I can't say enough good things about this deli! From the moment you walk in, you're greeted with the warm, savory aroma of fresh ingredients and a welcoming atmosphere. The staff is incredibly friendly and knowledgeable, always ready to offer recommendations or customize your order to perfection. I had the pastrami on rye with a side of homemade potato salad, and it was hands-down the best sandwich I've had in ages--perfectly seasoned, stacked high, and served on fresh, crusty bread. You can really taste the care that goes into every item here. Whether you're stopping in for a quick lunch or picking up dinner to go, this deli delivers on all fronts: flavor, quality, service, and value. It's the kind of place that turns first-time visitors into regulars. Highly recommended! read more

Hadn't been here in twenty years! Just took my son there for his first time. He said the sub was the best he's ever had! Quality and portions are exactly the same from twenty years ago!! God Bless Sam as he looks like his health is deteriorating but, he's still there working with a smile on his face. read more

Great service and awesome Italian subs. I was told that they own a 100+ acre farm where some of their food items are farm raised. Breakfast sausage links are a must and I will try the wings next time. read more

This is the best deli around! Anything on the menu is the best. Quality food where the people who prepare it are the owners and care.

Unfortunately my last visit here was disappointing. I got the ham joe it had slimmed down quite a bit. Less ham and less cheese. But same dressing! 4oz. of ham to be exact for a 10.00 sandwich. I believe 2 slices of swiss. But it tasted ok. The atmosphere there was pretty sad no smiles or happy greetings seemed a little tense. Service was very slow. I was kinda shocked maybe someone had recently passed but feel sad for this deli that was once great! read more

Excellent bread, premium meats. Great sub shop, worth a drive. Italian subs are great. Super roast beef. They are happy to customize! read more

Colonial Pantry - Menu. Note price added on left - Delis Near Me - Mendham, New Jersey

Been here few times, their cold subs are always delicious, especially the turkey and beef

this old-fashioned deli is run by 2 fine gentlman. Their food is whole, homemade nothing artificial. The meats are farm fresh. do you know they have been there 50 years that speak about how great the business is and how good the food is read more

I've been in 3-4 times since we moved to Mendham a little while ago and have enjoyed it each and every time. It's run by a great, friendly father and son team. Everything is fresh, with some items from a nearby farm and even some butchering on site. If you want a great, humongous sandwich, this is the place, especially their Italian sandwiches. They're made with awesome bread and piled high with meat and cheese. A whole one is easily enough for two. They are also famous for their chili, which is also excellent. Overall, if you are hungry for a great sandwich, definitely stop here! read more

Love this place. I've been getting sandwiches from here for over a decade. Small family business. The thing that sets their sandwiches apart is the bread from Hoboken. Great Italian bread. Not soft and fluffy. I'm read more

Great sandwich shop that also has items from their local farm; great steaks and honey. Rick & Sam take the time to make each meal a reflection of them- quality and care. Enjoy. read more

Super friendly owners and delicious food!!! We love this deli and their sandwiches. Their other products are also wonderful--we bought the strawberry wine and it is the best wine I have ever had. Ever. read more

I don't review much I'm not the type But hands down great deli .. Been going here for 5 years everything is fresh I've ordered one of everything on the menu it's all excellent! Sam and Rick are great ! read more

we've lived about a 15 minute walk away for over 27 years. this place has never gone down in quality. my son grew up loving the Reuben's and now lives in CA and still heads there for a Reuben whenever he comes home. It's his first food stop on his eating tour of NJ every trip. Honestly, every sandwich we've had is fantastic and good value in a small, overpriced town. Impressed with the consistency. It isn't fancy but the quality is there. read more

Great sandwiches, great salads, great prepared foods. Sausages, steaks, chickens are delicious, fresh, and healthy. A great place to go.

