I got a roast beef and extra American sandwich from this place for lunch and an ice tea. Total came out to $17 and change. The sandwich would have been tasty if there was about double the meat. Only seems like they put a few slices on the whole sandwich. If I didn't know better I would have thought I ordered a cheese sandwich. In the words of the old lady "where's the beef!?" read more

I used to love the sandwiches here . Had a roast beef sloppy Joe last week. There were very few pieces of meat in the sandwich .... What happened here ? read more

Ordered some sloppy joe platters from here for the holidays and they were great. The food was fresh and yummy. The staff was a pleasure to deal with and the price was great - good value. Highly recommend! read more

Hands down, best Sloppy Joe Sandwiches anywhere! On a recent trip back to NJ where I grew up, Hickory Tree was my number one choice for lunch. You see, outside of NJ, Sloppy Joe's (meat+Swiss+coleslaw+Russian Dressing) do not exist! It's sadly true. When you mention a Sloppy Joe, they think ground beef cooked in tomato sauce on a hamburger bun. You can't even buy Russian Dressing in the supermarket. So when I come "home" for a visit, I have to have a Sloppy Joe from Hickory Tree, a busy, bustling NY type of deli with lots of Italian offerings as well as these iconic sandwiches. So many memories this sandwich conjures up. Whenever my parents, and then me and my friends, hosted a party, we would order a platter of Turkey and a platter of Roast Beef Joe's. For any occasion, a platter of Sloppy Joe's was on the buffet. Each triple decker sandwich was cut into 6 pieces with a toothpick holding the goodness together. Never were there leftovers! If you order a sandwich, it's triple bread and cut in thirds. Definitely enough to share or save a third for the next day. My preference is the Turkey Joe and I like to get one from the case, where dozens of sandwiches are made every morning, stored, then sold completely during the lunch hour madness. Hickory Tree uses top quality meat and cheese and you can taste the difference. Since the sandwiches have been sitting, the flavors meld together and from the first bite, it's pure deliciousness! Russian dressing spilling out of the sandwich onto the wax paper, waiting to be sopped up with the bread. Have tried making them in Portland, OR, where I now live and my friends love my version, but they have never had the real deal. When I host parties, I ask one of our two Jewish Deli's to make a platter. They have never heard of them, but follow my direction and they are good. But no where near as good as those from Hickory Tree. On the last visit, my friend and I enjoyed our sandwiches with Joe's half and half iced tea and lemonade, zero calories. Killer! We sat outside enjoying the sunshine, catching up for five hours! I even told the owner how much these sandwiches mean to me, the memories they evoke. If you live in NJ or you are visiting, I highly recommend getting a Sloppy Joe from Hickory Tree. You will thank me! read more

Hickory Tree Delicatessen - Turkey Sloppy Joe!! The best. - Delis Near Me - Chatham, New Jersey

See all

Solid deli. Hate you can't give 3.5. Solid sloppy Joe. Service is nice. Prices are what you expect in the area. We've been here a few times. All the food is always dependable and solid. read more

Sold Taylor Ham Egg & Cheese Sandwich! Please rave about their Fried Eggplant, can't wait to try it! Conveniently located, friendly service and great sandwich menu with lots of prepared items to carry-out for dinner options. read more

Mediocre. Ordered a pastrami sandwich with mustard, got overcooked mediocre pastrami without mustard. Other sandwiches just as average. They charge a packing fee; what, are we fools? Just up the prices; don't play games. Nothing worthwhile; won't go back. read more

Bangin sloppy joe sammys!! Pastrami Joe we got was amazing. Perfect amount of dressing to meat to bread ratio. If it wasn't so far from us we would eat there once a week. Great nearby park to have your lunch at too. Our pro tip is grab a side of fries from the pizzeria next door. They don't sell any here. read more

Hickory Tree Delicatessen - Pastrami Joe - Delis Near Me - Chatham, New Jersey

Sad to say that our favorite go to deli has disappointed once again. Scanty meat, orders on line incorrect, this is just not the same quality we have come to know and love. The owner says that quality control has not changed and they weigh the meat on sandwiches but I think the scale is off. Seeking new lunch spot. Update: the owner refunded our last order. I appreciate that attention to customer service. The cubano panini is the only thing that seems to remain the same. I appreciate that he says nothing has changed in regards to amount of meat on sandwiches but we have seen a difference. C'est la vie but sadly we are done. read more

