Great stop! Great Service! Great Breakfast! Loved this little breakfast diner! We walked up and it looked crazy busy but they were able to seat us right away. The dining room was completely full so I thought we might be waiting a while for our breakfast, but it was served pretty quickly and everything was delicious! I would come back without hesitation! read more

See all

So, we woke up on our last morning in our rental house and the power was out! No coffee! Crisis! We packed up the car and headed here for breakfast. They are quick with the coffee and the menu had great choices at very affordable prices. I really loved that they had half orders of many items which made it possible to choose a breakfast size that fits what you want. I had a half stuffed cherry waffle and a side of bacon. The waffle was crispy and delicious and the cream cheese and cherry filling was perfect and just the right amount. The bacon was crispy, fresh and still hot. Service was fast and friendly. The atmosphere is casual and diner-like. Next trip we will plan to come here on purpose! read more

Carroll House Restaurant - Half cherry stuffed waffle - New American Near Me - Sister Bay, Wisconsin

See all

A truly hidden gem. This small eatery offers some great food at great prices with wonderful friendly service. Our breakfast was tasty and delicious in every respect. And the coffee was outstanding! We really enjoyed stopping by this cafe. Make sure to add it to your list. read more

We went for breakfast little before 10am on Thursday. It was busy but wait wasn't that long for five people. Food was served quick and everything tasted delicious. Really enjoyed the pancake with door county cherries. There were many old people and families dining in. It's very cozy and small place. read more

Service was great. They accommodated a party of six even though they were packed, busy but efficient spot for breakfast. Food was decent, good value for money. I wish the corned beef hash had fewer potatoes and morn corned beef but it was still good. Setting is a cross between a diner and a coffee shop, very casual, good spot for what we wanted. read more

See all

We have been visiting Door County for years and yet this is the first time we tried it. We are so sorry that we didn't go here earlier. The people were fantastic and the food was most excellent! Love the atmosphere! read more

When you're told you've got a wait of 1hr 40min at Al Johnson's (and you know that means probably more like just an hour), we figured to drive up to Carroll House since we hadn't eaten and we figured to see how busy it really was since they weren't picking up the phone. Got there and seeing a few empty spots in the lot with folks leaving was a good sign. They were clearing a table as we got in. We got the chorizo hash ($12.75) and a full order of the cherry stuffed waffles ($11.75 - half order option also available for $7.75, and this can be done with French toast instead). Tables are turned over quickly and there is counter seating too. Check the current menu at their Facebook page. You can see they've been trying out new things, particularly it seems Mexican inspired options. Closes in December for the winter and reopens in April. FB page will help you on exact dates. read more

Good food and good service. Plenty of parking and an easy way to get a good meal without the crowds of downtown.

Excellent food and service. Portions were more than adequate. Really enjoyed my breakfast. Will definitely visit again

Great coffee. Wonderful service. Waffle and bacon very good. I would vote this place as the 'most like home ' place on the peninsula! Cozy. Will go back again for sure! read more

Quickly got coffee but then service went downhill. Female servers looked happy but men were brusque. No extra plate with our omelet to split and $10 omelet with 2 toast and NO potatoes. Took time to get extra jam. The 7 am patrons done and we arrived just after 9. There must be a more pleasant place for tourists to have breakfast! read more

Small place, but service was quick. Entrees were as expected, maybe a bit pricey for the serving size.

