Went for breakfast while in town, haven't been in years and don't love the changes. Little things like the silverware being in little bags instead of on the table, or wrapped in a napkin seems silly, but used to make it seem like more care was put into it. The check coming right away and being encouraged to pay by scanning and entering credit card didn't help either. Food was fine, not as well seasoned as I remember. Also odd that every breakfast comes with pancakes or biscuits and gravy. Was looking for a lower carb option and there aren't options like that. Didn't even see an option to get eggs as a side a make my own combo without these. Server was friendly and explained the options, cashier seemed bored and bothered that we came up instead of paying via phone. They weren't very busy for a Saturday morning, and I am wondering if these things are why. Too bad, as it used to be a fun place to go grab breakfast! read more

See all

Very busy on Thanksgiving but service was efficient and friendly. Was not expecting that for dinner. Food was good. However, the traditional meal I ordered looked like much less food than the picture. Turkey slices were very thin. I was glad that others offered me pieces of their meal. read more

Cracker Barrel Old Country Store - Traditional Turkey Meal - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Pickerington, Ohio

See all

Comfort Food with a Side of Hit-or-Miss It's been a while since I sat down for a full meal at Cracker Barrel, but this visit reminded me that some of the old favorites don't always hit the way they used to. The standout? Our server Stephanie. After my peach mimosa arrived overly syrupy and flat, she offered to let us mix the next one at the table -- and it was so much better. (She confirmed it's optional -- definitely ask for the syrup on the side!) Another small disappointment: they no longer serve lemonade in the signature frosted mugs. Not a dealbreaker, but it took away a bit of the charm. On the plate: Bacon -- Perfectly cooked, no notes. Pancakes -- Looked great, but bland. Needed heavy syrup help. Berry pancakes (not mine) -- My dining partner admitted it was overkill. The mixed berries turned into mush, and they said strawberries alone would've been a better move. Pinto beans -- Usually my comfort go-to, but not this time. I didn't order greens, just beans -- and they were dry, flavorless, and not worth the cost or calories. I sent them back. (Check the pics -- you'll see what I mean.) And yes -- when Stephanie asked if I wanted a box to take the rest home, I almost said, "To do what? Reheat mid?" Stephanie's service was warm and appreciated. The nostalgia's still there. But overall, the food this time around just didn't deliver. read more

See all

Made a pitstop at Cracker Barrel and it's a great place to grab a bite. I must not have been there in a while, so was surprised that they have a build your own breakfast! It comes with eggs, sausage and gravy, and then a choice of meat and side. The ham was salty for my liking, but everything else was good! My kids loved the peg game and there is so much to look at around the store. It's a great place to stop by during a roadtrip and stretch your legs out for a bit. read more

Cracker Barrel Old Country Store - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Pickerington, Ohio

If you can get wait staff to actually come to your table, the food is usually consistent. The last three times we have been here, no one came to our table - so we left. This place used to be our go-to place but just can't recommend it anymore. read more

A wonderful throw back restaurant. A must try! The feel is a very rustic, old country atmosphere. Plenty of early American on the walls and wooden tables and chairs. There's even a huge fireplace in the dining room and rocking chairs for sale on the front porch. To enter, you're directed through an old country store with a wide variety of articles. Clothing, small toys, records and nostalgic candy and soda pop, to name a few. We scored a couple of outfits for the grand baby, both on sale, and an impressive old time ceramic coffee mug. A bit shocking to find Halloween merchandise right inside the door...on July 17th? That was until they pointed out that there will be two Christmas displays coming out before the end of this month. The food is more than adequate. Just as good as home cooked. A decent value for the price. I hustled a free Peach Cobbler off the waitress by solving the golf tee puzzle three times in a row. The manager told me that she was impressed and therefore paid for it. No freebies! I'll gladly accept a free dessert from the CBOC corporation, but not from this woman that is obviously working hard to put food on her table at home. I insisted the manager put the cobbler on my bill. He was so impressed by the gesture that HE bought it for us. 07/24 read more

See all

Both my pancakes came cold as well as my bacon and sausage and eggs. My Strawberry-Stuffed Cheesecake Pancakes came cold and without my whip cream and strawberries. There is barely any cheesecake filling inside one of my pancakes. read more

Cracker Barrel Old Country Store - Cold pancakes and cold eggs - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Pickerington, Ohio

I ordered a bowl of there chicken noodle to go. They are not stingy with the portions. The noodles are the thick egg style. The broth is more on the creamy side and has a nice warming taste. The chicken is rotisserie style. And they give plenty of meat. It is an inviting soup. read more

The thanksgiving dinner was excellent. The sales in their gift shop even better. I can't leave without shopping.

