Pros: -Very friendly servers. We've dined here multiple times, both as a foursome and as a couple. -Bartenders are great and really work to help you find a drink you'll like. They also have different specialty cocktails throughout the year. -Cheese curds...I know, it's Wisconsin, but these are right up there with the elite. Cons: -I'll let you know when I find some. We've been to Crafty Cow several times over the last year, probably four or five times, and we've always been impressed by how friendly the waitstaff and bar staff are. The owner is also very nice and clearly involved, which I think is cool. I almost always order the same thing: the chicken strip meal, which comes with three huge strips and a large side of fries. The chicken here is really interesting because it's marinated in pickle brine. You can definitely taste the brine, and it adds something you didn't even realize was missing. My wife used to order the same thing, but now she tries something different each time because she knows she can share my strips. Everything she has tried has been good. Also worth mentioning: they have really good ranch dressing. I was surprised when I looked up Crafty Cow on Yelp and saw that it had less than four stars. Looking at some of the older reviews, I'm guessing it may have had a bit of a rocky start. But based on our experiences, Crafty Cow has been consistently great, and we'll definitely keep coming back. read more

HIGHLY RECOMMEND Working with clients in Oconomowoc, I recently lunched at Crafty Cow Burgers & Fried Chicken; we had a terrific experience! The interior decor is very 'pub' like with expanses of dark wood and many art prints/framed works on the walls; there is a large bar in the front area with several tables/high-tops. In the back, the aesthetic is more 'industrial' with exposed brickwork and beams. We were greeted by the bartender (?) and seated immediately; our waitress brought us menus, reviewed the specials with us, and then brought our drinks. Crafty Cow specialises in 'craft' sodas and I enjoyed a very nice diet 'cola' drink with lemon; it was delicious. I ordered the chicken sandwich with the 'Nashville Hot' seasoning (because, hello, Nashville Hot) and it arrived piping hot with lots of shoe-string fries, also piping hot. The flavours were absolutely wonderful, full of contrast and balance. The 'heat' from the chicken was excellent; the chicken was plump and juicy, and had been perfectly breaded and fried. The slaw was also excellent: just the right balance of sweet and crunchy to offset the hot chicken. My clients and I enjoyed our visit to Crafty Cow Burgers & Fried Chicken and plan to return! HIGHLY RECOMMEND read more

The food was really good. The beer selection was great. The service was good overall and the vibes were fine. The only issue was we had to ask a few times for them to turn the game on the tv by us before it actually happened. But they were unusually busy for a Thursday it seemed. 10/10 would come eat girl dinner here again. read more

Crafty Cow - Burgers & Fried Chicken - Pickle chips - Burgers Near Me - Oconomowoc, Wisconsin

See all

Came in Saturday for brunch has a chilled Coors light and a hang over smasher burger with no bun and the cheesy potatoes the food and the service was perfect We will be back for sure So good had to order another cold one !!! read more

First off, the burgers and beverages are awesome here. I've been to this location and the one in Wauwatosa and there's no noticeable quality difference. Everything is fresh and delicious. But, you pay a premium for that. We're talking up to a $23 burger with avocado and bacon. The drinks are average cost for the area. I do wish I had been warned about the 414 Fire sauce though; they have it listed as 2 out of 4 spice level, so I got a side of it, and it was inedible. It tasted like pure cayenne pepper and the server told me it's actually ghost pepper!! I was actively crying trying to eat it would not recommend. I can't even imagine the two levels above it. The service has been above average when we've gone, with staff being attentive and helpful. Worth checking out but avoid the Fire sauce! read more

Crafty Cow - Burgers & Fried Chicken - CRAFTY CHICKEN TENDERS - Burgers Near Me - Oconomowoc, Wisconsin

The food is so good highly recommend . Waiters are so nice they made origami for me.I love the building so cool I love it so much.

First time at this location. I've found the other locations to be good, but not great. This one, however, was easily the best experience of all three. It's on a busy street with parking out front (and a public lot around the corner). There are patio tables in front, plus a large patio behind the building. Inside, the décor is casual and relaxed. We were seated right away. Our server did a great job getting us set up with waters, drinks, and menus. We took a while to place our order (we were lost in conversation), but the server was pleasant and patient throughout. We ended up ordering a couple of burgers: I got the OK Burger, and my friend the Fried Onion Burger. I also asked to have my smash patties cooked a bit longer for those crispy edges. While waiting for the burgers, we shared an order of Cheese Curds -- beer-battered white cheddar. They were just okay, nothing special, and could have been cooked a little longer. My OK Burger, on the other hand, was excellent, and cooked exactly as I asked, with crisp edges. The side salad was solid as well. The burger was a generous size, but I managed to finish it all. Overall, a very good experience. Great service (thanks, Jack), an excellent burger, and a relaxed atmosphere. Easily the best of their locations. I'll definitely be back. read more

