I went here with my friend... and holy moly. What a cute spot! The sweet treats were also amazing, but what stole the show was the incredible staff. read more

This place is sooooo cute!! I'm a huge Disney Adult dork and I sweat sporting it as much as I could. The decor was so beautiful I wanted it all. Hahaha. But the lead is the baked treats. They had a decent assortment of cookies that were representing the Mardi Gras spirit. We wound up getting the orange creamsicle cake pop, a Carmel butter bar, a 6 pack of various macarons (grey stuff, lava you, churro, and dole whip) and a spaceship earth cookie. We've eaten most of everything at this point. And it was amazing. The flavors bring you back to Disney and their amazing baked goods and yummy treats. They also sell a few of the cookie cutters that they use (they make them so they can make the cookies) seriously. Would recommend them for anything! read more

Wish Upon A Pastry - Spaceship Earth cookie and macarons. - Bakeries Near Me - Midland Park, New Jersey

When we found this bakery via instagram we couldnt wait to make the hour trip from CT. The husband and wife team are a delight bringing the most adorable Disney inspired treats to the North East! read more

Wish Upon A Pastry - Monsters Inc themed cookies! - Bakeries Near Me - Midland Park, New Jersey

If I could give more stars I would! Found out about this amazing pastry shop on Instagram when it popped up in my feed. Since I'm a Disney fanatic since the early 70's lol I had to go check it out. I bought three cookies, two macarons, a Mickey Rice Krispie treat and a Mickey chocolate covered marshmallow....they also have candles that have park scents and ice cream which I'm definitely buying next time I go which will most likely be next week lol. So the first thing I tried was a macaron. I'll first say I'm not normally a fan of macarons. The few places I've gotten them from (including in the France Pavilion in Epcot) they've always been really dry and I've always wondered why do people like these so much? Lol. I normally wouldn't have bought any but they have a POG juice flavor one and I had to try it (also got a Grey Stuff one). Let me tell you....finally! These were great! Not dry at all! Great flavor and texture. Definitely didn't fall apart in my hand as I tried to eat it! I'll definitely get more next time but honestly will probably stick to not buying macarons anywhere else. Lol. Next up I tried the cookies. So a lot of times cookies that are frosted/decorated like this don't taste great. That's been my experience anyway. Omg. Not at all the case with these!! They have great flavor, again not dry and crumbly and they're not sugary sweet either, just sweet enough. The Rice Krispie treat and the chocolate covered marshmallow were both yummy as well but the stand outs of what I got were the macaroons and the cookies! Those cookies! I'm trying to ration out the three I bought so I don't have all three eaten before I go back! The owners were really friendly too and answered any questions I had and also told me everything was handmade by them (even the candles!) I drove 30 mins to get there and it was totally worth it. I know they do custom cakes as well which look fantastic from what I've seen. You can also order from their website. Go get your cookies!!! You won't be disappointed! You might even get addicted like me! Lol. When you can't get to the parks this is the perfect substitute to hold you over. I actually was supposed to be in WDW for my bday but had to cancel the trip so I went to Wish Upon a Pastry because I thought I deserved some treats on my birthday lol. read more

See all

Top to bottom amazing experience with Wish Upon. The customer service was awesome, they were so attentive to detail and prompt at replying and the treats came out so beautifully. My son was so happy to see his favorite monster truck atop his 3rd birthday cake, Wish Upon really helped make our celebration special. And the best part- everything tasted even better than it looked! Will absolutely be using this bakery going forward and cannot recommend enough. read more

See all

I have placed numerous royal icing cookie orders from Wish Upon a Pastry, and there are many reasons why this is the only bakery I will ever use! I could not be more impressed! The cookies are always beautifully decorated, but also delicious. The icing is perfectly sweet and smooth, and the cookies themselves have the perfect balance of soft and crisp. You can tell a lot of care and skill go into each design. Michelle and Torre nail your vision. They are very responsive, friendly, and professional. The attention to detail is incredible. If you are looking for fabulous desserts for any occasion (or just a treat for yourself), I highly recommend this bakery. They have earned a loyal customer in me! read more

Everything looks and tastes like it came straight from a Disney Park! The owners are very kind and made it such a great experience.

WOW is all I can say. We used Wish Upon A Pastry this past weekend for my daughter's bridal shower. Ordered the mini donuts, macrons, rice krispie treats and cakesicles. One thing was more delicious than the next. Do yourself a favor and get the cakesicles and macrons, you will not be disappointed. Oh, and if you go to the store, make sure to get the the cheesecake!!! read more

See all

There is little to say here, other than OUT OF THIS WORLD!!! From the taste of the cake to the design- sheer perfection! I have not had such a delicious cake in a very long time. Torre and Michelle- thank you for making this engagement cake so lovely! My daughter and her fiancé were in love with it! We will be back, and will be highly recommending you to our friends! read more

Wish Upon A Pastry - a cake decorated with flowers - Bakeries Near Me - Midland Park, New Jersey

I am truly shocked this adorable bakery has not been reviewed yet! Torre and Michelle are absolute dolls and I couldn't be happier to support a fantastic couple in their small business adventure. When you walk in to the bakery you are greeted with a full pastry case of delicious and unique cakesicles, macaroons, cookie snack packs with dipping icing (YUM), and other tasty treats. They specialize in customization and proudly display their custom 3d printed cookie cutters and unique sprinkle mixes! I purchased a large batch of cookies for an upcoming party and Torre and Michelle made this part of planning an absolute breeze. I am so excited it's pies and cookie season! I'll definitely be returning for goodies to bring to all of the upcoming holiday celebrations! I wish I took more pictures but got distracted by chatting with Michelle and Torre. Do yourself a favor and stop in, order some cookies or other treats for a birthday party, wedding celebration, or just because- you won't regret it read more

Wish Upon A Pastry - a stone building with a sign that says wish upon a pastry - Bakeries Near Me - Midland Park, New Jersey

I went with Wish Upon a Pastry for my gender reveal cake and I'm so happy I did! Not only was it stunning (we got compliments from everyone all day) it was also delicious! Best cake I've ever eaten, by far. We will definitely be going back thank you! read more

Wish Upon A Pastry - a birthday cake on a table - Bakeries Near Me - Midland Park, New Jersey

Amazing custom cookies! We worked with Michelle to create a custom design pulling pieces together from a few different photos. She went above and beyond to make them perfect for our day. They were *almost* too beautiful to eat, but thankfully we had a few extra after our event to enjoy and they were delicious! Can't wait to order again soon. read more