I was worried about stopping at a Cracker Barrel after the disaster the CEO wrought on it. I was pleased to see that this location was unaffected. The service and food were good. I'm still not ready to trust the brand, but this stop was a bit better than expected. read more

Does cracker barrel need more introductions? Every time I come here I have a great time, the delicious Food is always there and the good service is never missing. If you are craving good pancakes, crispy bacon this is your place to enjoy the food and the ambiance. read more

Pam was awesome and holly was awesome. No complaints with the food, super delicious and very cost friendly. Prices weren't outrageous and the atmosphere was one of a kind. Highly recommend this Cracker Barrel in particular, it really feels like the employees like their job and I even witnessed they appreciate their regulars! Very sweet. The s'more skillet was phenomenal, pairs well with the s'more latte read more

Cracker Barrel Old Country Store - S'more latte - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Pickerington, Ohio

The food is always good and hot. The service is unparalleled.They offer seasonal menu items and their desserts are yummy.

This location never disappoints for breakfast service and food. Warm welcome and music is not too loud. Good selection in gift shop, sale stuff is a bit unorganized and a lot of different % signs. Very confusing. We love it that the same friendly faces take care of us daily read more

I can't remember the last time I was at a Cracker Barrel but I was craving it so we came for dinner this evening. It was exactly like I had remembered it. The little shop at the entrance has lots of fun things to browse through and they had a nice big fire going in the fireplace. We were seated right away and our server came quickly. He was really nice, helpful and friendly. The food was really good and everything tasted great! read more

See all

I don't eat here often, but no matter how long I'm away, when I come back it's always consistent. Who doesn't love the ole time feel that cracker barrel provides. A real fire place in the dining room?!? Yeah Cracker Barrel has that. Favorite here is the French toast, can't go wrong. Little glass bottles of maple syrup. Can't beat it! Always great service. read more

This used to be one of my favorite places to eat. They have ruined the cole slaw. Cole slaw should be chopped fine and be served with an adequate amount of dressing, preferably on the sweet side It should not be large slices of tough cabbage, served dry which is what the Cracker Barrel is doing I assume this was a corporate decision made by someone with no taste buds or someone trying to cut costs I ordered a salad in place of slaw and they don't offer a French dressing . Also, I ordered mashed potatoes as a side. They came cold and hard and formed to the contours of the plate. I can't imagine why but they had obviously been put on the plate at least an hour before we even arrived read more

Stopped in around lunch time and had Grandma's breakfast for $13.49. It was delicious! Pancakes were perfect, hash brown casserole to die for and the eggs were perfectly done. It's not often I go out to eat and leave feeling the food and experience were worth it but, Cracker Barrel delivered. Oh, our waitress was amazing too! read more

It's been a while since I've visited a Cracker Barrel and that was for breakfast. A relative suggested we go for dinner, so we obliged. The service was incredible, but the food left lots to be desired. My husband had catfish, and I had the fried shrimp. Both were just okay. The cornbread muffins that came with the meal were not fresh. I'd return but for breakfast, what the restaurant is know for. read more

We had the most amazing experience at Cracker Barrel on Thanksgiving Day! Our server,Ariel was simply amazing,as busy as the restaurant was she was still at our table like 4-5 times for refills etc! And as the time to pay the bill and to leave we gave her a 200.00 tip,our family wanted to bless a server for Christmas/thanksgiving this year! Ariel deserves the world! If you're ever in the area and want some good food and service, Ariel will take care of you! read more