I have drove by this place for years and finally made the effort to stop in for breakfast. I so wanted to love this place because it just seemed like a nice family business located in the heart of more touristy restaurants and bars. As I walked in we were told to sit were we would like and the waitress was very friendly. This changed as a couple of friends came in and sat at the counter. After that we basically only got attention when she delivered our bill! I was excited to try their "world famous" waffles, so my wife and I decided to split one as a side with our entree. The waffle was good, but nothing outstanding that would make the world famous claim... but I would still recommend. For my breakfast I ordered the county fried steak with hash browns and white toast. The steak was also very average but I did like the gravy. The hash browns were a bit burnt on the outside, yet somehow underdone in the middle... not good. And my toast was hurt black one one side and not as bad on the other. (Amazingly they turned the burnt side was turned down so I wouldn't see it... like I wouldn't notice!!!). Why not remake the damn toast? Should have sent it back, but didn't get to talk to the waitress until the bill came, and by then I lost interest. Long wait to eat here... big let down. read more

Ordered two breakfast croissants for carry out. One with bacon, egg and cheese, the other with sausage. Both were well prepared and tasty. Service was friendly and quick. read more

Food, service and price were all excellent! A cozy morning breakfast! Oh and the coffee was very good too... it's small so expect to wait!

Not the best. Lots of weird looks from strangers. We didn't have a big meal. Got stuck on the corner table but we could still people watch. Our server was nice but hubby said the chicken were subpar. Nothing special. I had a cinnamon roll and coffee. And it was alright. read more

See all

Nice restaurant as you're entering Sister Bay, not quite downtown which is great for breakfast on busy days. Quick service, friendly, good food. read more

Carroll House Restaurant - Cherry Waffles - New American Near Me - Sister Bay, Wisconsin

See all

I thought this was fine overall, but none of our food stuck out as exceptional or particularly recommend-able. I got Eggs Benedict which was, again, just fine, nothing special. It came with hash browns which also were very average. My mom ordered French toast which she was pleased with; they seem to have knowingly given her extra slices which was cool. My sister got a standard eggs/bacon/toast meal which was satisfying. Everything was just kind of down-the-line, and I felt like they could spice things up if they wanted to be really memorable. As it is, if you're around here and are looking for a simple breakfast place, this will definitely do. Also, we wish we'd known there was outdoor seating; we didn't know it existed until we spotted it on the way out. read more

See all

We were on a scouting trip to Sister Bay, WI. In a few weeks we are attending a wedding nearby and we wanted to learn more about the area. We spotted this nice breakfast place as we explored the shops, restaurants and surroundings. We sat down right away, received 2 waters, ordered our food, and in a bit our food arrived. My lovely travel partner ordered eggs, bacon, biscuit, and hash browns. I had the door county cherry stuffed french toast w/ side of bacon. Our food was nice. We will return. read more

See all

Had the fish boil and we enjoyed learning about the history. Friendly staff and the food was great. We got the single and that was more than enough. The fresh homemade cherry pie at the end was awesome! read more

We had a great breakfast here this morning. Cherry waffles, eggs. Everything was delicious. We come every year and this was my dad's favorite place for waffles. read more

Sausage patties were good! My eggs were undercooked & the hash browns were mush. Chorizo hash was alright - canned, not homemade. Service was quick but won't be back. read more

Just wanted to give a shout-out to this little family restaurant. It is definitely worth a visit for delicious homemade food. I ordered the potato pancakes for lunch and they were so good! Next time we'll go earlier for breakfast. read more

A Good general breakfast place. Omelette and waffle were good and fresh. Parking is limited, so go early.

What a pleasant surprise!! Driven past this place for years. Should have stopped in a long time ago. Such a nice place to have a simple delicious breakfast. Really good! Feels like Door Co and taste like Door Co. not going to recommend a specific dish. I'm sure they are all good. Eat what you like and enjoy the moment. We love Door Country read more

This restaurant is definitely OPEN!! It has been open for many years and is a Sister Bay institution. The food is delicious and prices are reasonable. Staff is friendly and efficient. My husband had the cherry cream cheese French toast and he said it was DELICIOUS!! My daughter is a vegetarian and had the veggie croissant which she loved! Perhaps this restaurant is marked CLOSED on Yelp so the locals can keep it all to themselves LOL) :-) read more

Cute little stop with great homemade breakfast options. Friendly service and very clean restaurant.

