I was blown away by the quality here. Despite keeping at least 30 flavors available, there were no…read moreice crystals interrupting the cream-forward spoonfuls of peanut butter Oreo that I went with. And wow, what a combination - the smooth peanut butter brought almost caramel overtones to the vanilla, while the Oreo cookies gave a softened crunch. They do offer samples, which is great since there are plenty of house flavors to choose from. Vibes-wise I definitely got that The Dairy is a family-run business. On an only mildly warm late spring day in April, there was still a steady trickle of to-go and dine-in customers. The Dairy feels like Americana.

They have the best soft serve ice cream in town! It's homemade and they even use their soft serve…read moreice cream to make their ice cream cakes, ice cream sandwiches, as well as ice cream cones you buy to take home

Awesome place to take your kids. Lady taught me you could order half soft serve half hard ice…read morecream. Woulda went the rest of my life choosing ! Thank you. Give it a visit if you haven't

Brought my nephew and family there for an after dinner treat and we loved it. Staff was so beyond…read morenice and welcoming. Highly recommend for a family trip especially during the summer

My go to spot for ice cream in Fairfield. Very nice selection of flavors. My fave is Coffee…read moreGrounds. Other solid choices I have tried are Chocolate Chip Mint, Pistachio, Vanilla, Apple Pie and Orange Sherbet. The staff is always friendly. Plenty of tables inside and out. The only occasional challenge is parking when they are busy. But it's usually fine. Definitely worth a try if you are craving ice cream while in the Fairfield area.

Came in on a Sunday afternoon. It was empty which was nice. They have a variety of flavors and…read moretoppings to pick from. The kids took a picture in the little ice cream truck inside. They also have a ping pong table. Cute outdoor seating area. Nice enough to sit outside so we did. We ordered a banana split. The three flavors were chocolate, Jersey can, and cake batter. The toppings we got were waffle cone pieces, cake crunchies, cherries, and rainbow sprinkles. The price was perfect. Can't complain about 7.50 for what we got. We were able to share it too. Yelp had a free coffee so I got a latte and it was pretty decent. Great service, they were patient and friendly. We will be coming back to try other flavors.

Never thought I would find ice cream that compared with the cream I grew up on Sip and Swirl is in…read morethe highest league with Applegrates Farm. I NOW PLACE HAVE 2 THAT I CAN IN ENJOY!!!!!! OH WHAT A FEELING!!!

I encountered this business food truck at the FIFA event at Sports Illustrated stadium…read more Be prepared for rude service and to double-check your bill at the Fairfield Ice Cream truck. I walked up and asked one of the employees, who was standing there and not helping another customer, what the ice cream sizes were. She gave me an annoyed look and responded, "What?!" Before she answered, another employee yelled from across the truck, "I have it right here. Wait your turn," while he was ringing up someone else. I apologized and said I thought I could ask her since she wasn't helping anyone. She then muttered, "You don't have to be fucking rude." When she realized I heard her, she immediately ducked back into the truck. The entire interaction was incredibly unprofessional. Then I was charged $10 for an item clearly posted as $7. I was told the extra $3 was "tax," which simply isn't possible. We even have video showing the posted price and confirming what other customers paid. I chose not to argue because I was there with my toddler and didn't want to ruin our family outing. Everyone can have an off day, but there is no excuse for swearing at customers, treating people with disrespect, or charging more than the posted price. What should have been a fun stop for ice cream ended up being one of the worst customer service experiences I've had.

The ice cream is delicious. They have a great selection and a variety of different flavors. The…read morestaff is always positive, friendly and excited to help us. Dogs are welcome. There is always a good crowd even on the coldest day of the year. Dogs welcome. They get served a Pup Cup.

When the sweet tooth hits you must oblige and ice cream always hits summer or winter! Was lucky…read moreenough to find this spot before closing. While looking at all the flavors I saw some of the same ol but once I saw banana pudding I knew I had found a gem. I asked for a sample and immediately after asked for a cone of the stuff. It is truly amazing!!! There are pieces of I can only presume is nilla wafers that gives it a nice texture against the creamy banana flavored icecream! Giving magnolia bakery a run for its money

This was by far my favorite roll ice cream place because they were generous with the extras. The…read moreNutella was ample and tasted amazing thick and partially frozen with the rolls. The strawberry Nutella banana was excellent!

The only word I can use to describe this ice cream is ASTONISHING!…read moreI had tried rolled ice cream before but hadn't found a place in NJ that served it, not that I moved to Montclair, I came across this place and had to try it - let me tell you, it did not disappoint!! The ice cream is $8.50 no matter what flavor you get, and it includes as many toppings as you want - which to me seems like a fantastic deal. I got the "Me Want Cookie" ice cream with fudge and pretzels ... and WOW! The way they mix the ice cream just enhances the oreo flavor but without taking away from the sweet cream they use. The place has tables and a "bar" for people to sit on, as well as some outside seating. The people who served us were really nice and got us our ice cream pretty quickly despite the place being packed. This is now my favorite ice cream place in town!

We visited this homemade ice cream shop after dinner at another local place. There wasn't much…read moredecor but it's a small space. The service was ok. The two girls working were not rude but definitely didn't seem like they wanted to be there. There are many different flavors that other ice cream places do not have. They are allergy friendly when it comes to peanuts and tree nuts. We each just got a small cup. It was delicious. Prices are fair.

It was really good ice cream! Would definitely return. I had the cherry blossom and the peanut…read morebutter pie. Even though the flavors I picked didn't go together I had to try both. The peanut butter pie was peanut butter ice cream with graham cracker and peanut butter cups in it. The cherry blossom was cherry ice cream with cherries in it. Both really good!

We love this place! The ice cream is always so good, and they do an awesome job helping with food…read moreallergies, which means a lot to our family. We also get all of our birthday ice cream cakes here--the personalized photo cakes always turn out great and are a big hit. Friendly staff, great service, and delicious treats every time!

I can see why this is a popular place. Had the banana split, which was way too much for one person…read more Really like how flexible they are with flavors and toppings. Really anything you want. Definitely recommend the apple pie one. By far the best in my books. The service was great. The gal was super helpful and gave great recommendations. Really liked that they offer samples. Please has a few tables and all were clean.