Had breakfast. The coffee was hot and tasted good. Then it went downhill after the food came. The biscuits were hard and the sausage was over cooked. The hash rows casserole was salty. I like my food hot and this was lukewarm. read more

See all

Items are missing from delivery driver orders. Bag is sealed upon arrival so I have to believe the restaurant is not checking the order before it leaves. This has happened more than once. read more

I kinda hate to do this review, can't help it. THEIR TUESDAY PORK CHOPS SPECIAL is to DIE FOR!!! Boneless, tender, breaded and fried, seasoned lightly, breading not thick or gummy, just the best I've had from a restaurant in years! read more

Cracker Barrel Old Country Store - Fried pork chops dinner, green beans and mashed potatoes - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Pickerington, Ohio

I always like coming to this location on my way to Pennsylvania. The service is always top-notch and quick. The food is always so delicious and fresh. I absolutely love that alchohol is now served. read more

See all

Where do I start? The lady who took the order got it wrong. So when the manager was called to the table he was very rude. John (manager) snatched the receipt from the young lady who was with me. John was very rude to our table. read more

BEWARE - PARKING LOT THEFT - SMASH AND GRAB! While parked at Cracker Barrel on July 8, 2023, my SUV and another customer's SUV were broken into - in mid-afternoon, on a bright, sunny day, with numerous customers entering and exiting Cracker Barrel. Thieves broke the back passenger window (driver's side) and grabbed everything they could fit through the back window - pulling items from the back seat and hatch, including electronics equipment, travel bags, totes, etc. We were on our way home from a conference and stopped at Cracker Barrel for a bite to eat. Our vehicle was locked with the alarm set - the alarm WILL NOT sound if someone breaks a window (most alarms won't) - so the alarm didn't go off. The other customer who was robbed also had the same types of items stolen - electronics, travel bags, etc., with the same back window broken. I feel that Cracker Barrel has an obligation to post numerous signs in the parking lot and on the front door that their parking lot is a high theft location, with theft even occurring in broad daylight. One of their security cameras was dirty, the other didn't pick up the license plate no. of the vehicle. We filed a police report, but the process with our insurance is now an arduous one, and the police told us we will most likely never see our belongings again. My wife lost her favorite gold necklace with the initial "B" charm and a turquoise and pink two-tone Dooney bag (pics attached). If you see these items, please contact the Pickerington, OH police dept. IF YOU HAVE OUT-OF-STATE LICENSE PLATES ON YOUR VEHICLE, PARK AT THIS CRACKER BARREL AT YOUR OWN RISK. Better yet, eat elsewhere. Police told us that thieves target out-of-state vehicles primarily. If you have a trunk, put all your belongings in your trunk, or take them with you into the restaurant. We have tinted back windows, but they still broke in. We surmised that thieves were in the parking lot when we arrived, waited for us to enter the restaurant, and then robbed us. Stay alert and stay safe. *****UPDATE****** 7/23/23 - CRACKER BARREL'S ONLINE RESPONSE TO PARKING LOT THEFT****** Lucretia S. - Customer Service - You sent me a copy/paste, canned response to my review, asking that I email Cracker Barrel's customer service to provide them with the store location and my contact information along with the details of this incident. I already provided the details to the Cracker Barrel management team when the robbery occurred and filed a police report with the Pickerington Police Dept. The review I posted is on the Yelp page of the Pickerington Cracker Barrel. It's poor customer service to ask me to rehash details for your customer service team, instead of directing them to this review or providing them with the details yourself. I sent you a private message to ask for clarification of why you are requesting the same information I already provided to Cracker Barrel, as well as to the Pickerington Police. Please feel free to notify your internal service team of this review and information from the Pickerington Cracker Barrel management team re: this incident. Thank you. read more

Food was really great! Hit the spot for cold rainy day. Wait was about 20 minutes for a Sunday afternoon for 2 people but had time to shop around cute store ! Huckleberry tea WINNER! Only suggestion, more xxl sweatshirts maybe. read more

