, textured cake! I added the simple fresh flowers on top. - Bakeries Near Me

This place says they need orders placed at least one month in advance, even for the tinyist order.

I love love love love loved everything about Theresa's cookies and cake and cupcakes! They were so moist and yummy and the designs were perfect and exactly how my son and I had wanted them to be! My son couldn't stop trying to touch his cake coz he liked it that much! He was soooo happy! The guests were so happy with the desserts too! They were all asking where we had ordered the cakes from! Thank you so much, Theresa for making my LO the perfect cake! Definitely going to be ordering again in the future! read more

See all

Superb service and delicious treats! We used Cici's for a recent kid's event and she made the most adorable monster cupcakes that the kids went crazy for. read more

It was such a treat to enjoy the cake Theresa made for my mom's surprise 60th birthday celebration. She was fast to respond, friendly and easy to communicate with, and cake pick-up on the day of the party was smooth! Everyone commented on how nice the cake looked and even more so, on how great it tasted! I would highly recommend CiCi's Cakery and hope to work with Theresa on another celebratory dessert in the future. read more

CiCi's Cakery cakes are perfect. Theresa's talent is obvious. I can honestly say this is the Best cake I ever tasted. She was quick to reply to my questions/concerns and asked lots of questions to make sure the cake I needed was done right. Even when I had issues scheduling my pickup, she was understanding and accommodating. Theresa added that she uses top quality ingredients, bakes from scratch, and everything is made-to-order when I mentioned the price. She also said she uses a Swiss Meringue buttercream that takes twice as long to make and not your typical buttercream most bakers use. All of these are reasons why her cakes taste as good as they do. I wanted to add this information from her because I did not realize what I was buying at first. A cake is a cake, right? No, this cake was absolutely delicious and looked perfect. For this you will pay much more than regular bakery pricing. I would not agree this is a two $$ price point business. What I paid for a 6 inch cake for a wedding was a lot more than I expected for that price point. This business is more like a $$$ or more price point. Also when I made a last minute request, I was quoted an additional high fee on top of the high price I felt I was already paying. The only reason I knocked a star was because I felt it was a little deceptive to classify your business as reasonably priced when it is not. I initially based my inquires on the $$ price point. After harping on the price, and knowing what I know now I have to say I would do it all over again. No regrets. Highly recommend her. read more

I've had the pleasure of trying a number of different cakes as well as cupcakes. I love the uniqueness of the different creations all made with fresh ingredients. I definitely recommend trying out some of their homemade creations you won't be disappointed. read more

Theresa is a very talented creative baker with great taste in decal! She knows how to bake you the most beautiful cake that will WOW you! I'm happy with the cake she baked me for my big 3-0 birthday! read more

CiCi's Cakery - Bakeries Near Me

Amazing desserts! The moon pies are off the charts and the blue velvet cupcakes were visually stunning as well as delicious. Nothing is overly sweet, beautifully rendered, pleasing to the palate and the eye. read more

Absolutely delicious, mouth watering, flavors bursting cakes, cupcakes and cookies. CiCi's cakery is among the best and uses only the finest ingredients. We have ordered from them many times and have been blown away. The owner is very enterprising and creative, will work with you to get you what you are looking for and can create very unique combinations of flavors that you won't find in many places. Highly, highly recommend Cici's Cakery. Come support your local business! read more

What a great find in the neighborhood! It was a pleasure to work with Theresa. She made a birthday cake for my 3 year old son as well as a dozen cupcakes. She accommodated 2 different flavors (vanilla and chocolate) for the cupcakes and created a train themed design for the cake based on example photos I provided. Everything was delicious and not too sweet! I'll definitely return to CiCi's Cakery for future celebrations. read more

I had ordered a few dessert ( birthday cake, cupcakes, cookies, macaroons and truffles) from Theresa for my husband`s surprise 40th birthday. Everything that I had ordered was absolutely delicious!! It was a pleasure to work with Theresa, she was very honest and patient in explaining what can or cannot be done. With things that cannot be done, Theresa gave alternatives and best suggestions on other options that can be done to the design. I had so much fun working with her. The night before my pick up, Theresa sent me a detailed email of instructions for the cake. My caterer was telling me that the cake was one of the best cake she had ever seen!! All the desserts do not only look good, all of them taste delicious!! The dessert table is DA BOMB of the party. The only one complain that my husband had made was why did I not order more!!! I am for sure coming back for more Theresa!! read more

I was in urgent need of a cake for a coworker and I found Theresa's information on Yelp. I placed an order for her green tea with black sesame cake (to be picked up in less than 48 hours) and she delivered! My coworker was in love with the cake decorations and everyone was pleased with the the blend that Theresa whipped! She constantly communicated with me and made sure I knew the status of the cake. If you're reading this you should definitely hit her up! read more