Colonial Pizza is a solid place to stop for dinner of lunch. They have recently expanded and haver a lot more seating. The food is pretty good, but not exceptional. The also have a pretty big menu, so you should be able to find something for everyone. The only real knock is that service can be a little slow, so call ahead. The service is usually pretty friendly, though I went once when they seemed annoyed that I asked for a box for the leftovers. They deliver(even to the dorms), which is a huge bonus if you don't have a car or you live on campus. The prices are middle of the road, not a great deal, not a rip off. Good for large groups to dine. read more

We moved to this little village in December and I was so thankful that there is a pizza place that serves a gluten free pizza. The gluten free pizza crust if great. It is small and on the pricey side ($9.25 for a small 10" just cheese with toppings at $1) but I'm thankful they offer it and it is good. We also really enjoy their wings. They are flavorful and juicy even without sauce. Their antipasto salad with Sandy's homemade Italian dressing is also good. This dressing is the best. I always take my extra home for my own salads. I have brought family here that have ordered the regular pizza crust and they enjoyed it. They have a rewards program using your phone number and I feel it is pretty generous as I get $5 off my orders pretty often. It's also very cute and cozy inside and there is a nice outdoor area that overlooks the creek. Service is always friendly and timely. I appreciate that they are open late, even on weekdays. Only drawbacks are the other salad dressings (packets, nothing special) and like I mentioned the price is a bit high. I wish they wouldn't charge $1 per topping even on the small 10 inch gluten free pizza. A sprinkling of toppings on an already small pizza should certainly not cost $1 each. read more

This place was FANTASTIC. Pizza was great their Sunday night special is the best, cheesy bread was fantastic, service was great, it's nice to get a great pizza at a reasonable price where you don't have to pay for the chain store prices is handmade. We will be back again. read more

Loved this place. I had driven by last weekend, but not at meal times. This weekend my mom and I are exploring this part of the state and we happened to be by around dinner time. We got a small pizza (they have several sizes to choose from and thin or thick crust), which was the perfect size since we are traveling about and can't take any leftovers with us. The pizza was hot and very tasty. We also got some breadsticks that were really good. The place is cute inside and the prices are fantastic. Our whole meal for two with drinks was under $15. I would definitely come back to the Colonial. read more

Great crust! Loved the buffalo chicken pizza. Service is a little slow, but the pie is worth the wait.

I realize that this is a hometown review, but Colonial Pizza has an earned reputation for great pizza, enzonis (a calzone at some other places), and sub sandwiches. A personal favorite is a mushroom and green olive pizza for my veggie option, and adding bacon to many of their pizzas is a great option. People who used to live here long for a pizza from Colonial, and when they visit they always want to go there! read more

Really good Enzoni, cheesy bread and subs! Haven't tried the pizza yet, but I've heard it's good too. Cozy atmosphere, reminds me of an old cottage. Staff were all nice and helpful. Went there for a birthday party. We will be back for sure! read more

My hometown pizza the best we ride 16miles just for best ever plus there subs great service the best love my hometown cedarville pizza. L. Nelson aka Willis read more

My family of nine at here last night. It was my first visit and I was so pleased. The pizza and breadsticks were amazing, and with the Friday family meal, it was an outstanding value. However, the bat part was the service. Our waiter was named Joe and he was great. I had my two grandsons with me and Joe was so friendly with them. They loved him. He also gave us advice about other attractions in Cedarville since we are not from there. I will go back again, and I encourage others to check this place out. You won't be disappointed. read more

We've been coming here a couple times a year and enjoy their pizza each time. Service was always great, just as the pizza. If we lived in the area would eat here more often read more

Love the pizza, especially the ham and pineapple. Pizza is only as greasy as the meat you put on it. Nice dining area with recent renovations to the resturant. read more

Nice looking place. However the person who took my order had no understanding of the menu. The dough was soggy and probably needed par baked. They get points for making their own dough and having a creative menu; but I wouldn't eat it again read more

Their pizza is pretty good. Their cheesy bread is really good. Their cheesecake is overpriced. We have ordered pizzas there for a long time. Sometimes it's a hit and miss on how good it is. Most of the time it is pretty good. One evening we decided to go in and eat. It has great atmosphere, a little loud, but that could be because a group came in. That was no biggie. I was really disappointed when the food came. We ordered lasagna and someone got spaghetti and meatsauce. The food came in containers that looked like frozen dinners, okay... couldn't you have taken a minute to put the food on a plate? I mean its one thing to serve frozen dinners, but to let you customers know they are frozen dinners and overpriced for what it is. I gave it 3 stars for their pizza. It's good most of the time. Just don't order the frozen dinners. read more

Best Pizza in Ohio! People drive from all around for this small town treasure.

Although the food is decent, the service is awful. Waited on a pizza that was made wrong, asked for mayo on sandwich when ordered. Came without and then two asks before she brought. Very unhappy server. This is in a college town and should be better prepared. A good pizza shop could do well in this town. read more

Family Loved it!!! Great stix and pizza. Too bad we are from out of state. Would love to visit more often. read more

Very good pizza. If you're a freshman college student you know about this place before you've gotten your fall syllabus.

We stumbled into this place, having seen it on the main road in town on the way to the Grafton mill Christmas lights. Being in the middle of nowhere, we checked out the reviews and decided to pop in. The lobby was big and the decor was inviting. There was a delicious looking case of cheesecakes, carrot cake and pies which all looked amazing too. We were seated in a booth where my husband could see the football game, while the girls (aged 6 and 9) ordered the salad, mozzarella sticks, and pizza. Eric opted for the todd's big meat pizza, based on other reviews and the server suggestion. The salads came out quick and the girls gobbled the up! Quick after we're the pizzas and they did not disappoint! Handmade Crust, not too thick and not too thin. The todds meat was good too, I think it had 5 meats and was loaded! We boxed up enough to leave room for a slice of cheesecake, which was devoured. We were out the door for under $50 And have a new tradition to stop after we see the lights each Christmas!! Highly recommend stopping if you're anywhere close!! read more

Decent food, meh service (usually the staff doesn't seem to be happy to do their jobs). Generally, this would be excusable and I'd rate 3-4 stars. However, they changed my order after placing it online to make it more expensive. I ordered a cheese pizza, added chicken and hot sauce and asked for ranch on the side, Total: $6.58. They changed it to a buffalo chicken pizza, Total: $8.99. I used to be a repeat customer, but not anymore! Shady business practices (something I've seen too often at restaurants in Cedarville) will make me stay away. read more

Pizzas and subs are always really great. Chicken nuggets are good, but serving sizes leave much to be desired.

The lobby of this restaurant was hotter than outside and it was a very hot and humid day when I visited. I nearly left without ordering. This appears to be the most popular restaurant in town, and for good reason. The pizza and salad that I had were both excellent and the dining area was cooler than the lobby. read more

Very good pizza. We got the thick crust which wasn't super thick on the bottom but the sides were high with super soft fluffy crust. Our boys loved it. We also got some salads and they were very fresh and tasty. Overall a very nice place for pizza with a pleasant atmosphere! read more

The Deluxe pizza (I prefer regular vs deep dish crust) and Colonial sub (multi-grain bun, please) are fantastic. I'm working about 5 miles away (60 miles from home) and stop by at least once a week. read more

I look forward to this pizza every year when we are in Cedarville with family! The BLT is my favorite but it is all good!

They have great pizza! The alfredo pizza is the best! Definitely one of the best pizza places in the area!