See all

Wow! The food is fabulous! One of the best burgers I've had. Chicken and Cheese Curds very good also. Service is fantastic also read more

See all

We ordered takeout and got two of the chicken sandwiches. Both sandwiches had good flavors and fries on the side which were shoestring -- my fave type! Overall, the food was good but the sandwiches were a bit smaller portions than I expected especially given the price. read more

Met a friend in a Madison halfway in Oconomowoc and we landed on Crafty Cow as our dinner spot. It was my first time. Apparently they're known for their fried chicken sandwiches (brined in pickle juice), but their fish fry, and burger were also appetizing. Unfortunately there's not a lot of vegetable options, but their slaw is really light and relatively healthy. Our waiter was the highlight of our experience; we had some good conversations and vibes. It's a typical pub with some trendy elements (ie vegan options, thc drinks, etc). I plan to try one of their other locations closer to the city. It was also a plus that the Wizard of Oz plaza was on the same street for a little local history. read more

Crafty Cow - Burgers & Fried Chicken - nearby Wizard of Oz plaza (apparently Downtown Oconomowoc had one of the first technicolor screenings of the movie) - Burgers Near Me - Oconomowoc, Wisconsin

See all

I ordered the Elote Loaded Nachoes. They were by far the best nachos I've ever had. It's not the traditional plate you're used to. These tortilla chips (great on their own) are topped with cheese sauce, street corn and picled red onion, salsa roja, cilantro, with cotija sprinkled over it. I added Ground beef to my order and they weren't stingy with it. In fact the whole order goes beyond filling. You get quite the value for the price. I've found my new "go to" order. read more

Looking for some great food, amazing server and great taps, this is the place for you. We were visiting from AZ and wanted to have a more local vibe. We hopped in and requested to sit on the patio to enjoy the beautiful weather. Samantha was promt to seat us and very attentive. We ordered the pretzels and plain cheeseburger for our 11 year old. We didn't order any food for ourselves, but he enjoyed it very much. We enjoyed two local beers the margarita. Will definitely come back to try the chicken! read more

Love their happy hour drinks and their appetizers have all been great! We also have really enjoyed the hamburgers and chicken sandwiches.

Great chicken tenders. Tasty waffle fries and unique slaw. Prompt service. Relaxed ambiance surrounded by antique memorabilia. read more

Ryan was excellent! We had a delicious quick dinner and drinks. Fancy chicken, cheese curds, mac&cheese so good. Ryan really helped us enjoy our meal. We will be back! read more

Huge shout out to Amalia for taking care of us on Friday May 1. Food and drinks are always great, but the service was the best. It was a packed house and she was on top of it all. Great job Amalia. Thank you read more

Food is delicious. Beer selection varies but typically an excellent selection. Service is always very good. Our family 'go to' are the Honey Cheese Curds, Classic Burger and Chicken Caesar Wrap. Nightly specials typically offer significant savings. read more

I've been here multiple times and it's never disappointed. The only complaint I have is that even with a smaller menu, it's INCREDIBLY difficult to decide what to order. Then there are the specials that change, that makes it even harder! read more

Crafty Cow - Burgers & Fried Chicken - Specialty menu - Burgers Near Me - Oconomowoc, Wisconsin

5 Stars - Crafty Cow Made Our Date Night Extra Special! My fiancé and I had such a great time at Crafty Cow! From the moment we walked in, the staff made us feel welcome and well taken care of. Everyone was so friendly, attentive, and on top of things--checking in just the right amount without being overbearing. You could tell they genuinely cared about the experience. And the food? Incredible. Everything we ordered was bursting with flavor and cooked to perfection. The menu had plenty of fun, creative options, and each bite delivered. Whether you're in the mood for something bold or a comforting classic, they've got you covered. Crafty Cow definitely left an impression--we felt relaxed, full, and appreciated. It's the kind of place you look forward to coming back to. Highly recommend for a cozy night out or a casual date with great vibes and even better food! read more

The food is great, but the service is better. Ryan not only has an amazing attitude but went above and beyond to accommodate my wife's dietary restrictions. We've been here before, and while the ambiance is stellar, I'd recommend coming back just to have Ryan as a server. 11/10 read more

Our server Ryan was fantastic. Food was great, but our experience with him will be bringing us back.

