Connie definitely knows what she's doing when it comes to her delicious creations. Her cakes are very impressive looking, but most importantly are always impressive tasting. The biggest positive for Connie's is that everything is consistent. I've ordered numerous cakes from her and it's been good every time. Also the taste is far better than the swill that you would get for a cake at Giant, Redners, or Weis. The only downside to the store is that there is no parking at all. There are only a couple of metered street spaces and once those are gone you are either parking a block or two away or need to go into a parking deck. Connie's is the perfect mix of taste and value. read more

I ordered a small Birthday cake for my fiance birthday. It was outstanding moist ,not to sweet just perfect .Thank you so much Connie !

She made my son cake and it was delicious. It was ready when she said it would be. Thank you so much..

I just ordered a cake from Connie's for my mom's birthday on 1/12/2014. I uploaded the picture above. I asked them to make her cake look like a quilt, since she is a quilter, and it turned out BEAUTIFUL. I also found the price to be great, too. I would have expected to pay more for such a beautiful cake. The store is small and homey. There is only metered parking, but I only had to put a quarter in for me to run in and pick up the cake. Not only did the cake look beautiful, it tasted great! The cake was almond flavored (with small pieces of almond throughout, soooooo yummy) with a layer of chocolate mousse inside. It was to die for. My whole family raved about this cake. I definitely will be going back to Connie's in the near future! read more

Connie's Cakes and Cookies - "Quilt Cake" made by Connie's Cakes and Cookies on 1/12/2014 for my Mom's Birthday - Bakeries Near Me

My sister orders here for my events even though I live in MD. Cakes aren't too sweet, just right. Cake isn't dry and fondant is well made. I'm not a frosting person, but i can eat theirs. Designs are always very nice. I absolutely loved my baby shower cake!!! So far I've had a cake made for my wedding shower (very pretty), baby shower (absolutely love), and my baby's baptism (very nice). I've liked every cake that has been made for me and would highly recommend it. I will continue to order cakes here for my events. read more

See all

I'm a big fan of Connie's. This small, privately-owned shop is such a great addition to downtown Bethlehem. Connie definitely knows what she's doing when it comes to her delicious creations. Her cakes are very impressive looking. She made my sister's engagement cake (decorated in fondant icing and ivy vines trailing all over) and it was beautiful and elegant. Her baked goods are really special here. Try her unbelievably delicious kiffles. You and everyone you know will be raving about them. I guarantee it. Her cakes, although beautiful, tend to be on the dry side (as most designer cakes are). They're still tasty, but if you're looking for a very moist cake, you might not find it here. I always enjoy coming in and picking up some random treats. The workers (who are almost always her family members) are all very warm and friendly. You'll definitely feel welcomed here. read more

I ordered a cake from Connie's for my parents 30th wedding anniversary and it was the best cake we've ever eaten. Not only could they do what I wanted (other bakeries told me they couldnt decorate the cake how I wanted), but the cake was delicious! Our guests RAVED about it and asked where we got it. Wonderful! Would definitely recommend and will use Connie's in the future! read more

Connie's Cakes and Cookies - a cake decorated with white frosting - Bakeries Near Me

Good place to get shoofly pie near Allentown. Connie works right there and is generous with her time and advice on selecting goodies. Got a nice selection of cookies and some pie to share. Tip for those unfamiliar with the area: West Broad St does a funny skip so the restaurant is off a side street (Guetter St). Edit: forgot to mention that you can buy really nice dog treats as well. My girlfriend's aunt's lovable but snobby dog, adored them! read more

Absolutely beautiful cake !! Moving from NYC a year ago I had yet to find a bakery for cakes for birthday's & events until Connie's. I will definitely be a return customer. Beautiful work, affordable, professional & most important delicious ! read more

Connie's Cakes and Cookies - Beautiful Rosette cake daughter loved it & delicious - Bakeries Near Me

See all

Fantastic !!!! We ordered a birthday cake for my party over Memorial Day weekend. We found a picture of a cake online and wanted to see if Connies could duplicate it. ( Cake shaped like a cutting board with marzipan vegatables). not only did they duplicate, we had them add on a stove top with a pot on top of it ! Chocolate cake with cherry filling. OMG was it great !! One of the best cakes I have ever had ! Thank you Connie's for helping make my birthday a memorable one !! read more