See all

Cracker Barrel is always a unique experience, something about walking into a general store is always interesting. I've been to several locations, but this was my first time at this restaurant. The decor was on par with every other restaurant, old timey trinkets and photos. Our service was good, drinks were always full and our server was very attentive. As for the food, it was as tasty and the biscuits seemed like they just came out of the oven. I wish there was a location closer to me, but I'll be back to this location when I'm in the area. read more

See all

I don't usually find myself in Pickerington but I was going to see a movie nearby so decided on Cracker Barrel for dinner. I've had CB many many times in my life but this was the first time at this location. The restaurant was pretty empty on a Monday night but we were sad at a tiny 2 top which seemed odd. Our server asked if we wanted to move to a larger table and we said no but later wish we had. Once the plates start piling up there is such little room. But beyond that we had great service and the food was really good. There was a mixup on one of my sides but it was resolved easily. The hashbrown casserole could have been a little hotter but it was still good. Overall we had a very positive experience here! read more

See all

I ordered the white fish that came with three sides. It tasted very good and not fishy. It was a rather large piece of fish. My sides were the Brussels sprouts with kale and it was delicious! The broccoli was steamed and good and the hash brown casserole was yummy! Biscuits were tasty. Service was attentive and friendly. A great place for a delicious meal ! Today we went for late lunch/early dinner. I ordered the Southern fried chicken dinner. It was double dipped batter which had a slight spicy flavor. The dinner came with 4 pieces (half chicken) and two sides and biscuits. Enough food for two people! Service was excellent! read more

I went a couple weeks with a group of 7 people at lunchtime. We had about a 25,'inure wait because they only have 1 table for large parties over 6. Seemed strange that they couldn't push a couple smaller tables to accommodate us but we didn't mind because their country store kept us busy shopping. Lots of really cute and unique merchandise. I ordered the maple bacon grilled chicken and it was ah-mazing! Chicken was juicy and had great flavor. The bacon was crisp. I would highly recommend ordering this dish. read more

Cracker Barrel Old Country Store - Maple bacon grilled chicken - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Pickerington, Ohio

I celebrated my birthday with breakfast at Cracker Barrel, and it was truly a memorable experience thanks to the outstanding service from our waitress, Terri. From the moment we arrived, Terri made us feel right at home with her warm smile and attentive approach. She went above and beyond to ensure everything was perfect--from recommending some delicious breakfast favorites to making sure our coffee cups were never empty. Her attention to detail and genuine care made the meal extra special, adding a personal touch that turned an ordinary breakfast into a cherished birthday celebration. Thank you, Terri, and Cracker Barrel, for a wonderful start to my day! Plus she is celebrating her work anniversary as well ! What a great day ! read more

I've been to Cracker Barrel tons of times but haven't been in a long time. Came today because I was craving chicken and dumplings. The service and food were good. Nothing was exceptional or amazing but everything was good. The sodas at $3.19 for a Cracker Barrel is a little steep but all the other prices are great. Same thing for there store is way overpriced $7 for a small bag of candy is a bit much. The check out took about 10 mins, which is too long. I think they do it on purpose so people will look at items but I was just trying to leave. read more

Poor service, poor food. Really disappointing experience. Usually love Cracker Barrel when we travel, Hard pass on this location.

SEVEN WORDS: TRADITIONAL HOMESTYLE BREAKFAST CHAIN RESTAURANT/ HEARTY VALUE. We came on a Sunny Friday and expected a heavy crowd. However, the crowd was moderate; we were seated immediately. The surroundings are comfy and quaint, even for a national chain, complete with hardwood tables and antique store furnishings. It's both intimate and gregarious, allowing for both conversationalists and kibbitzers to feel at home. We ordered Grilled Rainbow Trout and the new Sothern Fried Chicken. Both meals came with two sides and cornbread. Both the trout and chicken were yummy, but let's start with the fish. The Rainbow Trout was char grilled, and came without bones but with a bottom layer of skin. It tasted ftresh, and the flakes of fish were grassy, like and fresh lake-caught game fish. It was easy to clean the plate, as every bite had a fine, blackened lake fish taste. Likewise, the Southern Fried Chicken was fantastic, with well-breaded pieces of chicken (four ok f them: breast, thigh, wing, and leg) that melt in the mouth. The breading, seasoned generously with salt and pepper, crackled in the mouth, gushing forth with chicken goodness. The serving sizes were generous and the total bill came to $26 +tip. Overall, this was my one of my best eating experience at Picktowns Cracker Barrel, and really worth the trip. read more

