Worth the wait and money! We waited in line for around 15-20 minutes but it was worth it. I recommend going as soon as they open to avoid waiting. Savory bagel was the best bagel I've ever had. It was perfectly toasted, salmon was not fishy, other toppings were perfectly seasoned as well. Mayak egg bowl was amazing too. I didn't like sweet bagel as much as savory. Highly recommend savory bagel and mayak egg bowl. We ended up eating in the car due to there being many customers but it was a cute little shop and they sell other canned/tinned fish too. Would definitely go again when I visit Door County again. read more

See all

congradulations: one of 5 national finalists james beard awards.. the bagels are amazing, the sanwhich and the bread are to die for. read more

See all

Excellent service! As usual, extremely busy, even with that the wait was not long. A wonderfully prepared open face sandwich. Excellent blend of flavors and neatly stacked components. Once given my order, I was thanked sincerely for my business. read more

See all

The hype is real, y'all!!! Cultured is phenomenal, we loved their bagels and egg Kimchi bowl. The kimchi was not too spicy and was perfect for breakfast. The staff is so nice and despite the long line, they were patient, gave us time to pick out our food. I loved the cozy ambience and space filled with light and conversation. Its a perfect cafe for door county read more

See all

So! This was a spot we decided we'd "quickly grab breakfast" and then begin our 4 hour drive back home. We pulled up and we noticed there was a line starting at the front door, which indicated to us that they had into opened yet however! My curiosity grew even larger because of that line which told me this place was a solid choice! People were there for their bagels and their sourdough bread, which all looked amazing. We chose the breakfast bagel sandwiches, which were definitely worth the wait because they were delicious. Very simple and straightforward menu, absolutely no fluff, but this place definitely deserves all of the stars they can get. The staff definitely knew that we were first timers, but they were very kind and patient with us. I will definitely be back. Oh! And I regret not grabbing a loaf of sourdough bread. Well done, cultured! read more

Breakfast Sammie so big I got breakie and lunch out of it. Delicious. Bought a loaf of bread as a gift so didn't get to try it but smelled amazing. There can be lines but it goes fast and they take care of you. read more

Bagels and bread were amazing! So fresh and great flavors. Service is super, lots of enthusiasm. Fun outdoor seating. We will be back! read more

Visiting Door County in the fall. This spot caught my eye on Yelp. It's a bakery with a simple menu. Mostly folks just grabbed the baked goods and headed out. I ordered the veggie bagel on a toasted everything. It is topped with tomato &garlic cream cheese, a tomato on slice, thin cuke slices, pickled carrot chips and very thin sliced pickled garlic. It was unique and full of flavor. The bagel choices are slim and don't expect a NY bagel. But the taste is....cultured. And the friendly Midwest service is a stark contrast to the NYC brash counter help. Worth a visit. Oh, skip the coffee. Not the best. read more

Cultured - Veggie bagel - Bakeries Near Me - Sister Bay, Wisconsin

Wow! Just stopped in and this place was amazing I had the breakfast Sammy on an asiago bagel with garlic and herb cream cheese and it was so delicious. We also grabbed a loaf of the jalapeno bread and a ginger rhubarb and strawberry turnover and they are all perfect. So flaky and tasty with all the flavors. Highly recommend checking this place out if you're in door county! read more

Cultured - Jalapeno loaf and strawberry/rhubarb turnovers - Bakeries Near Me - Sister Bay, Wisconsin

DELICIOUS Breakfast bagel sandwiches. Outdoor seating and quick service! We will be back next time we're in door county! read more

Cultured - BBLT - Bakeries Near Me - Sister Bay, Wisconsin

Everything about this place is terrific. Friendly staff. Easy to navigate. My kids love their bagels!!!

Our good friends in Fish Creek bragged about this Sourdough Baker and her products and being from Chicago I thought this will be a tough Convince BUT They were RIGHT ! Their Sourdough Bread is Top Level ! Baker also is friendly and quite approachable willing to entertain questions and provide suggestions . Cute Storefront and welcoming . I can't wait to Return :) read more

Me encanta todo de este lugar. Los sándwiches son deliciosos y el pan es lo mejor, siempre con ingredientes súper frescos. El servicio es excelente todos son muy amables. Totalmente recomendado. read more

Worth the wait!! I love the breakfast sandwich and the focaccia (and, of course, the loaves of sourdough).

We got a whitefish open face and the pickled veggie bagel and both were absolutely delicious. We had to get some bagels to take home too because YUM! read more

Cultured - BeReal bagels - Bakeries Near Me - Sister Bay, Wisconsin

Fabulous food and quality staff add to the charms of Cultured. Don't leave Door County without treating yourself to something delicious made just for you at Cultutred read more

Likely the best bakery in Door County. Have to show up early and wait in line, but it will be worth it!

My favorite place to eat in Door County. I'll come here as much as I can. Don't let the size fool you, the open face Sammie's are generous portions. read more

See all

This place is one of the BEST bagels I have had in the Midwest. The location is super cute, the staff is super nice. If you are deep in Door County, please don't skip this spot!! read more

Great bagels and smear! Quaint bakery with a small menu that packs a punch. Get there early as they sell out of their popular items. Everything bagel was amazing. Kind staff which great recommendations! read more

So good!!! Service was lovely and the food was divine. We had two meals there, and each time the food was perfect - definitely made with love. Such a great spot - beautiful places to sit outside with your doggo and inside was cozy and light. Everyone has got to try this place out! The sweet cherry cream cheese came home with us, and I coveted that all week read more

Cultured - The sweet bagel - Bakeries Near Me - Sister Bay, Wisconsin

See all

The best sourdough I can remember having, delicious olive focaccia loaf and great atmosphere. It also has a fun, small selection of unique grocery items. Adorable vibe and cute owners! So happy to have this new spot to look forward to when we visit Door County. read more