Connie's cakes is AWESOME! They decorated my son's 10th birthday cake for his party last Friday. They made it so easy! They were on time, the cake was exactly as ordered, the cake itself was perfectly designed and delicious, and the price was right. I thought it might be tricky to get a Golden Freddy from the 5 nights at Freddy's video game exactly right, but the young lady who decorated it knew what I was talking about and had access to the images I emailed to them. Connie herself is reasonable and straightforward. My son was so happy with the result, and the cake was the hit of the party! Well done, Connie's Cakes! I'll recommend your shop to anyone who is planning a party, because you got it right. read more

Yesterday, my best friend, who is a student at Lehigh, texted me to tell me that she got a summer internship at a company that she had been dying to intern at. I wanted to give her a congratulatory gift, but since my college was nowhere near hers, I thought it would be cute to send her a cake instead. I found Connie's Cakes and Cookies online, and I decided to call them up. They were extremely friendly, and even though they need advanced notice to make cakes, they had a blank cake in the shop - so I had them write a message on it. They were able to get it to my friends dorm, where her roommate received it, in less than two hours after I called, which was impressive (there was an additional delivery charge, but it was very fair - I think it was $5.00). They were extremely friendly and professional over the phone, and texted me my receipt less than a minute after our phone call ended. Although they were friendly, professional, fairly priced, and paid great attention to customer service, I had not seen the cake, and since presentation is essentially as important as taste, I was nervous. After my friend finally got back to the dorm and saw her cake, she made it her snapchat story, and I was so impressed when I saw the picture. The cake was BEAUTIFUL! She also said it was delicious! Very pleased!! I wish I knew more people in Bethlehem so I could send them all cakes! As Marie Antoinette **didn't** say, ""let them eat cake" from Connie's Cakes and Cookies" lol read more

Connie's Cakes and Cookies - Bakeries Near Me

See all

The best cakes in Bethlehem, hands down. Great customer service and friendly clean atmosphere. You will not regret going here.

This place reminds me of your grandmother's kitchen. The woman who runs it is sweeter than pie, and her baked goods have a homey feel to them. As such, they're not super fancey, but they are cheap and delicious! I primarily snatch up the cookies, but the cake is pretty good, and from the displays in the store she seems quite talented. Check it out sometime. read more

We loved our wedding style cake for our 20th Anniversary Party. It was classic, festive, beautiful, scrumptious, and delivered with love and care. read more

I have been meaning to get a review down of this bakery for a while . . . 5 years in fact since Connie did our wedding cupcake tiers and groom's cake! First of all, she is a phenomenal individual, and really was the most accomodating person to work with. Second, her baked goods were excellent!! I can't believe how delicious the cupcakes and groom's cake were! And not only that, but here's the real kicker . . . we froze a handful of cupcakes and a section of groom's cake for our first anniversary . . . after defrosting one year later, there were still delicious!! So moist and the buttercream still creamy and yummy!! If you want a quality, reasonable priced wedding cake, this is the place to go in the valley!! read more

I have purchased every cookie, cake or cupcake I have ever used for any major occassion (baby shower, bridal shower, baptism cookies with kids pics on it, kids first birthday themes for farms, zoos, and kids subsequent birthdays themes) from Connie's. Her work is always amazing, the cake is so unbelievably delicious and moist, and its incredibly easy to order. Plus, the price is just right for the quality and craftmanship that goes into making a cake not only taste delish but also look gorgeous! Connie's has and will continue to always get my business, which is hard given that the Valley has a ton of other choices...but this one is still first class. read more

This is the best cake shoppe I have found in the Lehigh Valley. I just ordered a cake for my daughter's first birthday and it was absolutley exquisite looking not to mention it tasted outstanding and was fresh! The cake was a three tier cake with stripes and polka dots with buttercream icing and a bow made of fondant (spelling) on top. All of the guests at the party raved about it. Thanks so much!! read more

Every year, we throw a new challenge for a themed birthday cake for my daughter, and they come through every time. This year's Tardis (Doctor Who) cake was amazing. read more

Not the absolute prettiest cakes I've ever seen, but they're ridiculously delicious and reasonably priced. I would say the Connie's honestly has the best cakes and cupcakes I've come across in the Lehigh Valley. read more

For my nieces sweet 16 just last week, Connie designed the cake exactly as she wanted nothing different. Everyone was amazed at how beautiful it looked. As for the taste well you really need to try it yourself. All the guest loved the taste. And I mean everyone. Usually at parties you have a few that say well it looked pretty but tasted nasty. In all honesty and with great pride I can say Connie you really have the best tasting cakes in Pennsylvania. I have tried so many but your uniqueness is beyond compare. I will never hesitate to tell people where to go for their cakes. From now on no more local cakes. Another satisfied customer added to your list. Thank you Connie for making this a truly special day. read more