Thanks to Yelp I found this welcoming Deli in Chatham. They are in a the light tan strip mall on the northern most side of Shunpike Road. (GPS was confused). The pace inside is sort of what you find in a NYC deli, busy and several people behind the counter all looking to see who they may greet and help next. The front of the deli has drinks, snacks, pasta, cookies, small but unique. I found some honey filled candies imported from Italy there. The menu on the wall may be hard to read, but they have paper take out menus and its the same. I really wanted to try everything, but over three visits I ordered the same sandwich: Turkey Off The Bone, Bacon, Tomato, Avocado, Red Onion, Gruyere Cheese, Horseradish Sauce on a Ciabatta Roll ..Panini style. It tastes fresh, nothing was salty or weird. Each time I ordered the sandwich, I had some variations each time. I had a different type roll the first time. A softer/fluffier roll the second. A thinner crispier roll the third. First time was good, all ingredients plentiful. Second time very plentiful ingredients. Third time had slivers of avocado, not as much bacon, but still carried the same taste of the first two times. Loved this sandwich and I will now miss this spot, as my recent job project is now ending. I love supporting businesses such as this instead of chain places which I will always avoid whenever possible. My panini was also wrapped in a foil type wrapper which kept it warm even after 45 minutes until I was able to eat it (third visit). read more

Hickory Tree Delicatessen - Turkey off the bone, Bacon, Tomato, Avocado, Red Onion, Gruyere, Horseradish sauce on Ciabatta Roll (Panini) - Delis Near Me - Chatham, New Jersey

We used Hickory Tree for a business event today. John delivered bagels, muffins and a fruit bowl to the venue for breakfast and for lunch, we picked up. They would have delivered but it worked best for us logistically to pick up. We had a tray of assorted sloppy joe's and a tray of assorted wraps and sandwiches as well as orzo and spinach salad and a mixed salad. Everyone loved the lunch. The sloppy joes are so delicious and we were really impressed that they included chicken breast sandwiches as well as vegetarian options...not just standard lunchmeat sandwiches. John and Stephanie are super sweet and really helpful. Will definitely use again for future events. read more

Terrific sandwiches and amazing take out entrees for busy nights. The owners have been so accommodating when we order for large school events. I appreciate the order online option because teachers don't get a lot of time for lunch! read more

What happened here? Plenty of meat behind the counter. Very little on your sandwich. Try again, boys and girls. I've been coming here since the 80s. Used to love it. read more

Hickory Tree Delicatessen - Pandemic Roast Beef Joe. Does anyone see cheese on this? - Delis Near Me - Chatham, New Jersey

Local deli in Chatham in strip mall. No seating, only takeout. Expensive for sandwiches that are just ok. Roast beef was well done but not that tasty. read more

See all

Decent deli but expensive as others have mentioned. A normal sized vegetarian sub will run you around $9. The bread was fine and fillings ok, unfortunately everything mushed together quickly. I liked my sub at Chatham Sandwich Shop better. read more

Hickory Tree Delicatessen - Delis Near Me - Chatham, New Jersey

See all

Well if you read my reviews then you know I'm a sucker for a sandwich. When people ask me my last meal, I say it's a tie between a fat ass burrito smothered in Hatch's green chile and a fat ass sandwich smothered in cheese and anything else that a sandwich can have on it. Enter in Hickory Tree. My man's hometown deli. His mom used to buys us these all the time, till we had to have a little sit down and I explained that sloppy joes don't do wonders for my waist line. Sometimes you have to splurge. Enter in this Italianesque pantry convenience store. With pastas, dinners, and some dry/canned/packaged goods that you can pick up while you are at the deli. Enter this fantastic deli filled with meats, cheeses, homemade salads, slaws and gdknowswhatelse. I order the Hickory burrito with turkey bacon (twas bfast time). Whole wheat wrap, egg whites, smothered in the melty cheddar cheese that was just everywhere with of course the added turkey bacon. Amazing. The boys I were with thoroughly enjoyed their t-ham and egg sandwiches. Well now, let us talk about lunch that day. We took home a Joe with us. Ham, swiss, russian dressing and slaw on rye. It was huge, cut into three (thank you for that) and was amazing. It was dressed perfectly for our lunch date. Fully clothed with the mayoey dressing with extra left on the parchment paper to scrap up with the sandwich but, not so much where it was all dressing. You can tell this is a family joint too which is always nice. I like it when my man says he knows the dude makin' my sammy and that we are supportin' him. So, Steph, why not the five star review? Well, I'm no sloppy Joe connoisseur. I need to sample what else they got before I potentially up this rating. read more

I've lived just down the road from this place for almost 20 years, and have had sandwiches from here at least 20 - 30 times a year. Unfortunately, things have slid downhill since the pandemic. Ordered a chicken steak sandwich, which has always in the past come loaded with chicken, pepper, onion, and fresh moz. What I got instead was something akin to a "Steak-em" that you would buy from the grocery store frozen food section - i.e., not chicken (some sort of steak product), not a lot else (minimal pepper and onion), and most definitely not fresh moz (some sort of liquid cheese product). I don't know what's going on here, but I hope they can turn things around. read more