Great atmosphere. My husband and I have had all their burgers between the two of us and didn't have one we didn't love. Their fish fry is the only one I've had that actually had flavor. Service is always very good. And my husband likes their whiskey menu. Lol We have been back and will continue to come back whenever we can. read more

We made a trip from Madison to Oconomowoc for my husband's birthday and it was an amazing experience!! Six adults and a toddler and the staff did an amazing job making us all feel welcome. The food was delicious and the service was excellent. My toddler was getting a little squirrelly so they offered him crayons to color with and then a couple of fidget toys from their toy basket. No one complained about us needing more time to order or all of the questions that we had. Super friendly staff and we never felt rushed to finish up our visit. They even went out of their way to sing happy birthday and deliver us a birthday piece of cheesecake...which was DELICIOUS!!! Thank you Ryan and friends for being the best! read more

Crafty Cow makes the best burgers and cheese curds I've ever had in the Lake Country area. Their Oconomowoc location wouldn't win any prizes for ambiance, but it's a cozy, casual space that's perfectly fine for the kind of restaurant it is. Their service has always been friendly and attentive. Highly recommended. read more

I was so disappointed with the takeout I got. The fries were soggy and the caesar wrap had way too much dressing on it. Would not recommend.

Best Chicken sandwich and cheese curds in Oconomowoc! Great tap beer selection and above average service!!

I had an OK experience at crafty cow Oconomowoc. The best part were the cheese curds. My friends and I got the nashville hot chicken sandwich which was good in taste but very small portion. The burgers did not come wirh fries and were very small. Our server was awful and kept messing up the order. read more

Crafty Cow - Burgers & Fried Chicken - Cheese curds - Burgers Near Me - Oconomowoc, Wisconsin

There is way too much pepper on the burgers. You can't even taste beef. I like the sweet Savory thing you have going on but you have to have Savory with sweet potato fries. Did I mention way too much pepper... I should have sent it back but I'm kind of not confrontationable. And the whole party would have had to send their burgers back because we all felt the same. So disappointed I literally put you guys on pedestal. I'm really sorry to say that. My hopes were very high because I've been there before and it's been great. Again the pepper. I'm going to delete this in a week I hope you take it to hurt because you've got competition rolling in. Food trucks read more

My first visit. Got a bogo sandwich just for signing up to the app. Great burger and chicken sandwiches. Come hungry or share. Samantha (waitress, bartender, busboy/girl) was amazing. Working tables (one with 15 guests) while alone, but never rushed us and took a minute to explain the menu and app program. read more

We had a good time at the crafty cow! I got the messy breakfast and my husband got the peach french toast. My meal was delicious and I would definitely recommend trying to anyone going! The French toast was just average. I'd say you have to try the tater tots if you go, they were the hit at the table! The inside of the restaurant was kind of dark, but overall a good place to meet friends, especially with kids, read more

Crafty Cow - Burgers & Fried Chicken - French toast - Burgers Near Me - Oconomowoc, Wisconsin

See all

Absolutely blown away by the cheese curds at Crafty Cow, they were the best I've ever had. That's saying a lot as I'm a cheese curd fanatic. The Hot Honey dipping sauce was over the top. They are even better than Saz's State House. Our server, Ryan, took great care of us and he took the time to explain how these amazing cheese curds are made. When you visit Crafty Cow I highly recommend ordering "An OK smash burger" and don't forget the cheese curds!! If Ryan is your server you'll be in great hands. Great job Ryan!!! read more

Went to Crafty Cow in Bayview a couple of nights ago. We had great service and the food was great. Between the four of us we had lettuce wraps, and sandwiches (which I had no tried before). I also ordered the cheese curds as I find their light coating is the best. Unexpectedly we discovered there was trivia that night so we stayed and enjoyed the evening even taking second place. read more

I stopped in today at Crafty Cow for the OK burger and a Bloody Mary. Ben was super friendly and kind. I'm always happy when he is bartending. He made the recommendation for the OK burger, which was huge and delicious.! Can't wait to try Tuesday. Trivia night it sounds like a lot of fun! read more

Great Burgers & Chicken!! Cool atmosphere with friendly service Watch your favorite sporting event while enjoying lunch or dinner. read more

i loved my time an experience ! i will deff be back had the mush burger also hope this place stays so cool read more

Crafty Cow - Burgers & Fried Chicken - chicken - Burgers Near Me - Oconomowoc, Wisconsin

The OK burger is amazing! was fantastic and overall experience five star. We give it our highest recommendation.

Fun, awesome service, great selection and great prices! Fantastic location! Must stop when you come to oconomowoc. Will definitely make this a regular sto! read more

We moved to Oconomowoc recently and had to check out this place which has such good ads. The food lives up to the billing. Our server was very attentive, and the cheese curd appetizer came to our table quickly. Burgers were great. Mac and cheese with fried chicken was superb. We liked the vibe. We will be back. read more

Crafty Cow - Burgers & Fried Chicken - MAC BIG BOWL with fried chicken - Burgers Near Me - Oconomowoc, Wisconsin

Ryan was the most amazing server we have ever had, above and beyond service and so so kind

Cheese curds are always good here...tried the Canadian tuxedo burger and turned out to not really be my style, taste...I think it was made well, but not really what I expected; have had other burgers here that I've like a lot more; will get something else next time. Service was good, nice place inside... read more