Tony's cakes was a vendor for our wedding April 2nd 2026. Everything was A Plus from the setup to…read moreevery single bite of dessert. There was literally nothing left everyone raved about who made the sweets for the night. Tonys delivered more than we ever could expect, definitely will continue using their services for all of our family events going forward. Thank you guys so much from the Green family

**check the photos for Tony's response to this straight up MESSSSS…read more He tells us that for a full refund we would have to bring back the uneaten cake.?Unfortunately we didn't know our cake was wrong until we cut into it at OUR PARTY where yes it needed to be served as it was the only cake we bought. This company is a jooooke. Couldn't even do the right thing when they were alllll wrong. My boyfriend's parents put us in charge of their 50th anniversary party and I knew instantly I wanted to get them a special cake. No costco, no Whole Foods but a real bakery from a real local business. We would have used cakes by Karl ( also in Vallejo) but they did not do marble cake which we knew we wanted in order to match their original wedding cake. Tony's had marble cake as an option and good Yelp reviews so I thought I had found the perfect match! We did the online order form as requested, and my boyfriend confirmed with a woman on the phone TWICE( once the wk our cake was due) that our order was correct and we were on the same page. We even paid in full before we ever got our cake. When we arrived to pick uour cake up yesterday it was beautiful but it was WRONG!! We asked for a marble cake with chocolate buttercream frosting. No other flavors, fillings, or stuffings just marble cake with chocolate frosting. We got a cake covered in white frosting!!! We told the lady we asked for chocolate frosting and she checked her order form to prove us wrong but quickly realized she was wrong and then went to work making chocolate frosting right there in front of us. We were there to pick up our cake for a agreed upon time of 10:30 and we had to wait an additional 30 minutes for her to scrape the white frosting off, make chocolate frosting, and then redecorate our cake with the fresh flowers we ordered. " Tony" could be seen in the back decorating right in front of the girl who was doing our cake and he never addressed us or her about the lack of professionalism. He was probably rightfully embarrassed but it was sad to not see a business owner own up to their mistakes and make things right. No one should show up to cake pick up with the complete wrong cake. To make matters worse... yes it get worse than watching your cake scraped and remade in front of you. When we actually cut the cake at our party...it was wrong too!!! We got the marble cake but with a layer of white frosting in the middle and STRAWBERRIES?!!!! The chocolate frosting we asked for was completely disregarded!!!l They effed this cake up. It was nasty. No one asked where it was from. No one took home the leftovers. This place I feel is in over their heads. I do NOT recommend.

Absolutely Delicious!…read more We recently ordered cupcakes from Carl's Cakes for a graduation celebration, and they were a massive hit! Not only did they look beautiful, but they were also incredibly delicious, moist, and flavorful.

We ordered a red velvet cake from here. It was a bit of a distance but my husband loved it…read more True butter butter cream on the outside and yummy creamcheese on the inside.

Ready when scheduled .Everyone at event loved cake. Will definitely…read more use co again. Thanks !!

What a place! Delicious cakes at a reasonable price. They'll even roll with my silly ideas and…read moreprint images on the cakes. Tres leches is my go to. Cakes are nice and most, tasty, and don't fall apart. Thanks Javie!

Amazing cookies! They actually told me they would hold my purchase for me when I returned!…read more And they kept their promise! Have you ever tried cloud floating, velvety smooth Cinnamon Sugar Snickerdoodle cookies? I have had these delightfully described treats only twice! There is a certain taste I'm talking about, not grainy, like 99.9% of cookies. Dreamy and delectable, like these little nuggets of desire. Chocolate cookies were also damn good! Recommended! 10/10

Fox and Fawn has delicious baked goods and coffee! It's a little shop with a lot of character and…read morefocus on quality and taste. I had the goat cheese scone and chocolate chip cookie with a latte and honestly, it was incredible! I recommend to anyone in Benicia. It's worth checking out!

For my son's first birthday I requested a cookie monster themed cake and I was a little unsure of…read morethe flavor since I was planning on having adults and children (kinda hard to please both) luckily she suggested the chocolate chip cookie cake which went amazingly with the theme.. I had to call and up my cake size but it was easily adjusted and I received a 3 tier cake on time and beautifully decorated.. the cake was moist and a hit with everyone !! Thank you :0)

I have purchased several cakes from Bay City Bakers. All have been over the top in the taste…read moredepartment. Decorations have always been exactly what I asked for and better. Can get pricey but you will get an amazing cake.

Friendly service and pies are on point! Banana pudding is one of the bEst we have had! Will be back…read moreany chance I get!

The pies were all so good! My favorite was the minced beef…read moreand cheese. The crust was so buttery and flaky. We also had the butter chicken which was also so good. The lady helping us was so sweet. Cute little spot in Vallejo serving great food!

Service was fantastic! The bakeshop was nice, clean & welcoming. The young lady who helped me…read morementioned she had more cookies baking if I'd like to wait. All of the cookies I bought were fresh & delicious!! My favorite is the banana pudding cookie. I highly recommend the Butter Pecan Bakeshop & I can't wait to take these cookies to my next function!

Got a 12-pack of cookies, in separate boxes to gift half of them to someone else. The display case…read morewas well stocked with lots of unique and tantalizing flavors on a Saturday afternoon, nut free options on the left, others to the right. We appreciated receiving immediate service, as we were the only customers there. With so many flavors to choose from, our cookie selections included the brown butter pecan (most popular according to the worker), oatmeal raisin pecan, walnut brownie, chocolate butter pecan, rocky road, mint cookies & cream, birthday cake, and my fave, the dark chocolate walnut. They also offered other unique flavors like banana toffee, carrot cake, and strawberry lemonade pound cake. Unfortunately, no peanut butter flavor available. The cookies were inconsistent in size and a little pricey, but the taste was pretty good, with a soft and chewy texture I really enjoyed. Staff was friendly and helpful as well, which made for a positive experience overall.