To be honest, we CRAVE Roxy's chef salad, cheesy bread with…read morepizza sauce and Stromboli. CRAVE - that's high praise, and it's well deserved praise. Their pizza and subs are very tasty, too. Fresh food, great ingredients, and really nice people. And they deliver... WE REALLY LIKE Roxy's Pizza - it's the best we've had in Millersport and one of our favorites on the lake.

We love their food…read more Roxy's has one of the best pizzas around, and I especially love their salads. PLUS - they're one of the few pizza shops on the lake that deliver. Delicious.

Veg pizza amazing ... full of variety of toppings ....always the best…read more... Great value and exceptional taste

I unfortunately just got pretty bad food poisoning from here today. Had the hot honey pizza and a…read moreside salad. I think it might have been the salad. Worst part is I'm on a work trip puking my brains out in my hotel room :/

Called to place a order and was informed that a previous order had been delivered but did not get…read moretheir money. I explained that I have NEVER gotten a pizza delivered and wanted to speak to the owher abd was told by the wanna be manager kid that he wished me good luck with that. The pizza is not worth the mouth that answers the phone . Come to find out it was the neighbor upstairs who had gotten the pizza and the delivery guy did not want to get her change for a 50.00 ( 36.00 order) which would have only been 14.00 and was told done worry about it. She called the shop to make it right abd waited the next day for the delivery guy to never show up. In my 50 plus years I've NEVER heard of getting a pizza delivered and not receiving the payment. Come on crenos in buckeye lake , who's fault is this really?

Ordered from here tonight while traveling back to Alabama from Pennsylvania. The Stromboli was…read morefresh and hot the cheese bread was awesome! The brownie dessert was super moist and delicious!!!

We have had their subs, and pizza. They do specialty orders and the chicken, mushroom, bacon on…read moregarlic parmesan sauce is yummy! The Italian subs are GREAT! Highly recommend. Best pizza, great location for us.

I went there with a friend of mine to get some authentic Italian lasagna. I had heard good things…read moreabout their pizza by friends of mine. The menu is a little on the pricey side. The lasagna was of average price. It had no flavor. It was cold inside. I had to ask them to put it back in the oven for a little while to warm it up. I was asked if I wanted it to be put in the microwave when I asked specifically to have it placed in the oven. The wait staff was very nice and the place was little, not very fancy at all, but homey.

After living about 45 min away for 15 years and being a craft brew enjoyer, I can not believe I've…read morenever stopped in. I don't get out this way often, but it's been a week since my visit, and I've thought several times about my eventual return.... I really enjoyed this place. It was a sunny Sunday (Father's Day" and I had an hour or two to kill on my way back from someplace and I thought I'd try a new place. It was conveniently located off of I-70 and I had never been in the town of Buckeye Lake before, so I was a bit curious. I was quite pleased when I drove up to see a roadside patio and an open air indoors (large windows that open up) for nice days such as these. Parking was easy to find in back. There's a casual restaurant attached where you can sit in and drink your beer while eating their food, or vice versa: Sit in the brewery and go pick up your food when it's ready. The bartenders were great. There's a water station and clean bathrooms just beside the bar. Ordering my flight was easy, the menu was easy to read and the bartenders were knowledgeable and bonus: seemed happy to be there. The playlist sounded like it was taken from my Spotify playlists! It was like perfect for me. I told a friend afterward about several songs they played, and they were like, did they have access to your data somehow? Like, how did they know to play your favorite songs? So kudoos to whomever curated the playlist on the evening of Father's Day, 2026. It was perfect. I love the feel of the place. Lots of boaters stopping in from the dock across the street after a day at sea and some people just hanging out, chilling. It felt like I was in a resort town in the summertime (maybe I was?). It also appeared family-friendly, which is a selling point to me, but at the same time a comfortable place for adults to do adult things. I look forward to visiting again sometime soon, preferably while the weather is still nice.

If you are looking for a great atmosphere near Buckeye Lake go to Buckeye Lake Brewery. Great beer…read more the Buckeye Blonde is the best.!!

My absolute favorite ice cream is at this restaurant. I ask for the ice cream first and the food…read morecan come as it is ready. This restaurant is always busy and you honestly have to wait a while for the hot food. Our server was friendly and attentive to our needs. We ordered way more food than two people could possibly eat but we knew we could take it home. I love the cappuccino crunch ice cream. It is my all time favorite flavor. The ice cream came out pretty melty because of the extreme heat. Our server apologized for it. The restaurant has games available for the wait. The restaurant is quiet enough for conversation with one of your favorite sons also! The tables were clean as was the restroom. The food is decent. This is not gourmet dining nor is it necessarily healthy. As an occasional treat, the food hits the spot. We will be back!

We just got Stromboli delivered for a work meeting. Super good flavor, we got meat lovers,…read morepepperon, and a veggie one with mushrooms and peppers. All were good.

A 2 hour wait for bar food. It's a joke. Crappy service for…read morea beverage and no food basically.

SOME OF THE BEST FOOD & DRINKS ON BUCKEYE LAKE...!!!…read more As we walked in on a Friday night, we saw a chalkboard outside that read "Steak Night! Filet Mignon or Ribeye with salad and 2 sides for $16.99! Add a crab cake for $3 more!" Guess what? It was good. REALLY GOOD. The Beach House Pub is in the former Beachcomber in Fairfield Beach, on the south side of the lake. But it's new ownership, a new menu, and they've brought new life into this place. There were 5 of us. We had pizza, wings, 2 steak dinners, a burger, drinks, etc. Everything was really good. The steaks were an absolute bargain. The ribeye was delicious. The filet was delicious. The $3 crab cake was really good. Drinks were strong and very well executed. Sarah, the new owner, was a manager at the Copper Penny for many years. She has absolutely, positively "upped her game" here - the Beach House is really good. REALLY good... We're thrilled, because we have a house nearby. Service was great. The live band was good. We got seated right away, and served right away. And it wasn't a madhouse, like some of the other places on the lake can be on a weekend during boating season. I'm sure it will get busier as people realize what a gem this has become. If you find yourself on the south side of Buckeye Lake any time soon, I HIGHLY RECOMMEND the Beach House Pub.