One of my favorite sandwiches in the entire world!!!! I always get a turkey Joe but everything is good. I live in Colorado but make sure to visit whenever I am near. read more

Let's just say if you are looking for the North New Jersey quintessential sloppy joe, this is not your place. The bread tasted old and flavorless, the turkey a bit drab and dry, and not nearly enough Russian dressing. It's called a "sloppy" joe, not a, let's look like we're attending a wedding joe. Get sloppier my guys. - Food Yeatington read more

I went here for the first time today because I heard it was a good deli. Sadly, I was totally disappointed. I ordered the grilled chicken panini with broccoli rabe and fresh mozzarella. It was served on a sopping wet soggy roll. The chicken was inedible. It tasted like flavorless rubber, and the mozzarella & broccoli rabe also had no taste. It was as if someone threw the sandwich into a bowl of water before wrapping it up. I had to throw it out. My husbands fish sandwich was also soggy and the fish was really fishy tasting & served cold. My daughters plain Turkey and cheese on a roll was the only edible sandwich. I also got milk and a small ice cream pint. The bill was nearly $50. I called and asked if I could please be refunded and the owner said he can't refund my card, but will reimburse me for the bad sandwich if I come back in. I'm 8 months pregnant and in graduate school with a toddler - I have no time to come in this week or next. They should've easily been able to refund me. I am really upset about this experience. Please save yourself a trip and avoid this establishment at all costs. read more

I am going to temporarily give this place five stars, becauswe I think I will like it. I had the good fortune to receive a $10 gift certificate as a new resident of Madison, and went there this morning. I had the "Hickory Burrito" for $7 which was a burrito with eggs, onions, cheese , and chili. The chile overwhelmed the wrap. I was not able to taste anything else. There was nothing about this that would bring me back. BUT....the rest of the restaurant seems great...from homemade roast beef to homemade salads, I will try again. I am hoping that my next experience here meets my expectations. read more

Great variety in sandwich options, they have all of the classic combos you could possibly want with more unique options as well. Friendly workers and the food tastes great! A little pricey for what you get. read more

Hickory Tree Delicatessen - Smoked turkey and Brie on a whole wheat wrap - Delis Near Me - Chatham, New Jersey

Perfect egg sandwich on rye and to go deli turkey, plus drinks. They have other groceries if you need em. Great place to order, and they'll bring it out to your car! Even in the rain! Let's keep this great deli in business!! read more

My to go place for sloppy joe sandwiches. also excellent and staff is very accommodating I would recommend this place

If you're reading this, and you think a Sloppy Joe is some Manwich concoction with ground beef and generic red sauce on a hamburger bun, get yourself to Jersey, NOW. A real Sloppy Joe is none of these things. A Jersey Sloppy Joe is a triple decker sandwich with deli meat, swiss, coleslaw and Russian dressing on rye. It is awesome, and the best around this part of the state is at Hickory Tree. I've been coming here for a very long time. Back in my caddying days during the summer in high school and college we would often stop here for breakfast. Not only are they home to the best sloppy joes anywhere, but this is also where I was introduced to the wonder that is the bacon, egg and cheese sandwich. Now I usually only make it over here for lunch every now and then. But when I do, there is only one option, the Turkey Joe. They pre-make the sandwiches in the morning because so many people order them and they take some additional time to make. If you haven't been here before, do not worry about this. I can't explain it but I think the sandwich is even better when it sits in the fridge for a while. Also, side note, this is the best cole slaw I have ever had. If nothing else, come to this deli for the cole slaw. If for some strange reason you mouth is not already drooling over the sloppy joe, show up anyway. Their deli is great and they have a large selection of pre-made Italian dinners as well. After writing all this, I need a turkey joe. Maybe for lunch tomorrow. read more

Hands down best sloppy joe in the state of NJ. Also unrivaled Taylor ham, egg and cheese. One of the friendliest staffs you'll ever come across. The big guy John is the best! read more

This place is solid but nothing special. I have been here now three times and I have tried a different sandwich each time. Bacon egg and cheese on a everything bagel - the bacon was just average and he sandwich overall was okay Turkey cranberry panini - this was really good and I would recommend. The other time I got a breakfast sandwich with ham that was good. The service here is pretty slow for what the place is. Also there is nowhere to eat so you have to get the food to go and the sandwiches can get a little soggy. read more

Sloppy Joes and Pints o' marinara sauce to go! Awesome sandwiches and soups. This local Italian deli has been around for a while now, and it's a mainstay for the neighborhood. The frozen section is great too, with different meals in different sizes all ready to go. Definitely try the Sloppy Joes if you haven't before...you won't regret it! read more

Hickory Tree Delicatessen - Porchetta Sandwich w/Pork Gravy - Delis Near Me - Chatham, New Jersey

Best Deli in NJ! The amazing food is only trumped by the incredible staff. Sloppy joes! Salads! Prepared food!