Wow! The food was out standing! We travel a lot and always stop at a Cracker Barrel to eat at least 1 meal. This place has the best tasting food ever out of all the Cracker Barrel's we've stopped at and we have been all over the US. I'm adding this one as a favorite! read more

This was the first time I tried dinner at the Cracker Barrel. And I'm glad I did! The chicken breast was topped with cranberries which sounded questionable to me but it worked. It was one of the best pieces of chicken I have ever had which says a lot as I never usually order chicken because most places overcook it. I ordered greens on the side, which I love, but they had a funny taste and when I told the waitress she offered me to pick a new side. So I chose the fried okra which was the bomb. Our waitress went above and beyond to make sure that we were satisfied. And as you know the Cracker Barrel is always busy. But our waitress, Stephanie, was very attentive! My mom ordered the fish and chips. She is a very picky eater but she loved her meal as well. I will definitely try dinner again at the Cracker Barrel on the opportunity arises. read more

Cracker Barrel Old Country Store - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Pickerington, Ohio

See all

I'm usually here for breakfast and will easily give this place praise for one of the greater breakfast combos (in my book). I alternate between the Sunrise Sampler and the Double Meat breakfast. I love all of the meats, so I have to have each one (and extra portions). The winner here is their Hashbrown Casserole. That's an absolute must, considering I usually get grits when I have to choose between that and hash browns. Between the swinging chairs outside, the gift shop and the fireplace, it's a very relaxing environment. I particularly enjoy visiting during Christmas season because they have a beautiful arrangement of holiday items that you really can't find anywhere else. My friend and I often meet here on Friday mornings, from time to time and I look forward to every visit. Even though it's always busy, it's never really a long wait, so definitely give this place a try. If you're lucky, you'll get a spot by that fireplace! read more

Cracker Barrel Old Country Store - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Pickerington, Ohio

Worst meal we've had in a while. We decided days ago we were going this weekend so hubby could try the fried turkey and I wanted meatloaf. It took forever to get our food. When it came out the biscuits were burned on top edges, meatloaf was lukewarm and the fried turkey meal was a joke. It was hard, cold and had barely any gravy( see pic), the green bean casserole had one onion on top. The pic I posted is what my hubby left on his plate because he just couldn't eat it. We told our server and he just said sorry. I asked to speak to a manager when we were checking out and waited 10 min. No manager ever came so finally the person just took it off our bill after I showed them pics. We won't be going back. Very disappointed with our whole meal. read more

Cracker Barrel Old Country Store - Add photo of fried turkey compared to what we actually got. - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Pickerington, Ohio

See all

Pretty much like every other Cracker Barrel, for better or for worse. I thought we had been here, but now I'm not sure. They're all laid out the same, and have the same food. And the food is okay. Not quite "good not great," even, but fine. And enough variety that anyone can find something they like. Homestyle, southern-tinged cooking. We met Sweetie's friends here, so we had a big group that was half kids. Service was good, and the kids were kept occupied. The gift shop helped with that. Prices there are a little high, but again, everyone will find at least something they like. Baby K got yogurt, and I expected a Gogurt but it was actually a nice yogurt parfait with fruit and granola. Sweetie got French toast and said it was very good. I got the daily special: chicken and rice. Small chunks of decent chicken, sticky rice, some mushrooms. Okay, but not worth getting again. I chose dumplings and fried okra as my sides. The okra was okay, but probably frozen. The dumplings were good- dense, but tender, with mild brown gravy. I told Baby K they were like pasta and she ate some of the "big pasta." So, decent food, but you don't really come here for an amazing meal. Well, I don't. I come because it is kid-friendly and an easy place to meet friends. I've never had a bad meal at a Cracker Barrel, but I've never really had a great one either. Kinda like McDonald's, just better and slower: it's reliable, pretty generic, and sometimes handy. read more