I moved to Mendham about 2 years ago and have made many visits to this deli! I love that it's almost exactly the same as when my parents and grandparents lived in the area in the 80's and 90's, and is still run by the same people! My go-to is the Italian sub with hot peppers but everything I've tried has been fantastic. They make so many different homemade products and the people who run the shop are so nice. Once, I showed up as they were locking up and had already cleaned everything. Instead of turning me away, they took the time to make me the sandwiches my boyfriend and I were craving. Whenever friends are visiting this is where I bring them. I hope they are around for many years to come! read more

I live in California and we make Colonial Pantry's Sloppy Joes one of the "must haves" everytime we visit. They just have the right ratio of turkey,French dressing, and Cole slaw on every sandwich. We've had other Slopy Joe's from other delis and this is the best we have found. read more

It's a small shop with big flavors. I just ate the Lobster Salad Sandwich and my mouth wants me to order another one even though my stomach is full. The man who runs it is wonderfully nice and even the patrons that I talked to are fantastic. I may need to eat there at least once a week. read more

Best sloppy Joe I have ever had! This place is fantastic. I loved the stories and the history behind this hidden gem. ;) read more

Colonial Pantry - a person holding a hot dog - Delis Near Me - Mendham, New Jersey

Stopped in for a sandwich and they delivered. Ultra friendly family run establishment. The house made roast beef and potato salad were both delicious and seasoned appropriately. I will definitely be back. read more

Just moved to the area and discovered this place. Classic old school Italian deli with owners that care about the product. Amazing Italian sub. Everything here is cooked from scratch and they use great crispy sub bread (for me bread is make or break!). As I was waiting for my sub guy next to me told me they had the best Taylor Ham Egg and Cheese sandwiches so that's for my next trip! Give this place a shot for sure. read more

Woow!! Delicious! First time there and had a great overall experience! From the moment I walked in (I was greeted and helped) to the great after taste I have in my mouth right now. Literally jumped on yelp to show some love to the folks at Colonial Pantry. I got the famous sloppy joe(combo) after reading great things from other customers- amazing. I also got the hot pastrami with Swiss and homemade slaw and mustard- amazing. Also got the homemade chili- amazing. Their pickles are great too. Thank you guys for a great meal! I definitely recommend this spot if you're in Mendham. I haven't had good food here since Colonial. So happy I came here! read more

I love this tiny little place. It's takeout only, but the atmosphere is great. Take a gander at the oak meat locker and sundries on the shelves, and you feel like you stepped back in time. They make the best Italian sub around. The owner feels strongly about the quality of the food he sells and always has a small selection of homemade salads, fresh vegetables, and prime cuts of meat. My only complaint is that it seems a little pricey for a deli. read more

Nice, homey, friendly unpretentious place for breakfast or lunch. Has the feel of a fifties coffee shop.

Most delicious ham and Swiss on rye sloppy Joe anywhere! PLUS, they have their own farm and grow from which comes fresh eggs, their own pasta sauces, and they have a very nice assortment of meats and poultry available as well. Call ahead to see what they have or can get for you, depending on when they are doing the butchering. Best find in town by far! read more

Love at first bite - this place looks like a hole in the wall but has the best coslaw I've ever had! I ordered a simple turkey sandwich and it was the best I've ever had and I'm very picky! However, it is a little pricey. read more

Incredible sandwiches. Lovely owner, chatted with him for over 30 minutes. Huge selection of organic meat and poultry. Best bacon hands down. read more

Delicious fresh food :) Always a treat. I love their chili dogs, sausage and pepper sandwiches, and (of course) the sloppy joes!

Went here for the first time this past weekend, and I am definitely coming back! The place smelled amazing when I walked in. It is a small deli, but everything is visible, and there was a wide variety of choices. My sandwich was delicious. It was fresh, tasted amazing, and handmade right in front of me. I am very picky about sandwiches, and this place is definitely a gem. The service was fast, and everyone was super nice. They also had fresh peaches for sale, which is something I have not seen before at a deli. I highly recommend anyone go here if they are looking for high-quality, fresh ingredients. The only negative is that the storefront is not very visible from the road. I didn't even know this place existed until a friend mentioned we should get lunch here. Had I known, I would've tried it out much sooner! read more

My workmates and I visited the Deli during our storm restoration efforts after "Hurricane Sandy". We were so impressed with the quality of the food that we returned and brought more fellow workers with us. The food was excellent, the service superb and friendlier folks could not be found. They even offered to open up on Sunday and feed us if we needed them. I will drive out of my way for another visit with my wife the next time I'm in the area. I just wish they were closer to Indiana!!! read more

Very good quality and nice owners. Great Hot Dogs!!! Old Fashion deli with tradional values. Quality, service, value.