This is definitely one of the better delis in Chatham, if not in the surrounding area. It can be a bit pricey at times but as they say "you get what you pay for". All the food is great with a nice variety of soups each day. The breakfast sandwiches are very good on the large rolls and I recommend including the thick slices of taylor ham to your egg and cheese. But I think their best sandwiches are the pre-made turkey joe's which are served on three pieces of rye bread and packed with turkey, russian, dressing, and cole slaw. In addition to the quality of food, the quality of service is very high as well. They always have the right number of people working based on the time of day, even during the lunch time rush you can be in and out of there in about 5 minutes. Due to the great food and friendly service I highly recommend this deli as one of the best in the area. read more

Solid deli. Wide variety of high quality offerings. Quick service, personable staff, tons of parking. Not the cheapest place, but hey, it's in tony Chatham. The only stumble (and it's a common one in the area) is that they don't slice the rye for their sloppy joes on a meat slicer, so it's about 1/3 too thick-making the sandwich too much of a mouthful. Using the presliced rye takes away from a great sloppy joe. I usually try to pair a stop here with a visit to the nearby Green Village Packing abbatoir (check their retail hours though). All in all, this place delivers a nice sandwich. read more

I wish there was a 3 1/3 stars... Sandwiches are good, food tastes fresh. Long lines aren't a bad thing; it just means a lot of people like it there so I take that to be a good thing. Workers are friendly but not overly so. They have chips and plenty of drinks, fresh pickles and deli salads. Also a small grocery-like section with some specialties. Extensive menu of basic and special sandwiches. 3 stars for two reasons. There is only one option for sandwich sizes. Younger kids don't eat a large sandwich (actually neither do I for lunch) but I am forced to buy a large $7.00+ sandwich for them which isn't cost-effective for families. Also a star taken off for their gluten free options. They are trying which is great to see and I thought it might be a good alternative to the other gluten free deli in town, but it's not. They only have gluten free bagels (which did not look good) and white bread; so my sandwich was tiny and basically fell apart with one bite and I had to use a fork to eat it. Gluten free white bread can't support a deli sandwich, so I'm back to the other deli. So to sum it up, decent fresh sandwiches that are large but expensive,with poorly executed gluten free options. Long lines. With many different delis in town you'd have to try it to see if this is the best option for you. read more

Disappointted, I have been going here for a number of years and the meat on the sandwiches is basically disappearing, I was there today May 8, 2020 and ordered a Roast Beef / Turkey sub, there were 2 very thin slices of Roast Beef and 1 slice of Turkey between the sub roll, for $10.25 read more

Love the sandwiches here. Got the Italian Sandwich and chicken Caesar salad wrap. Both were good. Good friendly staff there as well.

Really like their sloppy Joe's. Not very happy with a recent experience, however. I have been a long-time customer of this deli. I called ahead to order a sandwich. When I arrived at the deli, I stood near the register to pick up my order when I was reprimanded by a young man who told me there's one line for everybody. Seems to me it would make more sense to have a separate line for phone orders instead of one line with other people waiting to have sandwiches made. I was embarrassed because he scolded me in front of other patrons. It may be a while before I go back. BTW - this place could use a facelift. read more

Love, LOVE this place. Awesome sandwiches. The NJ style sloppy joe is always a winner as are their club sandwiches. They also have amazing homemade ravioli and pasta. The crab and lobster ravioli are my favorites. Tons of bottled and canned drinks and a load of Italian staples. I just wished they delivered! read more

I've had sandwiches from here before, albeit years ago. I got the Turkey Sloppy Joe and a side of slaw. The sandwich had plenty of meat, but was lackluster, far from what I remembered. The bread didn't cut it. The dressing and slaw below par. The side of slaw didn't taste fresh, and had a bitter aftertaste. I've heard other sandwiches in here are really good, I'll give it another try, but I'll stay away from the sloppy Joe. read more

Good food but a bit on the pricey side. I would give them 3.5 stars but had to go down based on the $7 egg sandwiches. REALLY? It was just ok at that. read more

AMAZING selection of meats cheeses homemade condiments and toppings. If you can imagine it they can deliver it

More than just a great spot for sandwiches. They have home cooked dinners either in the fridge or frozen for you. Simply throw them in the oven and you are eating a home cooked meal for two in an hour for about 10 bucks each. If you want something a little different than what the supermarket offers, these guys have the speciality items that add a little "wow" to your dinner. read more