Service was fast and friendly! The food came out as fast as the fast friendly service They cycle through their busy tables quite efficiently and pleasantly, super great breakfast to top it off! read more

Nothing fancy about the establishment. But the breakfast was solid. Wife had a small biscuits and gravy, eggs and bacon. Very tasty. I've had better in the Southern US. but very good. I had fried eggs over easy with a side of hash browns. Cooked perfectly. Both eggs and crispy hash browns. Solid breakfast. . Good value. read more

I'd go to Carroll House over the popular touristy places nearby 99 times out of 100. They have much better food and service!

So on their sign. Says waffle. Well I guess they should knock your stocks off with their waffle. Not for me Got strawberries on waffle. Well this tis season for fresh strawberries. They used the can strawberries stuff. Not very good. Service lousy but that's pretty much all over the place with the shortage of workers. The waffle I toss in the toaster at home much better. I learned my lesson with this place. Skip it. read more

Very poor quality breakfast. Less than mediocre service. We had breakfast here on Aug 18,2022. This place only got one star because first of all the menus were dirty! Took awhile to get a cup of coffee and never got a refill! I ordered a simple two scrambled eggs and toast. Eggs were fair but only got one piece of toast. We had no butter at our table and only one tiny creamer. There is a reason there were only a few cars in there parking lot. Breakfast in a touristy area should be packed. Save yourself and eat at one of the more popular places. read more

I've been going here for decades. It's just as good now as it was 40 years ago. Great for adults, kids, families.

Food was very quick to come out. The prices are great for Door County. The biggest drawback is the wait staff. Our waiter was incredibly rude, rolling his eyes at one point. Had there not been Fallfest and so many people, we would have left and went elsewhere. This worked in a pinch, but we won't be back. read more

Very good place for a quick and good breakfast or a place to sit and chat with friends. I'm guessing the omelettes are two-egg, and as an alternative to the tourist-y Al Johnsons, this would be my go-to. The staff is very attentive, though somewhat flat affect of interaction with their customers. read more

when the cookery closed, we had to find a new go-to breakfast spot and Carroll's fits the bill. the stuffed french toast, country fried steak and potato pancakes are all excellent. but the waffles are incredible! thin, light, tender but still crispy. try one smothered with their homemade cherry topping. we've been back twice this week. owned by a local family with kids in local schools. go gibraltar! read more

Carroll House Restaurant - a cup of coffee on a table - New American Near Me - Sister Bay, Wisconsin

Such a great breakfast place. Waffles and pork chop breakfast were delicious. And the hash browns were the perfect amount of buttery and crispy. It was $24 for 2 coffees and 2 full breakfasts. I would definitely recommend! read more

This restaurant only exists because Al Johnson's has 2 hour waits. They even have a shirt they sell saying No Goats. Our first impression was being offered 2 separate tables. We have 5 very young children, so no we cannot separate. Then they remembered they have large picnic tables outside-weird. The food was subpar diner food. Canned mushrooms in the omelette-yuck! We had to ask for cream at least 3 times for our coffee, which was one of the worst cups I've ever had. Our waiter never returned to check on us or refill drinks. We won't return and wouldn't recommend. read more

I guess when you have a captive audience, it doesn't matter. This was a first for me: a dry omelet. How that is even possible I will never know. Very TIIIIIIIIIIIIINY place so it gets really crowded. Employees were very nice, but I was there for the food, which was a one time experience. read more

Checked this diner out for the first time with my husband. It's a small place, but had open seats so we were seated and had a server immediately. The menu is typical diner food. I got the bread pudding which did not disappoint. It was moist and the carmel drizzle was yummy. My husband got the special Mexican Omelet. The presentation was nice and pick de gallo was fresh, but the meat was a bit chewy. Overall the service was great (Eddie was a wonderful) and prompt. If you're looking for a hearty diner breakfast this is a great place to stop! read more

Carroll House Restaurant - New American Near Me - Sister Bay, Wisconsin